What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

As per the title...I have a Nokia with buttons and that's it. I use it with, what used to be called, "Ikea Family Mobile". It's now just "Family Mobile" and is connected to EE . It's PAYG at 9p a min with texts at 4p. My credit card recharges the balance below £10 so I don't have to do anything. It suits my low mobile phone usage and even lower text usage.

However, it's sometimes a bit frustrating when out and wanting to check something that, if at home, I'd have been able to look up (I don't have an iPad or anything other than a Windows desktop PC) which, in my ignorance, is OK .

Essentially I'd like to know what the cheapest and simplest (ie most intuitive) device would do the job of allowing me access to the internet when I'm away from home. I would like it to work independant of WiFi hotspots (as I believe they're called) .... I might want to use it when NOT in MacDonalds or the Tesco Cafe. I suppose it would have a phone connection as well and do away with my Nokia but presumably I'd transfer my current number over to it? Or maybe it'd have a new number and I'd keep the Nokia and it's number? Can't imagine many people would do that.

Is GiffGaff the sort of thing I want? and, I suppose more importantly, do I want an iPhone or a Samsung or an HTC or a Nokia Lumia thingy. Presumably I need to choose between Apple and Android? Is that the choice I have? Ideally, using it would be self explanatory to a complete idiot and also be big enough for a bloke with varifocals (which need changing for better ones) to actually see the thing and read whatever it happens to say.

So, that's it. I don't mind paying up front for it if it means Ihaven't got to pay a load of monthly fees for something I won't use every day of the week but it would be nice if it lasted a good couple of years without having to be upgraded or replaced, or whatever it is you do with these things.

I thank you (but please be gentle Mildred, and assume I know very little and we'll get on just fine).

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - galileo

I got what seems like a good deal at the Virgin shop - £8 a month for unlimited texts, 150 minutes talk time and 500MB data - I can cancel the arrangement with 30 days notice. Phone was £34.99 + £10 top-up.

Probably similar offers at the other shops, I went to Virgin as I have their landline/broadband/TV.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Thanks. Just to prove my ignorance....what does the £10 top up relate to given that the £8 a month gives texts, talk time on the phone and some internet usage? Is it a one off £10 payment? Don't quite understand that bit.

I imagine I'll have to face up to the fact that I'm not going to get anything like full use from the monthly calls and text provision as I won't use them up and I don't suppose they roll over?. The internet is the main thing, of course. Will the internet work anywhere? Does ithe internet service work off the phone terrestrial network or some sort of satellite system?

Having just looked I don't think GiffGaff is any better than the one you quote, but could be wrong.

Do I get to use my existing phone number with the new phone?

Not that it matters very much but what is the phone? Would it be an Android?...it's obviously not an Apple jobbie. And is it big enough to be useful when using the internet?

(I did say I didn't know much about theses things)

:-)

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

Firstly, I'm assuming you'll need a new handset. As to what you get, it really depends on you. For technophobes, I'd be inclined to recommend an iphone, as they are incredibly intuitive .My dad can use one, and he's still in the stone age on most things. But I've seen 2 or 3 year-olds playing on ipads (which is basically a big iphone, same principle entirely). If a 3 year old can use something, then it's really been well designed to be intuitive to use.

Secondly, if using internet on the phone, most of the time it comes through your network. If you live in larger towns or cities, then you'll almost certainly get good '3G' (short for 3rd Generation) coverage. (Not to be condused with the network '3') all networks have 3G.The more rural or small town area you are in, the less likely you are to get 3G. Worth bearing in mind.

There are also now '4G' networks. But pretty much irrelevant, as 3G will do all you need, by the sound of it.

As to network and pay-as-you-go(PAYG)/contract ... you can get some good deals on contract, that make PAYG seem expensive.

PAYG (generally) : you have to buy the handset outright, paying in full for it at the time of purchase. You then buy credit (£10 worth, as an example), as and when you need it. Depending on your usage, that £10 might last you 2 days, or a month.

NOTE : some PAYG setups require you to add credit each month to stay on the same tariff, or to get free internet usage (you pay for your calls and texts). You'd need to read lots of terms and conditions, really thoroughly.

