The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - leaseman

In this thread you may:

Ask any question for EVs which you need help, advice, suggestions or whatever

Discuss articles that have been hosted elsewhere (this may be reviewed after a while to see how it's working)

NB Some EV subjects may be more appropriate to continue in a separate thread. An example might be if someone is looking to buy a new car and giving an account of test-driving several ICE and EV vehicles. Another example might be if someone is giving an update on the EV they have bought and wants to feedback their experiences to others. Moderators will use their discretion in situations like these.

Rules:
No or minimal politics
No arguments or slanging matches
Nothing which we think is not following the spirit of the thread
Nothing that risks the future of this site (please see forum terms and conditions)

Any of the above are likely to be deleted. If the thread becomes difficult to maintain it will be removed.

When a thread gets to a certain size it will be made read-only and a new Volume created.

This is Volume 14. Previous Volumes will not be deleted but will get locked.

A list of previous Volumes can be found HERE



PLEASE NOTE:

When posting a NEW issue for discussion, please "Reply to" the first message in this thread, i.e. this one. This keeps each question in its own separate segment and stops each new question from getting mixed up in amongst existing questions. Also please remember to change the subject header.

Edited by leaseman on 03/03/2025 at 12:49

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
Currently in Frankfurt doing some work with Suzuki and their new e Vitara.

I can’t pass on any detail apart from what’s already in the public domain, but it does look good in the metal and I’m looking forward to spending more time in the car when it arrives.

No pricing announced yet, more info to follow as it’s made public.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - movilogo

EVs could be charged as fast as filling a petrol car after breakthrough

Chinese manufacturer BYD develops system that cuts wait time to five minutes

www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/03/18/evs-charge.../

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
Behind a paywall, unfortunately.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - movilogo

It works if you disable JavaScript in browser.

Also, the news in other places too - just search for BYD fast charge.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

To charge this quickly requires a power supply of 1000kw = 1 megawatt.

One MW will typically power 500-750 homes simultaneously noting that some homes will be drawing more, and some less, than their maximum demand.

Great that an EV could be fully recharged in under 5 minutes, but somewhat pointless without major upgrades to the power distribution network. Fred at No 63 plugs in his BYD and the whole estate suffers a power cut.

A koenigsegg can do over 500kmh. Fantastic technology but equally pointless without dead straight roads, no pedestrians, no HGVs, no traffic lights, no traffic jams, drivers with razor sharp reactions (or very very wide lanes) etc etc

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - movilogo

This level of technology will be useful in other domains - aircraft for example.

Electric Aircraft with long range (enough for regional flights) are being developed and the running cost will be lot less than traditional jets. It will also reduce cost of training pilots.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

Has the idea of a range extender as in the BMW i3 and i8 been discontinued ? Seemed a good idea and combining the power outputs gave the i8 amazing performance

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - misar

Has the idea of a range extender as in the BMW i3 and i8 been discontinued ? Seemed a good idea and combining the power outputs gave the i8 amazing performance

The i3 has a range extender whereas the i8 can combine power outputs because it is simply a hybrid with a bit of electric range.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

The Mazda MX-30 is available with a (rotary) range extender. I suppose you could argue that pretty much all PHEVs are range extenders in a way. Certainly, most combine the power of the two motors if you want them to.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

I have always thought of an EV with range extender as one where the motor acts only as a generator and does not drive the wheels. In the MX30 the range extender motor generates just 75bhp. i3 range extender has 34 bhp.

A hybrid may have the capacity for the ICE to power the car independently of batteries and electric motor.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
Nissan Qashqai works this way.
Drive is always electric, with the noisy bits just charging the hybrid battery. As a consequence, it drives like an EV but with an ICE soundtrack.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy
Nissan Qashqai works this way. Drive is always electric, with the noisy bits just charging the hybrid battery. As a consequence, it drives like an EV but with an ICE soundtrack.

Isn't the main - and very significant - difference that the QQ e-Power system cannot have it's electrical supply topped up via a cable like a range extender EV, and gets all its electrical power from petrol. Essentially it works like a permanent generator, whereas the range extenders provide a backup only.

It would be interesting to know which of the two systems produce less 'carbon' emissions, though it will obviously depend upon the local mix that a person's electricity provider uses, which varies a lot by country.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
‘ Isn't the main - and very significant - difference that the QQ e-Power system cannot have it's electrical supply topped up via a cable like a range extender EV, and gets all its electrical power from petrol. Essentially it works like a permanent generator, whereas the range extenders provide a backup only.

It would be interesting to know which of the two systems produce less 'carbon' emissions, though it will obviously depend upon the local mix that a person's electricity provider uses, which varies a lot by country.’

