What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Long term caretaking - k9dan
After the great Sedona story, settled on a new Octavia 1.9 PD 105hp, have looked at the HJ running in advice. I am looking to run this a long time 10yrs +, hence I chose the PD over the CR diesels. It will go onto variable service intervals which might mean up to 2 years before first oil change. Bit worried this is too long even with the fancy factory fill 507.0 spec oil.
HJ recommends running on factory fill oil for first year. To be honest I'm a bit old fashioned and like regular 6 month oil changes. Am I behind the times now and is that uneccessary?
Would I be better changing oil at one year with the special 507.0 spec oil, and every year? or six months after? Any other hints for looking after the PD engines? Body work should be fine as galvanised, anything else to keep eye on longterm apart from usual wear and tear items, (tyres, brakes etc)
Got a bit of a tear in me eye for the old motor going to scrappage, 14 yr old petrol Galaxy 120k original clutch, engine never been cracked open, but needs to much to pass next MOT, needs about a grand spent on it, plus Skoda gave me 3.5k on scrappage, too good to refuse really.
Long term caretaking - J1mbo
Hi, 50 reads and no reply, well here's my view for what its worth.
After the great Sedona story settled on a new Octavia 1.9 PD 105hp have looked
at the HJ running in advice. I am looking to run this a long time
10yrs + hence I chose the PD over the CR diesels.


I'd go for petrol, Derv very compex and if the DMF or something needs doing further down the line, might be very costly 90% of all the issues I see on the web relate to dervs, petrol seems more established and proven. Just my view.

>>It will go onto
variable service intervals which might mean up to 2 years before first oil change.


That's right, I agree its quite a long time, but what mileage do you do?

HJ recommends running on factory fill oil for first year.

What else would you use?????

>>To be honest I'm a
bit old fashioned and like regular 6 month oil changes. Am I behind the times
now and is that uneccessary?


Now't wrong with doing that but do wait until the first oil change is due, if on fixed servicing that would be 1 year. Then you could do 6 monthly changes, still using the top spec oil.

I gather it would be a manual, make sure you look after the paint work and it should last you well.
Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
I too would be setting my sights at more regular oil changes than the high mileages we now hear about...wonder oil or not.

For long term i'd also be donning my overalls and coating the underside in one of the good quality semi hardening underbody protections paying special attention to all suspension parts, not as they'll rust through, but it'll give you that warm glow when you pop under at 3 years old and everythings still covered in a tar like paint and not rusty marks.

Admit i cheated here, and had the pick up fully rustproofed by the pro's, my excuse being me bad back...oh and i could afford it..;)

Plus if you need any shockers, bushes etc replacing at say 5 years they'll undo easier.

If the exhaust shows evidence of rusting, rub down and coat with heatprof paint.

Good car, with care it'll last many years.

Many owners think all this is a waste of time, but then few keep their cars full life term.
Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
The benefits don't seem overwhelming

"not as they'll rust through, but it'll give you that warm glow when you pop under at 3 years old and everythings still covered in a tar like paint and not rusty marks"

So a cosmetic effect then.

"if you need any shockers, bushes etc replacing at say 5 years they'll undo easier"

Unless do your own servicing someone elses's problem.

"If the exhaust shows evidence of rusting, rub down and coat with heatproof paint"

Exhausts rust form inside out - a coat of a paint won't help.

I doubt whether a car will suffer from serious structural corrosion within ten years, rust proofing or no. Probably more important to pay attention to the bodywork and ensure any damage is promptly repaired
Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
I doubt whether a car will suffer from serious structural corrosion within ten years rust


The important part of the OP was 10+ years..all cars will probably last up to 10 bodywise.

The OP wants to care for his car, if you want to neglect yours thats fine and you pays your money, he was asking for suggestions for long life.
Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
I am simply unconvinced that the so called rustproofing of a new car is a worthwhile investment.

There is no convincing evidence that it will make any difference whatsoever to the life of a new car and is therefore in my view simply a waste of money and time. I would also wonder about the effect it may have on any manufacturers warranty

To maximise the life of a car:
Service it regularly
Wash it regularly and give it an occasional wax and polish
Repair any damaged bodywork promptly.

