What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
This weeks happening I will travel to a garage to see a car spend less than 20 seconds looking at it to discover that none of the front panels align properly or rust in a terminal place etc?

Are other people the same?

If after 20 seconds I am interested in the car, I start to get a little excited, then I will find other potential problems with it as I investigate or buy it. I assume this is fairly normal as us humans can make a first impresson in seconds and with cars the lesson I have learnt is the first impression is usualy right.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Pugugly
Sounds good. Bought a car in less than that the other week and test drove a suit for longer later that day.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - redviper
when I went to but my Laguna - it took me about the same time to decide that i really liked it - I still took it out on a test drive though, and all that did was make me like it even more
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - redviper
Rattle, I take it you did not like the Astra, what was it like? what are you going to see next :-)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
The Astra was the ex cop car, just too much put me off. The Astra is still very high on my wish list as and I think this what I will end up with as I think for the same amount of money I can get a better an Astra in better condition.

Must have phoned up about 6 cars last week and they were all sold ;( I am quick as well to respond to new adds as I am home a lot. So the ones I do get to the see are the unsold sheds, its just luck really. I also need a manual and a petrol so that limits my choices a little.

My dads just getting a little fed up as he will take me some where 8 miles away and I spend less than 30 seconds looking at the car! But I know I don't want it as thsi stage, what is the point on letting the trader come out and wasting their time?

I just need to keep looking and I will find a suitable car. There seems to be much less private sale cars on the market than they used to be as well and from past experience at this price level there is a lot less sheds on the private market.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - redviper
Nice one, good luck in your search i agree with the manual and petrol choice though - thats what i require, my girlfreinds car is a auto deisel.. i like it but still prefer my manual petrol.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Mapmaker
Sounds good. Bought a car in less than that the other week and test drove
a suit for longer later that day.


It always seems odd to spend more on a suit or a pair of shoes than a car. Done it a couple of times.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Altea Ego
>> Sounds good. Bought a car in less than that the other week and test
drove
>> a suit for longer later that day.
It always seems odd to spend more on a suit or a pair of shoes
than a car. Done it a couple of times.


Given the price of your cars you would need to shop at oxfam to get clothes or shoes cheaper
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Mapmaker
Given the price of your cars you would need to shop at oxfam to get
clothes or shoes cheaper


May I just point out that I've just bought a car that wasn't quite three years old when I bought it. So there.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - L'escargot
Buy in haste, and repent at leisure!
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Lud
Actually Rattle, with all due respect, it takes you 20 seconds to decide against a car. Seems to take you more or less for ever to decide in favour of one...

What you urgently need is motoring experience. For that you need to own a viable car and really drive about in it.

The problem seems to be that because all cars have weak points and some examples let their owners down, someone like you who does a lot of research on the internet ends by being put off all of them. Worrying and jittering take the place of driving and coping with the vagaries of a viable car.

It's no skin off our noses of course, but it must be a bit frustrating for you (although quite a lot cheaper than having a car).

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - harib
I have to say - you spend so long wringing your hands and deliberating about buying a car - do you actually need one?
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
I bet a good half the people don't actually need one :). Its not urgent but I do need to keep my driving up in case it becomes a point when I do need to drive and I am not confident, also it would make my life a lot lot easier.

I have another two months until my suspended policy runs out so I may end up buying one on the list week on a whim.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Lud
I don't think you are ever going to be a proper driver Rattle. I'd forgotten your extreme nervousness about driving.

Don't buy a car on a whim at the last moment. Find a decent one at leisure, and buy it.

Did you ever look at the Punto in Classifieds, or at its photos? Or did you never really consider a Punto at all because of its alleged hgf and power steering problems?

Think of all the perfectly good ones zooming about quite unaware of their weaknesses in these areas.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
At the moment due to various reasons my order of preference is

1) Focus
2) Astra G
3) Punto II

I will also consider other cars but the three above seem the best in terms of safety, insurance and value for money. I realise that finding a good Focus for less than £2k within 10 miles of my post code is going to be tricky. Not found any Puntos yet with service history, I let one go a few weeks back before I was considering them would have been a good car probably X 2001 Punto 50k with full FIAT history :(.

I am also looking at the 1.4 306 but they are getting pricey for what they are. I would even consider a Clio but the used ones seem poor value for money, I am not paying £1500 for a 9 year old Clio its madness.

With a Punto I would try and get one which has a 3 month warranty which covers the steering rack, that gives me enough to time to ensure it wasn't the reason it was sold on then if it fails 3 months later hopefully it should not cost more than £450 to have fixed.

