Sounds like either an airlock (best guess) or a blown head gasket (worst case)
I've found it impossible to clear airlocks on my car by just running the engine with a funnel in the radiator (for expansion.)
I now disable the fan and let the coolant boil into the funnel a few times. This is alarming, dangerous and potentially damaging, but it seems less potentially damaging than normal driving with airlocks in the cooling system.
I believe you can buy vacuum fill devices to avoid this problem, which might be improvisable
|
I believe you can buy vacuum fill devices to avoid this problem, which might be improvisable
www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QQHykK_RIw
Dunno if I'd buy one though, even if you could get them here. Pretty sure my cooling system has never been under significant vacuum and it might not thrive.
Nature is a mother, and abhors a vacuum.
Every cloud has a sooty lining, especially if its from China.
OTOH, Eric O's never had a problem, so it should be OK.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPMSzA2wOmw
|
|
|
renewed on my diesel car last year and found the reservoir empty when I got home - the techy just hadn't run the engine enough for the thermostat to open fully.
A lot don't realise there are sometimes two bleed points, or fail to run the engine at a higher speed than tickover
|
renewed on my diesel car last year and found the reservoir empty when I got home - the techy just hadn't run the engine enough for the thermostat to open fully.
A lot don't realise there are sometimes two bleed points, or fail to run the engine at a higher speed than tickover
I didn't realise there are sometimes two bleed points.
I did, however, realise that there are sometimes no bleed points, because I think that's all I've ever had on any of my cars. Can't remember it being a problem before.
I fail to run the engine at a higher speed than tickover, because I've found that running the engine at a higher speed than tickover on this car doesn't work.
With the scary boiling...er...method that I now use, I don't want to run the engine at a higher speed than tickover, because I dont want any more local heating (particularly around the exhaust valves, which are probably the area at greatest risk) than is necessary to get it to boil.
I suppose I could mist water into the air intake to slightly reduce the risk but there's a bit too much happening as it is.
Edited by edlithgow on 01/12/2020 at 14:12
|
|
|
The leak has definitely been repaired and despite the coolant bubbling after every trip to/from work, it doesn't look to have decreased in volume in the reservoir. The running temp (on the dashboard at least) seems to be normal, the only thing that's changed is that the fan boots in a lot sooner than it ever had done beforehand (I don't really expect it to have to come on for a 25 minute drive on residential roads). One thing I have noticed is that the fan doesn't seem to come on if I run the heater inside the car. Not entirely sure why this is, but in all honesty I know next to nothing about the internal workings of cars, hence why I went to a mechanic in the first place!
|
The leak has definitely been repaired and despite the coolant bubbling after every trip to/from work, it doesn't look to have decreased in volume in the reservoir. The running temp (on the dashboard at least) seems to be normal, the only thing that's changed is that the fan boots in a lot sooner than it ever had done beforehand (I don't really expect it to have to come on for a 25 minute drive on residential roads). One thing I have noticed is that the fan doesn't seem to come on if I run the heater inside the car. Not entirely sure why this is, but in all honesty I know next to nothing about the internal workings of cars, hence why I went to a mechanic in the first place!
Heater in a car acts the same as the radiator under the bonnet, which is why when the engine starts overheating its a help to use the heater in the car on max hot to help keep engine cooler
on older cars in the 70s 80s a lot of people when in town used to keep heater on hot even in summer to help keep engine cooler, modern cooling systems are more efficient usually...
|
|
The leak has definitely been repaired and despite the coolant bubbling after every trip to/from work, it doesn't look to have decreased in volume in the reservoir. The running temp (on the dashboard at least) seems to be normal, the only thing that's changed is that the fan boots in a lot sooner than it ever had done beforehand
That sounds to me the result of changing the thermostat. A petrol engine will usually open its thermostat after a couple of miles or five minutes, a diesel may take quite a bit longer. A thermostat may stick open or closed, or just react slowly.
|
Was the water pump definitely changed? If there's no leaking but overheating is possible the coolant isn't being circulated
|
|
Air locks not at all unusual in early Fiesta and very difficult to get rid. I had a similar problem years ago and finally cured it by running it up a very steep hill, not difficult finding steep hills in South Wales! If you are not loosing coolant it may clear itself overtime, keep the heater open
|
Air locks not at all unusual in early Fiesta and very difficult to get rid. I had a similar problem years ago and finally cured it by running it up a very steep hill, not difficult finding steep hills in South Wales! If you are not loosing coolant it may clear itself overtime, keep the heater open
I'd think there is a risk attached to the "it may clear itself over time " approach.
While you are waiting for this to happen, you are potentially running it up some very steep hills with an air pocket in the cylinder head, which is the highest point in the engine, and so most likely to have an air pocket.
Its also probably the hottest point in the engine, because its where the exhaust valves are, so its probably the point in the engine most likely to crack due to local heating.
I don't doubt that you could get away with it, but it seems to be asking for trouble.
