Last year I asked for advice on whether to swap cars as I had a 2010 KIA Ceed auto estate. One of the recommendations that I looked at was an Astra estate which on paper looked good and reliable; but I didn’t like it and decided to hang onto the Ceed for another year or so. It has been trouble free and has only just passed the MoT again.
But despite the car prices currently being inflated, I decided to replace the Ceed with a newer 18 plate Ceed. It was difficult to justify the extra 2k for an estate so I opted for a petrol DCT hatchback.
Although on paper the newer petrol Ceed has significantly more power (140bhp compared to 115), in normal driving it feels much slower. I suppose this is partly down to the engine, but presumably the newer car is heavier, and the gearbox non TC. The 1.4TGDi isn’t a bad engine but just doesn’t have the seemingly effortless acceleration of the 1.6 CRDi auto regardless of what speed one is doing; I’ve tried the sports mode to see if that’s any better, but in that mode the engine is just too frantic and noisy.
Nevertheless, with diesel out of fashion I think it was the sensible choice to make. The petrol is fine really and has sufficient power, but the CRDi was/is something special!
And yes I know that DCTs are complicated beasts and I would have preferred a torque converter auto; but compromises need to be made, and the KIA will be under warranty for a couple more years.
|