What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
Are dealers, main dealers especially, still knocking a huge chunk of part-ex value on UK spec. foreign imports?
Does the UK conformity cert. make any difference?
Or is there still the prejudice and sucking of teeth?
If so, what percentage are they knocking off the value?

Simon
Dealer Penalty for Imports - martint123
Same percentage as you saved when importing??
Dealer Penalty for Imports - SjB {P}
Same percentage as you saved when importing??

Totally irrelevant.

Just like when someone wins a car in a lottery, so it could effectively be 'free', and decides to sell it. As soon as the buyer hears it was a freebie, they want to knock the price down because they feel they should inherit some sort of knock-on benefit. Why? What the seller paid has no relevance to second hand price. The car is worth what the car is worth.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Altea Ego
Indeed, and so many good cheap second hand cars around that as soon as a buyer gets wind of the word "import" they toddle off and buy a non import.

Ok there might not be anything wrong with an import, it might just be scare stories spread around by dealers, but mud sticks.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
>it might just be scare stories spread around by dealers, but mud sticks
I don't see how this argument can be true with cars built in Britain, shipped out to somewhere in Europe and then re-imported.
Certain Nissans, Hondas and Peugeots especially fit this description. They will be identical to UK cars.
They are tarred with the same brush as far east 'oddities' and personally imported stuff.
Fair enough if you are trying to part-ex something that the dealer would find hard to shift. But most seem to be narrow minded on this matter.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Thommo
I can not off the top of my head think of a car that is made in two factories now.

Remember the old Granada how everyone wanted a German made one and not one made in Blighty?

As such all cars made in UK are either not imports or exported and re-imported or made abroad in which case they are all imports. Absolutely no difference except for spec. and most people who go on about UK spec don't even know what UK spec. is.

The dealers spread horror stories around to try and maintain their margins, simple as that. Any dealer who offers you a lower price for an import laugh in his face and sell it privately.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
>Any dealer who offers you a lower price for an import laugh in his face and sell it privately.

SWMBO has been offered 10k in part ex for an imported, but built in Swindon, 52reg Honda CRV auto. Looking on Autotrader the dealers have similar ones up at 13k to 13.5k.
So even if as a private sale we only managed 12.5k we would be 2500 better off. Thats 25%!!!
Scr3w3d by the dealer prejudice or what?
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Altea Ego
"Scr3w3d by the dealer prejudice or what?"

No thats called making a profit.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - wantone
Any dealer who offers you a lower price for an import laugh in his face and sell it privately.

from what ive heard about dealers and buyers? youll have a permanant laugh on your face.i havent heard of a dealer yet that doesnt tuttut at a import!!
Dealer Penalty for Imports - blue_haddock
I can not off the top of my head think of
a car that is made in two factories now.


Toyota Corolla is made in either Japan, UK or even turkey, Yaris is either Japan or France.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Thommo
Thank you Blue, thinking about it is the BMW 3 series made in Germany and South Africa now also?

Plus again there's a new Citroen plant in Vigo so maybe some Citroen models now made in France and Spain. Anyhow...

With regard to the Honda. Made in Swindon and its an IMPORT! If you didn't laugh you'd cry.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - mountainkat
the main point is not where it's made but to which countries specifications - a car may well be made in the UK but if it's intended for export to Europe the standard equipment list may well be different so you wouldn't be comparing like for like.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Thommo
And what piece of UK spec. equipment not on a non-UK spec. car is worth 25% of the cars value would you say?
Dealer Penalty for Imports - GrahamF1
Another great myth put about by the dealers to try and keep margins up. References to imported cars "not meeting UK safety standards" used to be commonplace, and for anyone who could see past the smokescreen - laughable.

For christ's sake, anyone with half a brain can see the reality. They are the SAME car, they came off the SAME production line in Spain, Germany, wherever. It's just that one got shipped to a dealer in Oxford and the other went to a dealer in Bruges.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
>the main point is not where it's made but to which countries specifications - a car may well be made in the UK but if it's intended for export to Europe the standard equipment list may well be different so you wouldn't be comparing like for like

Even if the spec is identical it is still worth less?
So are you saying the Cert. of UK conformity is pointless?

