What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Car

I've been reading all the threads on DPF problems, but wonder which manufacturers have fewer problems with them and why?

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - craig-pd130

From three and a half years of running a Mondeo IV with DPF, and being active on the Ford Mondeo / S-Max / Galaxy forums, there were virtually no DPF-related issues reported with these cars.

Plenty of other minor niggles that are typical of a relatively new design but the DPF and its related sensors etc seem very robust, especially as they're a high-volume car.

I haven't seen many reported DPF issues with diesel BMWs either, but that's just an impression gained from the lack of reports on motoring forums.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - thunderbird

Had BMW with DPF for 4 years, no problems so far.

Wifes had Kia for 18 months, same again plus as with BMW problems appear rare. Add to that the 7 year warranty covers the DPF providing the car is serviced etc. etc. thus we are not worrying.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - RT

The problem is related to car usage, not car brand.

Most of the problems with DPFs arise from usage consisting mainly of short journeys, which doesn't give the DPF long enough to regenerate passively or actively, so becoming blocked.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Collos25

Mercedes have been using the system for donkys years with no problem in the scheme of things not many cars do have problems .

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - xtrailman

Isnt 18K in 3 years short journeys?

Last trip was 1000 yards down the road and back because it was snowing.

No issues with the Nissan xtrail 2009 onwards.

I think it would be easier to list cars that are a problem, such as early mazda 6?

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - dieseldogg

I, as a non mercedes driver ( hobby "G" wagens excepted) am of the opinion that despite Mercedes much published fall from grace in respect of electronic reliability ( & the wee giltch with the ATF cooling courtsey of Valeo) Mercedes have not had any DMF issues either simply due to rigerous evaluation and proper engineering outweighing penny pinching production savings.

just a thought

I have been particularly impressed at the quality of design & construction in the wee old 1984 "G" wagen, which is also a pleasure to tinker at.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - RT

Isnt 18K in 3 years short journeys?

Maybe, maybe not.

It depends how many consecutive short journeys you do in between longer ones.

My own usage in winter is a pattern of 4 weeks of short journeys totalling about 200 miles and then a long high-speed run for 300 miles on the Sunday - this doesn't cause any problem for the DPF as it gets it's "Italian Tune-Up" regularly.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - xtrailman

Isnt 18K in 3 years short journeys?

Maybe, maybe not.

It depends how many consecutive short journeys you do in between longer ones.

My own usage in winter is a pattern of 4 weeks of short journeys totalling about 200 miles and then a long high-speed run for 300 miles on the Sunday - this doesn't cause any problem for the DPF as it gets it's "Italian Tune-Up" regularly.

I dont doo italian tune ups, the xtrail engine goes to the red line in first on a regular basis.

Typical driving week, 5 miles to super market mainly A57. 50 mph limit.

3 miles to other super market, 30mph limit.

Once a week A57 wifes keep fit, 6 miles.

6 miles to daughters. 30/40 mph limit

Twice a week fishing, 9 miles.

Very little crawling in traffic, other than when i go fishing, rush hour traffic

7 times a year towing, maximum 2.5 hours, not sure on mileage.

Typical towing 1 hour.

For got to mention caravan parked up for winter Nov to March.

Edited by xtrailman on 29/01/2012 at 16:00

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - mss1tw

I dont doo italian tune ups, the xtrail engine goes to the red line in first on a regular basis.

Then why do you drive a diesel? ;o)

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - xtrailman

I dont doo italian tune ups, the xtrail engine goes to the red line in first on a regular basis.

Then why do you drive a diesel? ;o)

Why not?

Modern diesels rev like petrol cars, hence its quite easy to find the red line with out trying.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - RT
Modern diesels rev like petrol cars, hence its quite easy to find the red line with out trying.

The Subaru diesel might - but the others don't !!

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - unthrottled

Whatever the maximum cut off speed is (usually somewhere around 5000 RPM) it is completely pointless revving past 4000 because the torque and power and efficiency are falling away rapidly. Diesels just aren't rev friendly-the fuel doesn't burn fast enough.

