What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Engine Oil - Dingle232

Some of the low life in society have recently relieved me of my pride and joy. After a few weeks of being without a vehicle I finally managed to get the insurance finalised but have taken a hit with only receiving market value.

I would like to change the oil and filter on my new car myself as it's quite a straightforward job but have seen a number of forum posts (elsewhere) suggesting that not all oil is the same (apart from the obvious supermarket stuff). The recommended oil for my car is Mobil 1 but I've read conflicting reports that it's 'not as good' as stuff like Shell Helix, even of the same grade and viscosity.

It's more of a point for debate rather than a worry but have the learned folks on here any views about that or indeed what the best stuff to buy is?

Engine Oil - elekie&a/c doctor
...and the car is???
Engine Oil - John F

Buying engine oil seems a bit like buying tea leaves or face cream - huge choice and price disparities but little difference in product effectiveness, thanks to the merchandising rules and regulations that pertain here. I think that 99% of the nation's cars would run perfectly satisfactorily on Wilko fully synthetic 5-30 at £22 per 5 litres. Time for a cup of PG tips...

Engine Oil - badbusdriver

Without knowing what kind of car it is, it is difficult to give accurate info. But, unless the car is some fancy high performance machine, or a modern turbo diesel, i'm not sure it is that big an issue, especially if it is a cheap, simple, n/a petrol runabout.

Engine Oil - RT

The big names like Mobil 1 and Helix have a multitude of different versions, only one or two will suit a specific car.

Look in the handbook, or contact the car maker (not a dealer) to find out the required oil - you'll need viscosity, eg 5W-30 and ACEA grade, eg ACEA-C3 - some makers like VW, Mercedes, BMW will specify an approval number, eg VW 507.00 either as well as the viscosity/acea or instead of.

Don't get hung up on big brand names and DON'T get hung up about mineral/semi-synthetic/fully synthetic.

Engine Oil - Terry W

I think the advice for a high spec engines is right.

But even lower down the technology chain, I would buy the spec listed in the handbook.

For an extra £10-25 per change you can be more confident that seals, piston rings, bearings, valve guides etc etc are getting the right formula. Otherwise you may be unlucky and screw up the engine at a cost of many £000s for the sake of a small saving.

Engine Oil - Dingle232

Without knowing what kind of car it is, it is difficult to give accurate info. But, unless the car is some fancy high performance machine, or a modern turbo diesel, i'm not sure it is that big an issue, especially if it is a cheap, simple, n/a petrol runabout.

Honda CR-V 1.6 i-DTEC Auto. The recommended oil is Mobil 1 ACEA C2/C3 OW-30.

Edited by Dingle232 on 31/07/2019 at 13:05

Engine Oil - Happy Blue!

In that case buy that oil!

Engine Oil - edlithgow

In that case buy that oil!

Fairly persistent reports of hiigh fuel dilution on those, so a 0W-30 might not be the best choice, though clearly better than a 0W-20.

I'd get the highest viscosity approved for that vehicle, Most manufacturers approve a range of viscosities for their vehicles, but you might have to dig for it a bit..

You could reasonably argue that the marginal fuel economy advantage of going for the recommended oil is worth having, but with a known fuel dilution issue that's a bit harder.to do.

Engine Oil - edlithgow

Description of the fuel dilution issue I mentioned, and some forum flak, of which there is a lot.

It mostly seems to be about a 1.5 engine, though, so maybe doesn't apply to your particular model.

www.hondaproblems.com/oil-dilution/

www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topic...1

www.crvownersclub.com/threads/oil-dilution-and-ass...7

I havn't researched this, not having any reason to, but IIRC

Thicker oil (5W30, 0W-40, etc) is predictably one suggested work-around, BUT I don't know if this came from Honda (I'd bet not) and this MIGHT come from the US where recommended oils are typically lower viscosity and I THINK were 0W-20 for this car.

Higher octane fuel is another suggested work-around.

Honda apparently produced a software update which ups engine revs to achieve warm-up and boil off the fuel faster. Only partly effective.

Its suggested in various places that all direct injection engines put fuel in the oil but most of them boil it off more efficiently so it isn't a problem. I think this is likely an oversimplification. That'll tend to concentrate the heavy end of the fuel residue in your oil, and will not be good for it. I suppose you either live with that or you change your oil more often.

Engine Oil - Metropolis.
I was about to say check the manual, and in the vast majority of cases it’s correct provided you choose the one listed for our climate. However, in the case of mine with the engine designed in the 60s, (my car is 2004!) the modern oils don’t contain adequate ZDDP and the dealers tend to go for too light an oil as well, so following the advice of RPI engineering, I use Valvoline 20w50 mineral racing oil, the rover v8 just isn’t designed for full synthetic. The answer isn’t always simple! However seeing as you’ve got a honda with a relatively new design i would just follow the handbook..