Combined CO2 emissions from an i3 REX are officially 13g/kM, whilst the Nissan is officially c117g/kM.
Electricity can be 100% from renewables, unleaded is considerably less so.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy
‘ Isn't the main - and very significant - difference that the QQ e-Power system cannot have it's electrical supply topped up via a cable like a range extender EV, and gets all its electrical power from petrol. Essentially it works like a permanent generator, whereas the range extenders provide a backup only. It would be interesting to know which of the two systems produce less 'carbon' emissions, though it will obviously depend upon the local mix that a person's electricity provider uses, which varies a lot by country.’ Combined CO2 emissions from an i3 REX are officially 13g/kM, whilst the Nissan is officially c117g/kM. Electricity can be 100% from renewables, unleaded is considerably less so.

The imperative word is can be. And even if the electricity is generated using 100% 'renewables', most of them are built in China where most electricity for production is coal-based, plus all the mining CO2 for all the components of the EV and for the 'renewables' equipment, quite a lot of which have a far short lifespan than traditional fossil-fuelled power plants.

That Nissan figure is not really any better than most non hybrid ICE petrol vehicles of the same size from the last decade, and more than many that are MHEVs or HEVs.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Andrew-T

To charge this quickly requires a power supply of 1000kw = 1 megawatt.

(haven't read the article) - is the energy transferred by superconducting cable, or some other method ?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

To charge this quickly requires a power supply of 1000kw = 1 megawatt.

(haven't read the article) - is the energy transferred by superconducting cable, or some other method ?

A 1 megawatt supply is not massive in terms of electrical supply, but massive in the context of domestic requirements.

The main transmission network (analogous to motorways) operates at 400,000 volts. This is stepped down at a local level to transformers which (I understand) operate at 11,000 volts and reduce it to 230 volts for domestic use.

Very high voltage wires are either aluminium (light weight) or copper (higher conductivity). As the power (watts) that can be carried is related to voltage, in very simple terms an 11,000 volt supply needs a cable with a cross section equal to 2% of one at 230 volts.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Andrew-T

<< A 1 megawatt supply is not massive in terms of electrical supply, but massive in the context of domestic requirements. >>

I was thinking about the connection to the vehicle, Terry. How the power reaches the charging station is a different matter.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

<< A 1 megawatt supply is not massive in terms of electrical supply, but massive in the context of domestic requirements. >>

I was thinking about the connection to the vehicle, Terry. How the power reaches the charging station is a different matter.

Not sure - TESLA superchargers have to compromise between short heavy cables to minimise the resistance and heat generated, or thinner lighter supercooled cables.

BYD which may take more power will, I assume, have to look towards supercooled cables.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - umani

>>It works if you disable JavaScript in browser.

Proper job!

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Marlin1

Car Tax (or whatever it's called nowadays).

£0 for electric vehicles until the end of March 25. Even if your tax has not expired, re-new it now for another year for £0.

Sorry if this has been posted before.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - catsdad

This does indeed work.

My friend’s EV tax renewal was due in September so he went online last weekend and renewed at £0 for another year. Of course he only saves the cost of half a year as his was £0 up to September anyway but still worth doing. Especially if your existing renewal date, with the new rate, is early in the new tax year.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - RT

It works, to a much lesser extent, for some IC cars - my VED expires 31st March so it's cheaper to renew it in March before it expires rather than on 1st April as the rate invariably goes up then.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - SLO76
mcb100, is there a two way wall charger available in the UK today that would allow me to use a Nissan Leaf (which can flow both ways) as a home battery system?

Was chatting with a colleague earlier who recently bought a 13.8kwh home battery pack which cost the best part of £8,000! This seems mad to me when an old Leaf 24kwh can be had for circa £2,500, and it doubles up as a backup car!
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Brit_in_Germany

How about the Wallbox Quasar 2?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - SLO76

How about the Wallbox Quasar 2?

Unavailable in the UK, and cost rules it out as being economically unviable. In Europe it costs the equivalent of £6,000!
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
Never looked, to be honest.
Just had a quick Google and Indra seem to do one, Wallbox another.

Renault 5 was initially talked about as being V2H compatible, but at launch is V2L only.

It’ll come, but I’d imagine progress will accelerate once V2G becomes viable - the ability to sell your cheaply bought electrons back to the energy providers.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
‘ Not sure - TESLA superchargers have to compromise between short heavy cables to minimise the resistance and heat generated, or thinner lighter supercooled cables.’

Plus, they were only ever intended to work with Tesla cars. All of whom have their charge ports on the near side rear corner.
Their latest V4 chargers, now more are accessible to the rest of us, have much longer cables.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W
‘ Not sure - TESLA superchargers have to compromise between short heavy cables to minimise the resistance and heat generated, or thinner lighter supercooled cables.’ Plus, they were only ever intended to work with Tesla cars. All of whom have their charge ports on the near side rear corner. Their latest V4 chargers, now more are accessible to the rest of us, have much longer cables.

TESLA, despite the understandable antipathy towards Mr Musk, apparently cool the V4 cables, and are increasingly embracing 800 volt batteries - the benefit of which is to reduce cable size necessary for high current charging.

