What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Car finance woes - groaver

Why doesn't anyone want to take responsibility for their own actions anymore?

It's always someone else and something should be done about it:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-your-money-48776454

Car finance woes - daveyjp
If she had applied for a credit card with a £20k limit on a part time wage and no assets she wouldn't have stood a chance.

To be leant a similar amount through a car finance company suggests absolutely no checks were made on her credit worthiness.

Yes she may have been foolish and fallen for salesman patter, but we were all young once. The FCA is in place to ensure there is an element of protection for the unwary, some car finance sellers appear to think it doesn't apply to them.
Car finance woes - SLO76
What ever happened to personal responsibility? The only person who should know what is affordable is the buyer themselves. Of course a seller is going to push a sale no matter what but it’s down to YOU the individual to decide what YOU can afford and no one else. I can’t stand all this nonsense, it’s all about deflecting the blame for one’s own mistakes.

The parents clearly knew about these unaffordable car purchases beforehand and never stepped up to voice reason, in fact I’m betting the reason why they’re now paying up is because they stood as guarantor which means they are fully responsible and equally as stupid as their over-ambitious and status obsessed offspring.

Idiots!
Car finance woes - Smileyman

I think the motor industry has some blame ... in their attempt to keep factories in production and dealers solvent they are selling cars on the never never like confetti - cars are being sold as a by-product of what is considered to be affordable finance. Have the car and after 3 years return it and have another one, or pay the balloon payment and keep the car. What is forgotten is the whole life cost of the deal, inclusive of interest & other finance charges (admin fees etc) as well as how to deal with unwelcome situations eg change in financial status. Add to this the cachet / desirability factor eg the VW advert on the school run, and people feel it's the norm to drive such cars and pay in such way. As for 0% finance, well it often is too good to be true, just look at the list price, compare with what discounts are available elsewhere and ask why the 0% deal is on offer.

My last two cars were paid for in cash (both with hefty list discounts) - taking advantage of special deals that worked for me.

Car finance woes - groaver

I think the motor industry has some blame ... in their attempt to keep factories in production and dealers solvent they are selling cars on the never never like confetti - cars are being sold as a by-product of what is considered to be affordable finance. H

Isn't that pretty much capitalism?

Car finance woes - Terry W

People should take responsibility for the consequences of their own actions. The only exception to this should be where a fraud has been commited.

The consequence of bailing out those who lose money through their own stupidity is to (a) reinforce the idea that it doesn't matter, and (b) those who are responsible pay to cover the inadequacies of others.

The solution of course is to scrap the age limit laws for financial transactions and get everyone to take and pass a course on fiscal responsibility.

This is wholly analogous to taking a driving test before being allowed to drive alone. Removing driving tests would simply encourage the incompetent, incapable or stupid to take to the roads whilst the rest of us pick up the pieces.

Car finance woes - gordonbennet

Parents are almost blackmailed into signing back up to their childrens wannabe unearned celebrity lifestyle these days, all on the never never, sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind and say no, but it takes some doing with the peer pressures young people are now under, brainwashed as they under the 'all must be winners' cobblers that's been pushed for a generation or more now.

Some parents are no better, one starts to wonder if their chidren's material outward wealth is a status symbol to be shown, sinister information gathering social media sites among the most addictive must be seen platforms.

Goodness knows what's lurking down the line in 20 years time when the current trends in brainwashing 4 year olds in the joys of multi genders bears fruit, i'm thoroughly on the side of the parents of the school in Birmingham where this has reached a head, amusing to see the lefty reptiles wondering which of their own feet to eat here with the two opposing sides.

My suggestion is to sack the entire establishment class and its common purpose trained appointees, starting with the two houses of parl, and to replace them with people chosen for acumen common sense and some sort of kind normalcy about them, breath not held, we haven't reached anywhere near the depths enough yet.

I have no sympathy whatsoever if financial institutions and credit sellers get their fingers burned in sub prime missolds, they are like cartoon characters with the pound/euro signs spinning round in wide eyes...oh silly me, that's what us taxpayers (who's democratic decisions are ignored) are for when their dodgy handshake mates in the govt give money borrowed in our, taxpayers, name to them to bail them out after their GRQ latest scheme bites them in the backside....heads we win tails you lose, you couldn't make it up.

Car finance woes - FP

I will ignore most of the egregious right-wing stuff in GB's post. (I did find "lefty reptiles wondering which of their own feet to eat here" amusing, though I don't understand what is meant.)

However, I have a question.

GB says, "My suggestion is to sack the entire establishment class and its common purpose trained appointees, starting with the two houses of parl, and to replace them with people chosen for acumen common sense and some sort of kind normalcy about them..."

How, exactly, do we do that? I mean, how do we find and choose these wonderful people? I have the feeling GB might not be keen on elections...