CONTRACT (generally) : the company subsidises the cost of the handset (so free to you, or hugely reduced cost), but in return you are required to sign up to a contract. Most contracts these days are for 18 months or 2 years. You pay your contract price each month (pretty much all insist on direct debit being set up for payments to be done automatically). Included in the contract are xxx minutes of call time per month, xxx texts per month, and xxx amount of internet data per month. If you use more calls, texts or data in a particular, you pay the extra on the next payment.

ALTERNATIVES : You can get a 'SIM card only' contract. Still a contract, like above, but NO handset included, so a lot cheaper. If you buy a second-hand phone from someone (friend, family, the evilbay, etc), and put your contract SIM card in it, then you get the same contract, but for less per month. DOWNSIDES are that if the phone breaks you'd need to get another one, and you might need to get a phone 'unlocked' to use it. Most companies 'lock' their phones to their network, so you can't put a vodafone sim in an orange phone unless you get the handset unlocked. That usually costs, but not a huge amount.

Finally, my apologies, a huge post. But I hope helpful.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Bromptonaut

I'm in a similar position KB. My Sony Ericcsson 'choc bar' does most things I want but, even with a WiFi Tesco Hudl I'm feeling slightly out of touch nowadays. I cannot for example join Mrs B and the adult offspring on their 'whatzap' group. I've researched but not yet taken plunge.

A SIM free phone from Amazon comes in at around £120 (Motorola or Samsung Galaxy III). You could simply move your existing SIM, swapping it for the new micro version if necessary but you'll need a PAYG deal or contract that includes data. If EE cannot oblige at a reasonable price you'll need a port code from them to take your current number to another provider.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - gordonbennet

I'll stick with me steam powered brick phone, it makes and receives calls brilliantly, once up to a full head of steam it lasts up to a month on standby, and best of all i'm away from internet contact.

So no help to you KB, my eyes glazed over at RobJPs very enlightening post.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Ben 10
If you can afford to buy your new phone, I suggest Giffgaff. I'm with them and Which? rate them top of service providers.
I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Very many thanks all. I'll print the replies off and sit and study them. Rob's post was indeed concise and most helpful - thanks again.

Just to confirm I can afford to buy whatever fitted the bill outright if that were to be the best route and could and/or would use direct debit id need be so will study the options of monthly versus outright....and live in the West Country on the south east edge of Dartmoor but where phone coverage is OK. I would think 3G would be OK most of the time.... I usually get a usable signal unless right up on the moor on my Nokia.

Is the general concensus that an iPhone is easier to master than whatever it is that isn't an iPhone....(would that be Android?)

No-one has mentioned Android. Could someone define the word for me. Is it more the phone or more the system it runs on? (or both?)

To summarise...ideally it would let me roll over the accrued minutes and texts and internet allowance so as not to ditch them every month. Whether I can do that by paying monthly I'm not sure. I'll look again at GiffGaff. It would ideally be easy to get the hang of and would have a big enough screen to see without a magnifying glass.

Whever I've called EE (or Orange as it apparently was) it hasn't been a pleasant experience and has taken forever. I now see that they want you to pay 50p to get to the front of the queue when calling them. Which will push the mere plebs who don't pay even further back along the queue. Not keen on that idea very much. I thought you paid for a decent service in the charges you paid them.

Why can't all providers be as efficient as IDNet, who provide my broadband and landline? An amazingly personal service in the UK and you don't hang on in a queue for ages.

Thanks again...appreciated.

Edited by KB. on 23/11/2014 at 16:21

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Bromptonaut

Android is simply an operating system used in touch screen phones and tablets like the Tesco Hudl etc. It's analogous to Windows in a PC or Apple's current OS on its devices.

It's open source and tends to be modified a bit by device manufacturers but the look and feel is pretty standard. Like anything new it takes some learning and at push/shove Apple's system is probably more intuitive but there's not much in it unless you're looking for commonality or interoperability with other apple kit.

Only way to find out is to go to shops and try out some kit.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Thanks Bmpt for the helpful explanation. You're right that I need to visit outlets...but I'd like to brush up on the basics before putting myself at the mercy of a young whippersnapper with gelled hair and pointy shoes who is likely to baffle me with terminology within seconds and very like assume I knew what he was talking about.

I tend to find that almost everyone expects everyone else to know all the words, terms and phrases when it comes to IT devices and services. Hence pleading here for words of one syllable. (and finding that you've all been pretty good in that respect....for which I'm grateful). I'm making a start though and am grateful for all advice rcvd.

