What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Please help me choose a car - bartsimpson
Hi, I really need some help choosing my next car.

Requirements:

- Big enough for dog (small), baby, me, wife, luggage, pushchair, luggage
- Very safe with the latest safety technology
- Less than 3 years old
- Quick
- Comfortable and luxurious
- Gadgets, eg xenon lights, sat nav (not essential), leather, memory/heated seats
- Must have a young person's image, coz im only 27 and dont want something like a Skoda

Budget: £30,000

What I'm currently considering (but open to more suggestions):

- Audi S4 (B7) - not sure if this is big enough?
- Merc ML 280/320 diesel - have test driven a 280, good but not remarkably quick.

Many thanks
Please help me choose a car - Pugugly
BMW 535d Touring. I am 48 I had one (albeit a saloon) but I sold it and bought a Skoda Roomster obviously as I'm very old.

Probably the best all round car you can get at any price. (and the Beemer's not bad either !)

Edited by Pugugly on 30/03/2008 at 21:51

Please help me choose a car - rtj70
for your budget you can get new cars that meet your requirements. It's a big budget @ £30k

World is your choice. What are your more specific requirements. If I was you I'd consider an Audi A6 estate with a good diesel (2.7 or 3.0)

But that is because I'd like one :-)
Please help me choose a car - bartsimpson
Not sure how I can be much more specific, except that:

- I need the car soon, and I dont know anything about buying new - doesnt it take weeks to arrive? Plus, I've heard that new cars lose loads more than used in depreciation, which is definitely a consideration as I'm paying cash rather than leasing (I think!)

- I would like a prestigious brand like merc, bmw, audi, and i reckon for most of these buying new would come in at well over 30k with extras added (I like gadgets).

- Something that can do better than 8 secs to 60 would be good.

Please help me choose a car - Jase
Another vote for the 535d estate please.
I think you should still prepare to lose "loads" in depreciation though. Virtually everything costing £30K will lose a lot.

Go and drive a 535d and report back!
Please help me choose a car - Pugugly
Preferably when I'm on holiday - I miss it a bit but my middle aged body was out of kilter with the image, which was more suited to a Skoda.
Please help me choose a car - Jase
PU - I can't help feeling if you could afford to run the 535d and willingly gave it up for a Skoda Roomster, then it's your mind that has failed you not your middle aged body!

( joke(ish) )

come on bartsimpson - go and drive one and give us a proper road test report.
Please help me choose a car - Pugugly
No there was a rational set of decisions behind it. But sometimes rational doesn't make emotional sense. My head hasn't regretted it but my heart hasn't.

However, yes the 535 will have all the toys you may or may not want, its a deeply involving car inasmuch as its a fast, practical and very very satisfying drive. Use the right dealer and you'll have an unbeatable combination, I would recommend you get one from a dealer, 25k to 30k should get you a decent one. This one is in Blue Bell in Wilmslow. Look beyond the badge and you will genuinely find one of the best cars money can buy. The sports suspension is acquired taste though.


2005 55 Reg BMW 535d 2993 cc M Sport Touring (trade)

Blue Bell Wilmslow

* 38,052 miles
* Automatic
* Blue
* Diesel

5 Doors, Automatic, Estate, Diesel, 38,052 miles, Mystic Blue, Flashlight Cloth/Nappa Leather, Bootlid operation. powered, Sport Model, Sports Suspension, Remote Control Alarm, De-chroming, Roof Rails,

Authorised BMW Dealer

BMW Approved Used Cars

£26,450

or




Photograph of BMW 5 SERIES DIESEL TOURING (2004 - 2007) 535D SPORT 5DR AUTO
2005 BMW 5 SERIES 3000 cc 535d Sport (trade)

Sytner Leicester

* 40,170 miles
* Automatic
* Black
* Diesel

5 Doors, Automatic, Estate, Diesel, 40,170 miles, Carbon Black Metallic, 2 Owner(s), Dark Poplar Wood - High Gloss,Comfort Seats - Electric,Media package,Visibiltiy Package,Coming Soon (Vehicle In
logo

£28,850


Sytner had a good write up here today. Black....mmmmm



Edited by Pugugly on 30/03/2008 at 23:02

Please help me choose a car - davros
Save 10K and enjoy a year old Subaru Legacy Spec B Tourer (10K buys a lot of fuel). Indecently rapid, too.

Manged three dogs, four adults and a baby in mine today - which was because the (newish) Audi wagon the other pasengers were suppposed to be travelling in had broken down....

Davros
Please help me choose a car - Billy Whizz
bart, what are you driving at the moment?
Please help me choose a car - bartsimpson
merc sports coupe
Please help me choose a car - bartsimpson
quick update, drove an s4 this morning, never thought i would say this but - i found it slightly boring.

extremely quick, no question, but in a funny way it was TOO quick. i got up to 80 on a dual carriageway and it felt like i was trundling along at 30. it was frustrating, like the car was crying out for you to push it to its limit, but you just couldn't.

so i reckon the merc is now favourite

bmw to be honest i just dont like the look of them. im sure theyre great to drive and everything, but they look really ugly to me
Please help me choose a car - Bagpuss
If you're looking at Mercs, have you tried an E-Class? The estate version is huge and they are massively better than an M-Class in terms of ride, handling, interior space and build quality. Don't know too much about prices in the UK, but I'm guessing for that money you could get an E350 (or E320 if it really must be diesel).
Please help me choose a car - DP
No car has ever grown on me styling-wise like the current 5-series. I think it's a gorgeous piece of design, particularly in Touring form.

I've never been in a 535d, but I have seen one given full beans off the line (off the lights on the Handy Cross roundabout and down the A404 towards the M4 and grinding its rear tyres into the tarmac, leaving a pair of light tread marks for about 200 yds). It is a seriously quick car, let alone for a diesel. Not even a puff of smoke out the back during the whole thing either.

Cheers
DP

Please help me choose a car - mlj
Two alternatives come to mind: Mondeo and Accord. In 2.5T Ghia spec you get your performance and toys, in the Honda 2.4 just slightly less. Add leather to the ford and still have the best part of 8K change.

You do need a big boot: these two give it to you.
Or, and I'm guessing you'll discount it, the new C5 Estate looks gorgeous and early impressions seem very favourable.
Please help me choose a car - boxsterboy
How about a Merc C320 CDI Estate? Sub 7.0 secs 0-60, but even quicker mid-range. Very smooth and economical when called-for. A little smaller and not quite as quick as a 535d, but less 'in yer face' (quite understated even?) and cheaper second hand. Mine is one of the few non Sport-Edition ones and is all the better for it with a better ride and self-levelling rear suspension. The interior is not disimilar to your Sports Coupe.
Please help me choose a car - bartsimpson
Many thanks for the advice given so far, i will have a look at all these suggestions and report back soon.