I still think it is the application that is most important-rather than the type of engine. The xtrail is a heavy car, and the engine has to work harder than if it were in a small car.

It's interesting that BMW haven't expanded their high powered diesel engines beyond 3.0 litres. I suspect DPF concerns were part of the reason.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - thunderbird
Modern diesels rev like petrol cars, hence its quite easy to find the red line with out trying.

The Subaru diesel might - but the others don't !!

No diesel engine revs like a petrol, the way the different fuels burn makes it impossible and totally pointless anyway. Even the 280 bhp 2 litre that Seat used in the WTCC peaked at 4000 rpm.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - xtrailman

Yes i was very impressed with the subaru engine, i tested one in 2009, revs just like the xtrail engine.

In comparison i tested the CRV, and found the engine very ordinary, much like my old T30 xtrail, just didnt like revs.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Car

Most of the problems with DPFs arise from usage consisting mainly of short journeys, which doesn't give the DPF long enough to regenerate passively or actively, so becoming blocked.

Are some DPF's more robust in this type of environment?

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Car

I haven't seen many reported DPF issues with diesel BMWs either, but that's just an impression gained from the lack of reports on motoring forums.

(1) I wonder if the manufacturers where there appear to be more failures have customers who are more likley to come on to forums stating their DPF failures.

(2) Are all people who post up about DPF failures giving the full story, it is easy to say the DPF have failed and blame it on the manufacturer but a lot harder to say that they failed to adhere to the instuctions in the handbook, the warning light on the dashboard.

(3) When something is working its is less likley that a person will post up a thread to say so?

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Avant

I would hope that these things are being developed and improved with time. I've read that the DPF fitted to the VAG common-rail diesel engine has a bigger 'reservoir' - if that's the word - for particulates than the old PD had.

My last car was a CR diesel and I never had a problem.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Armitage Shanks {p}

My impression is that the DPFs that give the most problems are those associated with the use of EOLYS. This certainly includes all PSA modern diesels SFAIK

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Sulphur Man

Taken from the VW UK website today

"The latest generation of filters operate without additives. This makes them maintenance-free for an exceptionally long time: an initial inspection is usually carried out only after 150,000 km. The filter's lifespan is dependent on factors such as fuel quality, driving style, use and oil consumption."

I'm looking at a new car, including various VAG products sporting the 1.6TDI engine.

I'd be interested to know what 'quality' fuel is recommended by VAG, together with driving style.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - macd

Hi, new to this forum but i thought i would add my recent experiences with a golf diesel, 2.0ltr common rail fitted with a dpf. Car is less than 3 yrs old, i have covered in excess of 84,000 miles with it (approx 3,000 miles per month) - ideal conditions for a dpf / diesel? Apparently not, my dpf failed at 64,000 miles - first the filter light came on - i followed the instructions re driving at high revs for x time, then the engine warning light came on so i followed the instructuions in the book and took the vehicle to a main dealer. They tried to regenerate the filter but couldn't (they also replaced the sensor) - then the bomb shell, sorry sirm, you need a new filter and that will be in excess of £2,000! This started alot of discussions with VW, dealer and anyone else i could talk to. Eventully they agreed to replace it but still at £750 (with some good will from VW)! This took over a month with my car off the road.

Since then (this was about 8mths ago) no problems but will i buy another diesel with dpf - very, very doubtful as my driving is ideal for a dpf , engine always warm, a little bit of revs etc. I am now in the process of getting a petrol even though it will cost me more in fuel. If you get a dpf vehicle factor in at least £1,000 for a replacemnt within your vehicle calcs. As an aside, my previous car, a Skoda 1.9TDi (04 plate) is still going strong with my wife at 185,000 miles - no dpf !!!!!

