What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
I think some of my friends and I are going through the beginnings of a mid life crisis, but whatever it is, we have this embryonic idea to have a 4x4 adventure holiday...but do it ourselves. We're serious about it, it's not just pub talk. It started off as lads only, but a couple of wives want in, so even though mine isn't overly convinced, it's looking like 5 or 6 couples, all in their own vehicles or maybe 1 or 2 vehicles with a couple of mates in it and 3 or 4 with couples.

The idea would be to aim for a trip in 2 years time, the likely venue would be North Africa using a ferry from Southern Spain...(after doing all the appropriate research re safety, overnight stop venues, fuel locations, etc). Some want full on camping, although some (inc me) are more keen on hotels and similar.

It would not be meant as a full on, serious, expert off road trip, but would no doubt involve a fair amount of rough roads etc..hence the 4x4 option.

So....what to do it in?

Most people are prepared to buy something for the occasion and sell it afterwards. I am torn with that (prepared to do so), but wonder if i could combine the trip vehicle with something i'd keep afterwards as retirement looms in a few years and i plan to be in the back end of Devon, somewhere well rural, so a 4x4 as a runabout would be a reasonable option, to keep as a second car, with us regularly updating my wife's car for long journeys etc. So do i buy something old for the trip, then sell afterwards...or..go a bit newer and keep afterwards. I'm not at all 'hands on' with mechanics, but others on the trip are.

My brother advocates a 15-20 year old Landcruiser (he's a mechanic and planning to join us). I was thinking a bit newer, if i'm going to keep it afterwards.

My first thoughts were to spend about £5K on: Discovery/Range Rover/Land Cruiser/ Patrol/ Shogun/Jeep....all diesel and manual....and pick something up from an auction i.e. whatever was sensible at the time...but little bruv has vehemently advised against a Land Rover product, even though i'd have him go right through it first.

My second thoughts are to have something a bit 'nicer' as i'd keep it afterwards and we're not planning on going on a full scale rally, so apart from the odd mishap they shouldn't get completely trashed....so would maybe stretch to say £7K or £8K, but what to have?... Land Cruisers hold their value well, LR's can be unreliable, not sure about the Jeep....which has left me looking at Nissan Patrol's, they're cheaper than Land Cruisers, but seemingly well built and reliable (the UN have enough of them).. how about a good specced Patrol to fulfil both criteria?

What do you people think? Which vehicle should it be? Anyone done something similar before? Any obvious pitfalls that a bunch of amateurs would be bound to fall in? I don't mind some honest feedback. The only thing is, we're not really looking for an organised thing with a company doing it all for us.

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Old Navy
My only experence of real off roading was in Australia, If your life depends on your wheels, Toyota every time.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - retgwte


www.fiatforum.com/panda-new/207382-panda-sahara-ii...l

bloke has taken a panda to the sahara and is planning to do the same again, maybe worth swapping ideas with him or others who have actually done this

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Altea Ego
Two options

1/ Buy the cheapest Toyota hilux or any other toyota ute you can get , one that has two month MOT left and wont pass. Drive it to your North african destination and sell it for dollars in Marakesh and fly home.

2/ buy a 3 year old mitsubushi l200 with a truckman top, and drive out and back and keep it in the uk.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - gordonbennet
AE has a good point about selling in North Africa after making use for the trip, a lot of old Hilux's and similar go to Nigeria and other countries.

Only trouble with all that is you'll probably be in a poor way after the pounding you'll get from such a vehicle over thousands of miles of rough terrain, you want to enjoy yourselves too.

Nothing wrong with a good auto box in either Landcruiser or Patrol, and you will probably find more choice with the auto option.

The toughest Landcruiser Amazon is the 105 which is basically the 100 series that we know from from about 98 to 2007 with proper steel spring suspension and a live front axle...thats the model used by the UN and the one anybody in really hostile terrain uses.

