What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
invisible indicators, grrr - Bilboman

I've noticed that a number of new cars have indicators that are all but invisible in daylight, all in the name of "styling", thanks to the almost universal fitment of clear lenses front and rear, requiring amber bulbs or amber interior lenses (BMW held out longest against this trend IIRC) makes a lot of signals hard to see and create an added hazard on the roads. Even 44 ton lorries are falling victim to this fad.
Amber bulbs seem to fade to clear very quickly and some motorists (deliberately or unwittingly) replace expired amber bulbs with clear ones. The Citroën Picasso is quite popular where I live and, strangely, they all seem to have ended up with clear rear indicator bulbs.
The placing of indicators so close to bright DRLs (the Qashqai is one example of many) renders them all but invisible and, at the rear, the adjacent LED brake lights on some cars (Audi Q7, I'm looking at you, with your pseudo-Knight Rider effects!) seem to absorb all the light from the indicators. (Not that Audi drivers are likely to wear the indicator bulbs out in record time...)
And finally - the eensy weensy "auxiliary" indicators mounted on door mirrors are as much use as fairy lights, at least in daylight, and contribute very little to road safety.
Surely it's time to tighten up regulations?

Edited by Bilboman on 19/07/2015 at 14:35

invisible indicators, grrr - Bladerrw

I really don't see this as a problem.

I'd go with an eyesight test before more regulations.

invisible indicators, grrr - Ben 10
I've had Amber bulb type clear lens. I always used to change them regularly whether blown or not. They seemed to be coated in a kind of paint. Which with heat from the bulb over time used to peel the paint enough for a white light to show. So the manufacturers need to find an alternative to the present coating.
As to the ones adjacent to DRLs. My wife's Fiesta LED type dim when the indicator is switched on. Making it more visible. If Im not mistaken, this happens on all models of car with DRLs. So I don't see your point on that.
invisible indicators, grrr - gordonbennet

Its the light wars, as fashionable bling and camp as possible, whether that dictates into clear useful indicators appears to be of no importance just so long as current image requirements are met.

VW started this trend of invisible indicators on Golf and Passat (and some Aldis) around the mid to late noughties, Passat and some A3/A4 rears being virtually useless and Golf fronts just as bad if the headlights were on.

Don't get me started on DRL's, surpassing crass in too many cases.

Fortunately the DRL's on my current lorry can be turned off via the dash menu, that's unusual these days, lorries are going down the fashion/image route just as much as cars.

Edited by gordonbennet on 19/07/2015 at 18:12

invisible indicators, grrr - SteveLee

VW started this trend of invisible indicators on Golf and Passat (and some Aldis) around the mid to late noughties, Passat and some A3/A4 rears being virtually useless and Golf fronts just as bad if the headlights were on.

I beleive the Austin Maestro was the first mass produced car to sport clear indicator lenses way back in 1983 - it was also the world's first mass produced car with a bonded in windscreen and "flat pack" wiring - Of course the Germans and Japs copied all these ideas and people forget about who actually did it first.

invisible indicators, grrr - Bilboman

"This happens on all models of car with DRLs" - unfortunately, not the case with the new Qashqai: the dazzling LED DRLs make a sharp chevron, and the indicators are quite small and are set into the apex of the chevron. The DRLS do not dim with indicators on, and this lack of contrast makes the indicators difficult to see.
I suspect Type Approval of DRLs takes into account light output etc., but does NOT take into account the location or light output of any adjacent lights, which is why I argue that regulations should be more stringent, e.g.
1. Minimum distance between DRLs and indicators (as with rear foglights and brake lights - 10cms minimum IIRC)
2. Minimum distance between rear indicators and brake lights.
3. DRLs that always dim when indicators are in use and are dimmed or even switched off when headlights are switched on. (Not all current DRL-equipped cars dim for indicators)

invisible indicators, grrr - Bilboman

("Eyesight test before more regulations") Rear foglights have to be at least 10cm away from brake lights, and - IMHO - indicators should all be bright orange and situated such that they are always clearly visible. If indicators are sandwiched between (Q7) or surrounded by (Seat Altea) enormous brake lights (often LEDs) or right next to a bank of large, non-dimming DRLs (Qashqai) , they are less easy to see.
(Eyesight tested fine last week, by the way.)

Edited by Bilboman on 19/07/2015 at 19:10

invisible indicators, grrr - Hamsafar

The Ford Focus of around 2000 with the tall sloping rear lights up the rear pillar is bad too, as there always seems to be a dazzling reflection concentrated over the indicator part.

invisible indicators, grrr - alan1302

Maybe if you don't see it you need the eyesight test ;-)

invisible indicators, grrr - TedCrilly

Agreed,....and the day I stop noticing flashing lights on the corners of vehicles, white, red, amber or sky blue pink will be the day I hand my license in!

invisible indicators, grrr - focussed

The bigger problem is not what sort of bulbs or what colour - it's what I would call the angle of visibility. Modern indicators in bright sunlight are next to invisible when viewed from the side of the approaching vehicle. The old style glass dome with a bulb inside it did not suffer from this problem-not that I have any desire to go back to glass dome-type indicator lenses, they used to get nicked!

invisible indicators, grrr - DirtyDieselDogg

This is indeed quite a problem, esp in daylight, regardless of ones visual acuity.

A triumph of style over substance.

At one particular junction I use several times a day, to go across a bypass, with a left onto the bypass and a right off it, it is neigh impossible to discern if oncoming traffic is turning in left, which is generally ones best opportunity to pull out.

The angle of the junction in respect of sunlight may be an issue, but only marginal.

marcus

invisible indicators, grrr - Bilboman

This raises another interesting point - not worth opening another thread, but aswe're here now:
Once again owing to the vagaries of "styling" an increasing number of cars have the "one foglight + one reversing light" set -up at the rear, which saves cost (bulbs, wiring, fuses, there's no end to it!) and headaches for car designers who just cannot decide where to slot all those beastly lights into their creations.
I'm thinking expecially of the Renault Scenic, where the single reversing light, set low down and a little "round the corner", is actually not a lot of use to the driver - I nearly always need to see what's behind/underneath BOTH sides of the car I'm reversing - but worse still is all but invisible to another road user or pedestrian from some angles. Can we PLEASE have two big bright reversing lights on all cars?

invisible indicators, grrr - Maximoose

He he, This thread has had me nodding all the way through it. Couldn't agree more with most of what's been said, this comment made me laugh in particular as my old boss managed to stuff a brand new sprinter by backing it into a post 'because he couldn't see in the dark'. Even with two revering lamps! :P

invisible indicators, grrr - concrete

Couldn't agree more, they are difficult to see in certain circumstances which is patently unsafe. No trouble seeing vehicles though with every form of light known to man glaring from every orifice.

Especially the 'boy racers' aroung here. Spot and Fog lights on no matter what the visibility. Just to show they have these 'desirable' extras of course. What use is a whistle unless it is blown?? Usually accompanied by the rear spoiler and power wing to keep the awesome power of that 1.3 Corsa firmly on the tarmac!!!!

Cheers Concrete.