What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Use of inverter... - Old Banger
I've borrower an inverter to take camping, to re-charge the video recorder battery, tooth-brushes, etc. It *could* be used to power a 240v inspection lamp, but I've a few doubts about doing this in an environment which may be damp. Could a "power breaker" (RCD) be usefully used with this equipment?
Use of inverter... - buzbee
An RCD activates when the current flowing is not equal in both of the two wires such that it differs by about 30 milliamps (0.03 amps) ---- that current is not usually short-term lethal.

You can look upon the two wires as a 'supply' one and a 'return' one (although strictly speaking they cary AC, assuming it is not a converter with a DC output.)

Now if you put yourself across both wires you will get a shock but the RCD does not operate because the 'supply' and 'return' wire currents are equal.

So your question is a bit tricky and depends on what you do with the inverter.

I would be inclined to knock a metal stake at least 3 feet into the ground where it is damp, then connect a wire from that to one of the inverter output terminals to earth it --- if one inverter terminal is already connected to the inverter casing, use that.

Then from the inverter terminals run two new wires to an RCD and take your supply from the RCD output.

If now you stand on earth (connected to earth) and touch the live (unearthed) wire the RCD will operate because your body's return current flows via the earth and so the 'return' wire current is not equal to the 'supply' wire current. You can actually use something (a resistor) to test this.

If you touch the wire from the converter that comes from the side that is also earthed you do not get a shock.
Use of inverter... - Altea Ego
I was always told

Its Volts what jolts and Mills what kills.

Being a solid state inverter, the case of the inverter may be earthed on the DC input side, the AC mains output side may not be earthed to the case - ie may not share the same earth. The only sure way is to take an earth lead from the three pin mains plug earth in and spike that in the ground.

For sure your source of mains (ie the car) will not be earthed to the ground -


Use of inverter... - Hugo {P}
Alternitively use an IP65 rated inspection lamp, and wire this to a length of 3 core flex in the same way you would connect it to the lighting circuit in a house. Stick the plug on the other end.

IP65 will cope with most outside conditions short of total immersion in water. An anti vandle bulkhead will suffice. I would consider mounting this on a piece of 20mm ply, making sure the mounting screws don't penetrate to the other side, and use it in the 'flat' postition outside.

Also, take careful note of the instructions. There are things you have to do to maintain the IP rating, like making sure the cable access is watertight, and make sure the holes for the screws are sealed with silicone sealent.

Also, make sure the mounting screws do not come into electrical contact with any of the live, neutral or earth. Alternitively think about using plasitc nuts and bolts to secure it.
Use of inverter... - hillman
I have a little experience in this, enough to know not to try to be clever with electrical devices, especially mains voltage ones. Why do you need mains voltage at a camp anyhow? You can get everything you need for a campsite with 12 Volt supply. I have had a 12 volt inspection lamp longer than I have had a 240 volt one. I bought it in Durban RSA in 1968, it has a magnetic base to attach it to the underside of the bonnet.

Separately, 24 Volts has been known to kill.
Use of inverter... - Hugo {P}
"Separately, 24 Volts has been known to kill."

As RF says, it's not the volts that kills it's the mills.

24v can kill if there is enough current going through you, think of it as water flow. The Voltage is the height between the ground you are standing on and the bottom of a huge water tower. The current is the rate of flow. A drip at several hundred feet up could be annoying, whereas the bottom falling out at 15 feet would probably knock you off your feet.

I have put 500v through me and I am still here. No, I am not a superhero (couldn't get the Y fronts in my colour) it was my mains insulation tester. The current was minimal so I just felt a sensation in my fingers.

Another factor is the time your body spends exposed to the voltage.....

For domestic installations the IEE use a 50V "rule". That is to say that a maximum of 50V for max suration of 0.4 seconds is "acceptable" to the body. In some circumstances this can be justified up to 5 seconds (plug in equipment etc). This is of course for normal installations.