Unfortunately they are grey imports only as the European spec model is the 100 with independent front suspension (air susp all round) and normal front drive shafts, don't get the idea these are not tough enough, but they can be broken if you try hard enough whereas the 105 will not break.

The LC5's predessessor the Colorado/LC4 would be well up to the job too, it's got the 3 litre 4 pot Diesel and very robust that is too....steel sprung all round, but indy front again.

Patrol's are as you say very good value, and are tough as old boots, for some reason they don't hold the price of the Landcruiser, and i'm at a loss as to why, as they will cope just as well.

There's some good 4x4 forums around and you'll get some good advice where to get obvious and fairly affordable stuff like sump/transmission underbody guards and rock sliders, and uprated springs/dampers.

I confess i would want to stick with either of these makes/models for this trip.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - BobbyG
I would be tempted to go to the lower end of the market, that way if it gets damaged on your trip or proves unreliable then you may be able to sell on your return and not lose a lot.
On the other hand, if you spend 2 or 3 grand on it, and it survives your trip without a blemish then you will want to keep it as it will have proved its reliability to you.

Spend a lot more and it won't be as much of a fun trip, you will always be being wary about your new car that you are planning to keep.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - NARU
Having lived in Kenya, I'd go for either a landcruiser, or a mk2 shogun. [Or a hilux pickup or a Surf - essentially the same thing, just different bodies].

If you want something offbeat, you try a landrover 101, but spares can be hard to find.

If you're interested in Landrovers, try frogs island or nene 4x4

Edited by Marlot on 02/09/2009 at 21:08

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - gordonbennet
Forgot to say in the previous post, the Landcruiser Amazon 80 (up to97) was the strongest for European market, live axles all steel suspension and if you could find one of those with low mileage they can last a long time with a bit of care, very tough.

Rereading your buying choices, if you are going for a keeper don't cross off the petrol version, many Amazons and petrol Colorado's have been lpg converted and the V8 (V6 in Col) engines are sublime...should be some cheap farm lpg sites in Devon too.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - SuperBuyer
I'd second the Shogun, pick up one for around the £2k mark, or an older Patrol, the 4.2 if you can find it...

Or how about a Shogun Sport?
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - ForumNeedsModerating
I wouldn't go the ownership route - I'd hire. Lots of UK companies offer 4x4 for overseas travel - you may pay £2000-2500 for a month or so, but that's your limit of your exposure.
The 'no worries' route I'd say.

If really don't need a 4x4 now, why persuade yourself you'll need one because you've 'got to buy' one for the holiday?
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
If really don't need a 4x4 now why persuade yourself you'll need one because you've 'got to buy' one for the holiday?


holiday won't be too far away from when i'd consider buying one as I will want one eventually anyway...it's just whether or not I keep the one i'd use on the holiday
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson
I don't know about midlife, but it looks like a crisis where the aim is to impress the even less adventurous at home while avoiding inconvenience away. Any group which can't decide between camping and hotels will not be camping, and is therefore after sanitised adventure with Macdonalds and air conditioning. A Panda should do for that, but the pre-packaged option with American Express and mobile phone coverage would be simpler.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Derfel
As you are intending on going to Spain, make sure you do not buy the Pajero variant of the Mitsubishi Shogun. Explanation below:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitsubishi_Pajero

And no offence intended!
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - jc2
Just make sure you don't use any ex-WD Land Rovers still in camouflage.My daughter got involved with a firm that was going to organize safaris in North Africa.They had a selection of vehicles-the Range Rovers were allowed in but anything looking the slightest warlike was banned.

Edited by jc2 on 03/09/2009 at 14:55

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
I don't know about midlife but it looks like a crisis where the aim is to impress the even less adventurous at home while avoiding inconvenience away. Any group which can't decide between camping and hotels will not be camping and is therefore after sanitised adventure with Macdonalds and air conditioning. A Panda should do for that but the pre-packaged option with American Express and mobile phone coverage would be simpler.

