What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - zsanett galantay

Hi all,

My coolant tank keeps cracking and then leaking. The car NEVER overheats cause i keep filling the coolant.

I had new WATERPUMP, THERMOSTAT, 3X COOLANT TANK AND CAP.

I dont have any of the other symptoms of a blown head gasket, but i think the increased pressure keeps cracking my coolant tanks. Some last a month, some last 3 months. Can it be still a cracked head gasket somewhere that only causes this symptom? I dont want to wait until another symptom shows up and then its worse but of course i dont want to spend all that money to take the engine apart for nothing.

I did a head gasket test bought from amazon, to see if there are any combustion gases mixed in but that was all fine too. Me and 2 other mechanics are really at a loss now what else could it be.

Thanks

Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - JONATHAN_11_80

There will be pressure in the cooling system when hot but excessive pressure from a headgasket problem would result in the car loosing coolant via the pressure cap on the coolant. Are you using genuine vauxhall parts in regard to your header tank and pressure cap.

Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - RT

Increased pressure won't crack the coolant tank - it would just release the extra pressure through it's cap giving a gradual loss of coolant

Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - Adampr

I'm not at all familiar with the engines, but is it possible that some kind of breather is blocked and the tank is actually cracking from vacuum when the engine cools?

Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - bathtub tom

Age and mileage of car, service record and how long have you owned it?

Vauxhall Astra GTC - Only one symptom for blown head gasket? - edlithgow

Age and mileage of car, service record and how long have you owned it?

None of which appears to matter at all, except maybe the last one, a bit, in that it might give a clue as to whether the previous owner was offloading a problem.

You have reasons for these questions, or are they just an SOP?

OP, you could probably get the cooling system pressure checked at operating temperature and see if it is way over spec, assuming you can find one, and pressure test it for leakage, engine off. You could also look for bubbles in the radiator filler, engine running, but some cars seem to do that anyway, maybe from cavitation.

Garages,have gas analysers, used for emissions testing. I havn't heard of these being used fo test for HG gasket failure, but its such an apparently obvious application you'd think someone would make adapter kits for it.

I suppose it might not be any more sensitive than the chemical kits, though, if the volume of leaked gas is small,

If it hasn't been done you probably wouldnt be able to get anyone to try it anyway, because they wont want to bust their expensive gadget.

I assume your cooling fan and thermostat both work.

You might try a crackle test on your oil, though thats by no means a sure-fire test for HG failure. I dont think there is one

Edited by edlithgow on 20/08/2023 at 02:28