If I went in to car showroom to check a particular model I wouldn't be daunted at all and could hold my own and would soon suspect if a salesperson was talking BS or trying to pull a fast one (unless we were discussing PCP's, in which case I'd be in the same boat as I am with IT).

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

Have a chat with friends/acquaintances too. Most people will be only to willing to let you have a play around with a phone to see what you think of it, and you've obviously got no sale pressure on you at the time.

The one thing that will be likely to happen is that, whether it's an samsung, apple, or anything else, most people will likely enthuse as to what they've got and use. I've recomended iphones, but I've got an iphone, so am undoubtedly biased to justifying my own purchase, so take my viewpoint with a pinch of salt.

Having said that, I only changed from my old iphone 3GS (3GS is the model) to a 4S due to vodafone offering me a new handset for the princely sum of £10, if I'd extend my £15 per month contract by 18 months. My old phone still works perfectly, and is sitting in its box at home, ready for use as an emergency phone if i manage to break this one.

Whatever phone you get, do make sure you get a decent carry case for it. Most smartphones are more slippery than eels, easy to end up juggling, and then dropping it.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Bromptonaut

Whatever phone you get, do make sure you get a decent carry case for it. Most smartphones are more slippery than eels, easy to end up juggling, and then dropping it.

Ahh, dropping a smartphone.....

Two guys in a pub comparing phones, one has an ancient Nokia 3210 the other latest I-phone. Nokia man bets is mate the 3210 can do something the i-phone cannot. Laughter ensues and stakes are raised to price of new i-phone. Nokia man is asked to demonstrate.

Hurls the nokia onto the floor then picks it up and makes a call............

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

Yup. Got a friend who has an old Nokia 'brick' with a rubberised protective case built in on it. Her party trick is to challenge smartphone owners like that, and she then throws her phone at a wall. She's even taken it out to the car park and got someone to drive over it before now.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

All advice received with thanks.

Although it's rare to see anyone in public places not grasping their smart phone with eyes glued to it I sometimes see blokes slide their phone into their back pocket and wonder how they don't get bent and the screen frazzled into obscurity. A case would be a must for me and a solution regarding where to carry it will have to be sought.

I've started doing a bit of homework and, thanks to your pointers, can see the significance of the distinction between iPhones the rest. The Moto G is mentioned above and I see it frequently features in reviews and comparisons (in both 2013 and 2014 versions)....along with the Nexus. I might not stretch to an Apple phone unless someone tells me it would be substantially easier than an Android phone to master from scratch.

I might favour the idea of buying a device outright and looking at the Virgin offers, as noted above, or GiffGaff, also noted above.

Thanks agin.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - SteVee

I'm in a similar position.

about a year ago I bought a Samsung Galaxy Ace - and moved my old O2 PAYG SIM onto it. It was a revelation - especially on texts. The camera has also been useful

I hardly ever use data via the phone service - just get data via hotspots. On the rare occasions then the £1/day maximum that O2 charge serves me well.

The free satnav app is useful.The camera has also been useful.

I will probably upgrade to another Samsung soon as the Ace is very limited on memory (not many things can be moved onto the memory card). This is an Android phone - there are many such phones as well as tablets. The Android phones are just as easy to use as iPhones.

I've also got an Apple iPod Touch - an iPhone that can't make phone calls. But apple's access to apps drives me mad - I just don't use it now.

I have no intention of getting a contract phone. Be very wary of the 'unlimited' offers.

Edited by SteVee on 25/11/2014 at 17:47

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Happy Blue!

Lots of good advice here KB. In reality you have two choices if you decide to buy a phone outright: what tariff and what phone.

You can sort out a tariff by shopping around. If you will not make any more calls or send more texts than before then it sounds like 500Mb of data a mobth will be more than enough. There are lots of options.

For the phone, iPhones come in very few varieties. Buying new now you will be looking at identical operating systems but with different bits of hardware; the 4S will do you. For Android there are many more options of make and model with huge variations in performance and kit as well grades of android. Chinese makes can be bought cheaply, but you may prefer a more well known make. Samsung are good phones but load up with various apps you don't need and can't remove. I have a Samsung Galaxy S4; its very good but I also use an iPhone overseas and like that also. I can see the benefits of both types.