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

Hi, new to this forum but i thought i would add my recent experiences with a golf diesel, 2.0ltr common rail fitted with a dpf. Car is less than 3 yrs old, i have covered in excess of 84,000 miles with it (approx 3,000 miles per month) - ideal conditions for a dpf / diesel? Apparently not, my dpf failed at 64,000 miles - first the filter light came on - i followed the instructions re driving at high revs for x time, then the engine warning light came on so i followed the instructuions in the book and took the vehicle to a main dealer. They tried to regenerate the filter but couldn't (they also replaced the sensor) - then the bomb shell, sorry sirm, you need a new filter and that will be in excess of £2,000! This started alot of discussions with VW, dealer and anyone else i could talk to. Eventully they agreed to replace it but still at £750 (with some good will from VW)! This took over a month with my car off the road.

Since then (this was about 8mths ago) no problems but will i buy another diesel with dpf - very, very doubtful as my driving is ideal for a dpf , engine always warm, a little bit of revs etc. I am now in the process of getting a petrol even though it will cost me more in fuel. If you get a dpf vehicle factor in at least £1,000 for a replacemnt within your vehicle calcs. As an aside, my previous car, a Skoda 1.9TDi (04 plate) is still going strong with my wife at 185,000 miles - no dpf !!!!!

They were having a laught at £2000, just hoped you paid up. Even at £750 they are making a profit, the part is under £500.

You are still well in pocket running a diesel even after this unfortunate expense, check the maths:

84,000 miles in a diesel (2.0 TDI 140) at say 53 mpg (Honest John figure) @ £6.30/gal = £9,985

84,000 miles in a petrol (1.4 TSi) at say 43 mpg (Honest John figure @ £6.05/gal = £11,818.

The difference is £1,833 meaning after your £750 bill you are still £1,083 in pocket and gaining with every mile. Add to that the cheaper road tax of the diesel and you have saved even more.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - oldroverboy

Our local taxis run the same as me, 2 chevrolet epicas, no problems, my brother in law, astra no problem, his nissan 1,5 diesel qasquai no problems, As others have said, depends on usage.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - Haminator

Hello all, I am down in OZ

As I see many people with DPF issues in UK forums, I thought I would share! My pain.

I was just advised that my DPF has gone to God and Mazda service have advised that I need to give them $8000.00 AU to have it rectified.

Now Mazda Australia will not warranty the unit as; the the ECU cycle was NOT reset at each oil change (10K). I have a valid reason for this, its because I did the oil changes myself, Mazda serviced the car at 40K, 60K 80K and 120K, the DPF blew after the 120K service (that service cost me $1300.00AU) at no point was I ever advised that this needed to be done or warranty would be denied, I even bought the oil and filters from the dealer where I bought the car. The manual has no warning in the service schedule section note...nothing anywhere in the entire documentation supplied. I am currently fighting Mazda Australia through consumer affairs on this basis. If they had advised me at the time of purchase that this requirement was on the vehicle - simply I would NOT have bought it.

This stance from Mazda is not acceptable, nor would it be acceptable to any customer - so warning, warning - NOT zoom zoom zoom.

if you have a Mazda diesel - sell it......

This is the "good oil" - diesel reference `

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

Now Mazda Australia will not warranty the unit as; the the ECU cycle was NOT reset at each oil change (10K). I have a valid reason for this, its because I did the oil changes myself, Mazda serviced the car at 40K, 60K 80K and 120K, the DPF blew after the 120K service (that service cost me $1300.00AU) at no point was I ever advised that this needed to be done or warranty would be denied,

Its a well known fact in the UK that if you don't have your car serviced to the manufacturers requirements your warranty is forfeit. Over here it is possble to have your car serviced outside the delaer network but the garage must be VAT registered and use genuine parts. DIY servicing does not count, you will loose your warranty. This applies to all manufacturers and is a well known fact that is shown in literature and in the service department of garages.

120,000K is a good life for a DPF, many die before that distance, would suggest you have done quite well.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - gordonbennet

''120,000K is a good life for a DPF, many die before that distance, would suggest you have done quite well''.

See thats quite interesting, not something Diesel devotees tend to talk about when making all sorts of dire predictions about replacement battery costs when the divisive subject of Hybrids is discussed.

I was one of those Diesel devotees until recently, indeed i've usually had a Diesel car in my stable since the early 80's, however i know that our current DPF equipped second car will eventually require a considerable sum spent on it, what that entails will depend on how the MOT changes pan out in practice.