I am guessing that even if a charging station is capable of delivering 500kw+, it is limited by the capacity constraints of the EV attached so can charge anything.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
800v is probably the future - it’s only really been used on high end stuff, but KIA and Hyundai have now adopted it. The use the windings in the motor to raise voltage/lower amperage between a typical 400v DC charger and an 800v vehicle architecture.

Tesla are not alone with the liquid cooled cabled, I believe IONITY and InstaVolt also use them -probably others. It does make for a very heavy cable to wrangle into position, I always keep pressure on the plug until I hear it lock into place - the cable weight has been known to pull the plug slightly out of alignment, thus preventing it locking and initiating charge.

You’re correct - charging speed is limited by whichever is slowest - car or charger. If there’s a 350kW charger next to a 50kW one, there’d be no advantage in plugging a car that will charge at only 50kW into the 350. It’ll only pull 50kW maximum. And even then not for long.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
‘ The imperative word is can be. And even if the electricity is generated using 100% 'renewables', most of them are built in China where most electricity for production is coal-based, plus all the mining CO2 for all the components of the EV and for the 'renewables' equipment, quite a lot of which have a far short lifespan than traditional fossil-fuelled power plants.’

Covered it a few times previously, so a quick recap.

China’s total CO2 emissions are levelling off and projected to start dropping by, at the latest, 2030. Their implementation of solar, wind and hydro has been monumental in scale.

Even with a less than optimal fossil fuelled car industry, a Chinese-built EV exported to Europe will have a lower, nett, whole life carbon intensity than an equivalent fossil fuelled car.

And the situation is improving year on year with China’s CO2 emissions peaking and soon falling and the use of renewables increasing globally.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

There was a report in the Telegraph that Motabilty who are responsible for one in five new car registration are struggling to get their customers to take EVs as part of the companies commitment and are even asking to return them even though the company are offering free charge points !

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

If the government want to increase EV registrations they should simply change the rules to mandate that all Motability sales must be EV.

Manufacturers would be happy as they would easily hit the targets mandated for the next few years - 28% required in 2025, 33% in 2026.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - badbusdriver

If the government want to increase EV registrations they should simply change the rules to mandate that all Motability sales must be EV.

How, and by what authority could this simple mandate be implemented?

Manufacturers would be happy as they would easily hit the targets mandated for the next few years - 28% required in 2025, 33% in 2026.

So as long as the manufacturers (and the government) are happy it doesn't matter about the Motability users who's circumstances mean an EV wouldn't work?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - pd

If the government want to increase EV registrations they should simply change the rules to mandate that all Motability sales must be EV.

How, and by what authority could this simple mandate be implemented?

Manufacturers would be happy as they would easily hit the targets mandated for the next few years - 28% required in 2025, 33% in 2026.

So as long as the manufacturers (and the government) are happy it doesn't matter about the Motability users who's circumstances mean an EV wouldn't work?

Actually pretty easy for the government to mandate it. Mobility payments are paid directly by the government from disability benefits so they could, if they wanted, put criteria on the cars supplied.

Although mobility isn't subsidised the payments are effectively guaranteed by the government as deducted "at source".

As for circumstances there are very few circumstances where an EV won't work at all, just varying degrees of convenience.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

Notwithstanding the somewhat bizarre idea of deciding all Motability customers should drive EVs but nobody else has to, Motability is a charity, not a Government scheme. If customer choice was reduced, people may well choose somewhere else to spend their allowance.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

The resistance from Motability ciustomers appears to be from the fact that many live in flats which do not have access to home charging forcing them to use costly public charging points .Maybe the delays in waiting for a charge to complete at a public charging point could also impact on them ?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Xileno

The problem could partly be alleviated almost immediately by removing the VAT difference between public chargers (20%) and domestic (5%)

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Ethan Edwards

Shoosh...our Dimwit Chancellor is more likely to level up by sticking 20% VAT on home energy. That also ties in with her mission to kill off all the wrinklies.

Still haven't found Geronticide in their Manifesto. Must keep looking at it..

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

Shoosh...our Dimwit Chancellor is more likely to level up by sticking 20% VAT on home energy. That also ties in with her mission to kill off all the wrinklies.

Still haven't found Geronticide in their Manifesto. Must keep looking at it..

No need - already in place and wanted to go 'further and faster' during the 'events' of the last 5 years. Quite effective at bumping off the boomer+ generation. This would just be the icing on the cake.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - alan1302

The resistance from Motability ciustomers appears to be from the fact that many live in flats which do not have access to home charging forcing them to use costly public charging points .Maybe the delays in waiting for a charge to complete at a public charging point could also impact on them ?

There is also the issue of access to chargers away from home - the spaces that EVs are allocated are not always big enough to get a wheelchair round and the process of charging with the weight of cables causes issues for some people as well.

