What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Jaguar XJ - Michelin Super Sport Vs PS3 and fitting error.... - partrir

Hi,

My tyres were due for replacement, and due to a slight bit of disatisfaction with the OEM Dunlop SP Sport Maxx, I decided to look at different makes.

After much reading, I settled on Michelins - either the Pilot Super Sport or the Pilot Sport 3. They're both a simialr price.

The PSS seems to get better reviews than the PS3, so I would have prefered them (I think!), problem was, whilst the PSS was available for my read tyre size (275/40/19), they not made in the front size (245/45/19), so I was forced down the PS3 route.

Ordered from a national chain of tyre fitters, and went to have them fitted this morning. I thought things a little odd, when they told me they couldn't fit the fronts, as they had ordered the wrong size, and that they would do the rears today, and could I go back on Monday to have the fronts fitted....no problems, I thought, we all make mistakes, and they offered to do a 4-wheel alignment for my trouble.

However, I have just noticed that they have fitted Pilot Super Sports to the rear, and I assume that they will be fitting PS3s to the front.

Is this a problem? I like to find a balance between wear and performance. Do I need to have PS3s all round, would there be a benefit, and should I insist that the fitter changes the rear to what I actually ordered, or would I be making a fuss over nothing?

Being a rear wheel drive car, the rears always wear faster than the fronts, so of the PSSs wear better, it might actually be a good thing.

Thoughts?

Jaguar XJ - Michelin Super Sport Vs PS3 and fitting error.... - RobJP

If you specified the same type/variant of tyre for front and back, then you're entitled to ask them to take off those new tyres that they've fitted, and supply what they were originally supposed to do. It would be covered under the Consumer Rights Act.

However, I doubt it would make much (if any) noticeable difference. To me, as long as the tyres on an axle are identical, that's all that really matters.