Damage to door

Honest John Back Room » Motoring discussion
What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
View Threaded
Thu 17 Jun 2004 21:50
Damage to door - Doc
One of my colleagues? at work has reversed into the front drivers door of my Rover.
Damage is two dents and a broken door mirror. The car was hit with some force.
She has admitted liability and payment will be via her insurance.
I have started to get quotes, but the suggested remedy is not consistent.

No.1: (Rover Main dealer): new door skin.

No.2 (large bodyshop linked to Nissan/Rover/VW dealer: repair to dents only.

No.3 (independant BMW Garage which does bodywork for all makes): new door!

The door now has uneven gaps around the edges.
I have no prices yet.

Can I push for a new door, or will the other insurance company try to go with the cheapest option?

Or can the existing door be sucessfully re-aligned after repair?

The car is in extremely good condition, so I want it returned to its previous state.
Any thoughts?


Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 17 Jun 2004 23:01
Damage to door - Sooty Tailpipes
I'g get a new door. As it's her insurance, you have a right to be put in the situation you were before the accident. You didn't have filler in your door, or a door skin which will probably skew the reflection down the flank of your car, and rust at the bottom after a few years. Just get two quotes for "replace door and make good."
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 17 Jun 2004 23:30
Damage to door - spinner
If her insurance is covering it - I'd go for the new door. Take it to the garage and they'll agree with you.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 18 Jun 2004 10:35
Damage to door - OldPeculiar
If the door has become warped as you suggested in your post then filling or a new skin is never going to make the door fit the gap as well as it used to - get a new door. Is there any damage to the adjacent door or wing or to the hinges etc?
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 19 Jun 2004 09:21
Damage to door - L'escargot
Won't whichever insurance company is paying for the repair want to have one of their assessors approve the cost (and hence the method) of the repair?
--
L'escargot by name, but not by nature.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 19 Jun 2004 12:17
Damage to door - Sooty Tailpipes
They may *want* to, but you have the right to have it repaired at the VBRA (or whatever it's now called) bodyshop of your choice. You will not lose statutory rights if you do, but you may lose rights such as them providing car hire free at the point of use (you would have to pay and claim it back which could take months)
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 19 Jun 2004 14:44
Damage to door - Doc
I have now spoken to several bodyshops and the general concensus seems to be that a new door is not required and that a sucessful repair can be made to the door. (It would seem that if inspected, the other party's insurance company would not agree to a new door)

I am told that a door skin is not necessary, but that if used would show that a repair had been made, as they would not be able to match the factory welding/sealing around the edges(viewed when the door is opened) which may put off future buyers.
Also, a door skin would involve more paint matching with adjacent panels.

I have found a small bodyshop locally and have been able to inspect their work.
As the man said: "if you come here, I will be the one actually working on the repair, but if you go to a large outfit you will never really be sure what has been done, or if the apprentice did it"

I am inclined to use this repairer as he was most helpful and a welcome change from the 'production line' attitude of the large dealers/bodyshops.

What do you think?


Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 19 Jun 2004 17:17
Damage to door - Altea Ego
Sounds like a bloke with some pride in his work.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 19 Jun 2004 19:56
Damage to door - Mondaywoe
Repairs from 'approved' bodyshops usually come with (at least) a 3 year warranty these days. You can always take it back if you're not happy and insist it's done properly.

A new door is possibly not necessary, but do make sure that the frame isn't very slightly twisted - enough to leave uneven gaps around the frame.

Graeme
Reply | Report as offensive | Link

We give you the low down on how to save on insurance, little-known tricks and tips, what insurance groups mean and how to use insurance aggregators to beat insurers.

Insurance group finder and how to save on insurance

Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.

The Good Garage Guide