What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Can anyone help!? I had a car accident last week, whilst slowing to turn on a sharp bend I attempted to change down gear in my car, and the clutch failed and gears would not change, to be honest I panicked and just kept thumping foot on clutch that was on the floor putting up no resistance.... and then bang into wall.

So I have contacted insurer, had a claims investigator come out, and engineer on behalf of insurance company has viewed car, I have not seen the car, cannot get to speak to anyone to tell me where the car has been moved to. The only contact I have had was one phonecall from investigator who has told me that the engineer says that clutch would not simlpy have went and after further investigation they believe that the clutch cable was disconnected by someone!?!

I had 2 passengers in the car at the time who witnessed this, and a driver who stopped after witnessing, and he gave his details to the insurer and police (who said they had no need to investigate anything further).

When I first spoke to investigator, I explained that when I first bought the car exactly the same thing happened, but as I had only purchased the car a week before the seller had the car towed and fixed, this was five years ago.

How do I proceed with this, should I have my own mechanic look at it (when they finally tell me where it is!)? I have spoken to him and he says they can loosen and work themselves loose?

Should I seek legal advice, I have never made a claim before so I'm not sure what to do?

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - FP

"...clutch would not simlpy have went..." Clutch cables CAN break - it happened to me once.

"...they believe that the clutch cable was disconnected by someone..." Really? So in effect you are being accused of doing this after the accident to cover up your bad driving? How will that be proved?

It should be possible to determine definitely why the clutch would not disengage and it sounds as if you need to find an independent engineer to do this; maybe your own mechanic isn't the best person.

Sounds as if you may need the advice of a specialist solicitor, though I think I'd wait for a while before rushing into anything - see what the official response of your insurance company is first.

If your witnesses are independent (i.e. not family or close friends) and can back up your story you should be in a strong position.

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Hi and Thanks

The people in the car are friends one of which I was driving home, the other witness in the oncoming car is independent I've never met him before and he was wit h me from the moment the accident happened.

They seem to be implying I somehow drove the car with no clutch? I don't know how this would be done? As when the clutch did go I ended up in a wall. They said the cable didn't snap it was disconnected, I asked how this would be done and they said someone would have had to do it from underneath the car?! They said their engineer did not believe that the connection could have loosened over time, I'm so confused about it all are they accusing me of fraud?! I feel like I'm being interviewed by the police every time I make a phonecall to request further information. :(

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - FP

It is clearly rubbish to suggest you started your journey with the clutch cable disconnected and the only other way it could be suggested that you were responsible is if you got under the car following the incident and disconnected the cable then.

If the car was removed to a location unknown to you, you could easily argue that someone else could have disconnected it. (Though what their motivation might be is unclear.)

Best wait and see what the insurance company come up with - they may see how ridiculous some of the things you've been told clearly are.

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Hi I had to ring them again this morning as still no communication from them, I have no been told that the car has been relocated and I am not allowed near it pending investigation. I have been told that if the cable has just went as described the casing enclosing tthe connection would have exploded?! And that the mechanic who towed the vehicle from scene of the accident told the insurance company that he believed the cable had been disconnected manually. They are now sending it to a dealership to have it stripped down to check if I drove the vehicle without a clutch to the scene of the accident, as they said it will show wear and tear, if I have previously forced the gears without a clutch?! Jesus I don't get this this I'm really upset now, are they saying that everytime in the past 5 years of owning this car and where I've scrunched the gears is going to end up with me being accussed of lying?! I have asked if they believe I manually disconnected it and they said they were not saying that?! But had I been coached in anyway to drive a car without a clutch? I said obviously not or I would not have ended up in a wall. But they may decide that they wont pay out and then I will be contacted are these people accusing me now of fraud?! I'm scared and confused?!

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - FP

I may be missing something here, but how does anyone get going if the clutch cable is disengaged? Is it even possible to slam the gear stick into first?

I suppose if you were on a slope you could get started like that. But you might have to come to a stop later on.

If you're really upset at the way things are going, you had better see a solicitor, preferably one with experience of motoring issues. But it will cost you!

I still think you'd be better off waiting.

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Thanks again, they say that the car can be driven by reving the engine and forcing it into gear. And asked if I had been coached to do this by anyone. I just hate feeling on edge like this, I'm currently unemployed so I don't even know if I can seek legal advice, due to cost or if I'm entitled to any legal aid. I obviously won't hear anything from them over the weekend, so I'm just going to have it hanging over me now. :(

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - bathtub tom

It is possible to drive a car without using the clutch. I've done it on a couple of occasions when the linkage has failed.

It seems the insurance company suspect fraud, could there be a reason for this?

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

This is my worry up until they informed me that it could be driven without a clutch I wasn't aware of this, I just don't understand an awful lot about the mechanical stuff they are talking about, all I understand is that they are implying fraud. Now I feel like I'm going to be dragged to court over something I know nothing about and will probably no longer be allowed to get insurance from what I've read on other websites, I'm totally confused over it all and have spent a week now crying firstly because my car has been damaged but now because I seem to be being accused of fraud and have lost my car and any possibility of getting another one.

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - bathtub tom

What's your previous claims history?

Was there any other damage to your car before it hit the wall?

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - FP

It's gone rather quiet in here.

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Hi sorry for the delay in getting back.... I've been sitting in deppresion all weekend, claim handling people have still not come back to me.... I have 5 years protected no claims bonus and no previous damage. And no one is claiming personal injury. Would this make a difference to them?

Thanks again everyone

Peugeot 206 1.4LX - Insurance Claim - CA810

Hi Guys

the insurer has agreed to offer a settlement as car has been written off, but they are deducting the cost and labour for a new clutch, so the offer I was advised isn't what I'm getting but they have said it is subject to my £250 excess? OMG I know I sound like a dumb female driver, but does that mean they are going to take a further £250 from my offer? there is no way I will even be able to buy a new car then?! Basically they have offered me £1175 for the car however I was advised allowing the deduction for the clutch not to settle for anything less than £1300 as the car had low mileage and was otherwise in good condition. Its a 206 1.4LX late 2002, with 76000 miles. I'm freaking out again sorry any advice guys?

Thanks