Does the main pipe get smaller as it gets to its last branch on the existing layout? If so, you may find the pressure drop when reversing the flow direction to be rather high, possibly starving outlets at the new end of the system if the outlet(s) nearer to the boiler are in use.
If not, then I don't see why not, unless my brain has gone to sleep (I am in need of food, so it could've).
|
Does the main pipe get smaller as it gets to its last branch on the existing layout? If so, you may find the pressure drop when reversing the flow direction to be rather high, possibly starving outlets at the new end of the system if the outlet(s) nearer to the boiler are in use.
If not, then I don't see why not, unless my brain has gone to sleep (I am in need of food, so it could've).
Good point Engineer Andy. Will check. Thank you.
|
|
The plumber should not have connected the 15mm hot water outlet from the Combi into a larger 22mm pipe. This is so inefficient and very bad practice. He should run the outlet to a part of the system where the connection is all 15mm and it provides a good supply to all hot water taps and outlets. That should not be too difficult to determine. I could do it in 10 minutes. Sounds like you need to recall this 'plumber'. He may be a plumber on his mothers side!!!
As for gas consumption, a Combi is generally rated above 90% efficiency for fuel burning. This alongside no hot water storage should be very efficient. Like everything else in this world the human factor counts. The Combi boiler is fairly fool proof, until you get a clever fool. They are factory set and need little or no burner maintenance. They are electronically controlled and operated once powered up. Only the odd clean out needed. Modern flue fans do not need regular lubrication any longer either. Pretty fool proof. It all depends on the installer for the rest of it. Give a good car to a bad mechanic etc etc.!!!!!
Cheers Concrete
|
<< The Combi boiler is fairly fool proof, ... They are factory set and need little or no burner maintenance. They are electronically controlled and operated once powered up. Only the odd clean out needed. Modern flue fans do not need regular lubrication any longer either. >>
At 15 years old our Combi developed a strange fault causing a steady drip of hot water from the external overflow, which raised our water consumption by about 50%. The cause turned out to be an internal leak in the heat exchanger. Not very long afterwards the fan started acting up and needed replacement. Otherwise - now 20 years old - it seems to be 100% reliable.
|
<< The Combi boiler is fairly fool proof, ... They are factory set and need little or no burner maintenance. They are electronically controlled and operated once powered up. Only the odd clean out needed. Modern flue fans do not need regular lubrication any longer either. >>
At 15 years old our Combi developed a strange fault causing a steady drip of hot water from the external overflow, which raised our water consumption by about 50%. The cause turned out to be an internal leak in the heat exchanger. Not very long afterwards the fan started acting up and needed replacement. Otherwise - now 20 years old - it seems to be 100% reliable.
The industry norm allowed for the expected life of a reasonably decent combi boiler is about 15 years.
|
|
|
|
It's not the direction of flow, it's the fact that the pipe is not there! The water is not going in the wrong direction, it's simply going on the country Sunday afternoon diversion route to where the old tank was and back again. If you want to get there faster you will need to build a bypass - i.e. a new pipe direct from the boiler to the pipe under the sink. Like I said - how easy this is will be depends on how much of the countryside (i.e. the Kitchen!) has to be dismantled to get there! If it's not too hard, then it would probably be better to connect the boiler to the pipework to this tap, and then cap off the current outlet from the boiler so that all water goes this way, it will probably be better for other taps as well. There is no worry on pipe size on a mains pressure combi boiler - the pressure drop down a 15mm pipe is naf all compared to the mains pressure.
|
It depends on what the local mains pressure is and if you have a large DWH load. Don't forget that the legal minimum for mains pressure is only 1bar at the meter (some areas have very low pressure as its easier and cheaper for the water company to reduce mains pressures to the legal minimum than to repair leaks in pipes), and an older home may well have a long pipework system to go to and from a HW cylinder with lots of bends and whose pipes have been there for decades, reducing in effective bore due to scaling, etc.
Additionally, if the home has a bath instead of a shower and/or (like mine) a hot fill washing machine, the DHW load is quite a bit higher than a very modern set-up. As such, all the above can have a large impact under the 'right' circumstances on the pressure drop. Not helped if a shower is a modern 'drench' unit requiring significant flow and pressure (over a standard unit) to work properly.
I'm not saying definitively this is the case here, but without all the details, we can't be certain either way.
|
As mentioned, the property is a bungalow, so everything is on same storey. Why can't the direction of flow be reversed, (change pipe connections) so that the adjacent sink would be first, not last, on the hot water journey ?
