What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Income to car value? - carl233

It seems there are many new 'top of the range' cars these days and I did begin to think are these people wealthy or living a lifetime of slavery with a plan to retire at 80? I drive a car worth £250 which I have owned for 15 year yet have a high income my salary alone is £80k basic plus 20-25% bonus. The other half earns nearly six figures and yet again drives a car worth less than £2k. Are we living in a country where many of the people in 'high end' cars are simply slaves to the system? Opinions welcome.

Income to car value? - Big John

You pays your money - you takes your choice

Myself doing 15,000 miles a year I usually buy cheap nearly new (usually on model changes buying a sorted last of an old model ) and run for 10 years then throw away - repeat until retired.

Have managed well less than £100 a month over 25 years thus far (Last car was Skoda 2003 Superb I bought at 18 months for just over 8k and sold for £800 10 years later. Current car Skoda Superb 2014 bought at 14 months old for just over £10k

When retired - buy a nice car!

Edited by Big John on 12/06/2018 at 23:38

Income to car value? - Avant

Not slaves to anything: on the contrary we are exercising our choice. Some of us like new cars; you prefer either to save your money or spend it on other things.

Income to car value? - Leif
My first car was bought secondhand and kept 5 or so years until it blew up. My next car bought new lasted ten years and then fell apart. It worked out cheaper per year than the first car. My next car bought new was sold after six years and 130,000 miles. It cost the same per year as the second car in terms of depreciation but saved £1,000 a year in fuel costs, and was cheaper to service. So a new car can work out cheaper. My latest car bought new cost £14,500 and should last a long while. Because it is new it is much safer than old models. And it has one careful owner, namely me. And it has the latest tech in the form of Apple CarPlay so I can listen to my CD collection controlled from the car in a fully legal manner. Bliss.

I do understand your attitude to cars. I’ve been in expensive cars and wondered why anyone would buy them, given high purchase and maintenance costs for someth8ng that felt no better than a more modestly priced car. I think some people live in the now, and spend money when it comes in. And I think for a lot of people the image and prestige of a badge draws them in. I once had a Mercedes A Class for three days on loan. Horrible car. Less room than in a VW Up, less comfortable, harder to get into, not as good an engine, poorer mpg, expensive to buy and maintain. Why?

However, if someone gets pleasure from an expensive car, good for them, why not. You only live once.
Income to car value? - drd63

Thanks for sharing carl233, you're clearly very proud of your enormous earnings. Funny thing is that you're posting on a motoring forum but seem more interested in telling us all how much you earn rather than what you drive.

Income to car value? - carl233

"Thanks for sharing carl233, you're clearly very proud of your enormous earnings. Funny thing is that you're posting on a motoring forum but seem more interested in telling us all how much you earn rather than what you drive."

Great point cannot post any more at this time need to go to the bank to see if I can incease the credit limit' If you read the post in its complete form you will see that it reflects the current stance that I cannot undertsand why so many people drive 'top of the range cars' yet earn what could be considered low salaries in some cases, it is strange society in my view that we live in these days, again just my opinion.

Income to car value? - SLO76
I was self employed for over fifteen years and earned well from it but decided I wanted to have more time to enjoy life so sold up and currently drive buses for a more easy going life in place of my old 80hr week.

The eye opener came from the first visit into our depot where the car park is full of expensive metal on PCP or contract hire, cars which cost vastly more than I would ever have considered even at the peak of my earnings yet these guys are (just like me) ordinary working Joes, mostly living in council estates with Golf R’s, Focus RS’s, Jags, high spec BM’s etc etc sat outside often rented properties. To me it’s madness but it’s the way the market has gone, finance is being given to people who really can’t afford any sort of fiscal trauma at all, they’re living week to week with a car payment that is crippling them just so they can show off to their friends when they should be building equity towards a stable retirement.

I was mortgage free by 36 yet most of my co workers haven’t even started one by this age yet you can almost guarantee they’ll have a pricey motor on HP.
Income to car value? - drd63

Others have said this already but it is up to the individual. This obviously won't apply to all but some of those with a Focus RS, Golf R might be real car fans and have chosen to spend their money on something they are passionate about.

Income to car value? - SLO76

Others have said this already but it is up to the individual. This obviously won't apply to all but some of those with a Focus RS, Golf R might be real car fans and have chosen to spend their money on something they are passionate about.