>>

that's a tad harsh William. How about a group of friends that have kept up their friendships for over 25 years since schooldays...fancy a holiday that's a bit different and has a degree of adventure and sort it out yourself, but doesn't want to take on too much, worried that their naivety might get them into trouble. I'm not aware that anyone gives two hoots about what others think. As for not being able to decide whether to camp or hotel, it's not a case of that, it's just that there are fairly polarised opinions, even at this early stage i.e. they can all decide, but the decisions don't coincide...so the initial thoughts are probably a bit of both...(so you can have a good meal and a scrub when it's hotel night)... although the hotelists, might win that arguement. Still got to be a more adventurous holiday than the average Costa del Wotsit package tour, even if purists turn their noses up.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson


As it 'appens, now then, now then, I was with a university friend of 39 years duration climbing in the Pyrenees last week.
that's a tad harsh William. How about a group of friends that have kept up
their friendships for over 25 years since schooldays.


The thing is, in the event that this trip does come off, the people that are strongly polarised into the hotel persuasion will definitely not be camping. Believe it or not, there actually are people who believe that camping is an unconscionable adventure in itself. Therefore, if they are to come along, it will have to be pretend off-roading- proper roads, but with some sand patches. There was a TV comedy some years ago in which the kitted up adventurers in bedouin dress or camo, with ladders and kitchen sinks aboard the gas-guzzling monstrosity would declare 'let's OFF ROAD!!', before venturing onto Chelsea High St.

I suppose we should be grateful the plans don't include any of the UK green lanes from which we haven't yet managed to ban 4WDs.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - alfatrike
that, my friend was the fast show, and this were they.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbPERR2aybc

and

www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNybnRkj-MY&feature=related

and so on.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson
Excellent. Thankyou. Exactly what I had in mind.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
I suppose we should be grateful the plans don't include any of the UK green
lanes from which we haven't yet managed to ban 4WDs.


i'd be prepared to take a 4x4 up a green lane....are they not for all to use....
responsibly. Who says some can use and some cannot?
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
Therefore if they are to come along it will have to be pretend off-roading- proper
roads but with some sand patches. There was a TV comedy some years ago in
which the kitted up adventurers in bedouin dress or camo with ladders and kitchen >>sinks aboard the gas-guzzling monstrosity would declare 'let's OFF ROAD!!' before >>venturing onto Chelsea High St.


So not an overly helpful post then, for someone seeking advice and maybe another angle for a holiday....presumably because it isn't raw enough for your tastes? Does that mean rudeness should apply? It's horses for courses isn't it. I wouldn't fancy a holiday in a city, but plently do and enjoy it, what does it matter to me, why should I sneer at their enjoyment?
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - alfatrike
in all honesty go for a landy, 110 preferably. more space for stuff and you can sleep in it if you have to. you can get bits nearly everywhere on the face of the planet and if you can't fix it, a local with a gas torch and a hammer will.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - the swiss tony
So not an overly helpful post then for someone seeking advice and maybe another
angle for a holiday....presumably because it isn't raw enough for your tastes? Does that mean
rudeness should apply? It's horses for courses isn't it. I wouldn't fancy a holiday in
a city but plently do and enjoy it what does it matter to me why
should I sneer at their enjoyment?


Reread it WP....

you yourself said 'Some want full on camping, although some (inc me) are more keen on hotels and similar.'

I think William was trying to be funny, but I do agree with he that IF there are people in your group who dont relish the idea of camping, then they MAY not go through with it - or at least spoil the enjoyment of those who do like camping....
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson
So not an overly helpful post then


On the contrary- it was a helpful post, but different! There are more than enough people recommending various types of " let's off road!" gas-guzzler, but I was suggesting that for the group as described a Panda would be quite good enough. It is not helpful to encourage a delusion, and it's going to be difficult to get far into the wilds when you have to get back to the hotel for tiffin, and the party isn't prepared for a night out when things go wrong.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - NARU
I suppose we should be grateful the plans don't include any of the UK green
lanes from which we haven't yet managed to ban 4WDs.

