4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - gingerian

Hi All,

Suggestions warmly welcomed for following situation. We are currently a no-car family, with new baby on way next month, and would love any thoughts on poss car purchase.

Looking to spend max £5000 (maybe nearer 4)

Decent boot capactity for pram/shoppign etc

may have to carry extra passengers + baby

Good visibility

Will not be doing to higher mileage, some possible occasional 200+mile trips in offing though.

Neither driver held car insurance lately, therefore low insurance group handy.

Am torn between people carrier and hatchbacks....Possible thoughts at moment

CMAX, Fabia, Scenic/Megane, Note, Jazz (if poss)

Any thoughts/experiences welcome

ta

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - E17latic

I was in a similar situation 18 months ago and ww went for a 2005 1.8 Nissan Ameira.

I didn't want to pay extra for a badge but I wanted something that was safe, hopefully bullet proof reliable and could overtake on the motorway.

The Almeira has never let me down although I would say the drawbacks are very average fuel consumption, quite high tax bracket and relatively uncomfortable driver's seat and low driving position.

If I was buying again I would go for something a little bigger, it is a real struggle getting everything in for a long weekend away (high chair, push chair etc.) so maybe you should go for a people carrier or an estate.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - gingerian

Thanks v much for he reply.

Yes, bulletproof is very much the key here!

Was also considering a Meriva....don't know how bulletproof they are? have seen one with 33K on the clock, at £4,500

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Armstrong Sid
If you're looking for space, cheap running/insurance and bullet proof, what about one of the last of the old model Focus.

And you'd get something that's good to drive as well
4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Paul G1pdc

i would 2nd the estate idea. I have a 4 and 7 year old. and sold my puma to buy a family car when the 7 year old was still a "bump" . Bought a volvo v40 and still have it...

(the v40 is a small focus size estate, v70 is the mondeo sized one)

as mentioned above,,,,,with prams/travel systems, nappies,,,more nappies and even more nappies....food,bottles, bottle warmers...(mums milk is easier haha) wipes, change of clothes for baby,,,,and you.....projectile vomit........etc etc etc......did i say nappies....and change of clothes.........

thats before you go to the supermarket and try and get a weeks shopping in there...and of course the first month, you'll have every friend and relative come over to see baby and expect tea/coffee.biscuits.......on line shopping helps....

good luck with the new addition....don't worry your home and money situation might start to recover in approx 30 years when they move out......hahahahahah

oh children are great at cleaning alloy wheels they can get there hands into the spokes really well.....the offset is it takes 3 times as long to wash the car,,,and you get soaked hahahaha..............

the estates great when you start buying cots/ etc etc....and also its easy to carry out a nappy change in an estate boot......

airbags....try and find a car, in which you can turn off the front passenger airbag. mums usually like to have baby in the front so they can see each other and in the first few months you will have a rear facing baby seat.... so having a working airbag is not recommended.....

paul.....dad......

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Paul G1pdc

we have friends in the village with a

"Was also considering a Meriva...."

its used as a second car, and a zaria as the family car....the boot on the mervia isn't that large...are you getting or do you have a pram/ buggy/ travel system which has wheels and a click on top section.... try them for size... then fit in the day bag that has the clothes and nappies etc etc, then imagine all the usual stuff you might take for yourself...and think right....where will the shopping go..........i wanted a 3 series compact...but we took the pram to the bmw dealer in oxford and it wouldn't fit between the suspension mounts....

paul

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - gingerian

Hi all - food for thought from everyone!

A Jazz looks favourite for me, i fear for an estate cars rear thanks to other halfs(recently acquired) parking skills....!

Centainly focus comes into the reckoning. I know someone who got a 1.6 Climate on the 56 plate 40k on clock for just over £4,000 so might be an option?

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - ablandy

re parking skills ---- get parking sensors. Can be fitted to most cars now. Very handy things. Spacial awareness can suffer during pregnancy from what i have seen.

Estates are probably easier to park in my opinion, because what you see out the back, is more or less where car finishes.

Big is definitely better when it comes to cars for kids. Have two little ones and a third on the way, so I have an idea of what im talking about.