Temptation is leading young minds down a road to poverty in old age. Of course any young lad would want one of these monster hot hatches but they’re building up trouble for later life by not getting started on the property ladder instead. I understand totally why people who’re already in their own homes and can afford to buy a new car doing so however. But yes as you say it is down to the individual, I just don’t want to be keeping them later in life.
Income to car value? - Leif

Others have said this already but it is up to the individual. This obviously won't apply to all but some of those with a Focus RS, Golf R might be real car fans and have chosen to spend their money on something they are passionate about.

Temptation is leading young minds down a road to poverty in old age. Of course any young lad would want one of these monster hot hatches but they’re building up trouble for later life by not getting started on the property ladder instead. I understand totally why people who’re already in their own homes and can afford to buy a new car doing so however. But yes as you say it is down to the individual, I just don’t want to be keeping them later in life.

I forgot to mention that almost 20 years ago I put £6,000 into a unit trust. Today it is worth over £60,000 and growing. I also have a house with no mortgage. I've driven small basic cars until recently, as I wanted a decent retirement. Poverty in old age is not nice. And anyway, I'm not a car nut. I've been in Jaguar XJs, Mercedes and BMWs and been unimpressed.

Income to car value? - Andrew-T

<< Temptation is leading young minds down a road to poverty in old age. Of course any young lad would want one of these monster hot hatches but they’re building up trouble for later life by not getting started on the property ladder instead. >>

SLO - the important phrase is (or was) Delayed Gratification. Many of us on here, including me, are from the generation which grew up having learned to accept D-G, at least for the 'luxuries' of life. The advent of easy credit taught younger people that D-G was not really necessary, leading to the situations described in this thread. In fact D-G has its upside, as anticipation can increase the pleasure of ownership.

Apart from a mortgage (long ago paid off) I have never been in debt except while waiting to pay the monthly credit-card bill. I realise many are not fortunate enough to be able to do this, but je ne regrette rien, as was once famously said (or sung).

Income to car value? - Leif

I guess they have grown up on cheap credit. It starts when at university and they get used to owing more money than I have ever owed in my life.

Income to car value? - colinh

Life of company cars - changed every 2 or 3 years - didn't change on retirement

Income to car value? - jc2

Something like 80%of new cars are bought by companies/lease firms.How many of the new cars you see are actually owned by the driver.There are companies now that lease used cars.

Income to car value? - Chris M

As has been said, it's personal choice. My current car is the newest and most expensive I've ever owned. A nearly new Astra, so hardly extravagant, but I do like it.

Slightly off topic, but I can't understand those that spend £35 or even £50 a month on a phone.

The 'must have' generation.

Edited by Chris M on 13/06/2018 at 09:24

Income to car value? - catsdad
colin, I took a different view on retirement and losing my company car. I bought an 18 month old car for cash and have had it for nearly five years and aim to keep it a while longer. As long as it gives no trouble and is safe. I actually enjoy making a car last and appreciate the way a car feels as it ages.

Also I can maintain it properly with no skimping on services and can change the tyres promptly when I feel like it and not when an accountant says so. There is a pleasure in ownership.

As for the OP's points, my car choice bears little relationship to my income or wealth. And if other people want to buy on some form of credit then I am relaxed about that. Against the extortionate interest rates on some other purchases the costs can be reasonable compared to buying new outright. And someone has to buy new so that they can feed the car back into the used market for cash buyers like me.

Income to car value? - Dabooka

We have two newish (well 2014, one bought new one at 18 months old) cars that are modest, but suit our individual and family needs perfectly. Both are now owned outright. My wife is a 'high' mileage user (~18-20k per year) whereas I am not.

We are often asked by certain folk why we don't drive 'better' cars as we could easily afford it. Being fit for purpose, reliable, fun (in my case at least!) and cheap to run is lost on them, they simply see the wrong badge, small cars and four years old.

These people are similar ages, family setups and earners as us. One example took a sizeable loan out for the deposit on a PCP deal. I think I know who the crazy ones are and it isn't us...

Income to car value? - Falkirk Bairn

5 years ago I traded in my then 5 yr old car for a new one - auto needed because of health issues.

Neighbour, "who likes to know", asked outright how much the car was. I said it did not really cost me anything...........slightly taken aback he then said "Did you boys buy you a new car?" I said indirectly they had...........there will be £15K less to divi up when I go!