Go to a good shop and have a play.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

This is all extremely helpful. I'm very grateful.

Spotted a reference to Lycamobile earlier. On the face of it it looks similar to GiffGaff. A£7.50 a month "bundle" appears to offer 150 mins and 150 texts (way more than enough) plus 500mb of internet (also more than enough I'm sure). There's also a £5 a month option but it looks as though the extra £2.50 a month might be worthwhile , even for my limited needs. Lots of local "shops"...by this I presume they mean places to top up if needed? www.lycamobile.co.uk/en/bundles

I feel fairly sure that an outright purchase of an Android device (maybe around £150...perhaps the MotoG or suchlike) plus a small monthly phone and text and internet availability would do the job. If the Apple alternative seemed worthwhile then maybe stretching further to that might be worthwhile...but I'm starting to doubt the latter.

Have started to take a peep at other people's phones, as suggested, which is adding to my understanding.

Am eminently happy to continue to read of the thoughts of anyone else but the above has helped a lot up to now....thanks.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

Android will give you more power for your money over a I phone because with apple you ate paying for the name. The only problem with a Motorola or a nexus devise is that it may be less user friendly than something like a Samsung with has touch wiz installed (Samsungs adaptation of android ). You can't always delete the bloat wear but you can hide or disable it.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

I'm narrowing it down as follows:

Feeling less inclined to get a high end phone such a the latest iPhone as I'll not use a fraction of it's potential at this stage.

I might lose or damage it.

I won't feel so bad changing it in a couple of years if it only cost £150 rather than £600

I can get a half decent phone such as the Motorola Moto G (with or without 4G...not sure if I want the 4G for future use)...and will look further at Samsung in view of Dan's advice.

Have looked at THREE's PAYG. It's 3P + 2p + 1p for calls/texts/internet...which seems the cheapest PAYG plus the coverage is apparently number two in the pecking order, after EE, which is top for coverage.....apparently. And when I called THREE they seemed to answer quickly enough and one of the two people I spoke to was in the UK (the other one wasn't but was helpful enough and spoke quite good English. And I found a geographical number to call them on - which I like. Plus there's an 0800 number for sales...but I suppose there would be, wouldn't there?

If I went for the Moto G do I really want the 4G model in view of what I've said about my requirements? Obviously I've never used 4G so have no experience. It's not available where I live but is in Exeter and, of courese, bigger towns...but I don't know what I means in practice.

I can buy a phone using my Tesco Boost (Clubcard) ponts, which is a bonus. Quite a fair choice of phones too.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

If you can live with speeds of up to 7mps then 3g will b okay but like I said speeds of up to. Where as 4G in some places I can get speeds of nearly 30 mps so it's up to you but just remember some operators charge more for a 4G plan.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

In terms of rollout of 4G, once you get out of large towns and cities, it will take a long time for them to upgrade less populated areas - I base that off the upgrading to 3G :

Chester (which is about 25 miles from me, here in rural North Wales) has had 3G on most networks for a long time. Even now, the nearest reasonably sized town to me (population about 9,000) doesn't have 3G on any networks.

So being (as I think you said you are) on Dartmoor, I'll confidently predict that 5G, and possibly even 6G, will have been introduced in big cities before people like you and me get 4G.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

It looks to me as though EE has a greater 4g coverage than Three in the South West (and probably everywhere else too?) Can I assume that the networks update their coverage independant of each other? Assuming that they do, then EE appear to cover very close my town (which is on the edge of Dartmoor - not in the remote inner part)....whereas Three is still some way off. I suspect, by looking at the coverage map, that the low lying, 'basin', geography of my small town is the reason for 4G being available right up to it but not within the low parts here. If EE do have the edge at the moment re. coverage then I suppose that might influence choice of network providers...ie EE better than Three. However if Three's 4G is in most of the larger towns then maybe it shouldn't matterr too much - especially as 3G is available in most areas and would be OK for my limited needs?

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

Agreed. 3G will do high-90-odd percent of what you need. If you wanted to watch TV programmes on your phone, or do online gaming, then yes, something like 4G would make a huge difference. But for a quick bit of internet research on occasions, then 3G should be entirely sufficient.

