What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Falsely accused - cockle {P}
Had a strange experience this afternoon.

Pulled into a busy filling station and, as usual, had to wait to get on a DERV pump while a chap in a 53 Merc filled up. After he had filled up he moved off the pump to let me refuel, nice, thoughtful chap, I thought and promptly filled up.

When I go in to pay the lady behind the till ran my agency card through and then says that leaves £23 to pay for the other transaction. It would appear that the Merc driver hadn't just pulled off the pump, he'd done a runner and now the cashier expected me to pay!

I politely, but firmly, pointed out that I was not going to pay for someone else's fuel, whereupon she called the manager over. I explained that I had seen the Merc driver on the pump before me to which she responded that she only had my word for it as the CCTV wasn't working so they couldn't check therefore she felt that I had probably had the fuel and should pay!

I then pointed out that the till slip showed me buying DERV and the previous transaction was for super un-leaded which would be of no use to me whatsoever, also the total volume of the two purchases exceeded the capacity of my tank.

She then accused me of filling up cans which I had hidden in the back of my van so I took her outside and showed her the inside of the van, which, surprise, surprise was devoid of petrol cans.
In the end it was only the fact that I was noisily demanding, in front of a shop full of people, that she call the police to settle the matter that caused her to climb down and accept that 'You might just be telling the truth, so I think I'll let it rest rather than bother the police.'

To say I was gob-smacked would be an understatement!
I'm still wondering if it was Candid Camera.

Cockle
Falsely accused - Sooty Tailpipes
Ugh! I wouldn't have had such patience, I have just waled out twice without paying at all recently...

a) Price on board outside was 2p less than on pump, noticed after it got to £21, went in and complained, man just shrugged and grinned, and said £21, he didn't understand English, I walked out, and complained to the petrol company by email about the price difference, and having a man who is not only supposed to provide a service to customers, but is also supposed to be a 'competent person' for the Petroleum license. They said the manager said I was looking at the wrong product so I dropped the matter and never paid.

b) Recently, a new XXXX Express opened with a supermarket running the shop and selling their goods. I went and filled up with fuel, and went in the shop, there was a queue of about 20 people, so I just walked out and went home. A week later I filled up again, and gave them the money for the time before, and she got all flummaxed and didn't know what to do and probably kept it for herself, but I got a scrawled receipt on their till slip.

STAND FIRM!
Falsely accused - Oz
Cockle, thanks for sharing this drama with us (I mean it) - I could almost see your hackles rising in the face of such sustained incompetence and fatuousness. Wish I had been there to express my opinions as systematically as you obviously did. Annoyingly for you they patronised you by implying there was still an element of doubt.
Oz (as was)
Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}
Cockle.

This false accusation obviously caused you some hurt. I would write a very strong letter to the managment of the Garage demading some compensation for your hurt feelings - especially in the way it was handled (publicly).
Falsely accused - Miller
Would anyone who could afford a 53 merc deliberately drive off without paying? (unless he had stolen it!)

Falsely accused - NorthernKev {P}
Perhaps how he could afford a new Merc...

Falsely accused - J Bonington Jagworth
"..anyone who could afford a 53 merc"

Actually, I thought he meant it was an old one... :-)
------------------
Die dulci fruere!
Falsely accused - borasport20
Cockle

I sit here, trawling the backroom, and every couple of weeks or so we see a post from Growler pointing out that we have no idea about service industries, and I think 'silly old ????' (No offence, Big G !)

And then you read FiF on motorway services, and you on petrol stations, and its all to easy to believe. In this country, the customer is always wrong unless they can prove otherwise.

Take Pugulgy's advice and stuff them at the highest level. Failing that, was it a 24 hr service station ? If not, a late night visit with a box of matches might make you feel better.....


--
Bora - what Bora ?
Falsely accused - scruffythedog118
Me thinks that some one is having a laugh!!!!!

They drop a clanger, then expect to wriggle their way out of it by charging the next person, err, yeah right!!!!

I would have loved every minute of it ( but I'm like that) & god damn it I would NOT pay for some elses fuel or anything else for that matter, and would have kicked up such a fuss with all and sundry especially as being accused of trying to nick / steal something......