Those are vehicular rights of way. There are not very many of them, and walkers have very many miles of other places they can legitimately go.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson
Those are vehicular rights of way.


They are not inviolable rights of way. You will find that there are some in the National Parks and elsewhere where 4WD access has been rightly banned. Foot, bike and horse are the legitimate modes of passage for these historic tracks. In the same vein, motorised water travel at greater than 10mph has been banned throughout the Lake District.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - legacylad
Wanderlust issue 106 (October 2009)
Book of the Month...Best of the Rest....Chris Scott's 'Morocco Overland' Trailblazer Guides £15.99...''the brand new bible for off-roading to and across this corner of North Africa, with 49 routes covering 10,000 km.''
Hope this helps
regards.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
....Chris Scott's 'Morocco Overland' Trailblazer Guides £15.99...''the brand new
bible for off-roading to and across this corner of North Africa with 49 routes covering
10 000 km.''



Sounds ideal, thank you....and thanks to all the sensible responses by others above, as well.
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Sofa Spud
If you need two vehicles, how about a Land Rover Defender and a Toyota Landcruiser.
The Landcruiser can tow the Defender when it breaks down and the Defender can pull the Landcruiser out when it gets stuck!

Actually, rather than offer advice on what to buy (my choice would be Land Rover Defender), can I suggest that if you have two vehicles, they are both of the same type.
That way you need to carry fewer spares and it's easier to familiarise the combined mechanical brainpower of the team with a single vehicle design.

Edited by Sofa Spud on 04/09/2009 at 20:10

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Lygonos
Could always put a Suzuki Jimny in the LC's boot for when a 'tow-out' is required ;-)
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Martin Devon
Could always put a Suzuki Jimny in the LC's boot for when a 'tow-out' is
required ;-)

I do like that. Very much in fact as I've just bought an auto. Goes anywhere and towed a transit (non runner) out of a very muddy field.

Wouldn't want to kip in it though!! No not the field you fools.

MD
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Sofa Spud
QUOTE:...""Those are vehicular rights of way. There are not very many of them, and walkers have very many miles of other places they can legitimately go."" .....and motorists have many thousands of miles of properly surfaced roads to drive on!!!

The vehicular rights can be extinguished, as has happened on some local green lanes in my area. The problem is that the irresponsible element among 4x4 users churn up the surface, making the lane impassable - even for other 4x4 users, let alone walkers or mountain bikers.

I used to go green laning when I had a Land Rover so I know the situation. When 'laning was a hobby for a small band of enthusiasts in old Land Rovers it wasn't much of a problem but the popularity grew and people started using modified vehicles with super-aggressive tyres. The council had a novel solution to one green lane in the area which was badly damaged by 4x4s, trail bikes and horses - they surfaced it - so now you can drive along it in a Ford Fiesta if you want to!!!

Edited by Sofa Spud on 04/09/2009 at 20:20

Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - William Stevenson
The vehicular rights can be extinguished as has happened on some local green lanes


This is interesting. My post supporting this abolition of vehicular rights and expressing a desire that 4WDs disappear off to old industrial sites or East Anglia or the South appeared and then got disappeared leaving no trace, presumably as a result of some pro-4WD decree by No 2 (cf The Prisoner). Maybe you have to expect this on a motoring site. Lets see what happens to this one!
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Westpig
William,

If I remember rightly, there were a load of asterix's at the bit where you suggested they vacate and travel somewhere else. Maybe you breached the site's swearing policy? Maybe a Mod thought you were a tad abrasive on a site known for its' good manners?
Ideas on an appropriate 4x4 - Brian Tryzers
As it 'appens, now then, now then, I was with a university friend of 39 years' duration climbing in the Pyrenees last week.

Gosh, William, that's an awful lot of retakes. Or were the Mountaineering Society's trips just too good to leave behind?
};---)