What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Random

www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/technology-news/hyundai...n

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Terry W

The news release suggests that it is for a 4x4 being used in remote locations where charging points are likely to be less than abundant.

Whether hydrogen refuelling points will be available on the edge of the Kalahari or Atacama is another matter!

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Bolt

BJ was talking about investing in Hydrogen as well, so there must be something in it whatever some say, IMO it will take off eventually as being more advantageous than battery operated cars/vehicles ie can be used to power houses if the mains fails

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - John F

As gas boilers are phased out I guess Mr Ratcliffe is hoping to find a use for his spare gas.

Won't help the planet much.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Sofa Spud

But a hydrogen fuel-cell car is an EV !! The fuel cell and hydrogen storage tanks take the place of the battery. The car is still driven by an electric motor (or motors). Fuel cell cars would most likely also have a battery, or maybe ultracapacitors, to take advantage of regenerative braking. So the propulsion system of a battery EV consists of an electric motor, a control system and a battery. For a fuel cell car, there would be an electric motor, a control system, a fuel-cell, hydrogen storage tanks and most likely a battery too, albeit a smaller one.

There was research into adapting petrol engines to run on hydrogen but in order to run them cool enough the mixture has to be very lean, meaning much less power output. I just read that a Shelby Cobra adapted to run on hydrogen that managed 108 mph!

Edited by Sofa Spud on 23/11/2020 at 16:49

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Heidfirst

As gas boilers are phased out I guess Mr Ratcliffe is hoping to find a use for his spare gas.

There are plans to switch the gas mains network & central heating boilers over to hydrogen, initially using a blended mix.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - John F

As gas boilers are phased out I guess Mr Ratcliffe is hoping to find a use for his spare gas.

There are plans to switch the gas mains network & central heating boilers over to hydrogen, initially using a blended mix.

Indeed, but they don't make sense if burning fossil fuel (gas), rather than wind power, makes the hydrogen. Are the plans sponsored by Mr Ratcliffe?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Heidfirst

As gas boilers are phased out I guess Mr Ratcliffe is hoping to find a use for his spare gas.

There are plans to switch the gas mains network & central heating boilers over to hydrogen, initially using a blended mix.

Indeed, but they don't make sense if burning fossil fuel (gas), rather than wind power, makes the hydrogen. Are the plans sponsored by Mr Ratcliffe?

Supposedly there are plans for carbon capture when using gas to produce hydrogen.

The boiler manufacturers have working hydrogen running boilers designs.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

Just to be clear virtually all hydrogen powered cars are and will be EVs. It is just another way to provide the electricity.

Whatever happens with EVs there is enormous interest in green (and blue!) hydrogen because industry has used enormous quantities for years. It also has a major interest as a green alternative feedstock for the chemical industry. That is where Ineos come in quite apart from their new 4x4.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - sammy1

I wonder why the rolling out of a decent charging network has been so slow. People will look ridiculous if hydrogen really takes off. Would a hydrogen car be dangerous in a serious accident if the container ruptured?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Sofa Spud

I wonder why the rolling out of a decent charging network has been so slow. People will look ridiculous if hydrogen really takes off. Would a hydrogen car be dangerous in a serious accident if the container ruptured?

Oh well, the hydrogen supply and refilling network has got a huge amount of catch-up to do in comparison to the EV charging network!

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - madf

I wonder why the rolling out of a decent charging network has been so slow. People will look ridiculous if hydrogen really takes off. Would a hydrogen car be dangerous in a serious accident if the container ruptured?

ABiut as dangerous as a lithium battery powered car.

In other words, rupture the batteries or short them and BANG!!!