Hay, Hay just my two pennies worth - well done for standing your ground and too right!
Falsely accused - No Do$h
Well, now you know the CCTV is kaput, put the word out amongst your friends (but not on here!) that free fuel can be had at this location.
Falsely accused - Dwight Van Driver
Not condoning the action of the Attendant (and PU gives excellent advice - go to it) but do not the Petrol firms make the Attendants responsible for shortcomings i.e. losses come out of their wages. Which is probably why an aggressive approach?

DVD
Falsely accused - Godfrey H {P}
Wouldn't it be illegal to dock the cashiers wages nowadays?
Falsely accused - daveyjp
I was once filling up when the car next to me drove off without paying. What amused me was they only nicked £5 of fuel. Surely if you are driving off anyway you fill up!!
Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}
A guy who used to do some work for me (sadly dead now) used to work a a service station, there were so many drive offs at one point that the Manager there (he had the site on licence from a very well known fuel company)threatened to dock the attendants pay. Another lad who worked there was known for chasing offenders on foot ! Both these lads I would have trusted with next month's salary worked hard for next to nothing and eventually moved on because of the Manager's attitude. I can understand why check out staff can get very worked up if they work for a Dickensian owners no excuse for being so rude and unprofessional about it though.
Falsely accused - patently
Wouldn't it be illegal to dock the cashiers wages nowadays?


Depends how vicious their lawyers were when they wrote the contract of employment. Hands up everyone who reads all contracts carefully before signing them.... (this is an excellent way to spot lawyers, btw)

I do remember waiting for ever in a supermarket petrol queue After 10 mins (no, I'm not kidding) I set a time limit - if they didn't offer to accept my cash within the next 2 mins then I would assume they didn't want it and drive off. The queue then accelerated, of course.

Next time its a 1 minute deadline.
Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}
"Hands up everyone who reads all contracts carefully before signing them.... (this is an excellent way to spot lawyers, btw)"

Wrote me own (tee hee)
Falsely accused - np
\"Hands up everyone who reads all contracts carefully before signing them....
(this is an excellent way to spot lawyers, btw)\"
Wrote me own (tee hee)



I have some sympathy with the plight of the petrol attendant as my wife works part time in a 24 hour Safeway/Petrol Station to supplement our income whilst she trains to be a teacher.

After checking the car against a list of known offenders, there is simply nothing she can do about drive-offs to prevent them. She is inside, they are outside. In addition, I would counsel her against ever trying to prevent one physically in case she came to any harm.

So I think stereotypes about shoddy workers and docking wages are a little unfair. Just think - she could be teaching your little ones in a few years!

Having said that, I sympathise with the original poster. The staff and manager were well out of line there. Well done for standing your ground.

A petrol station I often call at only allows the pumps furthest away to be used by pre-paying customers. This seems a sensible compromise. Perhaps a sensible industry standard would be to have the furthest pumps as the 24 hour type where you use your credit card and the nearest pumps the traditional type where you go in and pay...

...or do like they do in France where you pay as you leave in your car and a barrier prevents you leaving otherwise? No? Too much like common sense for GB :) (like putting a coin into the trolley to ensure it gets back to where it is supposed to)
Falsely accused - Fullchat
Reports of Making Off Without Payment (MOWP) are a real pain in the proverbial for the old bill. It seems that certain forecourts are targeted by regulars and word gets round. " We've got it on CCTV " Well for one CCTV quality is usually lousy. CCTV tapes have to be seized and sent for stills to be taken off and statements and Crime Reports completed.
There are False plates, hooded tops and non registered vehicles.
The answer is quite simple. Pre pay delivery. The fuel companies can afford it. Tradition is a wonderful thing but we must be practical. If adequate crime prevention methods are not taken why should a Police response be expected. Same thing applies to Credit Card fraud. The major banks and financial institutions seem reluctant to use state of the art technology or even a picture yet when the cards are stolen and then used in crime the complaints come flooding in.
Strangely MOWP did not carry a power of arrest BUT it does now. So for all those who think of leaving without payment for whatever reason think of the embarrasement factor! I do agree however that waiting in a long queue of grocery shoppers is extremely infuriating and have felt like it myself.