The Punto seems to be most love or hated car ever, but I suppose you can say that about the FIAT brand.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - DP
Research is a good thing, but can also make you over cautious. My purchase of a Renault Scenic dCi 2 yrs ago was, according to some, akin to taking six months net salary and handing it over to the car repair trade and local taxi companies. The reality couldn't be more different. It's given us two years thoroughly enjoyable and generally reliable service with very sensible maintenance and upkeep costs. Had I done the real in depth stuff and learned of some of the horror stories I have since heard, I probably wouldn't have bought the car. And it would have been my loss, genuinely.

As Lud says, there are lots of good cars of all makes which don't give a day's trouble. It's only the bad ones (or the really exceptionally good ones) which tend to get talked about. In the case of the "bad rep" manufacturers like Renault and Fiat, yes you will find a few hundred horror stories about these cars if you search for them or ask around. However, what is the significance of this against a backdrop of several million registrations a year? Are the other millions of owners suffering in silence, or are they generally pretty happy with their lot? I know which I suspect.

Buy on condition and history - don't worry too much what badge is on the front of it.

PS - the 306 is much, much nicer as a 1.6!

Edited by DP on 25/02/2009 at 16:14

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
The 1.6 306 is sadly a lot more to insure than a 1.6 Focus :(. I have driven a 1.4 Xsara XU engine and I didn't like it, so I guess the 306 1.4 will be pretty similar so thatys the 306 out, surprisingly even the none turbo diesel ones cost me well over £100 a month to insure.

You are right about the horror stories, my friend who had the crash had a Clio and she did over 10,000 miles in it without it needing a garage trip and on its 56,000 mile service all it needed was two new tyres and brake pads. The car has also had a fair bit of abuse, hopefully it will get repaired. If you asked her about cars she will tell you that Renault is the best brand ever - because of her good experience.

I have also have a couple of mates with 206 again a typical horror story car and they both have been no trouble, his 2.0 GTI has needed a new injector but other than that trouble free in the past four years.

I know the astras have problems with their ignition barrels but again it is one of them things every car has their horror stories, the Fiestas mainly being rust and suspension problems.

I've also noticed a tendancy for people to slag of their FIATs because of the badge if it develops a fault it is because its FIAT, if its a Toyota its because of wear and tear.



It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Number_Cruncher
>>I know the astras have problems with their ignition barrels but again it is one of them things every car has their horror stories

Rattle, wake up!

An ignition barrel is not a "horror story", and I've only known a handfull of problems with these ignition barrels that are fundamentally unchanged in Vauxhalls for over 25 years.

A "horror story" might be something like a camshaft snapping!

I tend to agree with Lud - for many reasons, perhaps Rattle + motoring is never going to be a beautiful equation.

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - quizman
My son had a 306 non turbo diesel. He sold it to a local girl at 125,000 miles. She had it for 3 years. I did not hear of any problems, I know her dad so I would have. It was a lovely car and was low insurance, that's why he bought it.

I looked on Autotrader last night, there are dozens on Seat Ibezas in the £1500-£2000 range. Some of them are private sales, which is what I would go for. The dealers will have put on at least £750 for their costs. I think these would be a good car for you.

You say it takes 20 seconds for you to make your mind up. You surely jest, it seems like this saga has been going on for years. It is now time to get yourself some wheels and please do as others have said, go for a few good drives and get your confidence back. Have you ever driven on a motorway?

Happy motoring.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - NickS
My other halfs Punto is still in the classifieds.............. ;-)

I think, Rattle, that you are possibly hoping for a little too much froma sub-2k, 8ish year old car. Whilst i'm sure there are plenty of complete sheds out there, I'm sure too that there are lots of bargains to be had.

For example, whilst at Uni, i helped a female friend buy a "new" car. She had a budget of about £1500, and we ended up looking at some complete heaps. We finally ended up buying her a less that cosmetically perfect Punto from a Dr's wife. The car didnt look immacualte, but had every receipt for everthing in place (including every Petrol recipt in the glove box!). Driven by her, maintained by him (or him taking to FIAT anway). A "dont judge a book situation" if you will.............

Going back to a previous post, where you mentioned distance as an issue, I think if you are as meticulous as your posts make out, then you proably need to be a little more willing to travel further afield to find your perfect wheels.............

Edited by NickS on 25/02/2009 at 17:30

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - oilrag
Having trouble flogging it Nick? ;-)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - bristol01
Seems to me that if you go for a mainstream car which has service history and which has been well looked after (private sale perhaps?) then you should be ok. I haven't owned an Astra, but had use of one about 10 years ago - it went very well indeed (G reg, probably long gone now).