My 3 sons are more into cars than I am - 2-3 years & the car is sold - they are not high mileage but want a car in warranty. 40 odd yr old - good salaries, mortgage free, do not smoke, drink, 1 overseas holiday a year is limit etc so a new car is a treat rather and not a millstone around their neck.

Income to car value? - skidpan

One example took a sizeable loan out for the deposit on a PCP deal. I think I know who the crazy ones are and it isn't us..

I worked with a chap whose wife was very aspirational. She insisted that they had a 4 x 4 to take the kids to school safely which was a laugh since the primary school was less than a mile from where they lived and the secondary school a few hundred yards up the road.

After much debate at home he gave in and they got a Volvo XC90 on a PCP. It was the top spec diesel with a list price of over £48,000. After 3 years it had done 12,000 and guess what, back to the dealers and out with a new model XC90 costing even more.

My colleague was on a good grade at work with a company car but his wife was part time self employed so how on earth were they funding the PCP with 2 kids and a mortgage to pay for?

Income to car value? - Andrew-T

<< My colleague was on a good grade at work with a company car but his wife was part time self employed so how on earth were they funding the PCP with 2 kids and a mortgage to pay for? >>

Taking note of some of the tales one hears of, or reads about, that may be a question one hesitates to ask. If the numbers don't seem to add up, something else must be going on.

Income to car value? - Manatee

5 years ago I traded in my then 5 yr old car for a new one - auto needed because of health issues.

Neighbour, "who likes to know", asked outright how much the car was. I said it did not really cost me anything...........slightly taken aback he then said "Did you boys buy you a new car?" I said indirectly they had...........there will be £15K less to divi up when I go!

That's pretty much how I try to look at it now. I don't expect that we'll be down to our last £10,000 when we snuff it, enough to pay for the burning longboat or whatever, so within reason we can have and do what we want - thanks to 42 years of spending less than our income.

We've given the youngest a house deposit and at some point I think we'll be able to do somehting to help the grandchildren. Our income is enough to live reasonably on and savings are for spending.

I have found that quite tricky to get my head around actually. Still do really. I still want to save up.

I do think we have been lucky. Rampant inflation followed our first mortage and virtually extinguished the debt in real terms. Things will never be as good again for plebs like me.

Income to car value? - oldroverboy.

One example took a sizeable loan out for the deposit on a PCP deal. I think I know who the crazy ones are and it isn't us...

I also know someone who has done this. A near neighbour, short of money for a deposit on a car on finance took out a doorsteo loan over 30 weeks, cost 50% interest. what's the APR on that?

Income to car value? - Gibbo_Wirral

The "keeping up with the Jones's" curse is no longer a stigma of middle ages familes, but the young too.

I know a few who want to start on the mid-rung of the property ladder rather than the bottom. (A £190,000 4 bedroom semi for your first house when a simple 2 bedroom terraced is a third of that price)

And to top it off they fill the home with new furnishings rather than second hand or hand-me-downs. And the cherry on the cake is the new or nearly new leased car on the drive.

Some of these people are one paycheck away from poverty and it scares me.

Income to car value? - FP

You can read what you like into people's priorities in life and how important money and keeping up appearances are to them. In some cases it's certainly a question of materialism and shallowness, unfortunately. Judging people by the car they drive is equally naive.

I have never bought a car from new - it just seems a terrible waste of money, given the amount of depreciation that kicks in as soon as you leave the dealer's premises. But then, for me, having a car is mainly about practicalities and I tend to buy good second-hand examples after a lot of research and keep them for years. I'm on my ninth car now, at age 72, having had my first at age 17 - and one of the nine was a write-off, its time with me cut short by the idiot who rammed into the back of it at a roundabout.

I'm always slightly surpised by some of my neighbours here in sunny Hemel Hempstead - living in very modest and in some cases downright unattractive houses or even bungalows (we have an incredible mixture of housing round here), who still have brand-new, prestigious cars on the drive. For me, the house has always taken priority over the car.

Each to their own. But I do worry about the amount of personal debt in this country and how far it might contribute to problems with the banks which might affect the thrifty majority - if they are a majority.

Edited by FP on 13/06/2018 at 13:53

Income to car value? - Leif

A new car can be cheaper than a used car when you work out the initial cost and the servicing costs, assuming you keep it a long while. But you have to buy it at a good price, not the list price. Of course if you can find a good used car at a good price, you're laughing. My own experience is not so good.

Income to car value? - Andrew-T

... - living in very modest and in some cases downright unattractive houses or even bungalows ...

