What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Rob_H
Hi,

I'm a photographer and I work a lot in the UK countryside. I've got a particular need this winter to do some scenic stuff. I need to carry a fair amount of kit with me, and I normally camp to save costs when I'm motoring around.

At the moment I have a Golf GTI which is lovely, but severely dented an alloy wheel the other day in a fairly small pothole in Kent. As I'm doing a lot more of this work over the winter, I think I need to treat myself to something which will not break or get stuck in normal UK countryside environments. I've also got the Golf stuck on an unmade road before, which was a bit embarrassing! :S

One of the difficulties is that I am based in London, so there will very significant motorway journeys to wherever I want to get to (Cornwall, Scotland and Wales to name a few), which makes anything like a Defender an unrealistic prospect. However, on the other hand there's little point buying a 'fake' 4x4 or a normal estate car which gets stuck in a Welsh puddle or grounds out on the unmade roads and paths.

As I'm a photographer, I've not got a great amount of money, maybe £2-£5k budget. Anyone have a sensible suggestion? Given that I'm going to be in the middle of nowhere, often at night on my own, it can't break down *ever* and needs to be from a manufacturer with lots of dealerships as I'm probably going to need the occasional thing far from home. I'm not worried about fuel economy or image, this is going to be a work tool and the fuel will be deductible. I'm also not worried about leather seats, air con, CD players, navigation or any mod cons, in many respects the less to go wrong the better.

Many thanks for any suggestions!

Rob

Must haves:
* Good off road ability
* Capable of going on a motorway at 70mph safely
* Reliable
* £3-5k
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - cjehuk
At that budget only sensible options would be a Toyota Landcruiser or a Mitsubishi Shogun. Both will likely be quite old though for that kind of money.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - gordonbennet
Suggest one of the estate cars based on Japanese 4 x 4 pick ups.

Toyota Hilux surf ( 4runner the genuine UK car), or Mitsubishi Shogun Sport..previously badged Challenger.
Many will be grey imports if so they should have been rustproofed at import time, do check.

Or indeed as above go the whole hog and get a Landcruiser, auto's are lovely to drive, get a well maintained one and it simply will not break down.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - 1400ted
I run a Suzuki LWB turbo diesel auto as second car. Just a big estate car, really, with 4wd if needed. Rugged chassis. Cruises at 70 happily and seems to be good on derv, although I don't really check it.
I don't know how wide the dealership base is, probably small compared to others.
It's a 96 and just cost £1400 when I bought it...primarily for towing the caravan... but I prefer to use it all the time now....SWMBO uses the other car.
You could pick up a later Grand Vitara for your budget.
Good hunting.

Ted
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Happy Blue!
For something Golf sized try a Subaru Forester, which is very comfortable, has a low ratio gearbox (in manual versions) and a raised drive height to 200mm.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Lud
Never driven one and the Lada car I had was horrible, but some people speak well of the Lada Niva's ruggedness, simplicity and off-road abilities. You might find a good one well within budget. Just a thought though.

A friend had an Isuzu 4wd with a van-like body (no windows in the rear). It was a non-turbo diesel with a large engine. I liked it a lot.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - stunorthants26
Id second the Suzuki Grand Vitara. My sister has a 1600 cc 3dr which she adores. I can voucn for its performance as I noticed once she had recorded a max speed of 89mph on my sat nav - naughty girl - so 70 would easily be doable in the more powerful diesel. Hers cost her £4500 a few years ago but is barely worth £1800 now. I suspect the 5dr would ride better than the 3dr.
They are also extremely reliable if serviced, more so than many 4x4s, perhaps a legacy of tried and tested mechaincs rather than anything cutting edge.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Nsar
Have a look at a Suzuki Jimny. I once saw one go round a VERY challenging off-road course to the slack jawed amazement of some real hard-core Defender and Discovery fans.

Might not be a barrel of laughs on the motorway but if it's only once in a while no worries and round city streets it will be a doddle to park.

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Lygonos
Forester or old model Grand Vitara.

Forester is far better on road, but GV has the edge for serious 4x4-ing. Both are estate cars, with AWD/4WD respectively.