I'll very soon be selling a 1997 Polo 1.4 owned by my Dad then me FSH absolutely bullet proof mechanically, easy to drive, etc, if you can get a coach down to Bristol! Wouldn't sell it but for growing family. Should I be using this forum for this type of info? Apologies to all if not.

What do you want the car for? Whatever happens, good luck - sounds like you just need to take the plunge!
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - oilrag
12 yrs old though...and not galvanised...

Rattles price range includes 6 year old Fiat Punto`s with galvanised bodywork.......

Edited by oilrag on 25/02/2009 at 17:50

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - rtj70
Rattle, limiting yourself to a distance of 10 miles (I can guess why) rules out a lot that is out there.

I did mention my step-son's 99/T plate Proton Compact Sport (1.5l) in an email. Well it was on ebay and sold for about £400. He just wanted it sold and it had MOT but no tax. He'd have taken £250 though.... you should have had a look - it was in Withington. Gone now though. Bright yellow mind!
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Yeah thanks Rob the main issue with that was the high insurance sort of deafeted the point its a shame though :).

I have just got back from Poynton to view a Focus. I actually test drove it was a lovely car to drive but I reved it to 4000rpm and a lot of water came out. After wards it started steaming badly and the temperature gauge was rising. I thought at this point its my imagination but I asked about warranty and he said its sold as seen even though he was a trader! I phoned my uncle who knows about cars and he reckoned the fuel mixture was wrong and to walk away because of the warranty thing.

He also agreed with me that the temperature seemed high considering the amount of smoke, it was about 10c outside. I don't think it was the HG as the coolant was clean and there was no mayo on the cap but Focuses are not known to be smokers. My dads dosn't even smoke as much and the stem seals have gone on that!

I am getting closer to the right car, just learning a lot in the process too :).

I was also put under a lot of preasure, I admit I did nearly buy this car.

Edited by Rattle on 25/02/2009 at 19:58

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - thomp1983
losing water whilst revved, smoking and clean coolant id bet the headgasket has gone and the trader has changed the fluids to make them look clean to try and get rid of it.

chris
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
My thought exactly the oil was lovely and clean so it was fresh. The temperature did not feel right either, I know its a different engine but my last car the temp gauge would only move sligtly to the middle after being stuck in a traffic jam, this was in the middle from the start so its been well warmed up.

Every time I tried to bring up any mechanical issues he just tried to change the subject saying how he dosn't sell faulty cars, how brilliant Focuses are, how there is nothing wrong with it yet he could not explain why the engine was so hot etc.

I am tired and shattered by all this now.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - oilrag
Modern cars do warm up rapidly to the halfway mark though. If it didn`t rise above that and it had been moved around cold in the yard a few times - the water and water vapour from the exhaust would be normal.

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Which is exactly what my uncle said was a possibility but the steam just seem to linger on, there was also dent marks in the boot too which I did not investigate further.

At the end of the day it was a trader selling the car and he made it clear it came with no warranty it is enough to walk away. The engine was also a little noisy but there was no rattles or knocks so was probably normal but I know my dads Escort 1.6 which had a different engine but still Zetec was pretty much silent.

If it had come with a warranty and the trader explained it was just condensation then I probably would have bought it, but the fact is he didn't have any explanation and just kept saying its a good car.

At the end of day it might have been a good car but a trader who offers no warranty is not a good seller.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - OldSock
And you thought War and Peace was a lengthy saga....

:-)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Lud
You may have been right about that car Rattle. Who knows? 'Water' and 'steam' don't mean much unless there's a precise description of where they come from and how much of them there is.

Why do you go and see all these dodgy sheds anyway? Why don't you take a look at some of the perfectly OK or not too bad with a bit of fettling cars the rest of us keep noticing?

I fear you may be a, what's the term HJ, goodness where is bell boy when you need him, yes, 'tyre kicker'.

If you aren't careful all these car dealers are going to start recognising you and hiding round the back and sending a chimpanzee out to force you to buy a classic BL rustbucket with grass growing out of the wings. That'll learn you.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - madux
Rattle: Why don't you just buy something with six month's MOT and tax for £350 or so and drive it until you get the feel of what you really want or need?
It might only last you 4 months but it might last a couple of years - either way you will not really be losing anything and you will be gaining experience (And a NCB perhaps.)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Mad already been there, didn't work out, I don't really like bangers anyway, one thing I loved about this Focus it was so easy to drive, even easier than my instructors brand new clio as the gearbox was a bit nothcy on that.