Oy! We've lived in a bungalow for 12 years, and we wish we'd done it earlier (when we decided to downsize). It's not a standard bungalow though, and its location near to almost all necessary amenities and with a quarter-acre of garden and a decent view, make all the difference. Climbing stairs needs a little concentration sometimes :-)

Income to car value? - Leif

... - living in very modest and in some cases downright unattractive houses or even bungalows ...

Oy! We've lived in a bungalow for 12 years, and we wish we'd done it earlier (when we decided to downsize). It's not a standard bungalow though, and its location near to almost all necessary amenities and with a quarter-acre of garden and a decent view, make all the difference. Climbing stairs needs a little concentration sometimes :-)

And you've cured the problem of going upstairs, and then forgetting what you went upstairs for.

Income to car value? - TheGentlemanThug
I was self employed for over fifteen years and earned well from it but decided I wanted to have more time to enjoy life so sold up and currently drive buses for a more easy going life in place of my old 80hr week.

The eye opener came from the first visit into our depot where the car park is full of expensive metal on PCP or contract hire, cars which cost vastly more than I would ever have considered even at the peak of my earnings yet these guys are (just like me) ordinary working Joes, mostly living in council estates with Golf R’s, Focus RS’s, Jags, high spec BM’s etc etc sat outside often rented properties. To me it’s madness but it’s the way the market has gone, finance is being given to people who really can’t afford any sort of fiscal trauma at all, they’re living week to week with a car payment that is crippling them just so they can show off to their friends when they should be building equity towards a stable retirement.

I was mortgage free by 36 yet most of my co workers haven’t even started one by this age yet you can almost guarantee they’ll have a pricey motor on HP.


That's pretty much what I was going to say. PCP deals mean that people can keep their monthly payments low and "afford" a car that would normally be out of their price range. Trouble is, very few of them consider what happens at the end of the deal.

To each their own though.
Income to car value? - barney100
finance is being given to people who really can’t afford any sort of fiscal trauma at all,

My daughter had summer job with one of the banks doing loans, most of the loans were for car purchases and people put themselves in financial stress buying a depreciating asset. Say you borrowed £20,000 on an averaging depreciation vehicle today, I wonder how much you lose over three years?

Income to car value? - P3t3r

My car is worth less than 10% of my annual salary. It's very reliable, I have owned it from new and it's condition is almost like new.

One reason for me having a cheap car is that I couldn't really find anything that I liked and while some cars may have been slightly better, it would have cost a huge amount of money (perhaps double) for very little benefit. Almost all cars could be considered to be fast these days. Almost all new cars will easily exceed 70+mph.

I hate buying a new car. It's very stressful and has the potential for so many things to go wrong. I hope to keep my current car for at least a few more years.

I hope to spend more when I get my next car but I'd need to find something that I like and is practical. Cheap city cars have many adantages, not just their size and low running costs. I found that sporty things tend to be bad in bad weather or poor road surfaces, but cheap small cars tend to have quite good ground clearance (obviously not in the same league as an off roader). Also if things go wrong then repairs are usually cheap and easy.

On my next car (new) I'd like to spend 25-60% of my annual salary but I'm not sure that I'd find one that I really like, so it'll probably be at the lower end.

Income to car value? - James2018

My motor is Korean but made in the Czech Republic I think.

The list price is £28k but I estimate it cost the lease company about £20k. Lease costs £378 per month for 25k miles.

I would like something cheaper but need an automatic and reliability (it has to start faultlessly each morning).

When i retire i will be getting a much cheaper car.

Income to car value? - P3t3r

My motor is Korean but made in the Czech Republic I think.

The list price is £28k but I estimate it cost the lease company about £20k. Lease costs £378 per month for 25k miles.

I would like something cheaper but need an automatic and reliability (it has to start faultlessly each morning).

When i retire i will be getting a much cheaper car.

My car has only had two faults in over 7 years. One was a dead battery (lasted 7 years though) and the other was a broken wing mirror adjuster (car was still driveable). Both were cheap and easy to fix/replace.

Not convinced that expensive cars are more reliable, particularly when they have loads of tech in them. In fact, I would trust my car more than a new car as if my car had faults then they would have been found by now.

Income to car value? - SLO76
“The list price is £28k but I estimate it cost the lease company about £20k. Lease costs £378 per month for 25k miles.”