Another thing to bear in mind (although the retailers don't like to tell you this, you really have to ask and push for it) is to ask them precisely what their policy is if you don't get coverage at home, etc. regarding how long you've got to walk away without penalties (if contract). Also, to get a copy of that policy in writing. Sometimes, the network coverage isn't quite as good as is made out, and the online maps of coverage have lots of disclaimers on them. In cases like that, it can be more beneficial to go direct to the mobile company's own shops, rather than places like Carphone Warehouse.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

That's a point well made, Rob.

Time to ask a couple of neighbours what thy use and what they might have tried in the past. Certainly EE is fine here...the merger / sharing of Orange and the other one (whose name seemed to change over the years...is it T Mobile?) has been useful in the past here at home - I saw that it swapped over from one to another when indoors occasionally.

Have alway been OK with CPW in the past (going back quite a few years) but point taken re. coverage.

Incidentally, I saw that one of the Moto G's has dual SIM capability. Presumably I could keep my old Ikea Family Mobile SIM in there and perhaps use the new SIM that came with the new PAYG SIM Free phone. But am not at all sure if the phone rings if someone calls the old (Ikea) number, AS WELL as the new number that would be allocated to the phone. That would be handy to know.

I tried, without success, once, to use a dual SIM card adaptor in the Nokia. Didn't work for me at the time. Bit of a bodge up i guess.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

AFAIK you can only use one simple at a time so you would have to switch the sims for it work. If for say you was using your ikea sim then someone rang you on say a EE sim it would go to voice mail. Duel sim capabilitie just means you can have two aims in the phone without having to remove one each time.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

"If for say you was using your ikea sim then someone rang you on say a EE sim it would go to voice mail."

I don't understand what you mean. At present I am with Three (and therefore have a Three SIM). I receive calls from every other network without problem, as I imagine everyone else does. Are dual SIM phones different?

Edited by FP on 28/11/2014 at 12:39

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - alan1302

"If for say you was using your ikea sim then someone rang you on say a EE sim it would go to voice mail."

I don't understand what you mean. At present I am with Three (and therefore have a Three SIM). I receive calls from every other network without problem, as I imagine everyone else does. Are dual SIM phones different?

A dual SIM phone means you can say have a Three SIM and a Vodafone SIM both at the same time in your phone. That allows you to choose which SIM to use when calling, texting or using data. People often have it so they can have a different SIM on holiday or when calling international numbers.

It's not to do with what calls you can receive but if you are using one SIM in your phone and someone calls your number on the other SIM it would go to voicemail rather than ring.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

"...if you are using one SIM in your phone and someone calls your number on the other SIM it would go to voicemail rather than ring."

I thought the "other" call showed as a "call waiting". No idea how easy it is to switch in mid-call, though.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - alan1302

"...if you are using one SIM in your phone and someone calls your number on the other SIM it would go to voicemail rather than ring."

I thought the "other" call showed as a "call waiting". No idea how easy it is to switch in mid-call, though.

No, the phone can only use one SIM at a time so it would have no idea the other call is coming through.

Dual SIM is more for outgoing that incoming calls.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Palcouk

I dont believe any responders have mentioned battery life.

I have to charge my phone daily, and that is used it rarely.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Interesting points re Dual Sim. I can see the two Sims would give me a choice of which one to use for outgoing....but still not sure what would happen to incoming calls. As mentioned, does it route the (not in use) one to voicemail...or notify you and give the chance to answer it? I'm sure we'll find an answer to that one. (Fairly academic anyway as no beggar calls me anyway).

Re. battery. I've gathered that you have to charge the thing every night if you've had it switched on during the day. Don't know how long it goes if it's switched off all day.

Haven't yet worked out the relationship between my home email and the email on the phone. I'm just now looking at the confusing Live Mail, Windows Mail, Outlook, etc along with how they relate to webmail and trying to see how I would manage incoming emails between my Windows PC and a smartphone. Currently use Outlook Express on the (XP) PC in conjunction with my ISP's email. I suspect I'll have to upgrade soon.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

I use a somewhat outdated Samsung with Android. Like the OP I was a smartphone virgin until my other half got a free upgrade phone and passed the old phone to me. Shortly after that, I realised that its wi-fi capability is invaluable. Frequently I'm a couple of hours' travel from home and need to check if meetings have been re-cheduled etc. for where I'm travelling; a lot of my communication is via e-mail.

Although I used to abandon e-mail while on holiday in this country and abroad, it has proved unwise to do so recently, and the phone has been useful in this situation too.

