What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
TDI, GDI - Death of the diesel? - Peartree

VVW could face penalties of $37,500 for each car sold in the US after deliberately cheating in emissions tests:

www.theguardian.com/business/2015/sep/21/volkswage...a

That's a whopping £11.6bn.

Seriously heavy fines is probably the only way to get car manufacturers to clean up their act. They have been treated far too leniently by legislators for far too long, dragging their automotive feet and cheating while we have paid the price in terms of respiratory and other disease.

But the problem is not limited to diesels. The high-efficiency GDI (petrol) engines producing eg. 125 bhp from a one-litre engine or 150 bhp from 1.4 litres emit huge amounts of particulate. While these engines have been around for several years now, car manufacturers have been given until 2017 to introduce filters.

Great to see the US take the lead in things environmental. We Europeans should join in and help force our car manufacturers to clean up their act. And VW is probably not the only culprit around.....

TDI, GDI - Death of the diesel? - skidpan

But the problem is not limited to diesels. The high-efficiency GDI (petrol) engines producing eg. 125 bhp from a one-litre engine or 150 bhp from 1.4 litres emit huge amounts of particulate. While these engines have been around for several years now, car manufacturers have been given until 2017 to introduce filters.

We have 2 petrol cars fitted with direct injection engines, one a Nissan the other a Seat. Whilst the particle emissions are probably higher than a non-direct injection engine of a similar capacity they are way short of diesels. But particle filters for petrols are way simpler and cheaper to produce than diesel ones and the higher exhaust temp pretty much means that regens are constant. Not going to panic. What will be will be.

TDI, GDI - Death of the diesel? - Ethan Edwards

It's far more complex than particles or CO2....see the link.

http://www.clickgreen.org.uk/product/directory/125055-petrol-vs-diesel-which-is-more-environmentally-friendly-.html

Much simpler to just drive what you want, enjoy it and to heck with everything else. And I owned a Hybrid until last week...replaced it with a 4wd TD. Has a dpf and is Euro 5 (I think).

TDI, GDI - Death of the diesel? - Sofa Spud

The US seems very keen on forcing re-calls of cars made by non-US companies, and this is just another example.

Possibly diesel and petrol engines are reaching the limit of how clean they can be made, practically.

Diesel engines are the most efficient type of internal combustion engines, which is why they're fitted to lorries, buses, vans, trains, ships, farm tractors, portable generators.

Electrically driven cars are the future, either pure battery electric, like the VW e-Golf, for local and medium range use, or range extender plug-in hybrids with on-board back-up generators powered by efficient small diesel engines to cope with long trips.

TDI, GDI - Death of the diesel? - slkfanboy

Very true euro car makes are on US regulators hate list.