What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
any - autonomous cars when? - gordonbennet

Not as soon as those trousering massive grants and investments might be insinuating?

Interesting article in Spectator about this subject, i'm a subscriber (its the only media slightly leaning in the direction of mainstream that i bother with), but if i recall correctly you can read the odd article online without the paywall triggering.

www.spectator.co.uk/2018/07/the-dream-of-driverles.../

any - autonomous cars when? - Bolt

there has been several articles relating to the problems in getting a real working autonomous car in full use on the road, and one is memory constraints in that to store all scenarios that a driver would deal with would need storage so great it would take up most of the car

I suspect its costing more than its worth anyway in r&d which the money should be spent on improving EV range and battery storage

any - autonomous cars when? - alan1302

Think most people know they won't be here that quickly - just the car companies that are developing that think it will be quick which is ually the way with companies. Fully autonomous cars are a huge challenge but will come eventually.

any - autonomous cars when? - FP

Probably the first stage to be reached will be autonomous driving on specific, designated roads - motorways, dual carriageways. The real challenges are urban roads.

However, taking a journey on a motorway where the software draws not only information from the immediate environment (adjusting distance from the vehicle in front, lane changing and so on), but is fed with the larger picture about traffic density up to several miles ahead, could make for a more relaxed drive and, if enough vehicles are using the system (because at first there will be a mixture of driver-controlled cars and autonomous ones) the journey could actually be quicker and more fuel-efficient.

any - autonomous cars when? - Miniman777

The longer they have tech problems, the better. I dont want to be atuononimously controlled. If I want to travel where someone else does the driving, I get a cab or use the train.

You can stick this tech where the sun wont shine. Barmy as the Government wanting lorry platooning when there is an adequate railway network.

any - autonomous cars when? - Bolt

Think most people know they won't be here that quickly - just the car companies that are developing that think it will be quick which is ually the way with companies. Fully autonomous cars are a huge challenge but will come eventually.

It really comes down to how big company pockets are in R&D and if there is a chance the public will accept them, I`m now sceptical they will take off and you are more likely to see autonomous robots than cars, they will be more usefull and labour costs will be nill using them?

any - autonomous cars when? - alan1302

It really comes down to how big company pockets are in R&D and if there is a chance the public will accept them, I`m now sceptical they will take off and you are more likely to see autonomous robots than cars, they will be more usefull and labour costs will be nill using them?

With companies like Google interesed in in the R&D costs probably won't phase them as long as they think they can make money out of it at the end of the day.

And even a robot has running costs - and they tend to be very complex

any - autonomous cars when? - Bolt

It really comes down to how big company pockets are in R&D and if there is a chance the public will accept them, I`m now sceptical they will take off and you are more likely to see autonomous robots than cars, they will be more usefull and labour costs will be nill using them?

With companies like Google interesed in in the R&D costs probably won't phase them as long as they think they can make money out of it at the end of the day.

And even a robot has running costs - and they tend to be very complex

even waymo is not thinking of getting the autonomous car on general sale untill 2025 at the earliest and alphabet, parent company of waymo, has the cash to throw away which so many projects have been, so I wouldnt rely on them to finish the project

as for robots, they are complex anyway, due to electronics involved but movement wise they must be faster and cheaper to run than they used to be and even the NHS is going to use them for operations, it was even mentioned MPs could be replaced by them now that would be something

We dont need a robot prime minister, we already have one lol

any - autonomous cars when? - colinh

Never! Find it difficult to disagree with this Autocar editorial:

"KUDOS TO BMW UK’s special advisor, Ian Robertson, for breaking ranks with so many senior spokespeople in the car industry and saying what we all really thought: fully ‘brainof’ autonomous cars are unlikely to ever happen .

It’s refreshing to hear such an influential industry executive speak in such a frank way. As Robertson says, the denial of full autonomy won’t be due to technical limitations from the car makers’ side, but more because of legal and moral arguments. How can a machine ever decide who lives or who dies? That simply cannot be answered.