I'll stop here before I have to moderate myself and put this in I have a question....

Before I go, taking on board what hillman wrote, why not pop into a car accessory shop and pick up one of those multi function light (torch, flasher and flourescent beam) that works off either 9v or 12v cigar lighter?
Use of inverter... - buzbee
If you must use one of these, my instructions above have a lot of merrit. There is need for use of an RCD but also great care in the way such a converter is connected. An RCD will not save you if you do not connect properly before its use.

RF says The only sure way is to take an earth lead from the three pin mains plug earth and spike that in the ground.

Not a bad idea. Even better if one of the two live wires is connected to the case. But is it?

We might have a converter with a pair of output wires that are a floating supply -- depending on its design. Neither wire is then earthed.

Now consider using such a converter with an RCD plugged in. But also that one piece of your equipment has contact with the ground and it happens to be faulty such that one of its two wires is leaking/connected to the case, due to dampness or whatever -- it does happen. So now we have one of the two wires from the converter that is being earthed. But the DC converter will continue to work.

Now suppose someone is standing on damp ground and makes use of another piece of equipment, possibly a metal cased lamp, and that the metal case of that happens to get into contact with the other wire, just as it is being handled --- it does happen.

That person now gets a potentially lethal shock! But worse, the RCD does NOT trip because the current flows equally through both wires. (draw the circuit out and see)

However, had it been wired as I suggested above, where one of the two wires was grounded BEFORE use of the RCD, it would have tripped!

Ideally test your system with a dummy load before use to make sure you have it right.
Use of inverter... - David Horn
Meh, if we're getting into the subject of voltages, I've had 2 million volts and a fairly sizable current put across me at Uni...
Use of inverter... - Hawesy1982
Use a 12v 13w compact fluorescent lamp instead of a 240v lamp.

A 13w will give you approx 600lumens, similar to your average 60w incandescent bulb.

No casing or IP protection required, will have a life of 10000 hours plus, and will cost you around £9.

And it's completely electrically safe.
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
Agree with Hawesy, although fluorescents do show false colours sometimes - not a big problem unless you're rewiring the car...

I used to have a cheap 12V inspection lamp that used ordinary 21W brake lamp bulbs. It was very effective despite the relatively low wattage.
Use of inverter... - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}
I've just toured France with a 'petit tente' for a few weeks.
Charged mobile phone and battery powered spotlight from the car sockets. Probably can get a similar charger for your video cameras.
Got too complacent after 2 weeks and left courtesy lights, 12V spotlight plus mobile 12V fridge running long enough to flatten battery on my Passat diesel.
Well, the rose wine needed chilling.
Campsite proprietor competently jump started my car with no problems.
Just needed to reset the clock and the fuel computer thingy had lost its memory.
--
I wasna fu but just had plenty.
Use of inverter... - IanJohnson
Stick with 12 Volts or use inside the car only.

IIRC RCDs work on mains because the earth is the return path to the power station, The electricity distribution grid is three wire distribution with neutral being the imaginary centre of the three phases. There is only a neutral where it is 240v single phase.

Your car is not earthed so the return current will not seek to return via the earth unless you connect the invertor neutral or car neutral to earth - as you would when getting into the car! Overload protection (std circuit breaker or fuse) will work but RCDs may not.

Having seen holes burnt through PCBs due to high induced earth voltages I would be very wary of earthing outside buildings.
Use of inverter... - buzbee
IIRC RCDs work on mains because the earth is the return path to the power station

Exactly. One of the two wires to your house is earthed BEFORE it gets to the RCD at the house. Just what I was advocating above, that should be done with one of the inverter outputs. In effect, make the inverter your new 'power station'.
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
IMHO the earth connection is not essential. It's the current going to earth (e.g. through you and/or when there's a fault) that creates an imbalance between live and neutral and trips the device.

In household mains, the neutral line is so called because it is at earth potential (0V) and the live alternates from +240V to -240V, which may not be the case with an inverter.