Starting with a blank sheet of paper any plumber worthy of his job title would design a system that uses the minimum of materials with the absolute minimum of tight bends. But in a property that already exists with an existing system its not always as simple as that. The amount of disturbance could be undesirable for starters plus the time element involved could result in a plumber that does the design correctly pricing himself out of work.
But that does not excuse any plumber doing what yours appears to have done. Utilising existing pipework that creates undesirably long runs and delays is very bad practice.
The UK Water regulations demand that water at a temp of 50 C must reach any outlet within 30 seconds with a max pipe run of 12 meters. That is not always possible of course. As I mentioned above at our last house it took ages to get hot water to our kitchen taps, because the sink was in an extension and due to location of the HW cylinder above what was at the time a coal boiler the total pipe run was 20 meters but along the way it passed through the upstairs bathroom and downstairs WC thus it did make a little sense. If the most direct route had been use multiple runs would have been required and it would still have been 14 meters to the sink at the very minimum. To reduce this a total redesign of the house would have been required. That is the problem starting with a 1920's property that had few mod cons in mind when built.
In the OP's case I would be concerned about using existing pipework when a simpler solution seems possible and if the plumber has carried out a shortcut here what other shortcuts has he made. A call to Gas Safe with a request for an inspection gassaferegister.co.uk/help-and-advice/gas-safety-i.../ would be a good idea but do consider that they are unlikely to be concerned about the hot water issue. That needs to be addressed by the installer.
Edited by thunderbird on 17/01/2020 at 16:21
|
Just spotted Concretes new post above where he says
The plumber should not have connected the 15mm hot water outlet from the Combi into a larger 22mm pipe.
I have read all the OP's posts again and simply cannot find where he has said that the plumber has done this. However I have spotted that the OP says in the original post
But the hot water is pumped round the rest of the system before arriving at the sink
and this is obviously not correct. The domestic hot water from the Combi Boiler is not pumped, it is simply a gravity flow.
Andrew T said above
But although our place was first built in 1970 and extended about 1980, the meter itself dates from 1989. No idea why it would have been changed then, as the combi boiler went in ten years after that, the only serious alteration I can trace.
At our old house we had gas installed in 1997 when we swapped from solid fuel heating to gas. The meter was swapped once between that date and 2017 when we sold the house simply because it was the policy of the transporter to swap them, never complained, nothing unusual with the readings.
|
<< The domestic hot water from the Combi Boiler is not pumped, it is simply a gravity flow. >>
I guess it is more accurate to say that it uses mains pressure, which is usually rather more than the 'gravity' provided by the header tank in a conventional system. Our mains pressure varies, but is usually quite high, so if hottish water is called for, it's no use opening the tap fully, the boiler can't keep up.
|
|
I'm wondering whether the combi is struggling because they normally need a reasonable flow rate for the DHW heat exchanger's sensor to realise there's a demand. I had to adapt my usage on my new one when changing from a Powermax thermal store boiler when I could get really low flows of DHW - not on my combi.
That plus a decent pressure drop on the DHW system as a whole compared to before and only a low head to begin with on a gravity-fed system? I'm surprised that the plumber didn't advise connecting the DHW cold feed directly to the mains cold water incommer to take advantage of the extra pressure, especially in a bunglow.
|
This thread explains why a lot of houses round here have the combi boiler where the airing cupboard was.
|
|
Interesting thread. Our Ravenheat combi is now 25 and a bit like Triggers broom over the years, gas valve,. couple of diverter valves. The central heating is of course sealed and it is the diverter valve that switches when the hot tap is opened. In winter when the mains feed is quite a bit colder than summer I always reduce the flow at the hot tap which gives hot water a lot quicker.
|
I guess it is more accurate to say that it uses mains pressure, which is usually rather more than the 'gravity' provided by the header tank in a conventional system. Our mains pressure varies, but is usually quite high,
Quite correct.
But the usually bit is rather important. At our old house upstairs the flow from the hot taps (fed by about a 6' head from the storage tank in the loft) was actually greater than the flow from the cold tap. Downstairs it was about the same. The downstairs loo could be quite embarrassing when we had visitors since it took a good 10 minutes to fill even with the correct bits in the tank for the low pressure.
We wanted to fit an electric shower but when we checked with Severn Trent they told us one would never work. Eventually they upgraded the mains and the pressure improved and we actually fitted an electric shower which worked on most days. But on a bad day it still no worky and there was nothing that could be done.
At the current property the pressure is quite a bit better but still not as good as in other parts of town. Had it checked before we bought just to ensure we were OK this time and there is adequate for all domestic needs but we were told that the properties at the top of the hill (we are about 1/2 way up it) do have bad days. Sound a bit like the old property. But at least the loos fill quickly probably helped by the fact they only hold about 1/2 the water.