I've got a Forester Turbo, but if I was offroading a lot I'd get the non-turbo as it has low/high ratio gearbox. The Turbo has a rear LSD but offroading is about control at slow speed rather than 'on-boost'...

Jimny can humble almost any large 4x4 but it is utterly inadequate on Motorways if you want to travel at 70+ mph.

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Harmattan
Some years ago a freelance cameraman with similar requirements to you bought my VW double-cab syncro for broadly your reasons -- go anywhere, cruise at 70 mph, underfloor lockers, working platform and comfortable captain seats. Unfortunately good secondhand ones are going up in price thanks to enthusiasts. You might be lucky to get one in your price range but otherwise I would agree that a Japanese double cab pickup is a good option. However, some photographers I have worked with prefer vans with blackened rear windows for secure carriage of equipment and there are a few syncro vans around. If that is too big I would not rule out a Renault Kangoo 4x4 or even a Peugeot Partner (I think the Escapade has the rough road option pack but not the limited slip diff available in France).
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - gordonbennet
I would agree that a Japanese double cab pickup is a good option.


Probably cheaper too, but they'll have cart sprung rear ends giving a rather hard ride, whether the OP's eqipment would suffer i don't know.
The estates based on the pick ups have coil spring* rear ends and are softer sprung too.
* that's the case with Surf/4runner, i can't guarantee Sport/Challenger but i suspect the same.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - moonshine


How about a front wheel drive with a decent set of mud and snow tyres? Unless you are driving through ploughed fields you should be able to cope with just about anything. Opens up a huge amount of options. You could also invest in a second set of wheels so you have summer and winter sets.

A 2 wheel drive will be much cheaper to run as well. Could be something to consider if you are clocking up a lot of miles.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Rob_H
Thanks for all the answers... much appreciated. Apologies for the long-winded post below!

I don't think I can really afford a Shogun or Landcruiser at that price as they're a bit too tatty/old/high-mileage at anything under the very top of my price range and then it's a bit iffy. If I had about £10k then I would probably go for a Shogun.

The grey import truck based 4x4s worry me a bit. I don't think I could easily guarantee the provenance of the vehicle and I have a feel I'd be unlucky on that front. I can't really gamble with my business funds on something which could have been clocked or stolen and risk losing an asset that way.

I have owned a Subaru Forester, and it was great except for the price of the insurance as it was the turbo version. I sold mine when the last two Subaru dealers within 20 miles went bust. I would probably avoid it for this reason alone as it was a royal pain getting it serviced.

I've tried a Jimny and although perfect price-wise and quite a useful little thing, it's not something I'd go to Scotland in and it would struggle to accommodate a location-shoot rig. As I'm driving 400+ miles on some trips (with only the last 10 off-road - although the last 10 are the most important!) I think it's not big or powerful enough for the motorway. It'd be a great London car though.

Having spent some time in camper vans and variants... the new ones are ok, but for that budget, I'm going to get an unreliable old rust bucket. They also seem artificially highly priced because of the surf crowd / hippy fondness for them.

I spent a lot of time in a Lada Niva in Russia. I think they've all rusted off the road by now.

One of my mates has a Kangoo which he bought new, and it has been a disaster. Breaks constantly and bits fall off it.

I think the best idea so far is the Grand Vitara... I was put off by the image of the old one, so unfairly assumed it was rubbish off-road and would fall over sideways. However, a bit of research on it and it ticks a lot of boxes and the reviews are very positive - I can afford one which is only a few years old with low mileage. A big plus would be folding away the back into a bed shape as it would add another sleeping option in the winter. I'll take a look at a couple to see if they're big enough, but it looks like a good match.

Thanks again - feel free to mention any others you might think of?

Rob
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Westpig
Have a look on You Tube for Suzuki Vitaras going off road. They are amazing things off road and being lighter than many proper 4x4's will in fact sometimes go places they can't.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dimdip
Another vote for the Subaru Forester. The latest version is significantly bigger in every direction, but the outgoing model is more of a small estate with increased ride height. Our two have been utterly reliable. Incidentally, my parents have just upgraded to the new model and are going to be selling their 03 2.0X 125 horsepower model if you are interested.