However, as the name implies, residual current detectors (RCD's) are current driven, and all they do is compare what goes up one wire with what comes back down the other, and trip out if they're not the same!
Use of inverter... - hillman
"24v can kill if there is enough current going through you"

Listen to Hugo. The current that flows through you depends on volts, certainly, but it depends more on the resistance of your skin. If your hands and feet are wet and muddy (as at a camp-site) it's a completely different situation and 24V has killed. The effect also depends on your state of health. What a young fit person can shrug off might stop an older person?s heart beating. The effect of an A.C shock from an inverter is different from D.C., from the car. A.C. will make your muscles go into spasm, and you will clutch the source. D.C. is much less onerous.

Don't compare it to a Megger insulation tester. That is the trick that you play on apprentice electricians. If you hold onto the wires tightly then you will be OK - although the voltage is 500V the current is very low. If you let go it will kick you. Likewise, one of the tricks played by old time mechanics would be to hold a finger on a spark plug and touch the arm of the apprentice. That was when the plugs fired at about 12 000 volts. Don't try it now, the voltage is much higher. Both cases were lots of voltage and very little current.

I can only repeat, Don't mess around with mains voltage devices, especially if you have a perfectly suitable 12V ones.
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
"A.C. will make your muscles go into spasm, and you will clutch the source. D.C. is much less onerous."

Other way round. One reason why DC mains didn't catch on, as if you got a shock, you couldn't let go!

Agree with everything else, though. 240V next to your ear while you're on your back in a muddy campsite is not a good idea!

Use of inverter... - wemyss
Bonnington I remember Nottingham being changed over from DC to AC. A friends Dad knowing this was to happen bought up some surplus DC machine tools from Raleigh Cycle factory.
When the changeover came the Electricity Boad replaced them all with new. This would have been in the 50s. I wonder who was the last City to change over.
Use of inverter... - wemyss
Hillman..your mention of the megger brings back memories of fifty years ago when they had handles on the side to wind up.
It used to be a competition on site who could hold on the longest. Didnt realise the one who used to win held it the tightest.
I was always impressed by the cable jointers who made new connections of one of the phases to supply a new building.
Working at the bottom of a muddy trench standing on a rubber mat with the supply on, stripping the insulation and making lead wiped soldered joints off them. Death wish crew we used to call them.
Use of inverter... - David Horn
When I had a part time job welding trailers it used to be a competition to see who could hold on to a live welding rod and the chassis the longest....
Use of inverter... - Roly93
IIRC RCDs work on mains because the earth is the return
path to the power station
Exactly. One of the two wires to your house is earthed
BEFORE it gets to the RCD at the house. Just
what I was advocating above, that should be done with one
of the inverter outputs. In effect, make the inverter your new
'power station'.

>>
I understand that the equivalent of the neutral wire is earthed at the source.
Use of inverter... - LHM
JBJ,

Just to put on my pedant's cap for a moment - the UK mains supply is 230V rms (approximately sinusoidal) which means the live terminal goes from +325 to -325V relative to the neutral!

I think that the physiological effects of DC mains were overshadowed by the ease of transforming AC to very high voltages (making transmission far more effecient), together with the advantages afforded by 3-phase operation.......

Pedant's hat now safely stored away :-)
Use of inverter... - hillman
No, AC current is far more likely to damage you than DC.

In cars the electric power used to be produced by a DC ?Generator? with commutator and brushes. For years now a different type of generator has been used, called an ?Alternator? because it generates AC. It still puts out DC though, because it has a rectifier on the output.
The output from a battery is smooth DC. A rectifier causes an amount of ripple on the current because the diodes only pass the current one way. The simplest type of rectifier is called a half wave. If the rectifier has four diodes it is a full wave, with less ripple. A three phase rectifier has six diodes, with less ripple still. In industry we use three phase controlled rectifiers with SCRs (silicon controlled rectifiers) ? it is then called 6 pulse. The next step up is a 12 pulse, with two 6 pulse sets and an interface transformer to give a much smoother output. Up to three 12 pulse sets can be used in parallel to give 36 pulse. The older systems might have currents up to 400 thousand amps at hundreds of volts. Men work on the busbars doing checks. If the rectifiers develop a problem and ripple appears on the current it would endanger the men. The ripple is in effect AC superimposed on the DC. For the protection of the men a device called an ?AC on DC? relay is used. This measures the ripple and if it exceeds a safe level the system has to be shut down. I hope this isn?t too much boring information.

