What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - sammy1

Just read HJ agony column part 2 re the above concerns with his new cars so called assisted driving extras. Regardless of the cost some £1600, what a nightmare experience he has had with the systems. How can the average driver be concentrating on the road when he appears to be at odds with what the cars electronic systems detating something else. What sort of testing and legislation is allowing all these systems to be introduced. I dread to think of anyone driving one of these cars and not knowing these systems are on

New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - Manatee

I'm quite prepared to believe the systems are poor but the complainant doesn't sound entirely reasonable. He complains when it intervenes, and complains when it doesn't.

But I wouldn't want such systems yet. Particularly anything dependent on road markings, which are virtually worn away on so many UK roads.

I do however wish the fools who tailgate me had these aids.

New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - James2018

I have these aids in a Hyundai.

1. The lane keeping system is good, but it does require clear road markings and will keep the car in lane or bleep if you cross the centre line without indicating. It also tightens up the steering and tries to recentre the car in the lane and you veer over towards the centre line without indicating but it is easy to overcome, which you would want for an emergency manouvre.

2. Blind spot detection. Superb. Saved a motorcyclists life. Checked my rear view mirrors and looked over my shoulder before indicating. Saw nothing. Motorcycle was in my blind spot. Little light on wing mirror was lit up showing something there. Looked so I didn't move over and the motorcycle passed me. If you indicate with something behind you it bleeps a warning. Its speed sensitive, so it warns you earlier if an approaching vehicle is much faster.

3. Cross traffic. Nightmare of a carpark, couldn't see to reverse out so did so gingerly. Cross traffic alerted me to a crossing vehicle and which side it was approaching from.

4. Automatic breaking. Saved me from a crash. I didn't think it worked tbh. It often bleeped when detecting cars slowing down quickly and turning off but never stopped the car. Then when I was on a motorway roundabout a car pulled on to the roundabout doing about 80 without stopping. I had just come off the throttle and was going for the brake but the system seriously beat me to it stopping the car dead. I really think there would have been a crash otherwise.

So thumbs up from me really. BTW all were standard equipment in the grade of car i chose and it made the insurance cheaper than the next model down that didn't have these features.

Edited by James2018 on 24/08/2018 at 23:29

New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - FP

"... when I was on a motorway roundabout..."

What is a "motorway roundabout"? Just curious.

New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - dan86

But I wouldn't want such systems yet. Particularly anything dependent on road markings, which are virtually worn away on so many UK roads.

One of our cars has lane departure warning and on a stretch of roadworks it was picking up the lines that had been blacked out.

New BMW X3 - Driving aids?? - Ethan Edwards

Our Ignis has these. I find the lane departure thing distracting. The brake support thing has alerted unnecessarily a few times. The Vitara has whilst on adaptive cruise decided i was drivng into an immovable object and slammed on. But it was a turning vehicle or there was a sharp bend. So they aren't perfect.

Out of ten...about an eight. I don't need them but I can live with them.