So where does that leave the fully autonomous car? Not going around the M25 with a ‘driver’ reading a newspaper, that’s for sure. Instead, the brain-of autonomous car won’t even be a car at all, but likely shuttle pods limited to controlled environments. Autonomy will still have its place, though, in the form of specific features – the types of ever-improving safety, parking and driver assistance technologies that can take the strain of driving for those who’d like to, and the option to turn them of for those who don’t. As Robertson also reassuringly says, every BMW in the future will also have a steering wheel."

any - autonomous cars when? - Oli rag

Legally i think it's a minefield. If a self driving car has an accident in full autonomous mode, who is responsible?

I've heard that Tesla have a " drop you off and I'll park myself mode" as a future option. Who is responsible if " your car" hits something or someone whilst parking itself?

More questions than answers on the subject of autonomous cars, I think the lawyers will have a field day.

any - autonomous cars when? - sandy56

There was a recent article on AUTOCAR quoting a senior manager at JLR that autonomous cars wont happen for decades. The technical challenges are huge and no fixes in sight, so dont expect it anytime soon.

any - autonomous cars when? - Leif
I’ve recently bought a new car, and they can’t even make basic electrical systems work reliably. Emergency brake assist goes off for no reason. Wipers failed. Radio won’t turn off. CarPlay crashes. Key won’t open the door. And they want to make a car that drives itself on the basis of inputs from electronic sensors? They’re avin’ a larf.

However, it might be that the only manufacturers that can make safe autonomous cars are Japanese.
any - autonomous cars when? - Bolt

However, it might be that the only manufacturers that can make safe autonomous cars are Japanese.

This could be interesting then.....

media.jaguar.com/news/2018/03/waymo-and-jaguar-lan...g

any - autonomous cars when? - Sofa Spud

The development of autonomous cars is occurring at the same time as the development of electric cars, and the two are somewhat interlinked because electric car technology lends itself to autonomous technology.

. . . But I don't see the two trends continuing together at the same rate.

The move to electric cars has begun in earnest and I can only see the pace picking up on this.

But while there are autonomous cars running in trials around the world, they are not foolproof yet and there's not the same public desire for autonomous cars as there seems to be for electric ones.

Instead the autonomous technology will continue to spin off into driver aids, intelligent speed limiting and suchlike, some way short of true 'driverless'.

any - autonomous cars when? - Leif

However, it might be that the only manufacturers that can make safe autonomous cars are Japanese.

This could be interesting then.....

media.jaguar.com/news/2018/03/waymo-and-jaguar-lan...g

I think you missed the point I was making. It’s all very well Jaguar making an announcement, but we know how unreliable cars are, including Jaguar. Do you really think they can be reliable enough that self driving will work? I don’t.

any - autonomous cars when? - Bolt

I think you missed the point I was making

No

it might be that the only manufacturers that can make safe autonomous cars are Japanese.

I was surprised they were going to use Jaguar knowing how unreliable they are and the amount involved, it could be interesting to see if their reliability will improve/or not.. I doubt autonomous cars will make it to market unless they are used as taxis, but who knows

imo they should spend the cash on getting more hybrids on the road untill there are much more EVs charging points around and improved range

autonomous perfection is a long way off

any - autonomous cars when? - SteVee

>>autonomous perfection is a long way off<<

So where are some working examples of automation ?
Aircraft can take off and land without pilot action - and can fly from one way-point to another. They've been able to do this for some time - but no-one wants to fly in aircraft that have no pilots.
We've had fully-automated trains for some time - and I think they're successful. Why are other rail services not automated ? Is it really only unions that are stopping this ?

What else ? Robot vacuum cleaners exist, but aren't really successful (could this be extended to robot pot-hole repairers and street cleaners ?)
Why has Robot-wars never produced an autonomous fighting robot ?

Car factories have long-used robots for vehicle production - but they're just following a defined sequence. They may deviate on safety grounds, but there is very little intelliigence in there.