The way cars and lorries are developing the load is becoming too great for 12 or 24 volts, and 48 volts might become the future norm. It is an interesting time.
Use of inverter... - Altea Ego
I am sorry hilman but DC is more dangerous than AC

You get also get very very severe burning with DC shocks and the body or limb is not jerked free as the DC causes a contraction and gripping to the source.
Use of inverter... - buzbee
I stand by what I said about use of the earth.

J Bonington Jagworth: IMHO the earth connection is not essential.

In that case you will be able to explain to me how you are able to get the current in the two wires to be unbalanced with a fully floating pair of wires coming out of the inverter.

On the contrary, what current flows out of one must go back up the other, and the RCD will NOT trip. It is a simple law of physics.

Where else is did you think the current was going to flow?
Use of inverter... - Hugo {P}
I think it's time we got onto motoring again chaps.

Yes I know I did indulge in this conversation earlier but I was hoping you'd all change the subject and I wouldn't have to come clean. Just can't rely on anyone these days ;)

Anyone who wishes to discuss the virtues of DC and AC would enjoy themselves on here:

www.screwfix.com/talk/forum.jspa?forumID=23

Electricians of all walks of life here. You'll have to register to post anything here. But it is to the building trade what this forum is to motoring.

Hugo - BR Moderator
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
Point taken, Hugo, but if I may respond briefly to my critics...

LHM, you're quite right about RMS. I'd like to say I was generalising deliberately, but in fact I'd just forgotten!

Buzbee, I stand by what I said: "It's the current going to earth (e.g. through you and/or when there's a fault) that creates an imbalance" and thus trips the RCD. Current will go to earth (through you if necessary) even if the supply is floating, believe me! The reason the mains neutral is normally bound to earth is to minimise the number of live wires.

I'll shut up now...
Use of inverter... - buzbee
It's the current going to earth . . . that creates an imbalance . . . believe me!

No I do not, because it is not true.

By definition a floating supply has no connection with earth. What flows out of one wire goes back to the other. (If you doubt this, consider the example of a secondary winding on a transformer for instance. At that stage it has no connection elsewhere) So if you touch either wire singly, no current passes through you. Period.

Also, if the two wires pass through an RCD before being used, there is no circuit that can be made, involving those wires coming out of the RCD, through you or otherwise, involving earth or otherwise, that will cause the current in the two wires to differ. So the RCD will not work. [For the pedantic, I am ignoring capacitor effects)

As I said earlier, draw out the circuit for yourself and you will see this. You are surely not suggesting the earth can be used as a current sink for current from one of the wires? It can't. At least not in the context here.
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
"So if you touch either wire singly, no current passes through you."

So you can't get a shock off a floating supply? You have invented safe electricity!
Use of inverter... - Steptoe
I must confess that I haven't fully grasped what the argument is about, but would like to mention that the 33Kv transmission line behind my house is frequently used as a perch. As the birds have quite a short wheelbase they come to no harm!!
Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
Indeed, but that's because they are birds and not standing on the ground! If you had long enough arms (or a pole or piece of wet string), you would find that contact with the earth makes a big difference. Buzbee will argue that this is because the power grid is itself earthed, and I will then invite him to hold a spark plug lead (also about 33kV) while the engine is running... :-)

(At last, a motoring link!)
Use of inverter... - tunacat
But Buzbee also told us to ignore capacitance effects.