Edit: And make sure you buy genuine Honda filters, or at least find the honda OEM if their is one. Not worth skimping and there is a difference!

Edited by Metropolis. on 31/07/2019 at 14:15

Engine Oil - edlithgow
I was about to say check the manual, and in the vast majority of cases it’s correct provided you choose the one listed for our climate. However, in the case of mine with the engine designed in the 60s, (my car is 2004!) the modern oils don’t contain adequate ZDDP and the dealers tend to go for too light an oil as well, so following the advice of RPI engineering, I use Valvoline 20w50 mineral racing oil, the rover v8 just isn’t designed for full synthetic. The answer isn’t always simple!

Last fill I ran a 50:50 mix of CPC SAE40 and Mobil Delvac MX 15W40 which probably was roughly 25iW40 ish.

The SAE40 is Group 1, the lowest tech oil you can buy, in fact you may not be able to buy Group 1 in the UK any more.

Since its a straight, single viscosity oil it wont sheer, and will reduce the amount of viscosity index improver (which can sheer, and can also gum up rings.with its breakdown products) in the mix.

Group 1 oil is less chemically stable than more modern higher numbers but has a higher solvency for varnish.

The Mobil Delvac MX is a "quality mineral oil" (probably Group 2) primarily intended for diesel trucks, so it'll have a good helping of detergents.

Engine had sheet varnish when I put this mix in it and its all gone now, which I attribute to the solvency of the G1. The Delvac alone didn't shift it.

CLEEEEEEAN

https://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topics/4884218/engine-after-sitting-in-humid-environment

But as you say, not always so simple.

Engine Oil - Dingle232
I’m happy to go with the recommended grade of oil, my question is more about (for example) whether Shell Helix is better than Mobil 1.

The OEM filter is a given.
Engine Oil - skidpan

Providing the oil meets the requirements of the handbook just use the brand that you want to.

I look out for bargains at places like Asda and snap then up if I need some. Asda don't make oil, they buy it from an oil company. The Asda container I have in the garage is exactly the same shape as that used by Millers Oils but a different colour thus I suspect their source is Millers.

As for filters the only one I have ever had issues with was an OEM Ford one on a Mondeo 2 litre. Never bought a Ford filter since.

Engine Oil - Dingle232

Providing the oil meets the requirements of the handbook just use the brand that you want to.

I look out for bargains at places like Asda and snap then up if I need some. Asda don't make oil, they buy it from an oil company. The Asda container I have in the garage is exactly the same shape as that used by Millers Oils but a different colour thus I suspect their source is Millers.

As for filters the only one I have ever had issues with was an OEM Ford one on a Mondeo 2 litre. Never bought a Ford filter since.

Am inclined to agree skidpan - I will just get the most reasonably priced decent oil of that spec I can find.

One last question - in stating ACEA C2/C3 is this the same as the annotation on Shell Helix Oil of ECT C2/C3? That looks to be the most reasonable priced one - just want to make sure it's the same stuff.

Engine Oil - edlithgow

One last question - in stating ACEA C2/C3 is this the same as the annotation on Shell Helix Oil of ECT C2/C3? That looks to be the most reasonable priced one - just want to make sure it's the same stuff.

I think ECT is a proprietary Shell specification, so not the same as ACEA C3, but they claim the ACEA C3, so it'll meet that as well.

Sometimes this is done on a "meets or exceeds" basis, and the oil isn't actually certified.

Mobil routinely do this with API certifications, (which cost money). They put a "meets or exceeds"statement on the package but it doesn't actually carry the API logo.

Doesn't mean its bad oil.

From a quick look on the Shell site its a bit more ambiguous as to certification, but I believe ACEA, unlike API, don't do testing but just define the standard, which is then self-certified by the manufacturer. This is unlikely to matter in practice.

https://www.ato24.de/en/blog/comparison-0w-30-engine-oils

German comparison of 0W30 oils. Rather unsophisticated, but the Helix comes out as relatively high viscosity, which is of course a good thing.

Edited by edlithgow on 01/08/2019 at 07:17

Engine Oil - Dingle232

One last question - in stating ACEA C2/C3 is this the same as the annotation on Shell Helix Oil of ECT C2/C3? That looks to be the most reasonable priced one - just want to make sure it's the same stuff.

I think ECT is a proprietary Shell specification, so not the same as ACEA C3, but they claim the ACEA C3, so it'll meet that as well.

Sometimes this is done on a "meets or exceeds" basis, and the oil isn't actually certified.