Edited by FP on 29/06/2019 at 23:59

Car finance woes - gordonbennet

FP, You should have ignored it all, but now you've asked.

GB is very keen on elections, especially if there's someone or a party or movement worth voting for, so a positive vote, and it's not the way it has been for a long time now, a case of if you care about the future of the country and your family voting for the least worse or hopefully the least dangerous of a poor selection, a negative vote, worse still if people have voted purely for what bunce they were bribed with money taken forcibly from net taxpayers.

A recent referendum result has been completely ignored by the political class, this is fairly normal practice when a country inside the EU votes the wrong way, which rather begs the point why bother voting at all if it makes no difference...which is what they actually want of course, a disillusioned and therefore compliant electorate worn down to the point of despair by the antics, ''just do what you want'' would be music to their ears.

Sadly for them it's working the other way, with millions having woken from their slumber and realised the British political system is no longer fit for purpose and hasn't been for a good number of years, and subject to what happens at Halloween is the date the establishment party ghouls currently in charge(ish) either fulfills it's last manifesto promise (labour made the same promise to honour the result) or it will be replaced at the next GE by an entirely new party who will fulfill the wishes of the majority of UK citizens in the ref vote cast 3 years ago.

It's no longer left versus right, that is now a side show being fought by throwback boot boys in balaclavas, the battle is now about democracy and reinstating it in this country, where parliament is the voice and servant of the people and not the other way round, where the instructions of the people are carried out, without false promises being made with no intention whatsoever of fulfilling them in now discredited manifestos, everything has changed, the establishment parties cannot put this genie back in the bottle despite the msm and social media giants trying their best to censor wrong think.

You may find the next govt's first 100 or so potential MP's have been selected by TBP this very weekend, selected as TBP MEP's were from all walks of previous working life and from all sides of the political spectrum.

Don't worry too much about the right wing stuff (of course he's an ignorant working class yobbo and doesn't trust labour are the party of the working class any more, roughly most of my life that's been the case), i've been accused of far worse than that here by the usual suspects, water off a duck's back, or what was it now, cap's fitting and wearing :-)

Edited by gordonbennet on 30/06/2019 at 00:45

Car finance woes - Bromptonaut

Goodness knows what's lurking down the line in 20 years time when the current trends in brainwashing 4 year olds in the joys of multi genders bears fruit, i'm thoroughly on the side of the parents of the school in Birmingham where this has reached a head, amusing to see the lefty reptiles wondering which of their own feet to eat here with the two opposing sides.

I think you've read to much propaganda GB. Surely, in the modern world, kids in primary 1 should understand that sex/gender is not binary. Some of their contemporaries might have two mummies or two daddies. Some people are born without the doctors being sure if they're a girl or a boy. Some people think they were born in the wrong body.

Those are facts.

It shouldn't be beyond the wit of educationalists to condense that into some age appropriate messages along with similar age appropriate stuff about appropriate boundaries for things adults might try on.

As somebody who is proud to be a lefty I've no trouble with saying parents are wrong to try and stop this stuff. I don't need to eat either foot.

My suggestion is to sack the entire establishment class and its common purpose trained appointees, starting with the two houses of parl, and to replace them with people chosen for acumen common sense and some sort of kind normalcy about them, breath not held, we haven't reached anywhere near the depths enough yet.

What is it with Common Purpose? There are dozens of organisations out there providing training for staff to develop people, team skills and get lights out from under bushells. I was a public servant for 35years and never heard of Common Purpose. If I'd needed to procure training of that type they might have been on my radar but I've never knowingly met a CP 'graduate'.

Anything I've found to explain the hostility seems to on evidence free conspiracy sites.

I'm much more bothered by Freemasonry.

Edited by Bromptonaut on 30/06/2019 at 15:03

Car finance woes - Avant

Another instance of the First and Only Law of Economics - the right price is what some other poor sap will pay.

As Groaver says above, it's just capitalism. If a business can sell someone a deal like that - £329 a month over 5 years for a secondhand A1 - they will do it, bad deal that it is. Whatever we might think about bad examples of capitalism like this, nowhere in the world as far as I know has any alternative system been found to be fairer.

A first-year student might not have realised the crippling nature of her commiment, but her parents should have done and got her into something more sensible instead of guaranteeing it as surely they must have done, and now whingeing about it.

Car finance woes - SLO76
In a free society we must be free to make our own mistakes and (hopefully) to learn from them.
Car finance woes - oldroverboy.

We have neighbours, young couple unmarried when they moved in. House in poor condition so both sets of parents did a fabulous job renovation. What next.. Remortgaged. Money used for 2 new cars and big wedding. Had another kid she stopped working.... Then short of money after a lot of spending Now car gone Sold for cash to pay for holidays. Up to elbows (or higher in debt)but got a BMW 1 series on a lease and both still round the pub with others in same situation whingeing no money.