The car?s battery and alternator are a floating source with respect to earth. If you hold a spark plug lead but touch no other part of the car, the only reason you?ll get a shock is because of the leakage current passing through the effective capacitors of the car?s tyres, your shoe soles, and the plug-lead?s insulation.
And this is really due to the fast risetime of the electrical spikes being sent to the plug. If the plug was being sent a 50Hz sinewave, the effect would be much much less.

Use of inverter... - J Bonington Jagworth
"the effective capacitors of the car?s tyres.."

First time I've heard them described as capacitors! Of course, the earth itself can behave like one, which is why current will flow to it from unearthed sources. If they were as safe as has been suggested, then the RCD that started this debate would be unnecessary, and Old Banger could use his inverter-driven mains lamp with impunity...
Use of inverter... - v8man
Since when did rubber become a capacitor? For this to happen the tyres would have to have the ability to store electricity and as we all know rubber is an insulator.
--
\"Nothing less than 8 cylinders will do\"
Use of inverter... - buzbee
Now the argument has gone to the silly 33KV extreme to try and win a point.

The original author asked a question about using an RCD with a 240v DC/AC converter supply. That AC supply *will* be provided by means of a winding on a transformer. I have built such things. I stayed relevant to that, in spite of all the way off subject dilution contributions.

Now the spurious tangent suggesting 33KV, a voltage 137 times higher, and no help to him.

What is dangerous is the totally erroneous statement that the use of an earth with the RCD is unnecessary. That was what needed refuting.

steptoe: The gist of all this is in my first reply at the top. Since the go and return current in a two wire supply like this must be equal, and an RCD drops out only when they are not equal, for the RCD to work with a fault, one of the two wires from the two-wire supply must have two paths, only one of them going via the RCD together with the other wire.

That second path, to one wire of the two-wire supply, is via an earth that is made before the use of the RCD. If you simply earth after the RDC you, in effect, cause the earth current to also flow through the RCD such that the two currents are equal and it does not work. All this can be shown using Kirchoffs laws. Hope this is legible. Must go. --- on to other things and back to my charm school --BYE.
Use of inverter... - Steptoe
Buzbee,
Sorry, my tangent off to the 33Kv lines was based on your username; you probably remember BT Busby sitting on the wires...perfectly safe with a telephone voltage of only 50dc plus 75ac ringing, the latter being the one that used to make me jump!

I do appreciate your reasoning re. the reqirement for an earth to create a flow imbalence through the RCD in the event of a fault.
Use of inverter... - local yokel
Getting back to motoring for a moment ...

Remember that a car's battery is designed to give a high output for a short time, whereas using an inverter will take low output for longer. Although the inverter should have a low voltage cut-off/alarm, you could easily run the battery too low. Campers etc. use a second "leisure" battery which is differently made and designed to be almost fully discharged. Do this to a starter battery and you kill it faster, although 2 weeks camping with the loads you describe won't do too much harm.
Use of inverter... - v8man
buzbee - I don't know where you studied electrical principles but Kirchoffs law refers to resistance, specifically measuring resistance in a circuit.
--
\"Nothing less than 8 cylinders will do\"
Use of inverter... - v8man
You do indedd get 'ripples' with rectifiers that is why smoothing capacitors are used. Big electrolytic ones that act as reservoirs.
--
\"Nothing less than 8 cylinders will do\"
Use of inverter... - Hugo {P}
Right!

I've asked politely for this to be kept to motoring. Whilst JBJ did push the issue a little further, many of you seemed to ignore my request above with impunity.

The sponsers are supporting a motoring forum, therefore we as moderators need to keep the site motoring related. We do have a couple of threads that are non motoring related and we can organise e mail address exchanges for any members who find they have a common interest outside motoring.

Those who wish to discuss motoring may do so in this thread or any other thread, except the Computer Related Questions or IHAQ threads.

Those who have any questions about AC or DC etc may use the IHAQ thread.

The next non motoring post I see on this thread will get it locked!

Hugo - BR Moderator