Fullchat
Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}
Fullchat,
What would have been your response if sent to the above incident
(note use of Police type words - too much time in custody units this Christmas)
Falsely accused - Fullchat
PU


I think stern words with the cashier and supervisor. Perhaps some advice as to how to prevent it happening again.
Having said that we all can a have a bad day but saying " sorry" costs nothing.


Fullchat
Falsely accused - cockle {P}
Fortunately I am not the sort of person to 'go off on one' and could see the ridiculousness of it all after 10 minutes or so. I have spent 30 years dealing with the public and can't believe the way I sometimes get treated as a customer, if I reacted the way these people did I wouldn't have a job.
I suppose that really I was more amused than anything else, I really do like watching these fools dig themselves in even deeper, especially when I know that I'm in the right!
All this experience has done really is to confirm my opinion of these Express places, I shall just avoid them even more in future, although that is sadly becoming more difficult.

Cockle
Falsely accused - Hugo {P}
Absolutely gobsmacked!

I think I've heard them all now!

Firstly, as PU suggested, a letter demanding compensation for this incident, followed by a phone call to your local tabloid newspaper, they love things like this!

The wife and I had a similar thing in a cafe in Cornwall years ago, nothing was said but the assistant obviously thought we were guilty of stealing a can of coke. A family in front of us waiting to pay were buying the shop out of sandwitches, pasties and coke when one of their number innocently took their can from the tray without the mother seeing. She then pointed out to the cashier that she was a can short and he put another one on her tray.

When it came to our turn, nothing was said and the transaction went through smoothly. However the dirty looks from said cashier was enough to prevent us from enjoying our meal. I could have put him right but I decided that his ignorence exceeded most of his other attributes and ignored the matter.

Hugo
Falsely accused - Quinny
One things for certain,I would never be able to drive off in my artic after filling up with diesel,(500ltr tank) as we have to present our Key Fuels card first,before paying.This is to make sure the card has not been stolen,and to make sure the bill has been paid by our head office.

But as for the garage making the accusations,I agree with a previous post of contacting your local paper's editor and asking him if he would be interested in the story.
Falsely accused - pdc {P}
...or do like they do in France where you pay as
you leave in your car and a barrier prevents you leaving
otherwise? No? Too much like common sense for GB
:) (like putting a coin into the trolley to ensure it
gets back to where it is supposed to)


The ASDA petrol station next to the Wolvs football ground has barriers at the pay point, and metal spikes preventing you from leaving by the entrance.
Falsely accused - THe Growler
You can call me anything you like Sir Borasport but there is a strong impression to the visitor that UK service standards of the one-on-one variety, to put it politely, frequently suck. And remember the attitude of the front-line staff more often than not reflects the way the management sees their job and the customer himself (dammit sorry, should have said "her"-self, still working on this PC thing).

The poster's experience here is appalling but I am not in the least surprised, for a service station minimum wage hire what are you going to get? Transient staff, maybe immigrants with poor English and no motivation, guys who never made it through high school. When your business is cost-driven rather than service-led, you have sown the seeds for what those flabby marketeers in their Armani suits like to call the "service experience" or, equally accurately, despite the ghastliness of the phrase, the "customer interface". Your staff will look after your customers in more or less the same way you look after them, because theior attitude reflects what it's like to work around here.

One thing I try hard to do when I encounter especially good service is to make a point of recognising it by means of simple thanks to the counter agent or whoever and a description of the behaviour that pleased me. Sometimes if I'm so sufficiently moved I might even drop a line to the GM with the employee's name.

How many of us bother to do that? It can come back to you too the next time you visit, you may just get that little bit of extra treatment.

We have an old Filipino saying which I commend to anyone involved with C/S attitude training and programme roll-out as the content for their first Power-Point overhead:

"You can catch more flies with a spoonful of honey than a barrel of vinegar".

That's a two-way street, customer or service provider.

...on the practical side, these places set themselves for failure with their petrol payment systems, so they can hardly be surprised if they experience a high proportion of runners. The answer is so simple I wonder what they're all whining about. Forecourt attendants or pre-pay. Just do it.