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - mcb100
Car manufacturers, not being totally irresponsible, have thought of this and recent testing has shown that an EV is at least as safe as a conventional ICE car.
Impact energy is channeled around the battery and occupants, whilst pyro fuses blow on high voltage cables, disconnecting them.
You can also bet that hydrogen tanks have been subject to all manner of testing.
The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Terry W

As of today battery vehicle technology is both proven and financially viable. There are no insuperable barriers to mass roll out

Improvements are needed - some are easily solved with the application of cash (eg: more fast charging points), some are desirable (eg: alternatives to lithium, recycling etc)

Hydrogen as of today is not remotely ready for mass rollout - technically, financially or operationally:

  • Most H2 is generated using fossil fuels.
  • There is no common approach to compression, distribution, storage.
  • There are only 13 hydrogen fuel stations in the UK
  • in 2019 less than 100 fuel cell vehicle were sold

Bar very specialist applications H2 has lost this green vehicle race - even if it starts to make real progress, battery tech will continue to improve.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

Hydrogen as of today is not remotely ready for mass rollout - technically, financially or operationally

Bar very specialist applications H2 has lost this green vehicle race - even if it starts to make real progress, battery tech will continue to improve.

Why the assumption of a winner takes all race? Nobody finds it odd that gasoline cars have thrived alongside diesel cars and trucks for years.

As for mass use of hydrogen, I previously pointed out in this thread that it already exists for industrial applications. That is driving research programmes around the world into economically viable green hydrogen production.

There are no technical problems with liquid hydrogen distribution now and no reason why the system cannot be scaled up. FWIW we once changed our domestic supply from town to natural gas when it became cost effective. We could change the same system again if gaseous hydrogen supply becomes a viable option for domestic heating and cooking.

Edited by misar on 24/11/2020 at 15:27

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

Deleted

Edited by misar on 24/11/2020 at 17:36

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

I wonder why the rolling out of a decent charging network has been so slow. People will look ridiculous if hydrogen really takes off. Would a hydrogen car be dangerous in a serious accident if the container ruptured?

It's slow as it will cost a lot and no one wants to pay and it need a large scale plan that will last for decades which no one likes to set in stone. If Hydrogen takes off no one will look ridiculous...why do you think they would?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - sammy1

If Hydrogen takes off no one will look ridiculous...why do you think they would?

Well if I had spent a shed load of money on chargers and digging the roads up for them to become rapidly obsolete in favour of a more portable tech. I imagine you could even have the AA running around with back up H should you run out.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

If Hydrogen takes off no one will look ridiculous...why do you think they would?

Well if I had spent a shed load of money on chargers and digging the roads up for them to become rapidly obsolete in favour of a more portable tech. I imagine you could even have the AA running around with back up H should you run out.

Have you ever thought the two could co-exist? Battery powered cars whilst larger vehicles or ones that do longer distances have Hydrogen power?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - focussed

Read how difficult and complicated it is to utilise hydrogen to power a fuel cell car - about all the subsidiary systems necessary to make it work.

ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-...1

And there are parts 2 and 3 to the blog too.

Edited by focussed on 23/11/2020 at 22:19

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Bolt

Read how difficult and complicated it is to utilise hydrogen to power a fuel cell car - about all the subsidiary systems necessary to make it work.

ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-...1

And there are parts 2 and 3 to the blog too.

I don`t remember anyone saying it will be easy, but some like a challenge which HFC is, battery EVs are as well where batteries are concerned, but not many are giving up on it, if anything more research is being done as is HFC

However much its impressed on us that its going to be a non runner, IMO, which is often wrong, HFC will be eventually a choice as Petrol and Diesel was. if it doesn`t happen fair enough -but it is a an interesting talking point which will go on for years yet :)

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

Read how difficult and complicated it is to utilise hydrogen to power a fuel cell car - about all the subsidiary systems necessary to make it work.

ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-...1

And there are parts 2 and 3 to the blog too.

I have no idea what expertise the blogger has but all three parts date from 2015. On the other hand there are already viable hydrogen EVs on sale commercially in the UK. At the very least they can be seen in many YouTube video reviews. Yet you prefer to believe an old blog rather than your own eyes.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - focussed

If you actually read all the article you would understand some of the technical problems with the use of hydrogen as a fuel for ev fuel cell cars.

With the level of complication described it is hard to see that they will be long-term reliable.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

Deleted

Edited by misar on 24/11/2020 at 17:37

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

Read how difficult and complicated it is to utilise hydrogen to power a fuel cell car - about all the subsidiary systems necessary to make it work.

ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-...1

And there are parts 2 and 3 to the blog too.

What experience does the blogger have in the field? It just looks like some old, random blog posting.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - focussed

What experience? You didn't read the blog did you?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

What experience? You didn't read the blog did you?

