What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - Sam M

I understand grants have dried up for electric cars, but can I get something decent for the budget and save on monthly petrol costs? Annual mileage is approx 7k miles p.a.

Thanks

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - badbusdriver

With that budget you won't get either if even if you wanted!. Looking at Autotrader, the cheapest hybrid Yaris is £5.5k, and that is for a 2013 car with more than 100k miles. The cheapest Zoe is £6300.

So you need to be a bit more realistic in your expectations of how far £4k will go, as the answer is, not that far!. A petrol Yaris would be a good option. and your £4k will get you into a 2013 car with 80-90k miles, or a 2012 car with >70 k miles. this is probably going to be about as good as you can get for that money, at least in terms of reliability.

Other options worth looking at would be the Mazda 2, Ford Fiesta (1.25 or 1.4, definately not the 1.0 ecoboost), Honda Jazz, Kia Rio, Hyundai i20.

If economy is the priority, and you don't need that much space (strictly 4 seats and small boot), consider the Toyota Aygo. Your £4k will get you into a 2015 car, the 1st of the facelifted 'X front' cars, very economical, cheap to insure, and low road tax.

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - SLO76
With your low annual mileage you’d save peanuts even if you could afford one. It would also add complexity and increase the likelihood of problems thus actually it would ultimately cost more to run overall.

Remember these three words when shopping on a limited budget... keep it simple. Instead of looking at complex hybrids or turbo diesels stick with a simple petrol engine. The following shortlist is where you should look for a reliable supermini that’ll do 50mpg plus on a run.

Mazda 2 1.3
Suzuki Swift 1.2
Ford Fiesta 1.25
Honda Jazz 1.4
Toyota Yaris 1.33

All are reliable and all will be cheap to run. There’s no way to reduce running costs on a budget car any further than a simple petrol engined supermini.

Edited by SLO76 on 09/06/2019 at 13:41

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - bazza

Completely agree with above posts. Much as I would love an electric vehicle, as most of our journeys are running around, whenever I go through the numbers, they are simply not a cost effective option at the moment. Even a decent, newish hybrid has many years to break even point on my mileage, compared to the alternatives.

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - nellyjak

Your budget doesn't match your desires I'm afraid.

As above...keep it simple...keep it petrol...and more than likely..Japanese.

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - LinuxGeek

Mazda 2 would be my priority. Purely because you'll be able to buy a lot of car for less money. Mazda isn't a highly desired brand in used car market (purely because a lot of people don't even know about it). I've had couple of Mazdas and they were solid and great to drive.

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - badbusdriver

Mazda 2 would be my priority. Purely because you'll be able to buy a lot of car for less money. Mazda isn't a highly desired brand in used car market (purely because a lot of people don't even know about it). I've had couple of Mazdas and they were solid and great to drive.

The Mazda 2 is pretty much the smallest car in its class, so maybe more a case of 'less car for less money'?. And actually, the £4k budget will get a Mazda only one year younger than a Yaris, whereas you'd get a Suzuki Swift two years younger (based on Autotrader search results of cars with >70k miles).

Yaris, Zoe? - Electric/Hybrid hatchback which one? £3-4k budget - skidpan

Electric cars are a financial disaster for private buyers, its as simple as that.

In 2015 we bought a Nissan Note 1.2 DIg-S which after discount cost us about £12000.

At exactly the same time friends bought a new Zoe which cost them £26,000 approx and no discount.

We sold the Note just over 12 months ago and got a good price for it from Evans Halshaw buys your car. If we were selling it now it would be worth about £5500.

If they were selling the Zoe now it would be worth about £9000. (both Parkers prices).

We would have lost about £6500, they would have lost about £17000.

In 40,000 miles at approx 50 mpg the Note would have cost us about £4000 in petrol, No idea how much the Zoe has cost to recharge and not going to ask them (even if they know). Bizarre thing is they are the only property on their close without PV cells on the roof so no free electricity. But they have only done about 15,000 miles and 15,000 miles of fuel for the Note would ahve cost £1500 approx.

Note was £0 VED as is the Zoe. Note was free servicing, no idea about the Zoe. No idea about insurance either, Note was about £230 a year.

So over 4 years the real ££££'s cost for the Zoe is about £6500 higher than the Note plus electricity cost, or £9000 if we had only done 15000 miles.

But you have to remember our Note was a proper car and could go long distances. Friends are afraid to go more than about 50 mile from home should the car run out. If they want to go further they have to borrow the sons SUV.

Mate hates the car, regrets buying it and rarely drives it. But his wife loves it and uses it to drive stupidly short distances to the hairdressers, about 300 yards.

They simply do not work in the real world at present.