Mobil routinely do this with API certifications, (which cost money). They put a "meets or exceeds"statement on the package but it doesn't actually carry the API logo.

Doesn't mean its bad oil.

From a quick look on the Shell site its a bit more ambiguous as to certification, but I believe ACEA, unlike API, don't do testing but just define the standard, which is then self-certified by the manufacturer. This is unlikely to matter in practice.

https://www.ato24.de/en/blog/comparison-0w-30-engine-oils

German comparison of 0W30 oils. Rather unsophisticated, but the Helix comes out as relatively high viscosity, which is of course a good thing.

Thanks - so if I ordered the Shell Helix ECT C2/C3 it would be fine for my car? Thanks for all the help.

Engine Oil - RT

Most car makers have a deal with one of the big oil companies so that the owners' manual and under-bonnet sticker proclaim they recommend one specific big brand - but if the viscosity/grade/approval is correct then there's no* difference between brands.

* there may be a marginal difference but only detectable by an oil chemist.

Engine Oil - CHarkin

There are many times more brands of oil than manufacturers that make the stuff and even fewer companies that make the additives. The brand name on the bottle is probably the least informative information on it. If a company makes a certain type of oil and sends it off for say two certifications it ends up with three types of oil to sell at three different prices but in fact they are all the same stuff.

For years I used Quantum long life oil, a VW own brand, and over the same years Halfords sold a VW specific oil that was twice the price of the genuine VW stuff. High profit margins and marketing create really stupid situations.

I tend to avoid the big retail brands and prefer to go for the more trade and garage brands that don't do much advertising like Fuchs, Quantum and Comma. When you can buy a 25L drum of oil for less than 2 X 5L bottles it shows how much money is being made at retail outlets.

Edited by CHarkin on 01/08/2019 at 09:56

Engine Oil - Andrew-T

When you can buy a 25L drum of oil for less than 2 X 5L bottles it shows how much money is being made at retail outlets.

And of course one 5L can costs much less than five 1L cans. Most owners of one car who change their oil every year or two probably don't need a whole 5 litres at once, so waste money buying three or even four.

Engine Oil - madf

When you can buy a 25L drum of oil for less than 2 X 5L bottles it shows how much money is being made at retail outlets.

And of course one 5L can costs much less than five 1L cans. Most owners of one car who change their oil every year or two probably don't need a whole 5 litres at once, so waste money buying three or even four.

Or accumulate half empty cans anuntil they have enough for a full oil change..(or use it in a lawn mower)

Engine Oil - RT

When you can buy a 25L drum of oil for less than 2 X 5L bottles it shows how much money is being made at retail outlets.

And of course one 5L can costs much less than five 1L cans. Most owners of one car who change their oil every year or two probably don't need a whole 5 litres at once, so waste money buying three or even four.

Or accumulate half empty cans anuntil they have enough for a full oil change..(or use it in a lawn mower)

Or use the half empty cans to top up the oil between services.

The only time I waste money on oil is when I buy 10 litres for an upcoming oil change and then circumstances force me to change the car - as the new one never uses the same oil specification !!!

Engine Oil - bathtub tom

The only time I waste money on oil is when I buy 10 litres for an upcoming oil change and then circumstances force me to change the car - as the new one never uses the same oil specification !!!

I've got three cans in my garage at the moment that aren't recommended for my car.

Engine Oil - gordonbennet

Handy reminder, as i type the oil is draining nicely out of the Landcruiser, after about 3 hours i'll shine a torch up the drain hole and inspect the oil strainer (directly above the drain), new filter is already on, will refill with the well priced Exol semi synth bought in 20 litre packs.

An interesting things about these oils, now according to the handbook 5w30 is the standard recommendation for these engines, but also in the book it lists all the alternatives depending on the temp ranges expected, these range from 5w30 via 10w30/40 right up to 20w50 being acceptable, the vehicle has no DPF.

I and some other owners have been experimenting with going back to 10w40 Diesel specific oil in our Diesels, (5w40 Diesel oil is rather more difficult to find except for PD spec), what those of us trialling this have noticed is how much quieter the engines are at all times with the oil pressure light going out faster than with the standard petrol/diesel oils.

I've gone back to Diesel specific oil for the specific cleaning properties, and as it's some £46 for 20 litres.

Purely anecdotally, the engine was at its noisiest when using top grade Helix Ultra, changed at the same twice yearly intervals.

Edited by gordonbennet on 01/08/2019 at 14:28

Engine Oil - madf

Just a point re Brexit..

A lot of oil is sold over the internet and delivered straight via plane from the EU and then to door- two days. If we have a hard Brexit, this will stop due to customs .. and take far longer...And cost a lot more..