I thought that was the reason for them. To make sure dealers could not give 'different spec, sorry mate' as an excuse for ripping Joe Public off.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Altea Ego
A Cert of UK conformity is to establish the car meets uk construction and use regulations, NOT that it matches the spec of the same model sold in the UK.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
>A Cert of UK conformity is to establish the car meets uk construction and use regulations, NOT that it matches the spec of the same model sold in the UK.

So, despite having a UK Conformity Cert. and other documentary proof that all the toys are there, they can still try to rip me off?
Something is still very wrong.
The only reason this dealer knew there was _anything_ unusual about the CRV was that the HPI check did not give the model as SE Sport, or the transmission as auto.
I suppose if the car got in to the hands of a dealer they could add the missing info in to the Experian database and add the 2500 quid back on.
Or am I being too harsh?
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Bromptonaut
If a customer perceives the import as being in some way inferior the facts are irrelevant. Was there not an earlier thread complaining about dealers not disclosing a vehicle offered for sale as imported and it being overpriced as a result?.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Altea Ego
Why did you buy an Import in the first place?
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
It was bought because it was identical to the CRV's in the local Honda showroom, but without the 3 month wait they had and only slightly cheaper.
At the time the new CRV had just come out and we were told 'there is a waiting list, so no discount off list'.
The local dealer was quite disinterested in doing anything other than working out what finance he could sell me after giving me a pathetic trade in for my car.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - BobbyG
Its an easy one here, we should all just buy imports from now on. That way we all save money and stop rip-off Britain!

Oh, and when your car breaks down and there are no garages left in UK to service it, you can take it abroad and get it serviced.
And ditto when you need a spare part. And then when you come to trade it in, you will only be able to trade it in on for someone else's import! And then you will want it cheaper....cos its an import!

If you honestly thought that when you paid £x cheaper for your car and it would not affect a resale value, then you were sadly mistaken. Also, by your comments that the dealer only knew it was import after the HPI check, I take it this is your way of saying you didn't tell them it was an import?

I understand what you are saying about the car being identical in your opinion, and your frustrations of your perceived value, but I am afraid the law of the jungle says that you cannot win at both ends of the deal!
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Aprilia
Its an easy one here, we should all just buy imports
from now on. That way we all save money and stop
rip-off Britain!
Oh, and when your car breaks down and there are no
garages left in UK to service it, you can take it
abroad and get it serviced.
And ditto when you need a spare part. And then when
you come to trade it in, you will only be able
to trade it in on for someone else's import! And then
you will want it cheaper....cos its an import!



Don't worry - there will be plenty of people willing to service import cars and supply spares - if only the manufacturers/import concessionaires will let them!
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Dalglish
simon -

in your initial post you ask "Are dealers, main dealers especially, still knocking a huge chunk of part-ex value on UK spec. foreign imports? Does the UK conformity cert. make any difference? Or is there still the prejudice and sucking of teeth?
If so, what percentage are they knocking off the value? "

that implies that you have not asked any dealer to value your car, and we are all asssuming that you are being ripped off when in fact you have not even tried to sell them your car yet.

in your last post you say "The local dealer was quite disinterested in doing anything other than working out what finance he could sell me after giving me a pathetic trade in for my car."

that implies that you will probably get a similar or worse attitude when trying to sell rather than buy.

however, in any case, it is all a question of demand and supply ( just as it was when you wanted to buy. ) you will get a price suited for the market conditions and the method by which you bring it to market. no compulsion. it is a free country. personally, i would not buy an import however better spec or quality it was unless it was heavily discounted. why - because i know that the stigma attached to an import will make it harder for me to sell it. chicken and egg, which came first?

Dealer Penalty for Imports - Altea Ego
Plus as I described the market is awash with good used cars. Your car comes up as suspect on the Experion register, so it will be tougher to sell.

Fact of life me old fruit. You are paying for the "I want it and I want it NOW"
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
>in your last post you say "The local dealer was quite disinterested in doing anything other than working out what finance he could sell me after giving me a pathetic trade in for my car."

This was the Honda dealer I went to try and by a 'proper' CRV, before I eventually bought the CRV from a car importer.