Falsely accused - Sooty Tailpipes
"The answer is quite simple. Pre pay delivery. The fuel companies can afford it. Tradition is a wonderful thing but we must be practical."

The trouble is with targetting the victims and decent people instead of the criminal scum, is that you just up the anty, we have seen this over the last 30 years or so with all sorts of other crimes.... the problem is, more force and violence is usually the criminal's answer.

ie, you make the cars more secure, they steal the keys from your house while you sleep, they tell you to hide your keys, so you get threatened witha gun or knife at traffic lights, and of course, now a lot of people lock their car doors, and many new cars lock them when you set off... so they will eventually just shoot you dead through the window like they do in Kingston of Johannesberg. Where will it end?

With fuel, they could just ram some sharp object into your plastic fuel tank and drain it out....this scum has all day every day to plot and scheme, they don't work, they want what they see, and will do whatever it takes to get it. For example, all steel roller shutters do is cause ram raids.
Falsely accused - Flat in Fifth
"...on the practical side, these places set themselves for failure with their petrol payment systems, so they can hardly be surprised if they experience a high proportion of runners. The answer is so simple I wonder what they're all whining about. Forecourt attendants or pre-pay. Just do it."

I wonder if the current payment system is maintained because the solutions suggested would reduce the traffic through the potentially much more profitable shop?

Where prepay is available, e.g. local Tesco forecourt, personally I use it every time. Though it can be irritating when the receipt fails to emerge and a trip into the shop past the display of King Size Twix bars is still necessary.

I do agree with many of Growler's comments above and previously, especially the recognition that the honey / vinegar issue really IS a two-way street.

Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}

Always get a receipt.A long standing client (not a criminal/motorist !) was arrested a few years ago. The circumstances where that she was reported as having done a drive-off to the local Police. Her car was circulated and she was stopped and nicked. She had pre-paid but not got a receipt. The attendant had had a genuine drive off but passed my client's details in error. It was eventually proved that she hadn't nicked the fuel. The Police acted quite fairly and had bailed her pending further enquires when they could have charged. The Supermarket garage where negligent. The Police reacted quite furiously and refused to act on calls from this garage until all reports had been fully documeted and backed up with corroborated evidence.

We managed to secure a "substantial" settlement in the end. Lesson to me was always get a receipt, always pay by credit card. If she hadn't she would have ended up in Court and we would have taken it to Crown and consequently would have dragged out for months.

Falsely accused - SteveH42
I wonder if the current payment system is maintained because
the solutions suggested would reduce the traffic through the
potentially much more profitable shop?


Possibly for petrol stations, but not always for supermarket forecourts. A lot of Asdas have kiosks and barriers on the exit rather than a shop and in many ways this speeds things up. Queues tend to be dealt with quicker and as you pull away from the pump to pay the next customer can pull on and be getting ready sooner.
Falsely accused - jc33
>>And then you read FiF on motorway services, and you on petrol stations, and its all to easy to believe. In this country, the customer is always wrong unless they can prove otherwise.

Take Pugulgy's advice and stuff them at the highest level. Failing that, was it a 24 hr service station ? If not, a late night visit with a box of matches might make you feel better.....>>

On this topic raised a few posts up by Borasport, what Borasport? (are they really that fast??...), I had an unpleasant experience back in my Uni days at a very well known chain of petrol stations. It was a 24hr garage and obviously was operating a night till. A couple of my friends and I rolled up (on foot) to get some bread or something, at some early hour of the morning and we had admittedly had quite a bit to drink. We then, in our drunken state, thought it would be amusing to send him to the other side of the store a couple of times to fetch various items of confectionary (which we had every intention of paying for). He took offence to this and after a short argument (him accusing us of taking the mick - a fair cop but only a bit of harmless fun), he proceeded to come out of the shop and physically attack us. The evening ended with my mate in hospital for facial abrasions from the contact between the shop attendant's boot and the forecourt.

We called the police and they went round to the garage the next day to have a word. No charges were pressed in the end but we also wrote a strongly worded letter to the head office of this organisation and were reliably informed that the employee in question no longer worked for the company. Result. Always worth having a go I say.
Falsely accused - Cardew
An MP asked in Parliament for statistics on Making Off Without Payment (MOWP) from Petrol Stations.