Seems expensive. My CRV had a list price of £26k and costs £259pcm over 40,000 miles. Standard Honda contact hire was just around £300pcm but shopping around is well worth the time. Waiting to see what sort of price I’m offered to buy it when it’s up in September, if it’s cheap enough I’ll be keeping it.
Income to car value? - V4 Heaven
You can spot the luxury cars that are on PCP or youngsters with brand new cars on PCP. They're the ones that only put £20 worth of petrol in every time.

Next time you fill up, watch!
Income to car value? - John F

This rather vague question can be answered in several ways. I offer two.......

For the first ten years of our married life we had two cars - for the last 28yrs we have had three (the TR7 was semi-retired). Their current guesstimated value is around 12% of our 2017/18 gross (before tax) household income.

Expressed another way, the total capital cost of eight cars spread over 38yrs (£55,000, and we still have three of them) has been less than £1500 per annum. This is less than 2% of current GHI and has probably been less than 4% of our annual combined GHI since 1980, especially as a varying percentage of the cost was put against tax.

Unless one owns an impractical rare classic, an everyday car is a rapidly wasting capital asset on which I for one prefer to invest as little as possible for maximum comfort and pleasure.

Income to car value? - Leif
Don’t you fancy treating yourself to a car that does not come with lumps of dried nasal mucous and other less salubrious secretions included in the price?
Income to car value? - drd63

I've bought a couple of used cars from dealers and theyve been really well prepared. I've also leased and purchased new. There really is something special about a bought and paid for new car. You know you're paying vat and the depreciation but if its what you really want that doesn't matter.

Income to car value? - Big John

There really is something special about a bought and paid for new car.

Indeed. Mr bigjohn and I have had two new cars over the years (the later Octavia bought at a huge discount!) and somehow they have been the better cars. The 84 polo was kept for 19 years and the 2001 Octavia is still on the go.

Saying that as mentioned above we've also had two nearly new Skoda Superbs that have been great

Edited by Big John on 16/06/2018 at 01:22

Income to car value? - Andrew-T
Don’t you fancy treating yourself to a car that does not come with lumps of dried nasal mucous and other less salubrious secretions included in the price?

Can't say I have ever found that problem in any of the second-hand cars I have owned. It is no longer recommended procedure, but in 'the old days' owners of new cars were advised to run them in gently while the moving parts bedded in. Buying used avoided that nuisance, but of course you had to assume the first owner had bothered to do it. Manufacturer's instructions seemed to assume that first owners kept their cars for a long time .....

Income to car value? - argybargy

My wife left her handbag on the bus a few months back. Cue mad panic for a couple of hours, with me chasing buses trying to get the phone number of the depot.

After ringing the number and getting no response, I drove to the depot to ask whether anyone had handed in her bag, with spare car and house keys, credit and bank cards, phone, the lot, inside it.

I did notice that the bus depot car park was full of expensive motors, including several Focus and Fiesta STs. Blimey, thought I, these bus drivers must be getting lots of overtime. But maybe not, maybe its the curse of PCP, as suggested above. The idea of committing myself to that kind of debt on a modest income gives me the horrors.

Anyhow, she got her bag back intact, and I felt mighty relieved as I drove home in my 4 year old bog standard but reliable Jazz.

.

Income to car value? - Bianconeri
Income to equity would be interesting, but there again my salary was never for public consumption.
Income to car value? - daveyK_UK
I think the OP had a point but there is also personal choice.

I always go for value and price over anything else.
Hence why I tend to buy van based MPVs!

I suppose I could afford something substantially more expensive, but I don’t see the value in giving a German manufacturer a small fortune in profits , never mind someone who works in a glass tower dealership.

I would however like to own a new Subaru Forrester, although the reason I haven’t is why should I as a UK customer pay substantially more than a USA or alternative world customer buying essentially the same car?
The reason seems to be because Subaru use a importer in the UK who appear to add a substantial fee on top.

Income to car value? - Bianconeri
I think the OP had a point but there is also personal choice. I always go for value and price over anything else. Hence why I tend to buy van based MPVs! I suppose I could afford something substantially more expensive, but I don’t see the value in giving a German manufacturer a small fortune in profits , never mind someone who works in a glass tower dealership. I would however like to own a new Subaru Forrester, although the reason I haven’t is why should I as a UK customer pay substantially more than a USA or alternative world customer buying essentially the same car? The reason seems to be because Subaru use a importer in the UK who appear to add a substantial fee on top.