However, it does need reasonably frequent charging - in my case every couple of days with not very intensive use.

Edited by FP on 28/11/2014 at 14:37

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Bromptonaut

Battery life is the Achilles' heel of smartphones. My Sony K800i will run a week between charges. Family members' smartphones seem to be back to days of Motorola MR20; dead in short order without access to the charging teat. Turning off 3G, WiFi and GPS when not in use help but return to call times in hours/standby in days are a long way from being acheived.

You should be able to set your Android device to recive POP3 email using the same configuration for maillboxas in OE. If, on the phone, you set it to leave a copy of message on server it will still be downloaded to your PC when you next log on. My ISP, Demon, is a bit hit and miss for sending when not on the 'home' connection so I also have an MS Live account which is web based.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Stop Press!

(a) A neighbout has generously given me a boxed, virtually unused, Samsung Galaxy S3 to play with. It's locked to Vodaphone. Haven't asked him if it could be unlocked and don't know what basis he aquired it...ie upgrade or bought outright. Will do so though. Also don't know if he might want to sell it....I'll play with it first before doing anything. He's really very good with IT and techy things but said he simply couldn't get on with it and found it much more tricky to live with compared to the iPhone. He has an iPhone 5c on a monthly contract with Vodaphone and loves it. Says it's a lot more intuitive. I'll get a £10 Sim card for it from local Vodaphone shop.

(b) A friend dropped me a line saying he had a Samsung S4 and hated it for the same reasons as noted above. He now has an iPhone 5 and loves everything about it (except it's a bit dearer than the Samsung).

(c) Another neighbour has a Samsung S5. Says he's always had Samsung on O2...loves it...wouldn't get anything else. Doesn't think it's difficult to use.

(d) Another friend has a Samsung S3 and is very happy with it...doesn't find it difficult to use but says he would happily try an iPhone and is being coerced by his son who has an iPhone and loves it.

If there is a definitive lesson to be learned here....I can't decipher it. Clearly it's horses for courses. Clearly some are OK with O2 and others Vodaphone. I've only spoken to one Three user - and he loves it.

Not yet at all sure how I'll sort this out, but it'll keep me occupied and off the streets for a while.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

The battery on the s3 is poor the s4 isn't much better but the s5 is good it will last all day with heavy use or can last up to 12 days in ultra low power moad. I know because I've had all three. Android is open source witch will alow more user freedom over a iPhone.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - alan1302

The battery on the s3 is poor the s4 isn't much better but the s5 is good it will last all day with heavy use or can last up to 12 days in ultra low power moad. I know because I've had all three. Android is open source witch will alow more user freedom over a iPhone.

You can see how battery levels can be different from person to person as when I had an S3 I didn't have any problems with battery life on it and found it pretty good.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

The s3 battery would last all day but I would have to charge it on the way home the s4 could wait until I got home the s5 will last from 7am until 10pm and still have 30% battery life with heavy usage. But that is from my experience of the phones.

Another thing to add is the version of the operating system. If you do go for a android phone then you want one that is running at least jelly bean but better still the latest software witch is kit kat. The reason for this is some apps won't work on the older software. A s3 would of came loded originally with gingerbread then upgraded to ice cream sandwich but only upgradeable to jelly bean where as the s4 is upgradable to kit kat same with the s5.

its the same with the iPhone if it's a older model it won't be able to upgrade to the latest o's.

What about the Nokia Lumia phones my dad isn't great with tech but he's got one not sure witch one but he gets on with it okay. Being windows phone the op might find it easier to use.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - alan1302

Another thing to add is the version of the operating system. If you do go for a android phone then you want one that is running at least jelly bean but better still the latest software witch is kit kat.

Lollipop is the latest version of Android.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Happy Blue!

As you can see it is a minefield. Personally, my Samsung Galaxy S4 has a decent battery life (measured in hours) but nowhere near as good as the amazing Nokia 6310i which would go for weeks.

Smartphones are constantly 'online' unless you turn off mobile data, wifi, bluetooth, location services etc, but then there is no point in having a smartphone. The pain of sharging up each night is the pleasure of being 'in contact' on the move.

Sampling the varius phones you have been offerd is a great way to choose. You will be able to unlock them all. It depends how long they have been in contract - the longer the period, the more likely you will be able to get the network to unlock the phone for a nominal (£20) charge. There are unauthorised unlock companies online and I have used them as well.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

OK, making progress. Thanks for all the replies which have helped a lot.