And when looking at the larger WAV (wheelchair accessible vehicles) the range on some of them can be quite low which makes longer trips potentially more awkward.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy
‘ The imperative word is can be. And even if the electricity is generated using 100% 'renewables', most of them are built in China where most electricity for production is coal-based, plus all the mining CO2 for all the components of the EV and for the 'renewables' equipment, quite a lot of which have a far short lifespan than traditional fossil-fuelled power plants.’ Covered it a few times previously, so a quick recap. China’s total CO2 emissions are levelling off and projected to start dropping by, at the latest, 2030. Their implementation of solar, wind and hydro has been monumental in scale. Even with a less than optimal fossil fuelled car industry, a Chinese-built EV exported to Europe will have a lower, nett, whole life carbon intensity than an equivalent fossil fuelled car. And the situation is improving year on year with China’s CO2 emissions peaking and soon falling and the use of renewables increasing globally.

Using the figures are actually true, given that nation are hardly renowned for truth-telling or letting outsiders get to the truth via full access looking around for themselves.

Bear in mind they still open a coal fired power station on a VERY frequent basis and their population has already more than levelled off, with little to no migrant replacement to keep the figure up.

Even if we completely stopped producing pollution, it would be a drop in the bucket compared to what China, India etc are increasing their output in that regard. And we're importing their stuff to do so, much of which is produced via VERY unethical and dirty means and enriches and props up one of THE worst regimes in the history of the planet, all whilst taking jobs from us.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - davecooper

While I would agree that there are issues with China, they can't be taking too many of our jobs as there are currently over 800,000 vacancies in the UK. The bigger problem is people not wanting to work. BYD sc***ped plans for a UK plant in 2023 citing brexit as one factor. I wonder whether holding on to a stable workforce was another.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
New experience for me over the weekend in that I’ve just done a couple of longish drives in a Ford E-Transit Custom.
It has all the usual Transit attributes of a comfortable driving position and seat, but also the quiet and refinement of an EV.
I’ve only done motorway runs in it, and a steady 65-70mph produced c2.4 miles per kW/h. Which meant 150 miles range.
Using Ford’s online range calculator (accurate for my drives) you’d be looking at up to 250 miles in an urban environment, lightly laden.
I did see it charging at 125kW, but with the charge port on the front offside corner there was occasionally a bit of shuffling required to get it in a bay.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - daveyjp

I attended a funeral this afternoon of an ex colleague and I was surprised to see the funeral directors family limo was an EV - a heavily modifed and extended Mustang Mach e.

https://coleman-milne.co.uk/range/the-etive-collection/

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - RT

Funeral cars are an obvious market for EVs, the weight isn't an issue and neither is range. They'll probably be the first EV I travel in!

Edited by RT on 01/04/2025 at 18:38

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

Funeral cars are an obvious market for EVs, the weight isn't an issue and neither is range. They'll probably be the first EV I travel in!

Imagine the shock at passers by when the driver reapplies the accelerator peddle after the 'walk' section of the cortege ends and the car vanishes into the distance in short order, assuming they don't have an accident!

Another good use - the 'time' car for the marathon! Not so good for cycle races (spare bike carrier / doctor) though - it may run out of juice before the end of the race on longer, hillier stages.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - SLO76
We trialled an E-Transit Minibus last year. It was pretty pleasant to drive, as Transits normally are. But we found the range was insufficient in the real world with a load on. Best we were getting in the winter was a load of kids and a fat bus driver was 110/120 miles, some drivers were closer to 90 miles. It was really poor

We stuck with diesel for the minibuses.


Though our new ADL E100 EV bus is working out well for us, barring a few tech glitches. We’re getting around 250 miles out of it in service on a busy rural route and it’s returning with 5-10% left.

I’m using our Altas Merc Cityline on a dial a bus service tomorrow which should really challenge it. Best I’ve managed is 160 miles with about 15% left.

Edited by SLO76 on 02/04/2025 at 00:28

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - badbusdriver

watch

I'm no fan of (so called) executive brands and am indifferent in general to JayEmm on cars (YouTube channel), but I watched with some amusement this damming review of the Audi Q4 E-Tron!

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - madf

watch

I'm no fan of (so called) executive brands and am indifferent in general to JayEmm on cars (YouTube channel), but I watched with some amusement this damming review of the Audi Q4 E-Tron!

Does not hold back,,,fascinating.. Thanks

Looks a POC

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Brit_in_Germany

It truly doesn't appear to be worth the extra over the sister version, the Skoda Elroq. The rear drum brakes are a good engineering choice, even if a poor marketing one.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Chips with everything

Interesting and valued review. I won't be buying one. Disc brakes anywhere on that :O

The reviewer, I like him. Bit like like Dom Joly meets Clarkson in a circus tent though. :)

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - John F

Interesting and valued review. I won't be buying one. Disc brakes anywhere on that :O

Drums and shoes probably make sense from an engineering point of view. With regen braking they will probably last the life of the car without attention. Even our old Focus only needed new shoes at around 140,000 miles. And barely used discs can easily get rusty and u/s after three or four salty winters - regular pad and disc replacement is a useful source of income for garages. Drums usually last the life of even high mileage cars.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Andrew-T

<< Drums usually last the life of even high mileage cars.>>

The drums and shoes on my 207SW are original after 16 years and 93K. I have had them serviced once (can't remember when ...).

