What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Cataract Surgery - skidpan

First I must say that I am not criticising the NHS since I think its a marvelous institution that we all should be immensely grateful for. What I am asking is why individual trusts/consultants appear to be interpreting the rules differently at different times.

2 years ago at my 6 monthly Glaucoma check up I was told that I had a developing Cataract in my right eye.

Last October I was told that in 6 months time (April this year) it would require removing and since I was short sighted I would get both eyes done to synchronize my vision

In April I was told that I did not quite meet the requirements but would do so in October.

In October I was told that the rules had changed and that I did not meet the requirements any longer. The consultant suggested to me that I should lie when I read the chart at my next check up in April about what I could read and this would get me on the list. He also suggested that I say that my vision in the eye affected by the cataracts did not improve when I viewed the chart through the pin holes. He also suggested getting re-referred by my optometrist.

The following week I went to get my annual sight test at my regular optometrist and told him about what had happened and had been told to do, he was furious. Basically he said that this hospital trust was doing this all the time and needed stopping. Regarding the things that had been suggested:

Lying when I read the chart was a definite non starter, this would possibly lead to the wrong lens being fitted if surgery was approved.

Lying about the pin holes not improving vision would ensure I did not get cataract surgery since it proved that my vision loss would be macular degeneration linked which would mean surgery would not improve my vision and mean I did not meet the criteria.

Being re-refereed would only succeed in putting me to the back of the queue.

After testing my eyes he confirmed that I met the guidelines for surgery and he also confirmed that they had not changed since April this year.

He suggested that I make another appointment and confront him about the decision.

Did this and also visited my GP who agreed that I met the guidelines and wrote the consultant a letter.

So this morning I went to see the consultant. As soon as I walked through the door he told me that I would be getting the surgery in both eyes with no argument whatsoever, first eye in 8 to 10 weeks, earlier if there is a cancellation. Nothing has changed in 2 months, when I read the chart at the hospital this morning I was able to read the exact same lines as I did 2 months ago.

Obviously not going to complain now but I do wonder how many people are missing out when they actually meet the guidelines.

Is it a case of you only get if you ask?

Cataract Surgery - Palcouk

Personally up to now I've never had any problems with consults and any surgery required was carried out promptly (Aortic Anurism) My wife however has had problems, we usually get round these by haveing a Private Consult (we have small health plan which pays a preportion) after the consult the Consultant then arranges a prompt appointment on his NHS list for any follow up required.

Cataract Surgery - John F

Is it a case of you only get if you ask?

Partly. The threshold of referral for surgery (assuming the patient desires it and has accepted the risks) is not quite as clear cut as you might think. It is easy enough to state an arbitrary cut-off point, e.g.....

www.sath.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Thresho...f

...but the reality can be more complex and will vary from one patient to another - illustrated by this link if you can bear to plough through it...

www.rcophth.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/2010-...f

NICE also has verbose, voluminous and to my mind rather unhelpful guidelines.

There might be a 'post-code lottery' of variable thresholds according to the availability of Trust funding, or the enthusiasm of eye surgeons to maintain their activity levels.

It's a bit like deciding if and when to replace an old blurry pock-marked windscreen. In the old days a cataract was visible at five paces (a white pupil) before anyone would countenance surgery!

Cataract Surgery - Vitesse6

No experience of ophthalmic services, but when I enquired about varicose vein surgery the GP was sorry but no point referring me as the local clinical commissioning group was refusing referrals even those that met NICE guidelines.

No clinical reason to refuse referrals, purely financial. GP was just as angry as me but CCG says no!

Cataract Surgery - RT

Like many things in the NHS, it's the way something affects your lifestyle which determines whether you qualify for a particular treatment.

My cataracts were first diagnosed a couple of decades ago but like many people's, they only developed very slowly until suddenly they "ripened" and dropped my prescription from 6+ down to under 1, requiring new glasses every 2-3 months.

In theory I didn't qualify for an NHS operation as my corrected vision was always 6/6 (20/20) - what did qualify was the effect of the cataracts on my driving at nght and in the wet, making it unsafe to do so - as driving was/is a necessary and fundamental part of my life, that over-ruled the visual acuity requirement.