I've bought the Galaxy S3 for £50 and two bottles of wine. It's 'as new' and UNLOCKED! (I thought it was locked to VF but was wrong) I have tried an EE Sim and a Three Sim, both OK.

Have been in to a couple of phone shops - Vodafone, EE and Carphone Warehouse - all were exceedingly helpful and not remotely pushy. Having listened to the contributors here, staff in the shops, a few friends, and a couple of knowledgable neighbours I gained the overall feeling that for my simple and low demand purposes it wouldn't make a huge difference whether I went iPhone or Android once I get the hang of the device. I can charge it nightly or in the car so hopefully battery life won't be a problem given my low use.

I'm currently looking at the PAYG plans/prices on offer. Vodafone, Three, EE and O2 all have resonable signals at home and in nearby towns BUT the fact that I have a reasonable THREE signal locally and their PAYG is 3p calls 2p texts & 1p per mb...the cheapest of the lot. seems to favour them. The fact that the THREE shop is a bit further to travel toand is the less well known and maybe the less well covered provider might be an issue but I wouldn't know until I've had it for a while how successful it would be. At 1p per mb am I right in thinking one GB would cost a tenner? If so that's no worse than a lot of contracts or bundles which cost a tenner or more....so presumably would be cheaper for the majority of months when I don't use that many megabytes.

Just remains to get a decent case for it (something like an OTTERBOX?). .... and spend countless hours getting used to the phone and it's myriad features.

Thanks again for assistance.

EDIT. Is has Jellybean. 4.1

PS. Is it likely that I might actually use quite a lot of mb's just by virtue of having it switched on??? Even if I only actually used it a couple of times a week would it still mount up to something like 500mb? I have no idea what to expect. Obviously an unlimited allowance of MB's would be ideal....but at what price???

I would use WiFi at home so it's only when I'm away from home that I'd use the paid for mb's.

Do I have to switch over to and from home WiFi manually or is it automatic?? If it's automatic i wouldn't keep forgetting to do it.


Edited by KB. on 30/11/2014 at 22:32

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

"Is it likely that I might actually use quite a lot of mb's just by virtue of having it switched on???"

Not unless you have data transfer activated. With this off, it's just a normal (unsmart) mobile phone. Wi-fi is something else you switch on and off. GPS also.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Just to clarify then: I would need to manually turn on and turn off the (non home WiFi) internet facility on the phone every time? And ,ditto, turn the home WiFi facility on the phone on and off every time? If so, if I forgot to turn the (non home WiFi) access off would it keep using up my megabytes all night and all the following day until such time as I DID turn it off?

This must sound ridiculous to all of you who are familiar with it. But in time I'll get the hang of it and look back thinking I was a right and proper Charlie in 2014

:-)

Edited by KB. on 30/11/2014 at 22:53

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

Don't apologise - it's OK!

If you leave the wi-fi on, the phone won't be able to connect to a particular wi-fi hotspot unless you log on to it. In any case, wi-fi data does not count towards your phone's running costs.

If data transfer (i.e. mobile network data) is on, again you would need to open a web page or app before any significant amount of data was actually transferred. If you leave data switched on and you're still accessing the internet then obviously some data is being transferred, but not much of it, unless you're downloading something significant.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

That's pretty clear, ta for that. Furthermore you've clarified the correct terminology in referring to data transfer/mobile network data which will help a lot.

It rather sounds as though the Three PAYG as described above would be OK provided the coverage proved OK. I'll go to a 'Three' shop (Torquay or Exeter) and get a SIM and some airtime.

Considerable advances made today then.

With our current old (but useful and reliable) Nokias, (1100.s and 3110's etc) I bought leather cases which kept them clean and damage free. You'll remember you used to be able to buy the cases on market stalls or Ebay for a couple of quid...they had a belt clip, a little metal hanging loop and a clear plastic sheet across the front, through which you operated the keys. They're now all but extinct of course.

My neighbour has a stonking 'LUVVITT ARMOUR' case for his iPhone but they're not available for the Galaxy S3. Shame. I'll probably go for something like the 'Otterbox Commuter' unless anyone tells me different.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - FP

Case: this is what I got; it's cheap enough and it seems OK - tinyurl.com/pk7ubqf

Network: I'm on Three PAYG; entirely satisfied.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - RobJP

Just to say that I'm very pleased we've all been able to help out with this lot.