Edit: D'oh.

Edited by dimdip on 08/11/2009 at 21:05

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - freakybacon
As an owner of a 54 reg Grand Vitara reliability wise I can recommend them. Go for the 5 door 2litre petrol or 2.5 litre v6- & this budget will give the option of the xl7 version with 7 seats. Avoid the ragtop like mine- lots of wind noise and hard work cruising at 70- although all the short wheelbase versions are great in town & offroad.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - 1400ted
Security would be no use with a ragtop of course.
There is a Suzi 4x4 owners club which is free to join.

www.suzuki4x4club.com/

Ted
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - nick
Another vote for a Forester. Once out of warranty, why do you need a main dealer for servicing? Any decent indy will do the job, they're easy enough to work on.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - ijws15
How about a Passat 4motion or Octavia Scout?

Estates as well.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dieseldogg
Or even an Octavia 4 by 4 estate, should give 40plus mpg
simples,
Is the Scout 4wd or merely jacked up /dressed up?
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - MVP
Another vote for a non-turbo Forester - any indi should be able to service it

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - legacylad
I posted on here quite recently about falling Subaru values.
Recently there was for sale locally a '55 plate 2.5 Outback @ £3995. After a month, the owner reduced this to offers around £3495, at which it sold. It was in pristine condition, with 4 good tyres, long MOT, short tax, but, the wrong spec..green, no leather or sunroof. No towbar either, which was a good sign! It did have 117k miles, but full Subaru main dealer service history.
None of my 3 previous Subarus have ever been near a main dealer, being purchased at 3 years old and serviced by a trusted independent, so the close proximity of a dealer is irrelevant.
Maybe you should consider buying one of these privately. Excellent, reliable workhorse with reasonable ground clearance.
Hope this helps.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - billythechid
I've a 55 plate Outback 2.5 SE. Bought at 90k in May now at nearly 110k. Mine tows trailers down deep rutted tracks and into muddy fields and often covers 400 miles in a day at 35 mpg.

Only thing needed so far have been two tyres and a service. No doubt it will need brakes and new bushes at some point but hopefully nothing much other than lots of fresh oil and appropriate filters.

Suzuki Vitara.....mmm no thanks!
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - OldSock
Nissan X-Trail?

Assorted reliability scare stories, but pretty well suited to your needs.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - 1400ted
This looks nice, I'm very tempted to trade the old girl in against it
Not far from home for me...and on LPG as well !

tinyurl.com/ygdjprf

Ted
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - NowWheels
The Suzuki Grand Vitara seems to get good marks for its off-road abilities, and the two people i know who own 7-year-old examples of them are v pleased ... but according to the review on the 4Car website it did very badly in the JD Power survey of owner satisfaction. I'd suggest checking that out before buying.

If I was in the OP's shoes, I'd be looking strongly at a Jap import. A modest mileage 3-door Mistubishi Pajero (aka Shogun) can be imported and placed on the road here for less than £4K. Having imported a campervan from Japan (through Algy's Autos), I'm very pleased with the deal I got and with the excellent condition of the vehicle: the Japanese don't use salt on their road and maintain their vehicles very well.

See www.algysautos.com/Pajero__SWB_28.html
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - gordonbennet
NowWheels...was your motorhome rustproofed upon arrival in the UK?

Japanese home market cars are not very well protected from the salty elements at all, and need rustproofing quickly.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - piston power
Nissan terano lwb 2.7 diesel these engines run very well and are cheap enough for your budget, besides if it gets too cold sleep inside with the seats down!

Or a good old landrover 110 station wagon again a good engine and reliable not fast but it's a landy.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - legacylad
The OP stated 'very significant motorway journeys' thus ruling out the Defender...for 6 months I ran a 90 and even the short journey from Lancaster to Penrith was awful. It got the bug out of my system though.
Two of my friends run Grand Vitaras, and although proving reliable, are not somewhere that neither they, nor I, would wish to spend several hours on the motorway.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - stunorthants26
>>Two of my friends run Grand Vitaras, and although proving reliable, are not somewhere that neither they, nor I, would wish to spend several hours on the motorway.<<

That is the nature of the 4x4s which have proper off-raod ability in this price range. A Range Rover is the best of both worlds, but then they cost a fortune to run, especially a well used example within the budget.