Engine Oil - Metropolis.
Yes, we can only wonder how the 89% of the world that is NOT in the EU somehow cope!!
Engine Oil - edlithgow

Just a point re Brexit..

A lot of oil is sold over the internet and delivered straight via plane from the EU and then to door- two days. If we have a hard Brexit, this will stop due to customs .. and take far longer...And cost a lot more..

Where were you when you were needed?

I was here. That'd be an OK excuse if you couldn't get a postal vote, but since I didn't enquire, it isn't.

Engine Oil - edlithgow

Handy reminder, as i type the oil is draining nicely out of the Landcruiser, after about 3 hours i'll shine a torch up the drain hole and inspect the oil strainer (directly above the drain), new filter is already on, will refill with the well priced Exol semi synth bought in 20 litre packs.

An interesting things about these oils, now according to the handbook 5w30 is the standard recommendation for these engines, but also in the book it lists all the alternatives depending on the temp ranges expected, these range from 5w30 via 10w30/40 right up to 20w50 being acceptable, the vehicle has no DPF.

I and some other owners have been experimenting with going back to 10w40 Diesel specific oil in our Diesels, (5w40 Diesel oil is rather more difficult to find except for PD spec), what those of us trialling this have noticed is how much quieter the engines are at all times with the oil pressure light going out faster than with the standard petrol/diesel oils.

I've gone back to Diesel specific oil for the specific cleaning properties, and as it's some £46 for 20 litres.

Purely anecdotally, the engine was at its noisiest when using top grade Helix Ultra, changed at the same twice yearly intervals.

The previous generation of 15W40 dual use (say up to SJ/CG) gave pretty good bang for the buck, and if I needed oil I'd probably just try and source a "fleet pack" of that, but I have a variety of stuff to use up.

Here, where it gets quite hot, light commercials (Mitsubishi Canter, etc) seem to use straight 40, and the drivers often use the same stuff in their private cars, though this is almost certainly not approved by the manufacturer.

My Ford Sierra DOHC 2L,for example, hydraulic tappets and all, came with a jug of straight Mobil Delvac 40. Seemed fine.

Assuming Taiwanese truck drivers know what they are doing is probably unwise, and I don't, necessarily, though their vehicles cost a whole lot more than mine did.

I bought the SAE40 to use in a motorcycle gearbox, and the 50:50 mix with Delvac MX 15W40 was an emergency response to a massive oil leak.

However, it seems to have worked out rather well. A British oil formulator, posting on an American website, said it would be pretty close to a 20W40 (which are rare but do apparently exist) which, apart from fuel economy, were the most robust oils he'd ever tested.

IIRC he used a phrase equivalent to "The mutts nuts" though since he was posting on an American website he used the British equivalent, which would probably activate the Mary Whitehouse Module here.

Testing, testing ""The dogs b******s""

Thought so.

Found it

https://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php/topics/4865769/re-can-too-thick-of-oil-be-damaging#Post4865769

The thread its in contains some very good technical iinfo on the "Thick versus Thin" question, almost definitive.

If you can be bothered to try and sort the wood from the trees, Shannow and Sonofjoe both tend to know whereof they speak,

I'd forgotten the plusses for 20W50, but I used some very old Mobil 20W50 I found in an abandoned shed for my current fil, so that's covered.l

Edited by edlithgow on 02/08/2019 at 05:37

Engine Oil - edlithgow

When you can buy a 25L drum of oil for less than 2 X 5L bottles it shows how much money is being made at retail outlets.

And of course one 5L can costs much less than five 1L cans. Most owners of one car who change their oil every year o two probably don't need a whole 5 litres at once, so waste money buying three or even four.

Here a 5L (or 4L) jug is quite often more than the 1L equivalent. Sometimes the 1L's are in fact US quarts, but not always.

Just the Taiwanese doing their "Ïrish of Asia" thing I suppose.

Engine Oil - edlithgow
I was about to say check the manual, and in the vast majority of cases it’s correct provided you choose the one listed for our climate. However, in the case of mine with the engine designed in the 60s, (my car is 2004!) the modern oils don’t contain adequate ZDDP and the dealers tend to go for too light an oil as well, so following the advice of RPI engineering, I use Valvoline 20w50 mineral racing oil, the rover v8 just isn’t designed for full synthetic. The answer isn’t always simple! However seeing as you’ve got a honda with a relatively new design i would just follow the handbook.. Edit: And make sure you buy genuine Honda filters, or at least find the honda OEM if their is one. Not worth skimping and there is a difference!

You aren't concerned about catalyst poisoning?

I don't have to worry about that, since I don't have one.

If I have to worry about it in the future (if there is a future) I don't know whether I will.