I had a couple of Legacies from 2006 to 2012 and put a monstrous mileage on both. Magnificent and, thankfully, very different. I could have affored something much more expensive (especially the second time) but really didn’t see the point and there was usually somthing far more important to spend the company’s money on.

I once spent a lot of money on a car. It was a car I enjoyed a lot but I wouldn’t do anything like that again, and I have never subscribed to the use of debt to create a ‘lifestyle’ though that seems to be the way of the world these days.

Edited by Bianconeri on 17/06/2018 at 19:09

Income to car value? - Alby Back
Yes but - a lot depends on what makes you happy though. Some people spend more than they probably should on following a football team, or playing golf, or holidays, or eating out. Some on cars.

I spend way too much on mountain bikes and their ancillary costs, but I'm never happier than when I'm on one in challenging terrain so I can justify it to myself.

On the other hand, I do suspect some people think they can buy happiness in the form of material possessions which is often a mistake. Happiness usually comes from enjoyable experiences and activities rather than acquisition.

Income to car value? - Avant

Very true! Hopefully people on forums like this are those who - despite everything - still find motoring an enjoyable experience, and so tend to buy cars with the heart as well as the head.

We must hope that cars of the future will still be fun to drive. The lively performance of most EVs is a good sign.

Income to car value? - John F

We must hope that cars of the future will still be fun to drive. The lively performance of most EVs is a good sign.

Sadly, hope in vain, Avant. Double -declutching down to second for a hairpin bend, calculated mild rear wheel spin on exit, perhaps with a little tail hang-out; hanging onto a corner at the tactile limit of non-power assisted steering adhesion; sliding round a damp greasy roundabout balancing acceleration to opposite lock; the exhaust music from slick gear changes; coasting down a long hill .....my TR7 might not be as lively as a Leaf but it's a darn sight more fun. But if I was commuting daily I would certainly want a car where you just pressed one pedal to go and another to stop.

Income to car value? - Leif

We must hope that cars of the future will still be fun to drive. The lively performance of most EVs is a good sign.

Sadly, hope in vain, Avant. Double -declutching down to second for a hairpin bend, calculated mild rear wheel spin on exit, perhaps with a little tail hang-out; hanging onto a corner at the tactile limit of non-power assisted steering adhesion; sliding round a damp greasy roundabout balancing acceleration to opposite lock; the exhaust music from slick gear changes; coasting down a long hill .....my TR7 might not be as lively as a Leaf but it's a darn sight more fun. But if I was commuting daily I would certainly want a car where you just pressed one pedal to go and another to stop.

Do you drive like that on public roads?

Income to car value? - Leif
Yes but - a lot depends on what makes you happy though. Some people spend more than they probably should on following a football team, or playing golf, or holidays, or eating out. Some on cars. I spend way too much on mountain bikes and their ancillary costs, but I'm never happier than when I'm on one in challenging terrain so I can justify it to myself. On the other hand, I do suspect some people think they can buy happiness in the form of material possessions which is often a mistake. Happiness usually comes from enjoyable experiences and activities rather than acquisition.

Research has proven that (in terms of happiness) money is best spent buying experiences rather than material possessions, though the latter is often needed to acquire the former of course.

They say money cannot buy happiness. My experience is that lack of money can cause considerable unhappiness, and money can indeed buy happiness, but using your logic.

Income to car value? - gordonbennet

They say money cannot buy happiness. My experience is that lack of money can cause considerable unhappiness, and money can indeed buy happiness, but using your logic.

Ah the clarion call of the extremely well heeled, espcially those who have never done a days work in their lives.

'Money doesn't buy you happiness'...only ever said by the well off who have every intention of staying rich.

'Hard work never killed anyone'..only ever said by those who don't ache from every joint after a lifetime of hard graft, and who have seen other hard workers drop dead long before their time.

Income to car value? - Leif
Ah the clarion call of the extremely well heeled, espcially those who have never done a days work in their lives.

'Money doesn't buy you happiness'...only ever said by the well off who have every intention of staying rich.

'Hard work never killed anyone'..only ever said by those who don't ache from every joint after a lifetime of hard graft, and who have seen other hard workers drop dead long before their time.

It's the kind of nonsense that teachers filled us with at school. It has taken decades to realise that so much of what I was taught at school was idealistic left wing nonsense. Anyway, I've heard many people of modest means say "Money can't buy you happiness", perhaps as a way of justifying to themselves their lack of wealth. Of course the modern generation are different, and I suspect more materialistic. So few modern students are revolting. (Pun intended).