The old classic would fit the bill here - yes, the ford mondeo. Cheap to buy, cheapish to run. Loads about and parts are easily obtained.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Avant

Agree with ablandy. You'll be surprised how much gubbins you have to take with you with even one baby. A Jazz wil be on the small side, and it has a vertical rear like a estate but with upswept styling at the back so that rear visibility isn't as good as an estate.

I'd say a small to medium estate might be your best bet. If a Mondeo is too big, try a Skoda Octavia estate, or (going down in size) Ford Focus or Skoda Fabia estates.

I wouldn't recommend anything French, as although there are good ones out there, they are more vulnerable to abuse and you aren't going to know how well the previous owner has treated it.

Don't go for a diesel: you aren't going to be doing enough mileage to make it worthwhile, and they can go wrong very expensively as they get older.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - daveyjp
Don't be lead into believing a long car means plenty of space. When our daughter arrived we had an A3 sportback. In terms of boot space it had ample space for all her day to day stuff and we did holidays no problem - even taking five of us and luggage for a foreign trip - pram, travel cot, suitcases etc all fitted.

When her legs grew it became a problem as the back seats were very cramped and she couldn't stretch them without hitting the passenger seat - our Aygo actually has more backseat legroom than the A3 had. So a large boot is useful, but rear seat legroom is more important. VAG cars share platforms so check backseat space before looking at Golfs, Octavias, Passats etc.


4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Glenn 42

Why not the good old Xsara Picasso, a relatively cheap, reliable and good to drive people carrier that has come down in price now the C4 has replaced it? Best models to go for would be the HDis, which can return 55 mpg and performs better than the petrol models.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - RichardW

Indeed - once you've had a high up car like a Picasso, and got used to putting a baby in that, an ordinary car is a right pain in the back - literally! We've got a Xsara Picasso HDi and a 20month old, and it's great - putting him in the Xantia when we use that is much harder work. The diesel ones are still holding their prices well, but £5k will buy a pretty decent one. The petrol ones are much cheaper, and if you're not doing lots of miles, the fuel penalty will not matter. Avoid if you can ones with light coloured dashboards - they reflect really badly in the windscreen - ours has black felt stuck on it - not pretty, but at least it stops you driving it into the ditch!
4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - barney100

Same scenario years ago and my answer was a Volvo estate. You can get a good one within your price range but keep a bit back for safety. Buy from a respectable indie outfit so you get some guarantee and you could have the car easyly see baby into school!. Add to that it swallows push chairs and the rest.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - barneybear

Estate, estate, estate.

Most MPV actually have a failry small loading area, and often a little higher off the ground (thus you need to lift loads higher to get them in). hatchbacks have boot lower than loading cill, meaning you need to lift the botom item (pram) up before you can lift out. I've had Escort and Xsara estates in past, and now have a 57' Megane and love it. The load area is huge. Rear seat passengers get decent leg room (and x3 proper seat belts without it coming from the roof) and loads of toys such as cruise control and air con etc. real nifty is the "auto-window-up" function when you remote lock it. 60mpg on a run and 50+ around town for the 1.9CDi. £130 tax and £300pa insurance and I have 3 points and one accident. Thinking of getting the next generation as it turns 3 next month, so I know its priced at 4500-5000 with 60k, FSH etc. No problems at all, and 18000 between servicing, great value. Another possible would be Clio Estate, but not many older one's around.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - SteveLee
£5K will buy you a nice 2004ish Honda Accord saloon, get a 2 litre petrol, it has a nice big boot and it won't go wrong. It's a very smart, even classy looking car that looks a lot more expensive than it is.

IMHO MPVs are overpriced for what you get - too many people chasing after them and the luggage space is usually disappointing in terms of size. Estates are great but who has owned them? A great number of them have been owned by Mr archetypal photocopy engineer, so the suspension has had a real hammering. Unless you know the car hasn't been used for heavy loads I'd avoid an estate. That's said, I've seen a few current shape Subaru Legacy Estates around that price - juicy but utterly reliable and very smart looking.
4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Paul G1pdc

when we had the first of our 2 boys (now 4+7) the mid-wife put us in touch with other mums within a 10mile radius, 12 mums used to meet up once a week at each others houses to moan about lack of sleep and nappies....when i returned home early one day and found all these cars parked near/on the drive at home......the list of cars....