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - barney100

Surely the point of a van is to laden it?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
Rear drums are commonplace across VAG EV’s.
As above, they do so little work it doesn’t warrant the fitting of discs, and, apparently, drums are lower rolling resistance than discs & calipers. Correctly adjusted, obviously.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Gibbo_Wirral

Big rise in electric vehicle charging cable thefts

InstaVolt, which owns EV charging points in the region, said that 13 of its sites had been targeted 33 times.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5zp064948o

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Ethan Edwards

Let's hope the owners are careful to ensure that the cables aren't live when they're being stolen. Otherwise the thieves might get seriously injured or killed.

I'm sure none of us want that to happen.

On a recent long trip I used eight public chargers. No queuing, no broken chargers. Perfect. Not saying it's like this all the time/ everywhere but (using ZapMap) I was careful to only select locations with multiple chargers, higher powered and not too far off my intended route. Planning.

Edited by Ethan Edwards on 07/04/2025 at 14:17

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

Big rise in electric vehicle charging cable thefts

InstaVolt, which owns EV charging points in the region, said that 13 of its sites had been targeted 33 times.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq5zp064948o

Imagine my shock (pun intended). I bet the same 'criminal gangs' behind this are just diversifying from nicking BT and railway cables, and copper pipes off building sites (probably one of the reasons why my old industry moved in a big way to plastic piping), given how many EV charging stations are unmanned and rarely monitored in the wee hours.

Copper and many of the rare Earth or precious metal used in electronics and power generation / transmission are very lucrative targets for theft, as are copper pipes.

This sort of thing is only going to get worse with forced move to EVs, especially with them being pushed for urban dwellers who may resort to less secure sites, on-road charging away from the home and in areas that are far more crime-ridden and where Plod is far more likely to go after mean tweets / complaints from locals than (say) other who often commit actual crimes like this but are left to their own devices out of fear, political correctness or lack of manpower / ability of their staff.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Andrew-T

I see that one response to Trump's recent promises has been an offer of govt help to save the threatened car industry. Rather unsurprisingly, [a] money takes priority over long-term green considerations, and [b] the car industry exists to employ people rather than make cars ... :-)

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - davecooper

As has been said a few times recently, the US car industry's biggest problem will be meeting greater demand on US built cars due to the tariffs on imported cars. A 3 to 4 year lead time has been touted for a new factory so what are they going to do in the meantime?

Also looks like Teslas woes continue:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14568115/prestige...l

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

I see that one response to Trump's recent promises has been an offer of govt help to save the threatened car industry. Rather unsurprisingly, [a] money takes priority over long-term green considerations, and [b] the car industry exists to employ people rather than make cars ... :-)

His plan is to bring back (or in) as much car-making to the US where those makes sell cars there, as he did in his first term with Ford coming back from Mexico to some degree. His argument is that if you want to sell lots of cars to our people, it would be financially advantageous (or at least detrimental if you didn't) if you made them in our country as well.

The problem US home-grown car 'manufacturers' have is that for the most part, their cars are not well-regarded outside of North America for both design/build quality, fuel efficiency and the driving experience, never mind the styling.

Unless and until that improves significantly, exports of US cars will likely stay very low compared to the likes of the Germans, Koreans, Japanese and now the Chinese.

The US would earn far more money if their own firms built better cars the rest of the world wants, and then such measures Trump advocates would like be not necessary / proposed.

Even taking out cars from the equation (a bit off topic I know), what these days IS actually made in the US that gets exported? Some foods, drinks (not many foods, but loads of drinks, given they like putting God-knows-what into them [hopefully something Sec Kennedy will reverse]), agricultural machinery, some clothing, and, of course aircraft, oil and LPG.

I suspect the Trump administration knows this and is now going full steam ahead to re-industrialise and pare-back / stop the net zero stuff because it is (or at least the rate of change was) impoverishing The West generally, leading to the balance of power moving towards China, some oil-rich Middle Eastern nations and others.

The rapid move to EVs has been nothing but trouble, as has the general 'green movement', significantly exacerbating many other societal problems faced in the West.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - davecooper

Yes, apparently US agricultural machinery manufacturers are desperate to get into the Chinese market. Not sure that the current US China situation is going to do much to help them achieve that in a hurry.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Ethan Edwards

Just browsing LeaseLoco. You'd be surprised what EV is coming up as the best value. The Ford Capri. I have no interest in one of these but is that desperation by Ford to get these shifted? I think third cheapest was the Ford Explorer....tbh there doesn't look to be that much difference between them. Both reworked from the same VW underpinning.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - pd

I

The rapid move to EVs has been nothing but trouble, as has the general 'green movement', significantly exacerbating many other societal problems faced in the West.

Although it has to be noted the one car design the USA has successfully exported to Europe and China is an EV.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - expat

Even taking out cars from the equation (a bit off topic I know), what these days IS actually made in the US that gets exported? Some foods, drinks (not many foods, but loads of drinks, given they like putting God-knows-what into them [hopefully something Sec Kennedy will reverse]), agricultural machinery, some clothing, and, of course aircraft, oil and LPG.

