Just to add some balance, I drive an Astra with the 150 CDTI engine and I've had no problems with it over the last 2 years and 19K miles (mostly urban). I drive spiritedly and give the car no special treatment.
Dont forget that most people on the internet complain about cars, very few satisfied people actually post anything so you dont get to hear about the good cars which vastly outnumber the lemons.
Just returned a Vectra 1.8 (not the VVTi) after 4 years and nearly 60k. I've also driven the CDTi 150 and VVTi on hire. I never thought I'd find myself leaping to the defence of the Vectra!
The good stuff is that they are very practical, cheap and pretty comfortable to drive over long distances. Seat goes back a long way so good for tall drivers. CDTI 150 seemed rapid, 1.8 VVTi a bit better than the older 1.8, but seemed to have more engine vibration at motorway cruising, certainly not a giant leap for engine-kind over the old model. I think they're much quieter than some of the smaller cars the OP was thinking of, particularly Focus II.
Bad stuff - clutch is juddery when cold, occasional error from coolant sensor, a few bits of fragile trim. The big one is that they (for me) appeared to be engineered reasonably competently but with absolutely no passion. I can't imagine that somebody sat in the prototype in Russelsheim, looked at the dash and thought, "Yes, I'm really happy with that so I'll sign it off for production".
Would agree with the comments about internet reviews... because it is a known problem does not make it inevitable, or even that common - there are a lot of vectras about, mostly 1.8 petrol or 1.9 diesels too, and the internet tends to get comments from vocal minorities (particularly the extremely unhappy!) - although that's not to say for a moment that people shouldn't report the problems they have.
Because they're common, it does mean that you can shop around, and I think that at auction, an ex-fleet vehicle that's spent its life on the motorway could be an excellent buy.
Lastly, you do get used to the indicator stalks. Trust me.
|