What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - FotheringtonThomas
From an article in "The Daily Telegraph".

"Forecasters have warned that the freezing blast will continue through next week raising concerns that if the grit runs out then the country will not be able to cope.

The AA has now called on the Government to step in and ensure that salt stocks are maintained over the coming days."


Oh dear. The AA, bless their little cotton socks, seem to be rather naive.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - gmac
If there is no grit/salt available why not use that natural resource that surrounds most of the UK ?
Sand off the beach.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Old Navy
I read or heard somewhere that the last time Councils ran short of rock salt it was collected or delivered direct from the source, (mine?).
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - FotheringtonThomas
Much of it is mined in Cheshire, where it was deposited around 250 million years ago in a very different climate, during the Permian and early Triassic ages.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Old Navy
>>Permian and early Triassic ages.>>

I take it that was a long time ago. :) Thanks, I knew there was a source somewhere near the middle of UK.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - L'escargot
Sand off the beach.


We like our beach just as it is, thank you very much. What about soil out of your local park?
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - boxsterboy
If there is no grit/salt available why not use that natural resource that surrounds most
of the UK ?
Sand off the beach.


Er, because it might block the drains when it gets washed off the road?

The advantage with using salt is that it dissolves in use and doesn't block the drains when washed off.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Mr X
Heard some council mouth piece bemoaning the cost of salt and gritting on the radio today.
Was unable to get my call through to ask about the money his council had saved over the last 8 or 9 mild winters which saw little or no snow.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Statistical outlier
Don't worry Mr X. Your constant rage about everything should ensure that you receive excellent value for money from the NHS when you succumb to a heart attack or chronic high blood pressure and need extensive and massively costly treatment.

Seriously, chill out man, you'll rage yourself to an early death.

Edited by Gordon M on 05/02/2009 at 18:22

AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Mr X
Better than going with out a fight.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - BobbyG
Wished you had got through with that call!

"Hi, this is Mr X , I know this is the worst snow in decades and is accepted as being abnormal in terms of our weather and has stretched us to the limit, but can you tell me how much money you have saved over previous years planning for this and it not happening"
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Hamsafar
I wish people would stop having a pop at Mr X, it's spoiling the site,

Edited by Webmaster on 07/02/2009 at 01:07

AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - L'escargot
I wish people would stop having a pop at Mr X ........


I bet he's absolutely laughing his socks off, and revelling in his notoriety!
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - daveyjp
Unfortunately Mr X Council's work on an annual budget. What was 'saved' last year was spent on something else. This year is new money and any 'savings' from this year will be spent on road salt.

Highway maintenance budgets have been cut to the bone, including road salt due to false sense that every winter would be mild. Like every commododity high in demand I'm sure the price has risen dramatically in the last few weeks.

BTW you can't use 100% sand - it doesn't dissolve and causes problems with drains when the snow does melt. A certian %age of sand may be used to make the salt go further.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - gordonbennet
Please don't let the government become involved, by the time we've appointed consultants (relative's?)and quango's (old mates) and passed legislation we'll be another 10 years behind in recovery, and even more broke.

Next we'll have the salt Czar.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - MikeTorque
I'd prefer it if the AA would focus on informing all its drivers on how to drive at a safe distance behind the car in front, unlike the AA tailgater who followed me today.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Armitage Shanks {p}
What can the Governement actually do? Is some financial help being asked for? Shame we can't put the government's principal products to use - hot air and bovine nitrogenous waste products!
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Nickdm
I'm with Mr. X on this one. It is absolutely PATHETIC that the various councils' bean-counters and pen-pushers haven't maintained ample stocks for our long winter period. Yes we've had a lot of mild winters recently, but we all know how unreliable and changeable the UK weather can be.

S'pose the Gubbermint will offer bail-out loans of taxpayers' money to local councils who will line the mining companies' pockets...
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - L'escargot
I'm with Mr. X on this one. It is absolutely PATHETIC that the various councils'
bean-counters and pen-pushers haven't maintained ample stocks for our long winter period.


In order to fund bigger stocks of winter road salt your council tax would have to go up, and then you'd be moaning about that. Some people are just never satisfied.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Mr X
'Unfortunately Mr X Council's work on an annual budget. What was 'saved' last year was spent on something else. This year is new money and any 'savings' from this year will be spent on road salt.'
As has been pointed out in another post, the councils HAD the money but choose to spend it on something else so as not to lose it when mild winters where predicted. Therefor they do not need to raise council tax in order to fund salt, simply stop spending it on what ever it was they choose to get rid of it on.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - L'escargot
if the grit runs out then the country will not be able to cope.