Cataract Surgery - skidpan

Update.

Cataract surgery 12 February and it was fine. Arrived about 1 pm, 9th out of 12 to be done that afternoon, discharged at 4.15 pm.

Saw consultant 4 weeks later (on a Sunday morning) and was told to go ahead and get new specs and then decide if I wanted the other eye doing. No cataract but apparently some people cannot cope with the imbalance between the 2 prescriptions. So far I have had no issues with this.

Had my eyes tested a week later and said thanks but no thanks to their kind offer of £500 for one pair of Varifocals. Took the prescription to Specsavers and got 2 pairs of Varifocals (one with a medium tint like I have had before) and a pair of single vision readers for £330, happier with that.

When the brighter weather arrived early May I soon found that the medium tint which was fine for driving etc was now a bit ineffective with my new lens implant when out walking etc on really bright days. Tried to get a suitable clip on but the ones I had used before were over £40 and none fitted the frame correctly.

So on the advice of a friend I went to Asda armed with my prescription. Chose a frame from their all in £45 range and that includes varifocal lenses if you need them, anti scratch and anti gale coatings. It also includes a free tint should you wish thus I chose the darker one. They decide what thickness lens you get, my stronger one dictated a 1.67 lens which is thinner than the Specsavers ones.

I was sceptical to say the least about what I would get but lets say that 2 months later I am more than happy. No more Specsavers varifocals for me, Asda every time but I will still use Specsavers for my readers, £25 all in is a £20 saving over Asdas best.

Only problems I have had were 6 weeks after the surgery I got conjunctivitis (probably unconnected) and then 2 weeks later further discomfort made me make another Sunday appointment (8.30 this time) with the consultant who told me I now have Blepharitis in both eyes and need more long term drops (probably unconnected again).

Visual field check early August and consultant early September for my regular twice a year check up for Glaucoma and here's hoping all is fine, it certainly seems to be.

Cataract Surgery - Chris M

+1 for Asda Opticians. I've been using them for about 15 years including the eye test itself.

After sale service has been excellent. Had a frame break outside of the guarantee period so they swapped my frame with the display pair. Lost a screw which they fixed while I waited and have readjusted the frame when they got a little bent. When I first tried switching to varifocal and didn't like them, they remade both pairs as single vision foc.

I'm sure some other opticians give similar service, but you don't really expect it at Asda prices.

Cataract Surgery - sammy1

we usually get round these by having a Private Consult (we have small health plan which pays a preportion) after the consult the Consultant then arranges a prompt appointment on his NHS list for any follow up required.

Yes, and this is the rub, this should not be allowed it happens in all areas whereby a private consultation putting inflated sums into a private hospital and consultants pocket. The hours the consultant works privately could be put into lowering the waiting lists and giving a even shake for all.

Cataract Surgery - Avant

Good luck with the next lot of eye tests, Skidpan.

I wear glasses all the time, and as an alternative to clip-ons, I've found that overglasses work very well - just slip them on over your glasses. Mine are made by Duco - under £20 from Amazon.

Cataract Surgery - skidpan

I wear glasses all the time, and as an alternative to clip-ons, I've found that overglasses work very well - just slip them on over your glasses. Mine are made by Duco - under £20 from Amazon.

I bought a couple of pairs of fit overs about 10 years ago. I was diagnosed with dry eye and found that after driving the Caterham I would suffer discomfort for a couple of days. Bought 2 pairs from our local garden centre, £12 a pair. one was the yellow night vision type (for when I was out at night - not very often but they were actually great on dull days) and the other a grey tint for normal weather. Both had UVA and UVB and good distortion free lenses. Worked a treat in the car, no more sore eyes, but when out walking I found the large frames to be quite distracting and they made photography using the viewfinder impossible.

Since getting the cataract sorted and buying the prescription sunglasses I have bought a pair of clear safety overspecs from a company called i-sunglasses and they are really great in the Caterham. Not cheap, about £20 but as well as UVA and UVB they have shatterproof lenses, potentially useful in the Caterham.