Bought an electric shower for this property but never actually fitted it. We found that the combi supplies a perfect flow with a controllable temp from a mixer so why complicate things. The cost of gas for a shower is a fraction of electricity for a 10kw shower. Only issue could be the day the combi no worky. With no shower (or bath) we would simply have to stink.
|
Yep - a lack of decent mains pressure to service newer boiler systems and outlets that require higher heads to get full flow are a real problem, especially for those people living near the tops of hills in populous areas.
I live in a 3-storey flat block, all on mains pressure with individual rising MCWS pipes for each flat. Fine for me on the Ground Floor (I get 2 bar minimum, mostly 3 bar+), not so good for those on the top floor if the local water company follows others (e.g. Thames Water) in saving money by reducing pressures to 1 bar to reduce leaks in their system.
By the time the water gets to the top floor, it'll have lost about 0.6 - 0.7 bar in pressure, possibly not enough to run some modern combis (mine requires a minimum of 0.35 bar for DHW handling). That would still leave precious little for the outlets, especially showers, which in our flats' case is the last outlet on the system and thus most susceptible to starvation.
Many new build (since the mid 90s at least) developers and builders deliberately save themselves a fortune by not allowing for this sort of eventuality - at least older buildings and homes have roof/loft-space tanks or space for them. On more than one occasion I had to specify a domestic cold water booster pump and little tank - about the size of a washing machine, to be able to serve a converted town house (to individual flats) off the mains in areas where mains pressures get near 1 bar and/or are being reduced for the reasons I spoke of earlier.
Some homes don't even have the space to accommodate them, so whole blocks may have to bite an extortionately expensive bullet and have a communal underground water booster and break tank installed for the site. Last time I costed that (just for a new build for buying, not installing) in the mid 2000s, it came to £50k for a unit serving 50 flats. And that's assuming you have the space to install one. The installation cost would be huge.
PS. When my old boiler broke, and also when my new one (only fitted in October) broke down twice in 2 months (two faulty gas valves), I had the same issue as regards personal use of hot water (I have an emergency 3kW fan convector for heating - blimmin' expensive to run!). My temporary solution for keeping me clean and getting some decent exercise was going swimming, and getting in a decent shower (for free) whilst there.
|
|
<< At the current property the pressure is quite a bit better but still not as good as in other parts of town. >>
My last (part-time) job before retiring was with the Leakage section of NW Water (United Utilities). I think water companies keep mains pressures as low as remains satisfactory, to keep leakage losses down. Those losses can be pretty staggering especially from elderly street mains.
How do things operate in 12-storey or higher buildings?
Edited by Andrew-T on 18/01/2020 at 18:29
|
<< At the current property the pressure is quite a bit better but still not as good as in other parts of town. >>
My last (part-time) job before retiring was with the Leakage section of NW Water (United Utilities). I think water companies keep mains pressures as low as remains satisfactory, to keep leakage losses down. Those losses can be pretty staggering especially from elderly street mains.
How do things operate in 12-storey or higher buildings?
The use a break tank and a booster pump set, and sometimes for taller buildings, one for the bottom 10-15 floors, and then another to boost up again to the next 10-15 situated on floor 12 (say), and so on. No actual storage at the roof/top floor. Some variants have just mains to the Basement, Ground and First floors, then boosted above.
Very expensive to buy and install, but the tanks do last a long time, and the pumps get replaced every 15-20 years. Difficult to retrofit in older buildings - a lack of space for the tanks (because they need to be at GF/Basement level) and newer rising pipework (the old has to remain until the switchover), never mind many old buildings are full of asbestos.
The old way was to have a smaller break tank and lower duty pump set, in order just to pump the water up to a great big honking storage tank or two above the top floor/on the roof. Then it acts just like a domestic system - people just one floor below get poor pressure, those nearer the Ground Floor far better.
I had to contend with the above situation for a residential block of flats in North London. An absolute pig of a project.
|
Well thunderbird it may be the case that the pressure difference is as you eloquently put it 'naff all'. I disagree and maintain the pressure drop is significant enough to cause delivery problems on a long pipe run. Beside any of this it is extremely bad practice to connect a 15mm supply to a 22mm pipe. I said this because the OP gave the impression that the the Combi replaced a conventional system. In which case the hot and cold water storage tanks will have been removed. If the plumber decided to reconnect to the hot water system at this point there will have invariably been a 22mm HW supply leaving the HW storage cupboard. My point is he should have made the connection elsewhere to increase efficiency and conform to good practice, or cut back the 22mm until he found 15mm pipe. As you say don't take a county hike, take the direct route. It is difficult to fully imagine the layout of the OP's bungalow and be precise about how the pipework should run, however good practice should be followed at all times IMHO. Cheers Concrete
PS. to another post. Hot water from a Combi is not pumped, but nor is it gravity fed. It relies entirely on mains pressure.
