What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Mkat19
I have a ‘59 plate hyundai i30 diesel 78k miles, due its MOT this month. I have got a new car now so I was going to sell this one. I enquired about how much it would cost to put the following MOT advisories right
(Minor defects)
Nearside Front Suspension arm ball joint dust cover severely deteriorated (5.3.4 (b) (i))
Offside Front Suspension arm ball joint dust cover severely deteriorated (5.3.4 (b) (i))

(Advisory)
Nearside Rear Brake disc worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened (1.1.14 (a) (ii))

I was quoted £393 for the suspension issue and the £292 for the rear disk (although he said it might not need doing once it gets driven? I’m a real novice so am very confused about this bit)

Does this seem like a fair quote? It seems a lot to me, looking online it seems that the parts are cheap?
Also there is a squealing noise coming from the engine which speeds up as the car revs/moves. Looking online it seems like it could be the serpentine belt- does anyone know how much this might cost? Ive booked it in with a garage next week to get a second quote but I’m just wondering what you guys think. I wont sell it to someone if there’s problems with it (no worse feeling than buying a car that needs work doing from a dishonest seller) so I’d either scrap it or sell it to one of those internet car buying sites. But obviously I’d like to take as small a loss as possible.
Thanks everyone :)
Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Oli rag

That sounds a bit pricey for the ballpoint problems. The rust on the rear discs would probably clear after a good drive and occasionally pulling on the handbrake gently as you go along. Not sure on the belt noise, as possibly just a belt or maybe a bearing.

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - galileo

That sounds a bit pricey for the ballpoint problems. The rust on the rear discs would Not sure on the belt noise, as possibly just a belt or maybe a bearing. probably clear after a good drive and occasionally pulling on the handbrake gently as you go along.

These cars have a handbrake which operates a drum brake in 'top-hat' rear discs: the handbrake has no effect whatsoever on the visible disc surface

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Engineer Andy

If you (the OP) still needs a car, then it's far better to get the existing one you know well fixed (but at a competent, honest repair shop) than flog it and buy another secondhand one, which you won't know how it was treated or used as much as yours.

Selling it and not replacing it may only be worthwhile if you're 100% you'll neve need a car again. To do so for scrap is unnecessary, given the faults, if taken as correctly diagnosed by the MOT, are not that serious, and whose repair would be well under what the car is currently worth in the current market.

What it will be (the second hand market) in 6 months as the likely big recession hits, people significantly tighten their belts (which is saying something given the current situation), depends on many factors, though I suspect second hand car prices will be much nearer the historical trend than has been the case over the last year or so.

I'd keep it and get it fixed if the things Oil Rag suggests don't resolve some of the problems flagged up.

Edited by Engineer Andy on 09/09/2022 at 11:40

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Andrew-T

All simple repair jobs which shouldn't be expensive. The MoT seems not to have reported any body corrosion problems, which might be more worrying (and expensive to fix). Get it fixed and sell it privately, as that is what it seems you intend to do.

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - John F
Does this seem like a fair quote?

No. Seems like a try-on.


Also there is a squealing noise coming from the engine which speeds up as the car revs/moves. Looking online it seems like it could be the serpentine belt-

Open the bonnet and spray some water on the belt when it's running. If the noise goes, it's the belt. if it doesn't, it might be something more serious like an imminent bearing failure, e.g. water pump?

does anyone know how much this might cost? Ive booked it in with a garage next week to get a second quote but I’m just wondering what you guys think.

Presumably it has just passed the MoT. I would never bother having 'advisory' work done, especially if minor.

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Andrew-T

<< Presumably it has just passed the MoT. I would never bother having 'advisory' work done, especially if minor. >>

John, the OP tells us the MoT is due this month ....

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - John F

<< Presumably it has just passed the MoT. I would never bother having 'advisory' work done, especially if minor. >>

John, the OP tells us the MoT is due this month ....

Well, where do the 'advisories' mentioned by the OP come from? Last year?

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - paul 1963

<< Presumably it has just passed the MoT. I would never bother having 'advisory' work done, especially if minor. >>

John, the OP tells us the MoT is due this month ....

Well, where do the 'advisories' mentioned by the OP come from? Last year?

Obviously yes John.

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - Big John
) I was quoted £393 for the suspension issue and the £292 for the rear disk (although he said it might not need doing once it gets driven?

It's worth getting another quote for the work as a comparison. It should be noted that most of the cost re suspension work will be labour as it can be a horrible job due to rusty / seized nuts/bolts/joints etc.

Presumably these were MOT advisorys from months ago at the previous MOT - the car may have other MOT failure points now so it might be worth getting it checked over re next MOT first to see if it's worth going ahead.

Hyundai i30 - How much to dix these MOT failures? - edlithgow

As I read it the OP had already replaced the car, so fix-to-keep isn't an option.

I would sell it with the faults declared. You might get someone like me who would be (over?) confident of DIYing it for buttons.

Re the ball joint covers, if keeping the car I might consider "first aid" with, say, cling film, gaffer tape or some bike inner tube, This would probably not pass an MOT (and would probably have to be taken off for one) but it could limit dirt entry between MOT's.

I used a protective cling film wrap on a CV joint here until I could get a replacement split boot kit (not available in Taiwan) from the UK, and it worked surprisingly well.

Edited by edlithgow on 12/09/2022 at 03:05