>in your initial post you ask "Are dealers, main dealers especially, still knocking a huge
>chunk of part-ex value on UK spec. foreign imports? Does the UK conformity cert. make
>any difference? Or is there still the prejudice and sucking of teeth?
>If so, what percentage are they knocking off the value? "

I have since tried to part ex it against another car last week and found the import prejudice.
The saving I made was only 800 quid, and so 2500 seems a hell of a lot to knock off at trade in.
That is what the original post is about.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Blue {P}
>>
I have since tried to part ex it against another car
last week and found the import prejudice.
The saving I made was only 800 quid, and so 2500
seems a hell of a lot to knock off at trade
in.
That is what the original post is about.


Where does this £2,500 figure come from? Is that the difference between the trade-in you were offered and what they sell for in the Autotrader?

If so, how much would you expect to get for the trade-in? Someone, somewhere has to make a profit in the region of £1,500 on selling your part exchange.

Blue
Dealer Penalty for Imports - madux
(Switches on Pedant Mode)
I had a strange conversation with an insurance company the other day.
"I'd like a quote for my Mazda please"
"Certainly sir. Is it an Import?"
(pause)
"Yes, but aren't they all imported?"
"Most of them aren't, sir"
"So we now build Mazdas in Britain, do we?"
"I wouldn't know about that, sir"
"But you've just said........"
Never mind. You know what I mean. I know what you lot mean.
Perhaps we should have another word for it.
(At least she was 'trained' to call me sir, if nothing else!)
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Thommo
You know if the car is made and imported from another EU country this is all discrimination under ther terms of the 8th Directive on Trade and totally illegal.

OK so none of us is going to take this to the European Court but it might be worth asking a dealer to put in writing that he values a car manufactured in a EU country other than UK and then sold by a dealer in that country and then imported to UK as less that one manufactured in an EU country but then imported in to this country and sold by a UK dealer as a 'UK' car. If he refers the matter to Head Office they will freak out as they probably remember the swinging fines when they were caught illegally stopping EU dealers selling right hand drive cars.

As to the post above about all the garages in UK disappearing if we don't let them rip us off on new car prices, if I posted that it is one of the most ridiculous things I have read on this website the Mods would complain so I won't post that.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - trancer
I propose we now refer to them as "UK Market" and "Foreign Market".

One thing I am not clear on, is Simon saying that his foreign market CRV is worth £2500 less on trade in than a UK market CRV?. Or is he basing the difference in price on what he sees used CRVs being sold for by main dealers?.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - costablancabloke
I have sold 2 properties through Propertybroker.co.uk or com (whatever) & both times the punters wanted to knock off the amount of estate agents fees & a bit more!!
hey try to take your saving as theirs. Human nature obviously.

CBB

PS No rant 2day
Dealer Penalty for Imports - BrianM
When selling on or trading in an import, I think you'll always get a lower price than an UK supplied model would fetch, regardless of whether the car is to full UK spec. Most buyers will go for a UK supplied car over an imported car every time and there are loads of UK supplied cars available. This means that the only way an import will sell is if the price is lower, so it is a more attractive buy than a UK equivalent. It just market forces. I don't think it is unreasonable for a dealer to offer a lower price. Its a recognition that the car will not sell for as much as a UK car.

I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with buying an import - I bought one myself - but the price has to be right. There has to be a decent saving to offset the lower value when you come to sell the car. If you are only saving hundreds, then its probably not worth it. You really need to be saving thousands.

Brian



Dealer Penalty for Imports - blue_haddock
Brian - thats a very well put explantation of why we offer less for an import, i couldn't have put it better myself.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - Simon (Anne\'s Other Half)
Trancer,
I found Autotrader had main dealer examples up at as much as 13,950 but the norm was 13,500. Non Franchise were asking between about 12,500 and 13,000.
I was expecting the Skoda dealer I took it to to offer around 12k.
Dealer Penalty for Imports - trancer
I thought that you might be getting your figures from others for sale. While I am not disputing that you were offered less for your car compared to a UK supplied, I really don't think that the difference would be as much as £2500 between. Only way to know would be to offer a similar UK supplied car and see what the trade in value was. Not saying you will find any consolation in that