Why ask for trouble?
|
Remove radiator cap when engine is cold. Check fluid level. If you cannot see any slowly top up till you can, Ensure car heater is switched to ON. - full on.
Squeeze lower large radiator hose sharply and let go.. repeat several times.
Check fluid level. If it has fallen , if yes, you have cleared some air. Top up.
When no level change, try top hose
Repeat with any hose you can.
That should clear any air locks.
Start engine leave to idle 30 minutes.
Wait till cool
Repeat.
|
Remove radiator cap when engine is cold. Check fluid level. If you cannot see any slowly top up till you can, Ensure car heater is switched to ON. - full on.
Squeeze lower large radiator hose sharply and let go.. repeat several times.
Check fluid level. If it has fallen , if yes, you have cleared some air. Top up.
When no level change, try top hose
Repeat with any hose you can.
That should clear any air locks.
Start engine leave to idle 30 minutes.
Wait till cool
Repeat.
and repeat.
and repeat
and repeat
and then do something more effective.
(Depending on your car of course)
|
While you are waiting for this to happen, you are potentially running it up some very steep hills with an air pocket in the cylinder head, which is the highest point in the engine, and so most likely to have an air pocket.
Its also probably the hottest point in the engine, because its where the exhaust valves are, so its probably the point in the engine most likely to crack due to local heating.
IF the air pocket is stuck in the cylinder head then you will have an hot point whether you are running up hill or on the flat. The point of the water jacket is to take the heat away and is circulating all the time. How else would you get rid of air if trapped at the highest point of the engine other than by continually draining and refilling until by luck the thing cures itself.
|
How else would you get rid of air if trapped at the highest point of the engine other than by continually draining and refilling until by luck the thing cures itself.
If you are running up very steep hills you are putting a significant load on the engine, so the exhaust valve area is likely to get significantly hotter than it would at idle. If you have an air pocket in the cylinder head, this may not end well.
by luck the thing cures itself assumes good luck. There is another kind,
I've suggested two alternative methods
(a) Letting it boil at idle, which displaces the air with steam.
I've done this a few times now on the Skywing. I don't much like doing it, but I think its less risky than your suggested laissez faire air alternative.
I never did it before on previous cars, because I never needed to.
(b) Use a vacuum pump. This seems to be the "professional" fix to tricky fills (see video links above) so the OP could get them to do it.
I wouldn't do that, and I probably wouldn't buy the kit they use, but it should be possible to adapt another form of pump.
I have a couple of fridge compressors that I could try, but I'm getting used to the boiling method so I probably won't bother..
Edited by edlithgow on 04/12/2020 at 22:45
|
|
While you are waiting for this to happen, you are potentially running it up some very steep hills with an air pocket in the cylinder head, which is the highest point in the engine, and so most likely to have an air pocket.
Its also probably the hottest point in the engine, because its where the exhaust valves are, so its probably the point in the engine most likely to crack due to local heating.
IF the air pocket is stuck in the cylinder head then you will have an hot point whether you are running up hill or on the flat. The point of the water jacket is to take the heat away and is circulating all the time. How else would you get rid of air if trapped at the highest point of the engine other than by continually draining and refilling until by luck the thing cures itself.
madf has the best idea and is usually very effective in stubborn air locks, if you mean literally emptying the system and refilling you will be doing it forever, as this engine is hard to bleed so best way is as mentioned....
|
|
|
Remove radiator cap when engine is cold. Check fluid level. If you cannot see any slowly top up till you can, Ensure car heater is switched to ON. - full on.
Squeeze lower large radiator hose sharply and let go.. repeat several times.
Check fluid level. If it has fallen , if yes, you have cleared some air. Top up.
When no level change, try top hose
Repeat with any hose you can.
That should clear any air locks.
Start engine leave to idle 30 minutes.
Wait till cool
Repeat.
and repeat.
and repeat
and repeat
and then do something more effective.
(Depending on your car of course)
Well I have done it with success on:
Fiesta
Peugeoy 106
Yaris 1.4 d4d.
Audi A4
But I may just have been lucky . :-)
|
same here . it always worked on vauxhalls
|
same here . it always worked on vauxhalls
I daresay. But one can't conclude that, because it always worked on Vauxhalls, it will always work on everything.
In my limited experience, it worked on a Triumph 1300, an1800 Marina, a Mk1 Lada, a Renault 5 Campus, and a Nissan Sunny (or I've just been lucky).
(I didn't try it om my Sierra or Mazda 626)
It does not work on a Daihatsu Skywing (or I've just been unlucky.)
Boiling, OTOH, works on it every time (or I've just been lucky)
The Internyet has many instances of cars that are difficult, for which the pro fix is a vacuum pump. The vid link (a Jeep Liberty IIRC) I give above is just one example.
Edited by edlithgow on 04/12/2020 at 00:52
|
|
|
|
|
|
|