2x volvo estates V40, 1X volvo estate v70, Astra estate, mondeo estate, astra hatch, focus hatch, zafira...etc....

i had a saloon for a while, only issue was if the 2 part pram (travel system) was put in before all the other bags.....getting it out first was impossible...with an estate no problems.. i would agree with the last poster. than a focus or astra estate might well have had a company car background. but theres dozens of manufacturers who make estates that arn't generally on the fleet car market... and estates are easier to park than a saloon.....ie in an estate you have an almost vertical back window, and the bumper sticks out 3inches or so on top of that....a saloon.....hmm about 3 feet hahahaha owned a mk2 escort and s40 saloon in my years.....reversing sensors can be bought for as little as £30 (stick on and don't need holes drilling....only 1 wire to connect, thats on to the reversing light...thats how the unit/sensor gets its power)

paul....

waffle almost over........

still got our v40, 11 years old in march, never spent more than £240 in any year on garage servcing,,and that was for a service and cambelt change...even swapped my impreza non-turbo estate for another old v40. this time a 2004 reg. so have 2 now......mine the almost 11 year old one, does 50mile round trips to work, and family trips to Devon with a dog guard to enable family junk to be safely stacked to the roof lining.....hahahaha

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - likerocks

might be stretching the budget but you may just get a corolla verso for £5k. certainly on my test drive list for when my wife goes back to work after 2nd child

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - John F

Ford Focus estate - for all the reasons already mentioned.....plus go for the 1.6 Auto....1.6 is plenty big enough and the auto means it will have had an easier life mechanically - boy racers don't like them - but you probably will, especially in today's stop-start traffic.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Mr Fox

Have you looked at the Renault Grand scenic ? or Vauxhall Zafira ?

Loads of space, very practical interior with the added possibility of 7 seats, very comfortable in the case of the Renault, and easy to manouvre as the visibility is so good, they are also available quite cheaply.

The greatest benefit is the higher seating position, when gettting baby in and out this puts a huge strain on the back, in normal cars as you have to bend right down, these type of higher cars are much better in this regard.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - GolfR_Caravelle_S-Max

With one baby, the BMW 530d Touring (Estate) year 2000 was grand. turning circle smaller than a suzuki ignis, 50mpg, huge boot, parking sensors, leather seats (ideal for catching raisins / vomit etc) lowish tax (£190 p.a.) very quiet and smooth at all speeds. Safe as houses and built in a time when everything was over-engineered for reliability. With two children... add a roofbox for camping trips / family holidays. You should be able to get one for less than £2800 with another 200,000 miles left in it. Ours will be going on autotrader this week.

Edited by Scooby_Ignis on 09/11/2010 at 15:30

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Botchit, Soddem & Leggit

No. 1 advice it avoid 3 doors. It is backbreaking loading an infant into a rear facing car seat sitting on the back seat of a 3-door car. Not to mention getting them out again (once asleep) without waking them up!!

When my first was born we had a 1999 Megane. Sufficient space, but loading child into seat, lifting child onto knee when seated in back seat for comforting, nappy change etc. was very difficult. Since switched to 2004 Scenic. This is much better in these respects. Always been cautious of the large D platform estates (Mondeo, Passat, Octavia etc) because they are very long cars and do not necessarily give that much more usable space.

My recommendation would be to but a compact MPV based on B or C platform (i.e. Modus or Scenic). Basically, short but tall. Not to big about town, plenty of space for the day to day, lots of headroom, lots of storage space. When you need to take heaps of "equipment" on holiday, get yourself a roofbox.

4k-5k to spend, baby on way - what to buy??????!!! - Glenn 42

Surrprised no one has mentioned the old shape Honda Civic, which is a lot taller than the new model and 05 models can be had for 4-5k. A reliable choice if serviced correctly and the tall shape makes it quite practical.