I have had a few bangers now, one of them rotten anyway and the other engine failed both could have been repaired but I just decided to give up. I am pretty sure there is a decent Focus out there in my budget but I am going to wait while I rushed into it. If the seller did not put me under so much preasure I may have bought that car tonight but I had to make a decision there and then and I wasnt' 100% sure.

I've still got a while until my insurance runs out. I did feel very comfortable in the Focus and I felt safe which I never really did in the Fiesta. If he said it came with 3 months warranty I would have bought the car tonight, it was the fact I was already a little concerned about the steam was it condensation but the biggest thing that made me walk away was when he said it was sold as seen with no warranty.

As for traders running away let 'em the garages I have been to so far I would never go back, there was one which seemed decent I just did not like the car but how would I know until I drove it? Tonight I certainly did not tyre kick I even came with £100 cash in my pocket to leave as a deposit and at one time I really thought I would buy it, its only when the steam wasn't clearing away even after the test drive I became suspicious.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Sorry about the above post, I need to get some sleep, I have some how just repeated myself.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Andrew-T
The fact is, Rattle, you feel so much more comfortable knowing you have NOT bought a 'shed' than worrying that the car you HAVE bought may turn into one next week ...

As you seem to get about quite nicely by bus, just think how you are helping the planet.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Mapmaker
If you're really worried about your ncb, then buy a moped.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Lud
I can quite see how you would have been put off by the trader's evasiveness and flimflam, Rattle. But a pool of water in the rear silencer box wouldn't necessarily all be dispelled after a short test drive. That might take a few miles of road, or say half an hour of slow traffic driving. You may have turned down a perfectly good car.

There's nothing wrong with playing safe if it makes you feel better. But I suspect a lot of traders' warranties aren't up to much. Don't you know anyone who could come with you when you go to assess a prospective purchase who could make an informed stab at judging the car's true condition?
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Lud I called my uncle who is very well qualified in this area and he said the puddle may have been normal if its been sat there and been allowed to idle for a while, but after the 15 minute test drive with the engine at mid temperature there was a huge amount of smoke coming out the back. It looked like it had just been started from cold on a -3c morning when it the engine was up to temperature and it was 10c outside. My uncle said he thinks there was something up with it but would need to check in, when I told him what to he said about the warranty he said just walk away.

Until my uncle said that my plan was to get some advice here then and then maybe go up and buy it this morning. Everytime I mentioned the mechanical aspects of the car he just kept going on about the vallet etc.

I admit this car may have been ok but there are plenty more to see. There is another one I may go and look at tomorrow which has just been advertised in the last hour.

What ever traders warranties offer there by law have obligations and I got the impression if I found it would have been a battle. People on here probably expect I want everything perfect I don't, there was a tinty dent in one of the door (key size) and it not put me off one bit. If the aircon does not work on a £1400 so what?

My experience with cars is if you see one which is appatrantly fault free the you still find niggles but I expect that but if you buy a car thinking the brake pipes will need replacing it will probably need that and a lot more work on top.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Lud
There are always niggles Rattle, even (to read some of the posts here) in brand new and expensive cars.

Sometimes a brilliant car can be let down by easily cured minor niggles that the former owner or dealer can't cope with or can't be bothered with. A car like that is what I would be looking out for.

One has to be philosophical though. Sometimes they turn out to be sheds anyway. I think you know this from recent experience.

However, a luta continua! You are due for some good luck if there's any justice. I want to see you racing smoothly and carefully about the country and starting to complain about people mimsing on A roads.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - oilrag
Well said, Lud.

Good luck in your continuing search Rattle ;-)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - oilrag
I think I`m vicariously searching with you actually ;-)

(enjoy your posts)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
hehe yeah. As I said before if the seller wasn't so cagey about the warranty I would have bought the car and just taken the risk. I was actually quite disapointed as everything about was ideal.

Niggles I can live with, dangerius faults or serious mechanical problems I cannot. What I loved about the Focus is I took it up to 50mph with no drama, on the cars I am used to driving you know when you have hit 50!

One thing I am a lot more clear about now is a slightly bigger car will be more suited to me and would offer a completly zero image solution. Turning to customers in a clean Focus nobody cars, on my old car with dents and rust on it people think its a cheap car.

I am lucky being self employed I can fit car hunting between jobs, if I had a 9-5 job I would just have to buy the first thing I saw but if i worked 9-5 I would have more money.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - SpamCan61 {P}
Well, when buying my bangernomics Vauxhalls in the 1K bracket I do get to see some right sheds, I usually end up looking at half a dozen cars to find a 'good' one.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - ifithelps
SpamCan61,

You couldn't help us all out could you and find a car for Rattle?

