What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
BMW 1 Series - Intermittent clutch judder - billdog
My 2012 116i petrol has less than 20K miles. Owned from new.

I have had intermittent vibration through clutch pedal for last 18 months but getting worse. Occurs when driving off in first on point of bite.Taken it to BMW dealer a couple of times but have not been able to reproduce it. Stated to notice after software upgrade but this may be coincidence.

Can go for days without it happening. Can happen when cold or hot, beginning or during extended journey - or not at all.

Last occasion was in stop start motorway journey (neural &!handbrake) each time I moved off.

Is it likely to be clutch / dmf related or could some other hydraulic or electrical problem be the cause?

If it is clutch related why is it intermittent/periodic?
BMW 1 Series - Intermittent clutch judder - RobJP

It sounds like the clutch friction surfaces are glazed, or that the clutch is heading towards knackered - not sure if that car with that particular engine has a DMF or not.

If it is the clutch, it's intermittent because sometimes, the bearing surfaces 'catch' and engage better than others.

BMW 1 Series - Intermittent clutch judder - billdog
Thanks for the response.

Is it possible to judiciously unglazed it?
BMW 1 Series - Intermittent clutch judder - Manatee

You can certainly roast it a bit to "resurface" the friction plate.

I am very easy on clutches in normal use, I have never had to replace one despite having had a few high mileage cars that probably had worn linings when I got them. But I have suffered what was probably glazing - manifested not as judder but as slip.

It happened on a Honda CRV. I parked up with the handbrake on, set the rpm at 3000 or so, selected a high gear, let the clutch in and allowed it to slip for 5 seconds or so, a couple of times. It cured it, and the clutch was still OK 50,000 miles later, though I had to repeat the treatment once in between.

I can't be certain that it was glazing rather than contamination as I never inspected the plate, but I am of the opinion that glazing was the problem.