Edited by oldroverboy. on 30/06/2019 at 07:56

Car finance woes - daveyjp
We know nothing about the patent/child relationship, no mention of them being guarantors in the article.

She is 23. I hope when my daughter is that age I'm not living in her pockets ticking off and agreeing all her life choices. At that age I bought my first house with no involvement of my parents.

When I was a similar age I also made a not quite as expensive mistake and we had two wages coming in. The thought of a car which was shiny and new at a monthly price I could just about afford was far better than the two years of bangernomics I had endured.

After 3 years I knew it was a mistake, the car finance was terminated and I have never had dealer finance since.
Car finance woes - groaver

Daveyjp, I'll wager you didn't go running to the press to tell everyone that the system needs to change, though.

Medicine should taste terrible for good reason. We shouldn't sugar-coat it.

Car finance woes - primus 1
Wife’s uncle recently bought a newish discovery sport, he was chatting to the salesman, ( who he knew) and he was saying he’s had people paying for deposits on new cars with up to five credit cards, !!!
Car finance woes - gordonbennet

We changed banks about 12 years ago, early 50's then, the nice lady handling our account was surprised we had no debts or finance repayments (apart from the short term mortgage with them) and at the time no credit cards, since then we have one credit card purely for online use.

If its really so noticeable that 50 somethings are debt and finance free, what sort of lesson are the children of people saddled with debts going to learn.

I too learned at a younger age and had been schooled in no borrowing by my father, first mortgage at 20, however my first wife was a spoiled child who genuinely thought the Croydon money trees were real, took me a long time to get myself sorted ( money and headwise) when she found more promising pastures.

The only borrowing IMHO ordinary salaried people should have is for the roof over their heads, and to clear that asap, from the moment you make that last mortgage payment, they, employers and especially the state no longer have you over a barrel.

Car finance woes - FP

I'm relieved to be able completely to agree with GB on this.

My parents' upbringing in the early years of the twentieth century emphasised frugality and spending only what you could afford, with the additional reinforcement of my mother's Scottish background.

So much so that at first I was reluctant to take out a mortgage and sought ways of saving the money beforehand - fruitlessly, of course. A mortgage is the only debt I would now advise anyone to take on. When I received an unexpected payout some years ago it went entirely on paying off the mortgage. I was taught that getting rid of any debt is an absolute priority.

The only exceptions have been a fairly recent purchase of a quite expensive bed which was offered at 0% finance and which I could have bought outright. As I could keep most of the purchase price in my account that way and earn interest on it, it was a no-brainer. Similarly with wedding rings a few years ago.

I have a credit card and pay off the balance in full every month, and get Air Miles or Avios or whatever they're called.

The amount of personal debt in the UK is in fact a threat to our financial stability. The average household apparently owes over £16,000 on credit cards alone. The amount owed in high-interest payday loans a few years ago was £2.8bn. Those figures are appalling and frightening.

Car finance woes - daveyjp
It is only by going to the press this issue of dodgy car financing is investigated properly.

Regulations are in place to reduce the much longer term implications which become 'our' problem.
Car finance woes - groaver

Schools teach food hygiene courses in my area to those less academically gifted (and to those who want to learn it as well). Why don't schools teach financial understanding too? Didn't Martin Lewis of MSE call for it?

"I was never much good at maths * giggle*" is an easy cop-out for some people.

Car finance woes - Bromptonaut

Schools teach food hygiene courses in my area to those less academically gifted (and to those who want to learn it as well).

There's a whole set of life skills stuff that should be taught in schools.

I was never much good at maths and had a fear of anything to do with number. It was only in adulthood when I had a job requiring me to calculate interest and carry out reconciliations that I acquired sufficient facility to be able to manipulate numbers fluently. I've had more than one advice client gobsmacked by fact I can work out their full rent from knowing how much they pay in 'bedroom tax' - the charge is fixed percentage of their rent.

Apart from Pythagoras' theorem I've never had any call to use geometry and as for quadratic equations......

Car finance woes - Avant

Basic financial education is covered in some schools, but it's patchy: it should be included in PSE or PSHE but I suspect the problem is not enough teachers who have the skills themselves. Some of them may be up to their eyes in debt themselves.

An alternative would be for maths teaching and examining to enter the 21st century and cover basic personal financial planning as part of arithmetic. Algebra is something needed by specialists, not schoolchildren, and a lot of time, as you imply, Brompt, is wasted on teaching something that 99% of people will never need to know.

