What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
BMW 2 Series Active Tourer - Mud guards or Mudflaps ? - Brian Lacey

All I want is to keep the muck off the sills.

We live rural so mud on road, narrow lanes, muck !!

I can either get a set of traditional old school mud flaps or a set of the plastic, smaller, fitted mud guards, BUT, being a tight-fisted Yorkshireman I will not be paying BMW prices !

So which would be effective ?

I suspect the flaps keep more muck off as they have more depth down toward the road surface but the guards look more pleasing aesthetically.

Who has fitted 'What" and to what effect ?

Cheers

Brian.

BMW 2 Series Active Tourer - Mud guards or Mudflaps ? - badbusdriver

I could well be mistaken, but I believe what you are referring to as a mudguard is actually just a 'mudflap', but in a 3d shape to better fit with the shape of the car. In so far as the surface presented to the tyre, they are pretty much the same and are certainly supposed to do the same thing. But with the mudguard, that surface will be smaller and it will be rigid, or semi-rigid. My own opinion is that the mudflap would be more effective at preventing stones being thrown up along the sill, but the aerodynamic considerations mean that the mud guard might be more effective at keeping the side of the car clean. To be honest, it isn't something I've spent a lot of time thinking about personally, but my brother is very much in favour of the mudflap, possibly because he is also a bit tight(!), but possibly also due to watching old school rally cars in the 70's and 80's with their enormous mudflaps!.

BMW 2 Series Active Tourer - Mud guards or Mudflaps ? - _

www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Moulded-Car-Mudflaps-BMW-2-Acti...9

cheap.so not much to lose if you don't like them

Edited by _ORB_ on 20/04/2021 at 08:34

BMW 2 Series Active Tourer - Mud guards or Mudflaps ? - catsdad

Some of these look like they use self tappers? I would not want to drill holes in the bodywork as this would create a rust trap especially with all the mud about. There used to be some with clamps that are less immediately damaging but still could cause damage if overtightened.

Beware too that big mudflats on low clearance cars can snag on verges or, as I did once, be torn off if you reverse in mud or long grass when the flap gets squeezed and bent back against the moving wheel.

Sorry just not a fan.

BMW 2 Series Active Tourer - Mud guards or Mudflaps ? - badbusdriver

Some of these look like they use self tappers? I would not want to drill holes in the bodywork as this would create a rust trap especially with all the mud about. There used to be some with clamps that are less immediately damaging but still could cause damage if overtightened.

The image does suggest putting the screws through the metal on the lip of the wheel arch. But that is a basic and universal image as opposed to being for a specific car. I say that because when I used to fit mudguards of the moulded type, screws like that were generally inserted into the plastic liner. But even if they were to be screwed into the metal, an extra couple of minutes preparation would (along with the metal being galvanised) reduce the risk of corrosion to the absolute minimum.

But, just to be clear, I wouldn't be drilling holes into the bodywork either, not so much due to any concerns about rust, or simply putting holes in the bodywork, but because I just don't see mudguards or flaps, worth the bother (and I also spend a lot of time driving on muddy rural roads). They may prevent the lower part of the body becoming as dirty as it may otherwise, but they won't keep it clean, so you will still have to wash the car. Assuming you use a power washer to do so, it isn't going to have any difficulty shifting lumps of mud from the sill.