Apparently the Home Office do not keep statistics of prosecutions for MOWP from Petrol Stations. They include those incidents with all other cases of MOWP from ??? (restaurants etc?). Surprisingly the total of cases brought to court in England and Wales is less than 2000 each year.

If the number of incidents of MOWP from Petrol Stations is as widespread as we are led to believe it would appear that you have a very good chance of getting away without being prosecuted. Even if 'caught' I suspect that you would not be brought to Court if you pleaded you had simply got distracted and forgot(a 'senior moment'); In all seriousness I bet there are many cases of exactly that happening. Thankfully that excuse is not valid for footballers!
Falsely accused - Flat in Fifth
"If the number of incidents of MOWP from Petrol Stations is as widespread as we are led to believe...."

Straw poll of one.

In the village where we used to live before, as DVD so eloquently puts it, beggaring orf darn sarf, we had just one filling station. Not particularly big with 4 pumps and a small shop, but it was rare to be the only vehicle filling up so reasonably busy I would say. Village population about 9,000 including surrounding areas.

Every quarter when the beat crime statistics came round there were usually around 3 to 4 occasions of MOWP which were all from this garage. I would think that all cases were reported.

To put this in context the report was usually 1 to 1-1/2 A4 pages one line per incident. There were always noticeably more shed/garage breaks and maybe a similar number of criminal damage, and car thefts. Fewer house breaks though maybe only 2/3. (Question were all incidents reported?)

Is this typical?

I don't know but in hindsight it would be interesting to know the clear up rate of these MOWP offences which ought to be easier to solve than, say, the shed breaks where the stuff was invariably up the car boot sale a few hours later. Equally in the overall scheme of things the value of the goods stolen in a MOWP from a filling station is going to be quite low on the Richter scale, even if easily quantified.

You walked round the "flea" market on a Thursday and a look at the stall selling slightly fishing rods, used power tools and almost new second hand mowers, generators etc really made you wonder where they got their stock. Untraceable unfortunately :(




Falsely accused - Pugugly {P}
"Fewer house breaks though maybe only 2/3. (Question were all incidents reported"

House breaks have the highest rate of reporting. I would agree though that a small, busy independant garage would probably report all the drive offs they encounter. My local garage is the same, I recently witnessed the owner overtly recording a number plate. He later told me he thought the driver was about to do a runner.
Falsely accused - Fullchat
In my experience most MOWPS involve vehicles that have disappeared into that big black hole of illegality. The few that are instantly traceable are often genuine people who have genuinly forgotten to pay and thats easily resolved.

Curent trends are for cars to be fitted with false plates and the owners filling up, cans as well, making off and then syphoning off the fuel and selling it before going off and hitting another outlet - quite lucrative!! They are skilled in avoiding CCTV facial shots although thats not too difficult.

Certain establishments seem to be hit more than others. The problem has been so commonplace at these that the Police no longer attend as a matter of course and after issuing a crime number the duty staff are directed to contact there local Police , make an appointment and physically attend for a statement and to hand over CCTV evidence. Not suprisingly few turn up and the matter goes undetected. Its easy to ring up to make a report and expect someone to turn up but actually putting themselves out is a different matter.

Some may say that this is not good service but as I have stated before the Police would spend allday at Filling Stations taking reports which are by and large undetectable. And the general feeling is that the fuel distributors are not really addressing crime prevention measures.


Fullchat
Falsely accused - Dwight Van Driver
>>Avoiding facial shots<<

Which is why the young bucks wear sweatshirts/parkas with hoods.
Should be made illegal.

History lesson FC - Under the Larceny Act 1916 used to be an offence to be found at night with face blackened or disguised with intent to commit an arrestable offence.

No longer on the Statute Book and no comments are needed.

DVD
Falsely accused - Rich Mixture
As I understand it, the problem with pre-pay delivery (as used in the U.S and elsewhere) is that to accomodate cash payment a highly accurate cut off valve is required in the pump dispensing equipment to ensure that the precise quantity of fuel that the customer has (pre) paid for is dispensed. These valves are extremely expensive both to purchase and maintain (calibrate). One can conclude from the fact that they're not in widespread use in the UK that losses from pump and run offences are insufficient to justify the extra expenditure.