My 75 year old neighbour worked as an upholsterer. His broken body shows that hard physical work can destroy the body, causing serious illness. Equally many of us sit at desks, and in our later years we are overweight, with type 2 diabetes, heart disease and other lifestyle diseases.

I like Ronald Reagan's quote: "I've heard that hard work never killed anyone, but I say why take the chance?"

Income to car value? - Alby Back
Absolutely, the sweet spot is enjoying doing something you can afford to enjoy.

With cars it's the same, by all means get one you like driving, but make sure it suits your practical needs and that it's not going to stretch you so much that you can't afford to do the things you want it to make it possible to do.

If you see what I mean... ;-)
Income to car value? - Bianconeri
Yes but - a lot depends on what makes you happy though. Some people spend more than they probably should on following a football team, or playing golf, or holidays, or eating out. Some on cars. I spend way too much on mountain bikes and their ancillary costs, but I'm never happier than when I'm on one in challenging terrain so I can justify it to myself. On the other hand, I do suspect some people think they can buy happiness in the form of material possessions which is often a mistake. Happiness usually comes from enjoyable experiences and activities rather than acquisition.

Research has proven that (in terms of happiness) money is best spent buying experiences rather than material possessions, though the latter is often needed to acquire the former of course.

They say money cannot buy happiness. My experience is that lack of money can cause considerable unhappiness, and money can indeed buy happiness, but using your logic.

I’m sure we can find research to support most things, in this case funded / commissioned by the companies that sell ‘expereinces’ or ‘holidays’ or ‘cars’. That may sound very cynical but the basic underlying financial principle in the complex state of ‘happiness’ was surely defined best by Dickens. I paraphrase but Income 20 shillings, expenditure 19/6 = happiness Income 20 shillings, expenditure 20/6 = misery You pays your money on what you spend your 19/6 on to make you happy. Earn more ‘20 shillings’and you have more ‘19/6’ to spend on whatever floats your boat. Not enough 20 shillings will doubtless cause misery because there are not enough 19/6s to pay for the basics (Maslow I guess).
Income to car value? - expat
They say money cannot buy happiness. My experience is that lack of money can cause considerable unhappiness, and money can indeed buy happiness, but using your logic.

That would appear to make sense however I have seen research that claims that people in poor countries like Bangladesh and Indonesia tend to be happier than those in rich countries. Perhaps they have just learnt to be content with their lot and not trying to keep up with the Jones.

Income to car value? - Andrew-T

<< I have seen research that claims that people in poor countries like Bangladesh and Indonesia tend to be happier than those in rich countries. Perhaps they have just learnt to be content with their lot and not trying to keep up with the Jones. >>

That's just it - most of them are keeping up with the Jones, but they aren't very far behind them. The unhappiness arises when others are conspicuously better off, causing envy. Can't say that I envy owning a Roller though .....

Income to car value? - Eyeball119
Interesting discussion, I was only thinking the other day that the number of Golf R’s on the Road has hugely increased!

To answer your question, I’ve just ordered a brand new XC60 R Design, it’s OTRP is about £47,000 which is approx 3/4 of my income. However it’s a company funded car and costs me personally just £150 per month. It is replacing my current Discovery Sport (which breaks a lot!) that was also new.

This is the first time I’ve has to buy a car on a personal lease as it’s more tax efficient. As a company, we’ve always done contract hire but the tax situation allowed me to look at PCP - it’s certainly not something I would sign up to. The whole thing is to ensure you are indebted to the dealer and can’t leave.

I wouldn’t have such an expensive car if it wasn’t funded by my work. I’m very conscious of being as debt free as possible. I have a young family and their holidays etc are much more important than my car. I work hard for it but I am in a fortunate position.
Income to car value? - Avant

Welcome to the forum, Eyeball119. Good luck with the XC60 when it comes: it's a good car and can only be an improvement over the Discovery.

Land Rover just don't seem to get the message about quality control. It's one make I've never coveted.

Income to car value? - Eyeball119
I’ve had it 2.5 years, at the moment we’re currently on a 4 month streak where it hasn’t spontaneously lost all power whilst driving. For a vehicle at that price range it’s just unbelievable that they can’t guarantee I’ll get to work each day (10 Miles!)

Wouldn’t buy another one and I’m very excited about the XC60!