Long term caretaking - adverse camber
"if you need any shockers bushes etc replacing at say 5 years they'll undo easier"
Unless do your own servicing someone elses's problem.


not really. As an example which may apply to this specific case : Say the pinch bolt siezes on the top suspension joint (I think that the octavia shares the A4 overcomplicated design), I've seen several cases where the whole suspension strut needed to be replaced due to the clamp part breaking when attempting removal of the bolt. That isnt cheap.
Long term caretaking - ifithelps
Perceived wisdom seems to be the first oil must be left in for 12 months/12,000miles to promote a little engine wear to aid bedding in.

If not, the engine could remain 'tight', which is definitely to be avoided.

I think annual oil changes should be enough, or 12,000miles, whichever is sooner, unless you are doing nothing other than chugging around town.

Some of these PD engines seem to use a drop of oil anyway, so you might find you are changing it litre by litre.

Long term caretaking - Waino
My mate has been running his 1.9 diesel (I assume PD) Octavia estate from new - it's a 2001 Y reg and is now on over 180k miles. He has a daily commute of about 80 miles down the A14. So far, afaik, it has only need a light bulb replacing. Very early on, he noticed some rust on the load door and it was replaced under warranty. He has it regularly serviced by the dealer - so I assume that's all done to the book. He just wants a reliable car, he isn't a petrolhead (or dieselhead!) and he is perfectly happy with the car.

I am seriously considering replacing the old Mondy with one of these - where did you get yours, k9dan?

Long term caretaking - J1mbo
Might i also suggest the OP gets some paint protection film fitted on the bumper and other parts prone to stone chips. Use of a good wax/sealant will help the paint stay fresh and make it easier to clean. Maybe some good fabric protector for the inside, rubber boot liner and keeping the alloys clean. All helps and adds up to a car looking nice and new.

I think the way the car is driven is also important, reduce the short journeys, taking it for a long run if you do commute locally. etc.....
Long term caretaking - oilrag
The chap who owns this vehicle polishes waxes and washes.
touches up bodywork and so on.

It`s just four years old

www.oilrag.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/rusty1.jpg

It`s `twinned` with a rusty old oil drum at the tip - but the owner hasn`t realized it yet.

(waxing, polishing and washing the upper body does nothing to extend vehicle life)

GB is right

Edited by oilrag on 16/08/2009 at 14:22

Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
Tried to upload a few piccies of the underside of the now pro rustproofed Hilux, hope it works....the link and the rustproofing..;)

tinyurl.com/lecl8n
tinyurl.com/lutu2j
tinyurl.com/m7thk4
tinyurl.com/np2dy3
tinyurl.com/krcy25


Pic 3 should be almost the same chassis part as Oily's pic above.
Pic 5 was the nsf suspension and brake caliper after 2 winters i think, possibly 1 and a half.
I rubbed down and painted the offending parts including the calipers earlier this year, remember this vehicle gets hosed off regularly during the winter, so goodness knows what a neglected example looks like.

The truck is 2 years old in 2 weeks.

Edited by gordonbennet on 16/08/2009 at 15:24

Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
One more showing a now treated osf suspension...rustproofing carried out about 1 month ago by the way


tinyurl.com/nvc2xv

Edited by gordonbennet on 16/08/2009 at 15:30

Long term caretaking - ifithelps
gb,

The rust proofed finish reminds me of the new Mini subframes we used to fit regularly or a reconditioned radiator.

Edited by ifithelps on 16/08/2009 at 16:20

Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
It's just four years old

And no doubt good for another 6 at least. I would bet good money that the reason the car is eventually scrapped will be mechanical or electrical failure, the cost of repair which exceeds the car's value and not structural corrosion.

Not worth worrying about and certainly not worth spending money on expensive rust proofing treatements.

It is worth taking care of the bodywork because this is largely what decides the car's resale value.

Long term caretaking - oilrag
I enjoyed those photos GB - a good professional job well worth the money.

Meanwhile in windy West Yorkshire.

www.oilrag.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/rusty2.jpg
Long term caretaking - oilrag
GB, Don`t you actually deliver some new cars with rust already eating into the nether regions?
Long term caretaking - oilrag
"And no doubt good for another 6 at least."

Cgn, These are irreplaceable diesels though without DPF`s. The last fully functional (short trips without problems diesels. As such they are likely to be worth fitting expensive parts even as old vehicles.

Particularly in a motor like GB`s with a relatively high price. you would have to be nuts (IMHO;-) to play tiddly winks while a vehicle of that caliber rusts away its chassis.