Enjoy your new phone !

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - dan86

1 Gig of data will be more than enough unless u plan on using it to play online games all day long. I've got 4 gig and some months I don't use half of that.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

What a thoroughly and agreeably informative discourse this has been. Thank you all.

I've been pointed in the right direction and will master the thing and find it very useful I'm very sure. Quite happy that the S3 will do the job for the foreseeable and will resist any urge to upgrade to the latest version but may, at some point, look to see if an iPhone is worth investigating but won't hanker after one thanks to the majority of advice received.

Will still be pleased to read what anyone might feel like commenting on but won't keep on boring people with loads of questions having had such useful stuff directed my way.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Briefly.....under the guidance of a friend, have connected up to my home WiFi and updated the Jelly Bean from 4.1.2 to 4.3 and am making good progress understanding and tweaking some of the the functions of the phone (and some of the apps. Have found out how to turn Network data and WiFi on and off. Have arranged to port a memorable phone number to Three and will use their PAYG at 3p, 2p and 1p. The Three shops didn't deal with PAYG at all (Contract only and no PAYG Sims available in store) but the Three Customer Service was fine on the phone. The Torquay shop said on the rare occasions they do get some PAYG Sims in stock they get mobbed by youngsters and sell out straight away. Ditto the Exeter store where students buy them up as soon as they get them.

Quite enjoying learning lessons and it's not quite the nightmare I was expecting it to be, but remain utterly amazed at what it's capable of.

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - Mike H

Currently use Outlook Express on the (XP) PC in conjunction with my ISP's email. I suspect I'll have to upgrade soon.

You should upgrade your PC asap. Microsoft have stopped supporting Windows XP, and there is a real danger of your machine becoming infected with viruses and other nasties. It's not recommended to connect XP machines to the internet any more.

I don't have a smartphone either, but have been thinking about it, so this has ben a useful thread for me! Battery life and phone size are the killers for me, and I'm still pondering whether I can live with the frequent charging needed (my current Samsung only needs charging once a week), and having half a house brick in my pocket.

Edited by Mike H on 05/12/2014 at 17:24

I don't own a "smartphone". Am I completely mad? - KB.

Point taken re. XP, Mike. TBH I'm very conscious of it being out of date. I suppose I must admit to awareness of the increased susceptibilty to unpleasantness creeping in the back passage but guess I rely on AVG and Malwarebytes to keep them at bay and try not to open unwise attachments etc. It has to be said that Firefox slowed down and down over time and accrued glitches to the point where it was a PITA to use - so started using Chrome which (for me) is hugely quicker and glitch free. Internet Explorer wasn't an option as it won't run it's latest version on XP, whereas Chrome seems to.

In reality I'm just waiting/hoping for the PC to develop a fault which would write it off and then I could have a new machine with the latest Windows. Although maybe I'm hoping it'll last until the new Windows is issued?? I gather this might be 8.2 (Ithink) or maybe it'll be 9? I'm no expert (as you well know).

But I do occasionally meet people who still use XP and seem to be hanging on OK with it. Probably unwisely so, you would say.

The S3 continues to please. Surprised myself by getting to grips with the basics...... switching between WiFi and mobile data, getting online, seting up email, even dictating stuff. Have ordered a CaseMate Tough case and some stylus pens to keep round the house and car and a car charger and a better mains charger.

Have been really impressed with "THREE" customer service and their promises to send the SIM etc and to help get my details registered for top ups etc. Sim card received quickly by post plus a nice memorable number from a recently purchased £1 EE Sim card was ported over to them quickly and efficiently in no time at all. The two advisors I spoke to were eminently helpful and there was virtually no difficulty in conversing despite being in another continent (or at least I assume they weren't UK based). THREE coverage is as good as EE locally and it remains to be seen what it's like elsewhere but I gather it's generally OK.

I would like tu use an iPhone just to compare but the S£ seems to be well regarded albeit two years out of date...at least I was able to update it to Jellybean 4.3. It is obvious it's old though as some accessories are no longer listed online. The iPhone seems extremely popular and there are millions of bits and pieces for it sold everywhere.

Will continue to learn though.