I think he needs your expertise at the lower end of the market.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - SpamCan61 {P}
LOL, unfortunately my 'expertise' is confined to Omegas and Vectra Bs, which are probably too high in the insurance groups for Rattle. In general I'd say go for full service history and apparent mechanical condition, buying cars pre-dented does tend to help lower the price as well, plus one can leave them in supermarket car parks without undue worry.

edit : OK the last point isn't really relevant for Rattle as the car needs to look nice.

Edited by SpamCan61 {P} on 26/02/2009 at 19:56

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
It depends what and where the dent is, a tiny little dent is nothing but a bit 5" dent can look a mess. My old car did look a right mess, it had two minor dents and a little bit of rust on the body work, the gray mumbers were also fading. It also needed a good t-cut as the paint was starting to fade.

My dads car on the otherhand polishes up very very well and would look fine.

I think darker colours hide dents better, a dent on a silver car looks very messy.



It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - L'escargot
........ the gray mumbers were also fading.


For those unfamiliar with mumbers (as I confess I was until I googled for it) here's an explanation. www.241mumbers.com/
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
I meant bumpers :) OK maybe typing at 300wpm is not a good idea!
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
I am now deciding more and more I want a Focus because I was just very very impressed witht he one I drove. However the 1.4 and 1.6s are fairly rare so I am now considered a 1.8 too. Insurance will be £90 a month compared with £78 on a 1.6 but if its the right car I could live with that. I seem to remember the 1.4 Corsa I nearly bought being £90 a month.

For some reason the Focus seems to be by far the cheapest proper car to insure. Premiums are 40% lower than an Escort.

My concern on the 1.8 is not the cost but being able to handle the 113bhp in the city, as most the places I drive are 30 or 40 limits would be very easy to control it at this speed?
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - TimOrridge
My concern on the 1.8 is not the cost but being able to handle the
113bhp in the city as most the places I drive are 30 or 40 limits
would be very easy to control it at this speed?


Rattle, I SERIOUSLY think you need to reevaluate your ability to drive. 113bhp is a small amount of power in a car. In answer to your question, yes it will be really easy. Please spend the full £2000 then you will have peace of mind, dont but another banger, they dont suit you.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - TheOilBurner
Rattle I SERIOUSLY think you need to reevaluate your ability to drive. 113bhp is a
small amount of power in a car....


That's a bit harsh. Most new drivers think 100bhp+ is a lot, and that somehow it will be like riding a raging bull.

It's only us jaded old timers who turn around and go "I suppose I can make do with 150bhp if I have to..." ;)
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - TimOrridge
Sorry all,

I only have 115bhp 2.0 (probably less now, the Audi 80 is 15 years old) and that is diabolically slow. Any focus will show mine a clean pair of heels.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Altea Ego
My concern on the 1.8 is not the cost but being able to handle the
113bhp in the city as most the places I drive are 30 or 40 limits
would be very easy to control it at this speed?


yes just dont press that little pedal to your right so hard.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
That is what I would have to get used to, on my old car if I needed to go anywhere I had to rev the pants of it, if I reved the pants of a Focus I would be doing 50 in seconds.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - TheOilBurner
Don't worry Rattle. If you can afford to buy it, fuel it and insure it, go for it.

With all the extra weight, it won't actually feel that much quicker anyway. The only problem is that once you start getting used to them extra horses, you'll feel hard done by if you ever have to go back to low powered motors again!

Edited by TheOilBurner on 27/02/2009 at 14:24

It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Well I noticed the 1.6 is the Zetec-S where the 1.8 is the slightly older Zetec design and I have a feeling this older design is actually stronger.

I just think with a more modern car with a bit of power (the 1.6 will be fine for this too) I will be more confident to go further.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - John F
I'm complete opposite - takes me years. Need to suss out whether they are likely to be reliable and, to a lesser extent, if they are still going to impart a sense of well-being and/or fun after several years. They need to have depreciated as well.

Since 1981 I have bought only three cars for personal use for a grand total of £16,500...and I've still got two of them. But then they have never done more than 8,000 miles a year and now do less than 4000. Wife's car does the most.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - Rattle
Johh you miss understood me a little, I am very very fussy and I tend probably spend half an hour looking at or four cars before I find a good one. However if there car is not for me it takes me 20 seconds to decide. After 20 seconds I want the car until I either get suspicious or find a fault.
It takes me 20 seconds to decide on a car - John F
Ah, I think I see what you mean, Rattle. I guess that's the difference between browsing and homing in on a particular specific example of a model you have already decided to buy, virtually ignoring all others on sale, which is what I do......very infrequently!