What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks
The new state pension - FoxyJukebox

Yes--the new state pension seems to be a difficult one to understand with many anomalies. BUT the one complaint I keep reading about more than anything is from those who have contracted out of "serps" wailing and gnashing that they will not be getting the full new state pension amount of £155 after their 35 years of contributions. Surely with their second pension (company pension?) plus their lower due state pension-the two pensions together should well exceed the £155 figure? That's the deal.

It is those who get the £155 and not contributed to anything else over 35 years who should be worried.

The new state pension - dimdip

Every benefit should be properly means-tested in these days of austerity. Dirt-poor single unemployed people with less than a tenner a day to live on are vilified, while wealthy retired folk and high-earning parents get money thrown at them. <shrugs>

Edited by dimdip on 03/04/2016 at 12:42

The new state pension - Falkirk Bairn

>>Every benefit should be properly means-tested in these days of austerity.

Agreed

Sorry - I am OAP and receive £120 / week or thereabouts BUT it is not a benefit - it is a Entitlement / Pension.

I paid NI, and to all intents & purposes drew nothing other than say "10 / 12 weeks sick pay", over 40+ years

It is taxed @ 20% in my case so receive a net Entitlement /State Pension of £96 / week.

The new state pension - dadbif
Well said Falkirk Bairn, I get sick of all of the countries woes being blamed on the "aging population", it is only thanks to the people who have paid NI contributions throughout their working lives that there are funds to pay for the treatment of today's younger generations.
As for pensions being a "benefit", we only get back what we have paid in, and still pay tax on it! We do not get anything for free....
The new state pension - Bromptonaut

FB & dadbif,

While you might have been led to believe your NI's were being put aside to meet your pension the reality is that they were paying those of youd parents an grandparents.

The new state pension - galileo

FB & dadbif,

While you might have been led to believe your NI's were being put aside to meet your pension the reality is that they were paying those of youd parents an grandparents.

Absolutely correct, Bromp. My first wife's uncle was high up in the Ministry of Pensions when Wilson was PM, he pointed out to Harold that NI/pensions was a Ponzi scheme, this week's pensions relying on last week's NI + taxes.

Unsurprisingly, no Government has changed this system much due to the political cost of the necessary changes; Gordon Brown's raid on company pension schemes' tax relief was the kiss of death for final salary pensions (except for the public sector and MP's, of course!)

The new state pension - Falkirk Bairn

>> the kiss of death for final salary pensions (except for the public sector and MP's, of >>course!)

Civil Service, MPs, Police, NHS, Fire Brigade, Teachers.....are all Ponzi Schemes.... there is no POT OF MONEY - pay this week's Pensions from last week's contributions.

Many Government Schemes fall foul of this - Fire Brigade in Scotland had to be bailed out as they pay out more per year than they get in.

Edited by Falkirk Bairn on 04/04/2016 at 13:21

The new state pension - gordonbennet

So where does the money come from to bail out civil service or other govt/council pensions when the pot runs dry i wonder, wouldn't be from the tax paid by those who weren't so fortunate when Brown needed money to prop up Blair's regime surely.

The new state pension - Bromptonaut

So where does the money come from to bail out civil service or other govt/council pensions when the pot runs dry i wonder, wouldn't be from the tax paid by those who weren't so fortunate when Brown needed money to prop up Blair's regime surely.

With the notable exception of Local Government (and posibly other associated schemes) few public sector schemes have a fund. The Civil Service scheme has always been paid for on basis that retired members pensions are an ongoing liability for the tax payer. There is some jiggery pokery over who's budget the money comes from - early retirees are a liability of their employing department until they reach normal pension age.

The latest budget shifted even more of the ongoing cost back onto department's current budgets. In the NHS for example the effect is to claw back some of the much trumpeted increase/ring fencing.

Edited by Bromptonaut on 04/04/2016 at 16:59

The new state pension - concrete

There are always iniquities in any system. The state pension is one of them.

Firstly the big trick about the National Insutance Fund is; There is NO FUND.