The present Diesel will in all probability be our last, too many modern cars are carrying an unpinned grenade of one form or another under the bonnet these days, if you happen to own the car when the pineapple off then costs far in excess of fuel savings over less fuel efficient cars are in order.

Edited by gordonbennet on 31/01/2012 at 08:14

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

''120,000K is a good life for a DPF, many die before that distance, would suggest you have done quite well''.

See thats quite interesting, not something Diesel devotees tend to talk about when making all sorts of dire predictions about replacement battery costs when the divisive subject of Hybrids is discussed.

A DPF is like any component on a car, they will eventually wear out. The type of use the car gets will probably affect its life, short town runs continually will probably result in a shorter life but if they get a good run out of town every 200 or 300 miles that would probably be enough to ensure they don'r get bunged up with soot. When we bought our last diesel we looked at a Ford Focus 1.6 TDCi which use the oelys tank thingy. I was shocked when I checked with Mr Ford for servicing costs, the oelys tank needed a refill every 3 years at £100+ (I have since read that some customers have paid over £300 for a refill) and at 6 years or 72,000 miles they said that in addition to the tank refill they replaced the DPF as a service item, over £1,000. We quickly ran from the forecourt and bought a diesel without an oelys tank.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - gordonbennet

at 6 years or 72,000 miles they said that in addition to the tank refill they replaced the DPF as a service item, over £1,000. We quickly ran from the forecourt and bought a diesel without an oelys tank.

Our C2 VTS has the tank of liquid gold but i understand most PSA cars last around 60k miles before top up is needed, and DPF change possibly?

Not making any decisions what to do about this yet, we may not even have the car then,but if we do i understand that indies can remover the DPF and clean it out by brute force hot pressure water reverse flushing and simply bung it back in.

Whatever happens it will be going to a competent indy not a fitting palace for new parts.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - unthrottled

The tank of Eloys is normally good for 60,000 miles. So if a solid catalyst DPF regenerates about every 300 miles, that's 200 regens over 60,000 miles. At an average of 15 minutes/regen a lot of diesel is being chucked straight out of the exhaust for the regen. Could you save over £100 of diesel over the course of the life of the eolys tank and hence break even? I reckon you might.

Eolys gets a bad rep because refilling it was awkward-and it didn't automatically recognise when the reservoir was refilled. But I think the system wasn't that bad.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

The tank of Eloys is normally good for 60,000 miles. So if a solid catalyst DPF regenerates about every 300 miles, that's 200 regens over 60,000 miles. At an average of 15 minutes/regen a lot of diesel is being chucked straight out of the exhaust for the regen. Could you save over £100 of diesel over the course of the life of the eolys tank and hence break even? I reckon you might.

Eolys gets a bad rep because refilling it was awkward-and it didn't automatically recognise when the reservoir was refilled. But I think the system wasn't that bad.

When I asked Mr Ford why the tank needed refilling after 36,000 rather than the 72,000 previously recommended his answer was low mileage users were using up the eolys faster since a fixed amount was injected at every fill up regardless of the amount of diesel bought. If the tank ran out and the owner ignored any lights it caused further damage. Thus Ford were robbing responsible people like myself because of the people who did a splash and dash every few days. They were not prepared to be flexible thus they lost my potential custom.

Some time ago to either depress myself or alternatively cheer myself up I calculated that over a regen approx 0.1 gallons of diesel is wasted. Wifes commute is 19 miles and fuel confuser says 52 mpg on average, 0.36 gallons,on a regen trip the fuel confuser says 40 mpg average, 0.47 gallans, as I said it was very approximate. If a regen happens every 300 miles say over 36,000 miles that is 120 regens and at 0.1 gallons a go thats 12 gallons, approx £75 at todays price. I know wasting diesel to protect the environment is a pain but I recon its cheaper than a tank of eolys at £100 and a bargain if a tank of eolys is more.

Correct me if I am wrong but I was told that eolys was needed because on some cars the DPF is to far away from the turbo to allow it to reach high enough temps during a regen.If that is a fact and an eolys equipped car still varies the injector timing to put unburned diesel into the DPF along with the eolys its game set and match to a non-eolys car.