With an outdoor payment terminal of course, the payment is made by credit card so accurate control of volume dispense is not required. Having said that, until recently, outdoor payment terminals have been something of a white card fraudsters dream. More sophisticated terminals, coupled with the new EMV chip & pin card standards and the move away from magnetic stripe held data are addressing these shorcomings.

RM
Falsely accused - mikeyb
Our Local Tesco has some kind of digiatl CCTV system which records the number of the car before the pump is activated.

Also I would have thought that pre payment would work OK. During the fuel crisis a few years ago my Local Asda would only allow you £10 of fuel. The pump stopped at £10 every time I used it.
Falsely accused - pdc {P}
I'm not one of these people who fill up in multiples of £5, so how would prepay work for me? I always fill the tank to the top, as it means less refuelling stops over the year, and it also allows me to monitor fuel consumption based on mileage done against fuel just put in.
Falsely accused - Galaxy
There are two petrol stations on the A 127 in Essex which I regularly use fairly to fill up with fuel, usually fairly late at night.

For as long as I can remember, both have signs prominently displayed which say that prepayment is required after 9.00pm before any fuel will be supplied. There aren't any pumps that can read a credit card there, so this is, in practice, a matter of going over to the cash till and handing over cash or a credit card. This has to be done before the staff will switch the pumps on.

One of these stations will switch the pumps on for me, without prepayment, when they see it's me if there is one particular person on duty, but the other members of staff there will not.

I would be very interested to learn whether this practice occurs elsewhere in the country.

I have to say that I am not entirely happy about this arrangement, but the previous lectures that I have given to forecourt staff regarding the importance that I put on trusting people and that I, in turn, also expect to be trusted by others all seem to have fallen on deaf ears! I very much feel that I am not to be trusted, and feel sure that the filling station, if they really wanted to, could find a more satisfactory solution to drive-aways, which I assume is what all this is really about.

What can you do? Perhaps I should write to the fuel company's head office about this practice and see what they have to say?!

Falsely accused - THe Growler
I think it's perfectly reasonable. Can't blame the gas station owner for protecting his business. Anyway it's not personal.
Falsely accused - Dynamic Dave
I would be very interested to learn whether this practice
occurs elsewhere in the country.


Sure does. An Esso garage in Oxfordshire had this policy enforced after 10pm. However, like yourself, one member of staff recognised me after a short period of time and just switched the pump on, trusting that I would pay. The garage closes at 10pm now though; the BP garage down the road was taking most of their customers as it is directly off the main road, rather than a 100 yard drive down to the Esso garage.

Personally I don't see any problem with paying beforehand. Typically it's just the minority of non payers that spoil it for the majority of honest people though.
Falsely accused - pdc {P}
The Sainsburys petrol station in Ashton-under-Lyne is totally automated. There isnt even a booth there for anyone to sit in. All 12 pumps are pre-pay by card.
Falsely accused - stackman
There is a major petrol station near here on a major holiday trunk route which would seem to be a prime candidate for drive-offs. I have noticed that every time I drove past, especialy in the summer, there is a police car parked on the forecourt.

Closer inspection reveals that this is actualy an old-style 'S' reg astra and would appear to be a defunct patrol car which has been parked there by the police to deter drive-offs. (There are never any police officers to be seen.)

This strikes me as quite an imagintive piece of crime prevention and a sensible use of an old panda which otherwise would only realise a trifling sum if sold off. Presumably the garage would make some sort of financial contribution to have the car there.
Falsely accused - J Bonington Jagworth
"..she only had my word for it"

But surely she had to reset the pump after the previous delivery? I should have thought it was second nature to look for the car involved, especially if the CCTV wasn't working!

I have to admit to having driven off without paying at a local Safeway a few years back, when I was rather preoccupied with work. I had a frantic phone call from home less than 2 hours later when the police arrived, so the CCTV clearly was working...
------------------
Die dulci fruere!