Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - patters1978
Hi guys

I'm looking to get a estate! Lol

And have been looking at the 2 mentioned above..
I have seen 2 cars going for around my budget of £5500 -£6000

BMW 520d se touring auto

Audi A6 advant sline auto

Both have 2.0 Diesel engines, sat nav and full leather etc and have around 100k on the clock
Both look good just can't really decide the best one

I have only owned VW in the past (and no I don't want a Passat lol)
Something different this time around?

Cheers
Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - RT

Test drive them both - then decide which YOU like best - they were/are aimed at slightly different segments of the premium sector.

Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - Steveieb
Count the Audi out in that spec as it has a potentially troublesome engine and auto box.

The A6 to go for is the 3.0 Tdi coupled to a manual gearbox and if possible Quattro drive train.
Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - Avant

You may not want to hear this, but you'll get a newer Mondeo estate (and a lot more room) for your budget than you would an Audi or BMW. Does your annual mileage justify a diesel? If not a petrol might be less of a risk.

The advantage of Mondeos is that there are plenty to choose from. Alternatively you could try to find a Toyota Avensis, Mazda 6 (but don't go near a Mazda diesel) or Honda Accord Tourer.

Whatever you go for, make sure it's got a full service history.

Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - Engineer Andy

What amazes me is that after all the horror stories about the huge bills that are likely to occur when owning an older German/non-Japanese premimum car, people on an obvious small budget still want to buy the blighters! Badge snobbery still reigns supreme!

One major problem (of many which can occur wuite esily in such cars, as is well documented in the Good & Bad sections of the car-by-car reviews here) will result in the car being an effective write-off due to the huge cost of major replacement parts, such as engines or gearboxes.

I always assumed that people on a budget mean that they buy a cheaper car which they can afford to run for a good few years, not just write off when it goes wrong for the first time - they may as well (as you've said) go for a newer, far more reliable, less 'fashionable' car which will last longer and cost less to run.

Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - Graham567

I have had my Mondeo for 6 years now from new and i still love it.I no intention of getting rid of it.Highly underated cars with masses of space.Very refined,cheap to service and if you go for a higher model,then lots of toys that are genuinely useful.Just make sure you go for the 2.0 diesel,not the 1.8 which is underpowered and more noisy.

Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - John F

The big difference is one is RWD, the other is FWD or 4WD. If this is a long term family car for every day use there will be times when you will wish you had, or will be grateful for, at least FWD (snowy hills, wet fields etc).

Bmw 5 series or Audi A6 07/08 - gordonbennet

Thought it was only me, to be perfectly honest a German car of this type, marque age engine combination, is the very last car i'd want to own.

Some good advice above.