Even my £7,400 van..... cough.................
Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
Cgn, These are irreplaceable diesels though without DPF`s. The last fully functional (short trips without problems diesels. As such they are likely to be worth fitting expensive parts even as old vehicles.

I'd like to think so as I own one but realistically the value of a a 12 year old Octavia II is likely to be about the same as a 12 year old Octavia I i.e about £500. A requirement for a new clutch or even a cambelt will see them on the way to the scrapyard however good the "rustproofing".

Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
Meanwhile in windy West Yorkshire.


Runners or cabbage?..;)

Strange how some folk will never see the wood for the trees, the 55 plate 4x4 in your pic won't make another 6 years because of sheer neglect, though it will shine quite nicely as it descends into the crusher.

However the heavily greased Punto with it's now superclean breathing will be trundling around for donkeys years, apart from getting a bit mucky i know which vehicle i'd rather try to replace the shockers on, the rust bucket 4x4's bolts will in all likelihood snap off, that'll be fun for some poor blighter.

Your brake pipes will last the life of the car, and the flexi's will come undone without seizing onto the pipe should you need to change them too, but you already know that and have taken a bit of effort to thwart the tin worm.

Incidentally most older pick ups are destroyed by the tin worm, and the pick up body cross members in your pic will rust through in the next year, if you zoom in you can see the state of them already. A ton bag of sand in the back will most likely end up on the road.

Carry on Oily, your in good company..;)

Edit...yes i do see rusty suspension parts and exhausts often...and stains from more concerning parts on one or two the make of which slips my poor mind..;)
Oh yes Oily..no DPF and no DMF...

Edited by gordonbennet on 16/08/2009 at 16:03

Long term caretaking - Pugugly
It was touched upon above - check the oik regularly in the first few months - the PD engine on the Skoda used a fair amount of oil in the fist couple of thousand miles and then settled to none. Make sure you use VAG recommended oil.
Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
The PD engine on the Skoda used a fair amount of oil in the first couple of thousand miles and then settled to none.

Mine followed the same pattern - Initially a little alarmed by how much oil used in the first 6,000 mile but at 20,000 oil use minimal. Engine definitely becomes more economical post 10,000 miles.
Long term caretaking - oilrag
It`s the 1.9D, now without the EGR, GB. Did you see the thread in tech?
Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
. Did you see the thread in tech?


I did Oily, but i've never got too involved with the breathing apparatus, thats however likely to change as the pick up is bound to have some form of EGR.

Maybe the Millers has kept them clean over the years, and i'll carry on with the 'snake oil' till i find different..;)

The BMW 320d in our family went into a recommended indy specialist few weeks ago to have the inlet manifold flaps removed, they also cleaned out the EGR and replaced the lower engine breather during this job for a very reasonable cost.
The engine in question is known to ingest the flaps and or their securing screws with catastrophic results.

The feedback i'm getting is that the car is just as driveable without them at all revs, so quite why they fit stuff like this is beyond me, but then much is these days.

Ifithelps,
yes it does look like chassis paint now it's dried out but it's pro waxoyl underbody paint, thickly applied and doesn't dry hard.
My chassis was in very good condition before, any signs of rust appearing were treated as and when.
I would have had the car treated when new but we wanted to be sure it was a for life vehicle before the investment..as it is swmbo loves it to bits so it's here for good, should be interesting experiment whether in careful maintenance (over), rustproofing, millers, allowing to cool down/warm up etc really do lead to a long trouble free life.
The rustproofers would like to top up the treatment every 3 or so years and that will happen.

As an aside the chap that treated the vehicle said ours was only the second vehicle he'd never had to steam clean underneath before treating (aprt from brand new), that would be apparent from these threads too.


Edited by gordonbennet on 16/08/2009 at 17:01

Long term caretaking - oilrag
"but realistically the value of a a 12 year old Octavia II is likely to"

What does market value matter though at 12 yrs Cg? Some cars will be rust buckets underneath needing new subframes and worse. Others will be like new from rustproofing and will likely have a greatly enhanced life *if the owner wishes it.*

Without his efforts - agreed he likely has a pile of junk - hence £500 book value - as that`s typical care. Or rather lack of it, that turns a car into a pile of junk in 12 years

I think that applies to extended service intervals too. I`ve been reading very interesting results (survey) over on Freds TDI forum on PD engines regarding oil and cam wear.