No, I didn't - who are they and what experience do they have?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Avant

Terry, thanks for that very clear exposition of where we are at the moment. We are at the awkward stage where industry is thinking 'is this going to take off, and do we risk the 'rock' of going in and getting our fingers burnt, or the 'hard place' of not doing anything while our competitors go ahead and make money'?

Hydrogen power could go either way. Like you, I'm sceptical - but then I never thought two years ago that I'd be ordering a battery EV.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - nick62

Off topic, buy my lad was involved in research this summer looking at hydrogen powered airliners (the engine modifications are very straightforward to convert from kerosene to hydrogen).

In a very basic nutshell any existing twin-jet powered by hydrogen would be able to fly <= half the distance with <= half the payload!

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - misar

In a very basic nutshell any existing twin-jet powered by hydrogen would be able to fly <= half the distance with <= half the payload!

Can't wait for you to tell us how far the battery powered version would get!

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - focussed

The biggest electric plane ever, it was a modified Cessna Caravan 208B – which can take a maximum of nine passengers. And the test aircraft only had a seat installed for the pilot.

And it flew for 30 minutes this year.

www.bbc.com/future/article/20200617-the-largest-el...y

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - mcb100
I can see us having a diminished range of availability of models post-2030, in that unless other major markets also put a similar timescale in place, manufacturers will continue to produce ICE’s and hybrids for a global marketplace and we’ll just get the EV variants from their offerings.
The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - nick62
I can see us having a diminished range of availability of models post-2030, in that unless other major markets also put a similar timescale in place, manufacturers will continue to produce ICE’s and hybrids for a global marketplace and we’ll just get the EV variants from their offerings.

Seems about right for the UK, based on current trends for shooting ourselves in both feet.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Terry W

I would go for an alternative proposition - entirely plausible if there is a belief that in the long term EV will dominate globally.

The UK could become hugely proficient in EVs - technology, batteries, recharging infrastructures, taxation implications, road pricing, repair, manufacturing and design. It will make the UK one of the "go to" places in this market globally.

The losers in the next two decades will be those countries which embrace only old technologies. They will increasingly find that their export markets no longer want ICE (irrespective of price). And the UK will carry on playing "catch up" with the rest of the world.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - madf

I would go for an alternative proposition - entirely plausible if there is a belief that in the long term EV will dominate globally.

The UK could become hugely proficient in EVs - technology, batteries, recharging infrastructures, taxation implications, road pricing, repair, manufacturing and design. It will make the UK one of the "go to" places in this market globally.

The losers in the next two decades will be those countries which embrace only old technologies. They will increasingly find that their export markets no longer want ICE (irrespective of price). And the UK will carry on playing "catch up" with the rest of the world.

If it wanted to

If it trained enough engineers.

It won't as it is lead by people untrained in anything but history and English literature and politics.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - focussed

I would go for an alternative proposition - entirely plausible if there is a belief that in the long term EV will dominate globally.

The UK could become hugely proficient in EVs - technology, batteries, recharging infrastructures, taxation implications, road pricing, repair, manufacturing and design. It will make the UK one of the "go to" places in this market globally.

The losers in the next two decades will be those countries which embrace only old technologies. They will increasingly find that their export markets no longer want ICE (irrespective of price). And the UK will carry on playing "catch up" with the rest of the world.

"those countries which embrace only old technologies"

You sound just like a politician!

You really think that the UK can compete with China, South Korea,Taiwan etc on electronic technology and when their labour costs are about tenth of the UK's?

Some common sense needs to injected into this lemming-like rush into EV's.

EV's are fine to reduce urban and city pollution, but as a replacement for the current highly efficient, low polluting iC powered vehicles for longer journeys outside cities they don't add up, no matter how you spin it.

So stop wasting resources on trying to make an EV the equivalent of a decent IC petrol or diesel vehicle and spend the funds on something useful, like alleviating poverty, building houses, getting the homeless into jobs and accomodation is my advice.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

and spend the funds on something useful, like alleviating poverty, building houses, getting the homeless into jobs and accomodation is my advice.