Not the whole country! Here on the east coast of Lincolnshire we haven't had any problems yet.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - madf
Xomw counties : Staffs- get it right.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - ijws15

If the doom forecasters are right about global warming then the effect on the UK will be worse than what we are seeing now - colder winters more akin to those other countries at the same latitude as us.

Birmingham 52 degrees north
Ottawa 45 degrees north.

Government are not planning for it to happen so why should we accept their statements that it is happening and the associated increases in taxation!

Where is the joined up government?
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Armitage Shanks {p}
Government isn't joined up - it is screwed up!
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - madf
It's not joined up Government. It's Councils planning on a mean case.

Mean is fine except you can get 2 standard deviations.

They should plan for 1 standard deviation...
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - David Horn
Some dozy bint on the radio yesterday said, and I paraphrase from memory, "It's shocking that in this era of climate change the councils don't have larger grit reserves."

I was so flabbergasted I nearly drove off the road, but spent a much more enjoyable 10 minutes shouting at the radio.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - jbif
They should plan for 1 standard deviation...


They should employ some statisticians/consultants to help them understand the stats.

All you saw/heard them saying was the grit stocks have run out because this is a 1 in 20 year event. In the next sentence they then say the last time so much snow fell was 18 years ago. So maybe they thought they could safely wait until 2011 before an "exceptional snow event" needed to be planned for.

The other interesting fact that emerged was that they all thought because they have a contract with the grit supplier to deliver at 5 days notice, there was no need to worry. Fine, except that the supplier can do that only in the "normal years", not to cope with scores of councils all ordering at the same time.

AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - b308
They should employ some statisticians/consultants to help them understand the stats.



On about £50k pa do you reckon? It'll cut the dole queue a little I suppose!

TBH I didn't have any problems at all this week, so Worcestershire and West Mids have done ok... perhaps its just that many people now live in out of the places that would have been considerred only suitable for farm workers years ago but are now considered "commuter" suitable these days, which is ok until the weather gets bad and they want their little lane gritted....
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Bromptonaut
Neither the highway authority councils or the supplier will necessarily have the infrastrucure to cope with exceptional events such as we are seeing now. How is the salt/grit stored? The salt bit must require controlled, probably indoor, storage to prevent both deterioration and leaching into the environment.

Any storage space costs, particularly in recent years where sale for housing would raise significant capital.


AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - jbif
.. On about £50k pa do you reckon? It'll cut the dole queue a little I suppose!


Too cheap. At leat £200k pa all in.

AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}
I am surpised that the rock salt we see is intended to get rid of the snow. News to me- AFAIK it was always only intended to stop the snow sticking to the road so that it could be ploughed off. Proper 'grit' spread onto frozen compacted snow works quite well in continental Europe . However with the temperature bobbing up and down , it tends not to work here.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - midlifecrisis
It's the lies that annoy me. I've just spent a couple of interesting night shifts knowing that Worcestershire ran out of grit on wednesday evening. I've heard two days of spokeman on the radio talking about 'selective' gritting . No, there's been no gritting because you haven't got any.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Mr X
The government bang on about road safety & the use of speed cameras, but something that could actually save a few lives like properly gritting the road & they don't want to know - because it costs them money rather than makes them money.
AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - jbif
The government .. - because it costs them money rather than makes them money. >>


If it costs "them" money, they have to get it from you & I in the end. Because, you may be surprised to know, the Government's money is your money and my money. [ I am assuming you are a taxpayer and not a scrounger. ]

If it makes "them" money, it saves you & I some money as the idiot caught [idiot either because he was speeding and/or because he got caught] breaking the speed limit has to pay "them" the money. That money helps keep a lot of people employed who otherwise would be unemployed and/or busy dreaming up other schemes to get money off you and I.

So good result all round, I say.

Not to hxj: I know, I should not feed a troll; but as Cantona said, just like a seagull, I cannot resist the sardines being thrown in to the sea from the trawler.


Edited by jbif on 06/02/2009 at 15:23

AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - madf
jbif

Yes.

This idea that the Government just gets money from nowhere is a bit strange.


As anyone speeding through a fixed camera painted yellow is driving without due care and attention (as they did not see it), it's called fleecing the idiots.



AA asks for Gov't intervention re gritting. - Mr X
'As anyone speeding through a fixed camera painted yellow is driving without due care and attention (as they did not see it), it's called fleecing the idiots.'
and failing to grit roads when they have collected billions in road and motoring taxes is also called fleecing the idiots.