Wheres the evidence? (anticipating ifithelps) You can`t find it because few people take cars into the extended life zone made possible by extra care.

I would say the classic car scene gives `some` examples. If book values determined car lifespan there would be mostly an empty void pre 1997.

Edited by oilrag on 16/08/2009 at 17:36

Long term caretaking - CGNorwich
I'm afraid that whatever you do to a car its value will be largely determined by its age and mileage. Looked upon as an economic investment, time and money spent on rustproofing is likely to be money down the drain. Few people take cars into the "extended life zone" you mention simply for that reason i.e its not economically worthwhile. I do appreciate that you like messing about with the underside of cars and thats great if you enjoy it but I don't think it makes any economic sense.
Long term caretaking - oilrag
Here is a link to the thread on Freds TDI forum, where i was reading this morning on oil choice and PD engine longevity - or more specifically the cams and followers.
Must be `peak time` very slow loading just now.

tinyurl.com/mnf4ob

Edit

forums.tdiclub.com/showthread.php?t=237678

Edited by oilrag on 16/08/2009 at 18:41

Long term caretaking - gordonbennet
Here is a link to the thread on Freds TDI forum where i was reading
this morning on oil choice and PD engine longevity -


That makes interesting reading Oily, the results are predictable and confirm our thoughts.

Some of the cam failed engine's oil change intervals are frankly laughable, and false economy.
Long term caretaking - k9dan
Hi Bud, previously had a 1.8d Mondy good car but not greatly economical (38 mpg whether caned or not) got from local dealer in Hamilton, SKoda doing 3.5k scrappage on all the pd's as they are pushing the new CR engine. Thanks to everyone else for posting I will probably run along the brake lines with waterproof grease, after seeing the Punto greased up might do the rest when I'm there. Would probably have went for a petrol owing the new diesel durability, but the big scrappage was on the PD's. It gives me a grand up plus better economy till something happens.
Long term caretaking - oilrag
K9, That`s my Punto and it`s Castrol CL waterproof grease (Halfords)

GB, Agree about about the oil. Some seemed to be saying it was more evident with 5w30 instead of 5w40 and that a different oil at every change could be a factor..wonder if that`s a sign of being lax with the actual spec?

Those specs required for PD and then further spec changes to protect the new DPF`s..

It seems a nightmare to me.

Edited by oilrag on 16/08/2009 at 22:05

Long term caretaking - bell boy
i always find it amazing that those in the motortrade always look after their vehicles undersides
and those that probably chew on pens all day would prefer to pay high labour rates to have seized components removed at their expense when mot time comes
well done gb by the way and nice pictures
k9dan well done for considering a long term plan
Long term caretaking - k9dan
Funnily enough the missus runs a Panda and about a month ago I greased the brake lines with waterproof grease. Didn't take long so Will probably grease the Octavia. The old Galaxy is basically a VAG with a Ford engine it's full of vag part numbers on the bits. As an amateur mechanic what usually beats me is seized up bits, then having to hand it over to the professionals to deal with. If a can of grease stops that then I'm happy to slap it on once a year. Don't think the galaxy is galvanised, and it has stood up to damp, salt ridden scottish roads astonishingly well, there is no corrosion underneath on the bodyshell. The Octavia is galvanised and built to VAG standard so should rust less? That only leaves suspension etc underneath so it will get a coat of greasy goo. The Galaxy was done with Supagard, from new so again will do that, as it's inexpensive from a well known auction site.
Use all sorts of potions and lotions on paintwork, don't mind the elbow work. The old motor still looks great, I get a kick from an old motor looking newer than it is.
Long term caretaking - madf
My experience of 17 years of ownership of a Peugoet 106 is that the bits you cannot rust proof without drilling (eg box sections) are the only ones to rot.

SO unless the job is done professionally in the box sections it's a waste of time and money..

And greasing the underneath may give a warm glow but a waste of time...

Our Peugeot is near immaculate but worth buttons so if it breaks, scrapyard job...
Long term caretaking - oilrag
"And greasing the underneath may give a warm glow but a waste of time..."

A couple of hours with a brush and a few pots of grease - every four or five years.

Bet you spend more time than that breathing on and buffing up the badge on the Toyota , MF.

(Written with warmth and humour ;-) ;-)