|
Well thunderbird it may be the case that the pressure difference is as you eloquently put it 'naff all'. I disagree and maintain the pressure drop is significant enough to cause delivery problems on a long pipe run. Beside any of this it is extremely bad practice to connect a 15mm supply to a 22mm pipe. I said this because the OP gave the impression that the the Combi replaced a conventional system. In which case the hot and cold water storage tanks will have been removed. If the plumber decided to reconnect to the hot water system at this point there will have invariably been a 22mm HW supply leaving the HW storage cupboard. My point is he should have made the connection elsewhere to increase efficiency and conform to good practice, or cut back the 22mm until he found 15mm pipe. As you say don't take a county hike, take the direct route. It is difficult to fully imagine the layout of the OP's bungalow and be precise about how the pipework should run, however good practice should be followed at all times IMHO. Cheers Concrete
Checked and I never used the term "naff all". Plus I agree you should never step up a pipe size
PS. to another post. Hot water from a Combi is not pumped, but nor is it gravity fed. It relies entirely on mains pressure.
I said several posts ago that I was incorrect using the term gravity when I should have said mains pressure.
Think you are a bit behind.
|
... it may be the case that the pressure difference is as you eloquently put it 'naff all'. I disagree and maintain the pressure drop is significant enough to cause delivery problems on a long pipe run.
One important thing to avoid is angle corners instead of more gradual bends. I learnt this as a graduate student doing gas kinetics in a glass vacuum system, so the effect will be much worse with liquids.
It was brought home to me a few years ago when our new neighbour was building an extension which required our water supply main to be rerouted. The builders used an elbow to get round the corner of the foundation, and the effect on our water pressure was immediately obvious. I got them to simply curve the pipe, and things were back to normal.
|
One important thing to avoid is angle corners instead of more gradual bends. I learnt this as a graduate student doing gas kinetics in a glass vacuum system, so the effect will be much worse with liquids
I hinted at that a few posts ago
"Starting with a blank sheet of paper any plumber worthy of his job title would design a system that uses the minimum of materials with the absolute minimum of tight bends."
but you probably have made it clearer.
|
<< Starting with a blank sheet of paper any plumber worthy of his job title would design a system that uses the minimum of materials with the absolute minimum of tight bends . >>
And elbows make a lot of extra noise too ...
|
One important thing to avoid is angle corners instead of more gradual bends. I learnt this as a graduate student doing gas kinetics in a glass vacuum system, so the effect will be much worse with liquids
I hinted at that a few posts ago
"Starting with a blank sheet of paper any plumber worthy of his job title would design a system that uses the minimum of materials with the absolute minimum of tight bends."
but you probably have made it clearer.
I agree about system design. If possible the least amount of bends necessary and those that are there should be gradual bends, preferably pulled via a bending machine or spring. It seems logical to me. In the dim and distant past when pumps were not that efficient the system design could be crucial. Indeed a lot of early systems relied on gravity to circulate water so design and pipe runs were important. However nowadays I am told by well qualified system designers that modern pumps are very efficient and in an enclosed pressurise system will overcome resistance very well. I suppose small bore and micro bore systems were driven by this advance in technology.
I apologise if you did not write 'naff all'. I does convey the meaning instantly though! It seems we are in accord when it comes to good design and practice.
Cheers Concrete
|
<< However nowadays I am told by well qualified system designers that modern pumps are very efficient and in an enclosed pressurise system will overcome resistance very well. I suppose small bore and micro bore systems were driven by this advance in technology. >>
No doubt advances have been made. But I don't like to think of the noise which a pump might create with an elbow-fitted system ....
|
<< However nowadays I am told by well qualified system designers that modern pumps are very efficient and in an enclosed pressurise system will overcome resistance very well. I suppose small bore and micro bore systems were driven by this advance in technology. >>
No doubt advances have been made. But Idon't like to think of the noise which a pump might create with an elbow-fitted system ....
Quite right. That was always a consideration with micro bore heating pipework. The pressure at the manifold could cause vibration. Also if the pump was close to elbows and usually a diverter valve, as in a cylinder cupboard, the flow rate could cause cavitation and cause free air in the system. This is where the installer has to use his experience to minimise the risk of such problems occurring. As is often stated here, the man with the tools is a very important person. The vast majority of problems with heating systems are results of poor practice and design. Cheers Concrete
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|