The US is only complaining about trade in goods. They are very quiet about services because that is where the US is making heaps of money. Microsoft, Google, Meta and others are extremely profitable and have little or no foreign competition. Mastercard and Visa dominate the provision of debit and credit cards. Big profits there. If there is going to be a trade war then the US should expect action against those companies.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

The US is only complaining about trade in goods. They are very quiet about services because that is where the US is making heaps of money. Microsoft, Google, Meta and others are extremely profitable and have little or no foreign competition. Mastercard and Visa dominate the provision of debit and credit cards. Big profits there. If there is going to be a trade war then the US should expect action against those companies.

We rely upon companies like Meta, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, Apple etc for the very existence of a modern functioning society and economy - communications, IT, smartphones, social interaction etc.

They could bring countries and world trade to a halt if they withdrew services - in many ways a far greater threat than military action or anything relatively trivial related to tariffs.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - davecooper

Amazon, Facebook X and Apple are not crucial to human existence. Now I've stopped using Amazon, I don't use any of these and I am still managing to function very well thanks. Also, no Netflix or Disney channel either.

We need to start reducing our reliance on the US and hopefully the current situation will be a wake up call.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

Amazon, Facebook X and Apple are not crucial to human existence. Now I've stopped using Amazon, I don't use any of these and I am still managing to function very well thanks. Also, no Netflix or Disney channel either.

We need to start reducing our reliance on the US and hopefully the current situation will be a wake up call.

You are entitled to your view but I think it complacent. 99% of smartphones and 90%+ of personal computers are Apple, Microsoft or Android. Without them:

  • online shopping comes to a halt - 25%+ of retail sales
  • booking systems collapse - rail, airlines, restaurants, theatres etc
  • online banking stops - personal financial chaos - 40% of UK wholly reliant on digital
  • GPS can be disabled - no more sat-nav - traffic congestion, failed deliveries etc
  • major impacts on supply chains - supermarket shortages, fuel deliveries

There are some plus points - teenagers may get jobs rather than spending 10 hours a day staring vacantly at a small screen, damage from online pawn and other objectionable output no longer available.

The UK needs a strategic contingency plan urgently just as it needs to spend more on defence.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Andrew-T

<< There are some plus points - damage from online pawn and other objectionable output >>

I don't think that is what you meant, Terry, but it's an interesting concept ...

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - davecooper

Amazon, Facebook X and Apple are not crucial to human existence. Now I've stopped using Amazon, I don't use any of these and I am still managing to function very well thanks. Also, no Netflix or Disney channel either.

We need to start reducing our reliance on the US and hopefully the current situation will be a wake up call.

You are entitled to your view but I think it complacent. 99% of smartphones and 90%+ of personal computers are Apple, Microsoft or Android. Without them:

  • online shopping comes to a halt - 25%+ of retail sales
  • booking systems collapse - rail, airlines, restaurants, theatres etc
  • online banking stops - personal financial chaos - 40% of UK wholly reliant on digital
  • GPS can be disabled - no more sat-nav - traffic congestion, failed deliveries etc
  • major impacts on supply chains - supermarket shortages, fuel deliveries

There are some plus points - teenagers may get jobs rather than spending 10 hours a day staring vacantly at a small screen, damage from online pawn and other objectionable output no longer available.

The UK needs a strategic contingency plan urgently just as it needs to spend more on defence.

I only mentioned Amazon, Facebook, X and Apple.

You dont have to online shop through Amazon, Facebook and X are just social media and Apple, well, other smartphones and tablets are available.

I agree that Google, Mastercard and Visa are another story.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - alan1302

You dont have to online shop through Amazon, Facebook and X are just social media and Apple, well, other smartphones and tablets are available.

There are others available but the vast majority of smartphones and tablets run on Googles Android that are not Apple iPhones/iPads. The only other OS that's supported from a major manufactuer is Harmony OS which is made by Huawei...who only created Harmony as they are banned from using Google due to being in part owned by the Chinese government.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - expat

There are others available but the vast majority of smartphones and tablets run on Googles Android that are not Apple iPhones/iPads. The only other OS that's supported from a major manufactuer is Harmony OS which is made by Huawei...who only created Harmony as they are banned from using Google due to being in part owned by the Chinese government.

Android is based on Linux which is freely available for anyone to use at no charge. What Google did when they used Linux to create Android was to add proprietary customisations and drivers for the various chips used in phones. It will be a major job to duplicate those but it is doable and has already been done by some organisations.

I can't think of any non US company or organisation which has a search engine comparable with Google. Bing is a Microsoft product and DuckDuckGo uses Bing.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

Android is based on Linux which is freely available for anyone to use at no charge. What Google did when they used Linux to create Android was to add proprietary customisations and drivers for the various chips used in phones. It will be a major job to duplicate those but it is doable and has already been done by some organisations.

