MoT inspection manual....6.1.8 (a) ( i)............'severely damaged or deterioration resulting in excessive movement....'
You are in the hands of the examiner and their interpretation of 'excessive'. Sadly, their opinion almost always trumps yours, especially when the measurement is unquantified. However, I think that easily producing a noise of something banging against something else adds sufficient weight to your opinion that the movement is excessive enough to fail the MoT, and should not have passed. That should outweigh their opinion that it was OK. In view of the small timeframe, their counter argument that the deterioration might have occured since the test would carry very little weight. Hope this helps - good luck!
|