Dunno.
Hard to even guess without seeing it, but evidently the old plug didn't prevent a problem.
You havn't said there was anything wrong with the old plug, (cracked, perished, oil-degraded, etc) and if its a design limitation, fitting a new one with the same design limitation wont fix it long term.
In general, a fitting that retains water is worse than no fitting at all.
I'd be inclined to attempt addressing this issue with goo, maybe a silicone grease variety of goo, applied in the original or either proposed repair situation, with, optionally, some creative use of RTV sealant, rubber glove fingers, a condom, etc. There are contact cleaning anti oxidant sprays too but I've had unfortunate plastic cracking experiences with them, though I suppose they might remove your problematic rubber plug for you.
I'd probably do whichever was cheapest and/or easiest first. This may not be what you would do, but then it isn't your car either.
Plus I don't like the sound of "soldering", probably because my soldering is lousy.
I prefer the sound of "crimping", though TBH my crimping is pretty lousy too.
Edited by edlithgow on 13/07/2024 at 05:24
|