I can't think of any non US company or organisation which has a search engine comparable with Google. Bing is a Microsoft product and DuckDuckGo uses Bing.

If Apple and Android became unavailable communications across much of the western world would cease. Linux may provide a base, but even if a workable contingency plan already exists it would take months to roll it out to users most of whom are IT illiterate.

The absence of a search engine with no platform to run it on is somewhat academic.

It may be in the event of the withdrawal of US systems that the effect would be to allow China with their Baidu search engine to get traction in the west, making use of the Huawei smartphone systems.

A further mitigating factor is that failure of comms and search engines would effectively put other US giants out of business - eg: Netflix, Amazon, etc.

This would seriously upset the US.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Ethan Edwards

Are well now your talking. American Re Insurance market has been highly protectionist since for ever. The application of FET Federal Excise Tax...Admitted Reinsurers etc

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

Even taking out cars from the equation (a bit off topic I know), what these days IS actually made in the US that gets exported? Some foods, drinks (not many foods, but loads of drinks, given they like putting God-knows-what into them [hopefully something Sec Kennedy will reverse]), agricultural machinery, some clothing, and, of course aircraft, oil and LPG.

The US is only complaining about trade in goods. They are very quiet about services because that is where the US is making heaps of money. Microsoft, Google, Meta and others are extremely profitable and have little or no foreign competition. Mastercard and Visa dominate the provision of debit and credit cards. Big profits there. If there is going to be a trade war then the US should expect action against those companies.

Probably because that part of their trade doesn't employ loads of people for the amount of foreign business they do, given a lot is automated via computer and often uses lots of data centres in the locale doing business, and so uses local expertise to set them up / maintain them.

Th reason why it's a good idea for big players on the international scene to have a big manufacturing base that does a lot of exporting as well as domestically is that it gives them a big advantage over geopolitical issues and can also have a big impact on whether countries go to war and the outcome.

Being self-sufficient is an obvious boon too in this regard, though rarely has it been sustainable for very long periods, because supplies of raw materials inevitably run out, as the UK is seeing with coal, oil and natural gas.

If the US didn't act, then China, effectively now controlling much of trade and where raw materials go in order to feed its producers and armed forces, would soon become as powerful as the US and likely move against Taiwan and possibly others in the region, rather like Japan did in the opposite direction before WW2.

For all their faults over the years, I'd easily rather have the US heading up things than the Chinese.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

That ship sailed a long time ago, Andy.

China is the dominant power in consumer goods and electronic components, and about the in cars.

It's simply because the 'developed' world is addicted to consumption of cheap goods. The US could manufacture what it needs but not for a generation and not at a price that consumers want to pay.

Trump wants to put a 10% tariff on everything but, being how he is, it has to be a deal where he goes in with a ludicrous offer, then it gets negotiated down and he can tell everyone what a great deal he did for them. He won't frame it as holding the world economy to ransom, but that's what it is. He's now got two problems; firstly, a 10% tariff is unlikely to achieve much other than drive inflation up. Secondly, China has called his bluff. That's why he now trying to frame this as China being disrespectful of the world economy by not doing what he says

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - SLO76
Not getting involved in the politics (the world’s a bit too mad to figure at the moment) but Honda shipped production of the Jazz from the UK to low cost China a number of years ago and the result for the UK consumer was… a near trebling of the list prices.

Wonder why Honda dealerships are disappearing quickly and the once huge selling Jazz is now a comparatively rare sight round here of late, despite our dealership still being open - for now.

UK and I suppose US consumers rarely see the benefit from huge multi-billion pound/dollar companies shipping production to low wage economies like China. The fat cats are too greedy to pass on any savings, and the short term greed leads to long term loss as the one time consumer can no longer afford to buy what they make as they’re on the dole.
The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy
Not getting involved in the politics (the world’s a bit too mad to figure at the moment) but Honda shipped production of the Jazz from the UK to low cost China a number of years ago and the result for the UK consumer was… a near trebling of the list prices. Wonder why Honda dealerships are disappearing quickly and the once huge selling Jazz is now a comparatively rare sight round here of late, despite our dealership still being open - for now. UK and I suppose US consumers rarely see the benefit from huge multi-billion pound/dollar companies shipping production to low wage economies like China. The fat cats are too greedy to pass on any savings, and the short term greed leads to long term loss as the one time consumer can no longer afford to buy what they make as they’re on the dole.

Plus the serious decline of Swindon, where Honda's huge UK factory was, and presumably its biggest employer by some margin. Seen recent videos of the town, especially the main shopping area, and whilst it never was fantastic (I last visited around 25 years ago for a work 'do' for the weekend), these days it resembles Stevenage for looking like a dump, not helped by other issues affecting the UK over the last 5-10 years.

What didn't help Honda either was their previously bullet-proof reputation for engineering quality significantly recede when they had problems with their 'standard' turbo-petrol cars and general quality issues, for example the issues I previously relayed concerning my sister and B-I-L's newish hybrid HRV (which doesn't use either the 1L or 1.5L turbo-petrols).