There are many examples where I would expect to see automation before cars, and these are just not appearing

any - autonomous cars when? - Sofa Spud

>>autonomous perfection is a long way off<<

So where are some working examples of automation ?
Aircraft can take off and land without pilot action - and can fly from one way-point to another. They've been able to do this for some time - but no-one wants to fly in aircraft that have no pilots.
We've had fully-automated trains for some time - and I think they're successful. Why are other rail services not automated ? Is it really only unions that are stopping this ?

What else ? Robot vacuum cleaners exist, but aren't really successful (could this be extended to robot pot-hole repairers and street cleaners ?)
Why has Robot-wars never produced an autonomous fighting robot ?

Car factories have long-used robots for vehicle production - but they're just following a defined sequence. They may deviate on safety grounds, but there is very little intelliigence in there.

There are many examples where I would expect to see automation before cars, and these are just not appearing

All the examples of fully automated trains I can think of are on self-contained railways designed from the outset for automation, e.g. the Docklands Light Railway or the Dubai Metro. It would be much more difficult to automate an existing railway shared by different types of trains on different journeys.

any - autonomous cars when? - expat
What else ? Robot vacuum cleaners exist, but aren't really successful

My Xiaomi robot vacuum is actually very good. OK - the missus grumbles that it doesn't do the picture rails but I find it does the floors fine and I don't want it climbing the walls. Have a look at reviews for it on the net. I am not the only person who thinks it is good.

any - autonomous cars when? - FoxyJukebox

Ah yes- these are the cars that are completely automatic and drive themselves. Great-nothing can go wrong, can go wrong ,can go wrong, can go wrong...

any - autonomous cars when? - gordonbennet

Doesn't appear too many here are holding their breath for the arrival of driverless cars then.

The more intrusive systems, ie lane departure, automatic emergency braking and terrain adaptive cruise control (lorries), and to some extent traction and stability controls (again lorries) we already have, i'm not exactly impressed by so far, so there is no way i want a vehicle that has any input on steering, nor do i want a steering system that isn't connected mechanically, let alone allow the vehicle to have complete control, that IMHO is generations away if it ever becomes reality on open shared roads.

Edited by gordonbennet on 10/07/2018 at 15:09

any - autonomous cars when? - Terry W

There seems to be an underpinning assumption that conventional manufacturers will dominate future sales of autonomous vehicles. However success may be lead by IT or aerospace specialists with jaguar, ford, VW etc etc simply providing the largely low tech packaging.

It also seems likely that much of the development and trouble shooting will be in markets with more limited litigation culture so that what comes to UK will already be largely proven..

As to when - I would expect them to be rolled out for certain uses in conrrollabe conditions within 5 - 7 years with full rollout in 10 - 12 years.

any - autonomous cars when? - SteVee

>>All the examples of fully automated trains I can think of are on self-contained railways designed from the outset for automation<<

Exactly - how many of our roads are designed for automated machines ? How many of the users on those roads have been trained for their use ? The industry appears to have chosen one of the most complex automation processes possible, and wants to do it before any other large scale automation involving untrained users. Let's do easier projects first and try to learn something in the process.

Thanks for the details on the Xiaomi robot vacuum - I'm pleased to see some projects actually produce something usable.

any - autonomous cars when? - Sofa Spud

As I said in a post above, I think it will be a long time before fully autonomous cars become anything more than experimental. Production cars that do have an autopilot system still require a qualified and alert driver behind the wheel to grab hold of it of stamp on the brake if need be. As the adoption of electric cars gathers pace, full autonomy will lag further and further behind.

If and when we do start to move to autonomous vehicles, we'll start to see the road infrastructure being modified to make more suitable for them.

any - autonomous cars when? - Terry W

I don't think energy source (electric or oil) is connected to the method of control - they are independant but coincidendentally being developed at the same time

I do expect however that autonomous will be fitted to electic vehicles first if for no other reason than govts around the world are legislating againg ICE.

And whilst as individuals we may consider ourselves top notch drivers - alert, aware, thoughtful etc - the realitty is that most are not - hence 3000 fatalities on UK road pa.