Pensions, as most benefits, are paid straight from Treasury income as it comes in, it goes out. There is no huge fund invested to provide the income, unlike private pension savings. This is the biggest Ponsy Scheme in the universe and if it was operated by a company they would be shut down and prosecuted.

I was contracted out of Serps for about 10 years and consequently I receive less state pension, however the Serps contributions were placed into my private scheme and I get the benefit that way. So it works out pretty much the same. SWMBO has recently claimed her state pension and she falls short of the birthday deadline so is receiving about £15 less per week than someone who may never have worked all their life and not saved anything. Not fair maybe, but the line was drawn and that is it. It is much cheaper to pay a universal benefit than to means test or attempt to target it. Fact of life. Fair or unfair. To paraphrase that famous American saying: You can't fight City Hall.

Cheers Concrete

The new state pension - RT

The huge unfairness is that those retiring BEFORE the New State Pension came in, may be receiving much less that the £155/week.

SWMBO who paid full contributions but "retired" 7 years ago still only gets £120/week, not the £155 that some retiring recently gets.

The new state pension - concrete

Hello RT. I fully sympathise with your situation. The sad part is that all the information needed to predict your future state pension was and is available. The trouble is, it is so convoluted you need to be a fully qualified accountant and lawyer to decipher it. We all could have easily enhanced our state pensions had we been able to decipher the rules and had the foresight to implement some small changes years ago. Just like the tax system it is a simple proposition made into a byzantine one because it does not benefit the government to have it's citizens understand any system used to part them from their money. SWMBO is in the same boat as your wife. The birthday lottery strikes again. She doesn't complain though because her sister who is a year younger has to wait until she is 66 to collect her pension. Over 3 years difference in pension payments because of a 1 year age gap. Now that is a kick in the whatsits. Cheers Concrete

The new state pension - Kia Ora

If "SWMBO" wants to qualify for the higher rate she needs to be in the age bracket that has to wait longer to claim it. Those due the higher pension are having to wait longer to receive it. "SWMBO" may not have the higher rate but she did retire ealier, unlike me I have to wait until I am 67.

Must be nice to have a pension at age 60. Stop moaning.

The new state pension - Ian91

I have over 30 years but less than 35, now retired, but under state pension age. I was told that making up previous years contributions in my case, would not increase my pension. I could however add to the amount I would get by @ £4.45/wk by paying class 3 voluntary contributions, as this is £14.10 a week (£733.2 a year) for Class 3 an alternative I was thinking of was having a go at self employment for a couple of years as the class 2 rate is £2.80 a week (£145.60 a year).

Has anyone used this approach to increase their state pension now the goal posts have changed, also I cannot afford the £733/yr voluntary NI payments. The payment would increase the pension by £231/yr and would take @3 years to claw back the £733 payment but the pension would increase each year.

(nb the class 2 rate/category will be changing in 2018)

Not too sure what to do if I do go self employed as HMRC guide on self employment is a bit sketchy and not really doing this to make loads of money but enough to pay the lower voluntary N I contribution.

Edited by Ian91 on 31/05/2016 at 15:24

The new state pension - Falkirk Bairn

My wife worked for roughly 8 years after graduating - then brought up the 3 kids+ looked after her mother for some 25+ years (died 97 yo)

Pension contribution were 8 years, credit for 20 years - she was entitled to around £30 / week - we bought 7 years (IIRC) some £3,000 at the time which increase it to about £67/ week - she had to live about 2 years to get the lump sum back. 11 years on she is well in pocket for what was a modest investment.

What we did not know, and found out fairly recently, she would have earned a BIGGER pension had her mother claimed £70 / week carers allowance for looking after her.

i.e. By not claiming Carer's Allowance the government saved money - now for not claiming she is penalised - seems unfair.

The new state pension - Falkirk Bairn

>>Not too sure what to do if I do go self employed as HMRC guide on self >>employment is a bit sketchy and not really doing this to make loads of >>money but enough to pay the lower voluntary N I contribution.

Self Employed is £2.80 / week + 12%(IIRC) of the earnings - so not cheap if you earn a realistic take home pay.

The new state pension - Ian91
Good point, the main idea was to pay class 2 NI if I register as self employed sole trader it would only be on a small scale, with small scale profit.