There won't be any country left though if pollution keeps on increasing - you need to deal with it now.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Bolt

and spend the funds on something useful, like alleviating poverty, building houses, getting the homeless into jobs and accomodation is my advice.

There won't be any country left though if pollution keeps on increasing - you need to deal with it now.

How do you know pollution is going to get better even if we do go all EVs, global warming may not get better, no one has proved we can prevent GW so far unless you know better?

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - sammy1

A very sound point. GB is but a dot on the globe and responsible for less than 1% of world pollution. If EVs clean up the UK air than that is something though at what price. Pollution in cities is far greater than elsewhere. EVs operating in the countryside will not make much difference. As far as climate change is concerned well what is causing it. Is it human activity or the sun? Humans generally are not helping and are indeed the most selfish and dirty species on the planet and slowly destroying and bringing misery on other species and indeed themselves. From my own observations I see no sign in the last 60 years that weather is changing in the UK although from a selfish point of view it would be nice to have a Mediterranean climate what with winter rapidly approaching.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - alan1302

and spend the funds on something useful, like alleviating poverty, building houses, getting the homeless into jobs and accomodation is my advice.

There won't be any country left though if pollution keeps on increasing - you need to deal with it now.

How do you know pollution is going to get better even if we do go all EVs, global warming may not get better, no one has proved we can prevent GW so far unless you know better?

Just going EV's won't sort everything out - a lot of other things need to be done - as with most things there is not just one simple thing you need to do.

If you get rid of all fossil fuelled vehicles why would you think pollution levels would not decrease?

We know we are changing the climate - so it would usually follow that if we stop polluting as we do then the Earth climate will settle down more to where it should be - I suppose there is no proof as such - but it's not something you can really wait to see if it will work.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Bolt

and spend the funds on something useful, like alleviating poverty, building houses, getting the homeless into jobs and accomodation is my advice.

There won't be any country left though if pollution keeps on increasing - you need to deal with it now.

How do you know pollution is going to get better even if we do go all EVs, global warming may not get better, no one has proved we can prevent GW so far unless you know better?

Just going EV's won't sort everything out - a lot of other things need to be done - as with most things there is not just one simple thing you need to do.

If you get rid of all fossil fuelled vehicles why would you think pollution levels would not decrease?

We know we are changing the climate - so it would usually follow that if we stop polluting as we do then the Earth climate will settle down more to where it should be - I suppose there is no proof as such - but it's not something you can really wait to see if it will work.

Thats the point though, we are told we are changing the climate but the whole Universe is changing, so it stands to reason the earth changes, you wouldn`t expect earthquakes not to cause damage or anything the earth does to stop because we are here.

but to listen to some people you would think everything the earth does is our Fault, we do cause problems no doubt about it, where plastic pollution and other waste is concerned and should clean up our act, but we should be doing it in different ways

I have seen as most have Keep oil in the ground where it belongs, problem is we cannot as its used for so many things not just running our Vehicles, so its not as people think once we stop using crude oil we stop needing it...we do for other things

As a PS I am not against EVs, when they come down in price will get one myself (though won`t have a choice) but will get a Hybrid before that because of the range, and use of heater and other things in the car will limit my distance by a lot more than a Hybrid

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Terry W

I'm not a politician - they say what people want to hear, I try to say that which I think (albeit courteously I hope).

China labour costs may have been (two decades ago) around 10% of Uk, Today they are catching up fast, are about 50% of UK now, and growing much faster.

Labour element of manufacturing is reducing due mainly to automation. In higher level jobs - design, IT, technical - pay costs are not much different to UK.

Machinery (robots, presses, moulding machines, computers etc) cost much the same wherever you are in the world (ignoring import duties and volume issues).

Slowly, perhaps over the next decade, China will change from a source of cheap labour and products to a "normal cost producer". This is what happened to many other once low cost producers - eg: Japan, Hong Kong, Singapore, Korea.

The question will increasingly be - do the savings made through production overseas justify the additional shipping costs, delivery lead times, stock investment and inflexibility.

The future isn't just EV - Ineos/Hyundai hydrogen - Random

The raw materials cost of switching to EVs.

www.autocar.co.uk/opinion/electric-cars/opinion-ra...s