Car finance woes - carl233

As I have said in many other threads in my opinion if you cannot afford a car cash you cannot afford the car. A car is very different to a house purchase it will drop it's value by a large margin within a short time. Whilst Britain has become in general a dumbed down society full of debt junkies with no understanding being personally responsible it highlights cars are too expensive.

Car finance woes - John F

It seems that at the adult age of 21, but as merely a first year student (many have graduated at that age) she was persuaded that a £20,000+ motor car would be suitable for her needs. Or perhaps it was an extravagant 21st present gone sadly wrong? Anyway, a good example of the old adage ' a fool and his/her money are easily parted'.

Car finance woes - Smileyman

It seems that at the adult age of 21, but as merely a first year student (many have graduated at that age) she was persuaded that a £20,000+ motor car would be suitable for her needs. Or perhaps it was an extravagant 21st present gone sadly wrong? Anyway, a good example of the old adage ' a fool and his/her money are easily parted'.

I would say a 21 year old who may be old enough to vote, and old enough to become a parent is not necessarily old enough to combat the marketing & selling skills of an experienced and skilled motor sales person. Such deals may be fit in law, but in life is the 21 year old is too inexperienced to understand the affordability of such a level of car debt? So step in a wiser and more experienced body, and make it law that the provision of finance requires checks for affordability, both in and out of work. Not so much fool and money easily parted but inexperienced being taken in and money easily parted.

Even if parental guarantees are asked a check on affordability should be included in the process. Like getting an indication of what mortgage a certain level of income would cover, there needs to be an indication of what level of car debt certain level of income would be appropriate, including a recommended level of debt for the income in question to guide buyer to a more affordable purchase.

Car finance woes - Terry W

To expect a car dealer or leasing company to provide financial advice to a customer is truly daft. Even if it is fair and balanced they are not trained financial advisors, make their money by selling cars to punters and have a fundamental conflict of interest.

Basic personal finance should be taught at school. If the finance agreement is not repaid the losers must be (a) the finance company for not undertaking effective credit checks, (b) the buyer of the vehicle who clearly behaved with little or no regard for repayments.

If parents guarantee the loan then they should stop whingeing and pay the price for their own stupidity.

Car finance woes - FoxyJukebox

I wouldn't mind betting that this story from BBC News via the Money Box programme might have been manipulated. If it was-it is a warning. If it wasn't --then this girl and whoever advised her that this was in some way a good deal deserves absolutely no sympathy at all.

Car finance woes - groaver

I wouldn't mind betting that this story from BBC News via the Money Box programme might have been manipulated.

What!? Surely not?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/help-41670342

That bastion of impartiality?

Car finance woes - Bromptonaut

I wouldn't mind betting that this story from BBC News via the Money Box programme might have been manipulated. If it was-it is a warning. If it wasn't --then this girl and whoever advised her that this was in some way a good deal deserves absolutely no sympathy at all.

I heard the article on Money Box. I don't think anything was manipulated. The young woman's Mother, who was interviewed was a bit over dramatic. An encounter with a one off debt like this really does not deserve a 'ruined our life' headline. She and her daughter both need some advice on dealing with the debt and taking a robust line with enforcement agents. Get in toucj with the creditor and put your cards on the table. Tell the debt agency clearly that you are speaking to the lender and that you won't hesitate to report them for harassment if they continue to phone and text daily.

There is almost certainly a significant issue with commission hungry salesmen selling PCP or HP on cars and 'frigging' the controls to prevent loans going to people they ought not to.

There a better examples than silly uni students.

Car finance woes - Gibbo_Wirral

Any idea where she lives, I've got some magic beans that she might be interested in investing in.

Car finance woes - barney100

FIL always maintained that he wouldn't buy anything he couldn't pay cash for, he would rather do without. I've had a couple of car loans and it's a great feeling when you have paid them off. I now see the wisdom of paying cash. People have to take responsibility for their financial decisions.

Car finance woes - carl233

If you cannot afford your desired car cash you should make do with a vehicle that costs less e.g. an older vehicle. At the the company I work for it is so interesting to see the people on larger salaries e.g. six figures running older vehicles and the younger 'executives' that are earning a low salary such as £25-30k driving a 'top of the range' and highly respected plus 'exclusive' German metal package that must eat in to their salary in a large way as they use such vehicle to drive back to their mortgaged terraced house.....

Car finance woes - Energyman
The 21 year old deemed to be inexperienced in life (and I agree), but old enough to vote, could also have been a Member of Parliament for the last 3 years.....
Car finance woes - Jungerns

You gotta laugh at these clowns. Sleepless nights over a car ?? When you are charged with running prostitution rings when you're completely innocent and facing a 7 yeats stretch that gives you sleepless nights....(fortunately the spurious accusations were unmasked pre trial)

Just drive to the finance company hand over the documents and keys and walk away