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

Nationwide are also based in Swindon and their office is enormous. I think WH Smiths were and probably still are.

The biggest problem Swindon has is that it's surrounded by very nice villages and all the money is out there and not in the town.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Engineer Andy

Nationwide are also based in Swindon and their office is enormous. I think WH Smiths were and probably still are.

I forgot about Nationwide. I doubt that Smiths will be much of an employer for much longer, given what was (ironically) in the news of late.

The biggest problem Swindon has is that it's surrounded by very nice villages and all the money is out there and not in the town.

Like rather a lot of larger towns and cities these days. I'm even seeing this regarding Cambridge, where its secondary shopping centre is a ghost town and likely to be redeveloped into, yep, housing. People don't shop in shops any more, they just do it online and have it delivered.

Sorry to drag this off-topic somewhat.

Ironically, only the rich (relative) newcomers to villages are those who can afford EVs, those in lesser housing (often long-stand residents / families who've lived [and often worked] the countryside) have to stick with (now extortionately-priced) ICE cars well into old age, because they need better range to get about and many can't afford cars well over £10k.

Few EVs have made it to that price point and where they could reasonably be relied upon for (say) another 10 years.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

Another airport car fire today , this time at Gatwick..

Maybe an EV according to airport staff but yet to be confirmed.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - badbusdriver

Another airport car fire today , this time at Gatwick..

Maybe an EV according to airport staff but yet to be confirmed.

Maybe an EV?

So fair to say maybe not an EV then?

Would I be right in thinking that you won't mention it again if it turns out it wasn't an EV?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Xileno

The video here shows a reg that indicates it's a hybrid according the the Vehicle Enquiry website.

uk.news.yahoo.com/dramatic-moment-car-erupts-flame...l

Not sure it proves anything apart from all cars occasionally go pop, whether ICE, hybrid or EV.

Good work by the fire fighters, I assume airport ones rather than general?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - FiestaOwner

The video here shows a reg that indicates it's a hybrid according the the Vehicle Enquiry website.

uk.news.yahoo.com/dramatic-moment-car-erupts-flame...l

Not sure it proves anything apart from all cars occasionally go pop, whether ICE, hybrid or EV.

Good work by the fire fighters, I assume airport ones rather than general?

Looked up the MOT History site. That shows the car as being a VW Tiguan PHEV. 1st registered 27/3/25. So just 2 ½ weeks old.

Frightening though. Seen conventional fuelled vehicles go up and the fires were ferocious too.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

Oopsie.. Someone's car hire has got off to an inauspicious start.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

Does the car involved in the fire have a track record of catching fire or faults that could cause a fire ?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

Answering my own question.

like potential fire hazards, defective locking mechanisms on tow bars, and issues with the roof spoiler or front brake discs.

Here's

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Adampr

Answering my own question.

like potential fire hazards, defective locking mechanisms on tow bars, and issues with the roof spoiler or front brake discs.

Here's

It's the latest model of VW Tiguan. There seem to be quite a lot of issues being reported with these. Another VW product released before being tested?

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Steveieb

Later reports say that a defective HV fuse can cause the problem . Not enough sand in the fuse capsule !

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - focussed

I prefer internal combustion over spontaneous combustion thanks all the same.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Ethan Edwards

New charger installed at Colchester region pub. Oh yes...my kind of thing that.

New electric vehicle charger installed at popular country pub in Colchester

The station is easy to use, allowing customers to simply tap, charge, and go.

www.gazette-news.co.uk


Let's read on. '22kw charger can charge two vehicles '...noooooooooo!

That's an AC charger.
That's only ok for a few EVs like the Zoe. I'll only get 11 kw from it at best..ie slooow!


I'd have preferred one single 50kw charger ie DC.
Much more useful.

Who makes these decisions, cos they know flip all about EVs.

Edited by Ethan Edwards on 16/04/2025 at 18:13

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - mcb100
It could depend on the feed coming to the property - it may not support a DC rapid.

But it’s two 11kW chargers more than there were before. Pop in for a meal, spend a couple of hours there, put 100 miles range back in.

Not sure about your statement about it only being suitable for Zoe - most EV’s max out at 11kW on AC, regardless of their DC charge capability. Both Tesla models will only cope with 11kW.

Edited by mcb100 on 16/04/2025 at 21:08

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - Terry W

It may have nothing to do with technical or capacity issues.

It comfortably provides a get you home charge for the typical pub user, most of whom stop for 1-2 hours and probably live within 20 miles.

For the few who genuinely need to fast charge a range of 300+ miles in a pub not usually a stopping place for those on a long motorway journey - tough.

The Electric Vehicle (EV) thread Vol 14 - expat

It comfortably provides a get you home charge for the typical pub user, most of whom stop for 1-2 hours and probably live within 20 miles.

Should we be encouraging drivers to spend 1-2 hours in the pub and then drive home? Perhaps they will only have a small lemonade before they drive off but some may have a lot more.