What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - Alan Goodman

Hello all, hope you are all doing well.
Can I have a little info or any heads up? Anything greatly appreciated.
Saturday, when I pressed the clutch pedal down, it made a horrible grinding sound, but gears still changed okay.
I called the AA and was told it was the "Thrust Bearing" and need to get a new clutch and flywheel.
It calmed down a bit and by Monday had all but gone. Then in the evening, I pushed the clutch pedal down to start and it struggled to fire up, but, alas it did.
I've had clutch failure before, spectacularly!! so booked it into a reputable garage for Clutch & Flywheel replacement. £1250
Thinking I could hang on until Friday, the clutch went on Tuesday whilst stuck on a small hill behind 3 other cars.
AA came again, towed me back and told me "Clutch pressure plate/release bearing collapsed causing pedal to be stuck half way down"
I still managed to start the engine but could not change any gears.
AA towed me home and today they were going to charge me £120 to tow the car literally 3 minutes down the road! Sod that! I have RAC on my Insurance and got them to tow me.
RAC chap tried to start the car, clutch pedal down to the floor, would not start! The engine "warm up" light came on. (Looks like a Pretzel sort of!)
He hooked it up to a computer and came up with a reading of a duff starter motor sensor!
So the car is now in the garage awaiting surgery, I'm now cacking myself that there will be another hefty bill on top of that for a starter motor.
To my knowledge, I thought that the car would start again once the new clutch was fitted. The AA chap even said, the engine wont start because of the broken part.
Any pointers, greatly appreciated.
Thank you.

BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - Andrew-T

Are you convinced the actual clutch has failed, or might it be a failure in the clutch hydraulics - which could make the pedal stop halfway down (I'm assuming this car has hydraulic operation) ?

BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - Alan Goodman

Are you convinced the actual clutch has failed, or might it be a failure in the clutch hydraulics - which could make the pedal stop halfway down (I'm assuming this car has hydraulic operation) ?

Hi, yes I think it has, it started stalling a lot and yesterday on the hill when it went it gave off that distinctive burning smell.
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - elekie&a/c doctor
There’s a sensor on the clutch hydraulic system that monitors clutch pedal travel . The ecm needs to see this activity to allow the engine to start .
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - Alan Goodman
There’s a sensor on the clutch hydraulic system that monitors clutch pedal travel . The ecm needs to see this activity to allow the engine to start .

Hi, do you think it will start up again once the new clutch & flywheel are fitted or is this an additional job. Cost? Thank you
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - elekie&a/c doctor
Once the gearbox has been removed from the vehicle, the garage will be able to give a better indication as to what has failed. Move on from here .
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - Alan Goodman
Once the gearbox has been removed from the vehicle, the garage will be able to give a better indication as to what has failed. Move on from here .

Reading up, it sounds likely. The part seems to cost around £50 so shouldn’t really be that much. I’ll be keeping everything crossed. I think you’re definitely correct. ????
BMW 3 Series - BMW 320D 2010 Clutch knackered, car wont start! - edlithgow

Its BROKEN.

Stop trying to drive it