What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - hotukdeal

My car touched the rearview mirror of the white car on the left , but the other white car driver removed the cover of the right rearview mirror, claiming that I damaged it, but judging from the video (15th-40th seconds), after touching it, his rearview mirror was not broken. The white cover is clearly still there. Later, when he got out of the car to check his car with me, I found that his left rearview mirror also had no cover. I felt that his right rearview mirror was originally broken with cover removable, and then he used this opportunity to ask me to replace it with a new one. At present, he wrote down my license plate number and said it was private, but I think that although I touched his right rearview mirror, no actual damage was materialized, because his right rearview mirror was originally broken. He said to send me invoice to replace his right rear car mirror. Do I need to pay or what should i do please?

www.youtube.com/watch?v=_e0MdLiv8wg

Please copy and paste above youtube link to watch the video (15th-40th seconds

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Crickleymal

Put it through your insurance if you feel you have a case. I'm not sure having looked at the video whether you're right or not.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Adampr

Well, you hit him and it's now broken so I guess it was because you hit it. You do have to pay attention going through the Blackwall Tunnel - there are a lot of broken mirrors brushed to the side. Incidentally, you're not supposed to cross solid white lines.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Chris M

"you're not supposed to cross solid white lines." That'll be why the overhead signs say "Keep in Lane" :)

The Golf does seem to have a habit of driving close to the line. Other cars are having difficulty in passing at times. The right hand lane is very narrow and I prefer the left lane when I occasionally use the Blackwall Tunnel.

Edited by Chris M on 22/11/2022 at 20:13

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - John F

Difficult to assess, but after reviewing 35-45secs several times it just looks as though the mirror has been pushed forwards by your mirror (was that damaged?) and remains undamaged.

If the white cover had broken I would have thought it would have fallen off. Difficult to see how it would have been damaged as the impact was from behind onto the frame. Was the glass broken? Anyway, it looks like both cars are contributory - each going too close to the edge of the lane. The video shows the white car does this. It looks as though it swerved into your airspace. I would 'do' nothing as there appears to be no damage. If insurance companies become involved, they will probably treat it as 50/50 and jack up both your premiums.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Andrew-T

If insurance companies become involved, they will probably treat it as 50/50 and jack up both your premiums.

How much is at stake anyway ? May be best to do nowt.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Bolt

If insurance companies become involved, they will probably treat it as 50/50 and jack up both your premiums.

How much is at stake anyway ? May be best to do nowt.

Thats what I would do as imo at that speed its at most a scratch on the facing side/mirror side.

the rear covers are not easy to break from the front unless going a lot faster, the mirror caps are not easily damaged from that angle in fact all I have seen broken are from frontal hits from opposite direction of which are many...

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Gibbo_Wirral

I noticed immediately after hitting the white car's mirror the camera car lurched to the right.

And if you watch the video at 1 minute you see the black car in the right lane also drifts over the line as it takes the left bend.

Sadly I see this kind of driving every day now, cars can't seem to be able to stay in their own lane without crossing the central line.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Adampr

In fairness, that particular tunnel is extremely narrow. Most people take it in turns to go round the corners because it's not at all easy to fit two cars on a bend designed for one horse.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Ian_SW

Just treat it as you would any accident.

1: Exchange details after crash (think legally that has to be name and address).

2: Advise insurance company of the incident and if needed make a claim for any repairs to your own car.

There is no legal requirement to get into a discussion of any type with the other party after the event, and its best not to.

Ultimately, it's a minor collision in a narrow tunnel, so both parties would be seen as contributing to the collision - the Golf was drifting across, but unless the OP also hit the wall on the other side trying to avoid it both could have done more to avoid the collision.

In this case, given the age of the other car, and the fact that it looks modified, I suspect it unlikely the driver will be contacting his insurance at all. He's just hoping you will hand over a bit of cash and not involve insurance. Have you also checked whether the car is insured (AskMID) and has a valid MOT.

Even if you do settle directly with the other party, it makes no difference from the future insurance cost perspective. When you apply for insurance, you are required to tell them of any accidents/collisions you have had, regardless if whether you claimed on the insurance. If you don't, and the insurance company find out later, they are entitled to cancel your insurance or refuse a claim.

Volkswagen Golf - Just had car accident, feeling being scammed - Bolt

In fairness, that particular tunnel is extremely narrow.

Since when hasn`t there been an accident in that Tunnel, you still get i****s trying to get through there asap, and being narrow lanes they misjudge the bends which imo are treacherous for some drivers anyway

Some Van drivers always take it too fast on bends, ill say no more....

Not certain but aren`t golf door mirror covers cheap around £20 each?

Edited by Bolt on 23/11/2022 at 14:33