Ive thought about this a bit more though - how about a RAV 4? They have better road manners than most, but then it depends how far off road the OP wants to go - if it is proper off the beaten track, then a certain level of sacrifice to on road comfort has to be made.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dimdip
I would maintain that the Forester fits the bill. The RAV4 is at the very softest end of soft-roaders; some aren't even 4WD, IIRC? I drove a 980-mile round-trip in a Forester the other week and it was fine under all circumstances, while retaining proper off-road capability. It also has the facility to lay the seats flat for sleeping. (How am I selling it? Missed my calling . . .)

Edited by dimdip on 12/11/2009 at 17:01

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - stunorthants26
Only thing that stopped me recommending the Forester was firstly the requirement for good off-road ability - its not a proper off-roader, its a muddly lane car and secondly, its quite thirsty unless driven like a vicar.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dimdip
However, muddy lane / unsurfaced roads ability is exactly what the OP requires. It does have low ratio, plus proper offroad tyres. OP also states that economy is not a primary consideration since it is deductable.

[Still available btw, immaculate, 45k mi fsh etc ;) ]

Edited by dimdip on 12/11/2009 at 17:45

Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - Cabusa
Had exactly your problem through the 90`s early 20`s lugging TV cameras/men around various stately home parks for equestrian events.

I used a Ford Sierra 2.0 DOHC 4x4 Estate, which was brilliant across country (the LSD system made a monkey out of Range Rovers). However you have to be realistic about ruts.

Bought a Subaru Legacy in 2000 to replace it - very similar spec, but I didn`t like it as much as the Ford, not so good on motorways (less grunt, too short-geared for comfy 90 mph cruise) - so kept Ford until 2007/250,000 miles. If you could find a good one your problems are over. If!

Being realistic, I think your best bet would be a Legacy/Outback around 5 years old; I`ve still got mine, the wife tows her horses around with it. They ARE astonishingly reliable, even if the MWay noise is too high for me - but a lot better than e.g my current Ford Focus (or - a VW Golf?). I`m now beginning to quite like the Legacy!

Remember the Forester is basically a jumped up Impreza - on the same chassis, think Ford Escort - Subaru are not as good as Ford at conforming cars for max space. My daughter just bought a Legacy to replace a Forester when her second child arrived.

Be interested to know how you get on. I`m on a similar quest, but worries about the huge potential costs of modern hi-tech diesels puts me off anything like that from VW, Skoda, Audi and just about any other estate derived 4x4 car from recent years.

Don`t know anything about breeze-blocks or mini breeze blocks; none seem to add up on cost/utilty grounds (but Suzuki????)

I`ll probably go for a Subaru Outback with lo-ratio and LPG conversion; IF I can find one!

Good luck,

AS


Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dimdip
>>Being realistic, I think your best bet would be a Legacy/Outback>>

They are surprisingly long, though ? I wouldn't relish the prospect of having to parallel park one in London, where the OP is based.

>>Remember the Forester is basically a jumped up Impreza - on the same chassis >>

... and nothing wrong with that. If the OP is currently using a Golf, I'm sure a Forester would be big enough.

[Climate control, CD player, adjustable headlamps . . . ]
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - stunorthants26
If fuel cost isnt a consideration, id go for an early 90's V8 Range Rover - for that budget you could get a very sorted example, plus you get a totally comfortable long distance crusier aswell.
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - dimdip
I think the OP wrote something like "it can't break down *ever*"



[£3650 ovno. Can deliver.]
Budget 4x4 advice anyone? - skittles
how about a Kia Sportage, I have seen a 05 model for £5500, I do not know what the off road capabilities are but they seem OK, my cousin has one on their farm, but they use it as a road car

Another one is the Hyundi Santafe, a 54 reg one is about £4000, nice car, OK on muddy fields although not to muddy. Had one on hire in Iceland, was fine on snow

How about a Rav 4, 52 plate for about £5000

Edited by skittles on 12/11/2009 at 20:37