A couple of years ago I was shown a DPF that had been removed from a car, wish I had taken a photo, the mechanic showed me that it was just an urban myth that they could be power washed clean. The power washer would probably clean the ends but never get down to the centre plus I believe the soot is bonded to the matrix and can only be removed by temps above 600 C.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - unthrottled

Interesting observations regarding the regens. Eolys equipped cars still require post injection but not as much since the soot burn off occurs at a lower temperature.

It's true that the exhaust gas temperature tends to decrease asyou get further downstream-but most of the temperature drop is across the turbo (even with the vanes open).

Most manufacturers have now abandoned eolys so it can't have been that attractive.

probably clean the ends but never get down to the centre plus I believe the soot is bonded to the matrix and can only be removed by temps above 600 C.

The soot burns off. It's the ash from diesel and engine oill that clogs DPFs. I was sceptical about pressure washing-but some swear that it can be done.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

The soot burns off. It's the ash from diesel and engine oill that clogs DPFs. I was sceptical about pressure washing-but some swear that it can be done.

That's why you can only buy BS EN590 diesel and manufacturers using DPF's specify a low ash fully synthetic oil at about £50 a change.

I read about a taxi driver some time ago that took his car to his favourite garage to have the DPF removed and cleaned out every couple of weeks at a cost of £30 or so. The garage were having a laugh, he could not understand that the regens were cleaning it for him while he drove.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - unthrottled

That's tragic!

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

That's tragic!

If I can find the thread I will post a link later.

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - skidpan

That's tragic!

If I can find the thread I will post a link later.

Infernal Explorer won't let me post a link but here are 2 posts the guy put up.

"The only comment I'd make on Pauls post is the dpf has caused MAJOR problems for the cab drivers down here in Brighton (& I imagine elsewhere too). The round town/stop start driving soon clogs it up, most of the Mk3 Carens last no more than 2 months before having to be cleaned out (why I've gone back to a Mk2).

The clean can be done by any garage with the correct knowledge of the process however only a main dealer can do a "forced" regeneration which actually clears out all the soot that you loosen up with the "poking". My local dealer has a home made tool just for this job, an old wiper arm sharpened to a point (almost like an arrow) which fits the gaps perfectly, they charge £40&vat for the privilege!" AND "The garage remove both connecting pipes at the ends of the dpf then poke the tool through the channel to release/soften some of the sooty buildup then do a forced regen (like a dyno rod drain engineer would use a long wire to ease the blockage before jetting with a high pressure water gun). I've watched them do this, the poking does release some of the soot, obviously the forced regen burns the rest off. Hope that makes it clearer" Wish was closer to Brighton and could use that garage.

Edited by skidpan on 31/01/2012 at 13:59

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - unthrottled

Fantastic! I've got a whole load of goodies that the taxi driver could benefit from.

There's the magnet on the sump for a start. It collects any metallic particles and prevents the engine from seizing. I've been running one for 120,000 miles and the engine hasn't seized once-which proves that it works!

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - master aka

i visited a company in london called s*******


www.s*******.co.uk
they do dpf for quiet a lot of cars done my mazda 6 once never had a problem 2007 mines been running fine for the past 2 years you guys should try them i recommended one of my friends and his car is working even better



apparantly the diseal particular filter was in these cars to stop pulluting the air
when the engine burns fuel passes threw to the filter which get blocked up and people try regenerating by cleaning them but they fail again so thats why i tryed s******* they got my car done within 2 hours

Which Manufacturers Have Less DPF Issues - OldSkoOL

The diesel i drive pulls strong up to 5k

However, italian tune ups dont do anything apart from add to the problem. You are just dumping a whole load soot that wasn't needed.

Get it working in the max torque range, keep it burning efficiently, accelerate hard within max torque and make sure the coolant temperature reaches a level where an active DPF purge can begin.

I guarantee short journeys will significantly reduce the life of the DPF regardless of make/model.

Edited by OldSkoOL on 01/03/2012 at 15:23