There seems to be a dearth of real, hard facts both about the benefits of staying and the consequences of leaving. Each side seems to think they can provide a clinching argument, but I don't think one exists. People will have to vote with their hearts.
However, it's worth remembering that "leaving" could mean a whole range of relationships with Europe, from having absolutely nothing to do with it (unlikely, in view of our geographical proximity) to having extensive trade agreements and other links - sporting, cultural and so on. The difference would be that these would not be framed within the protocols of the EU.
There have been arguments made about those who represent, or claim to represent, each side of the issue. For example, some say they could never be bedfellows with Farage and UKIP. To make this the criterion for a decision is idiotic, of course. It is not a party-political matter either.
Then there is the matter of Cameron's concessions. These are probably too insignificant in themselves to make much difference in the long term - no doubt to Cameron's chagrin. Doubt has been cast on whether they are water-tight and there is no guarantee that future legislation by the EU would not nullify any special status of the UK.
Despite claims by the "remain" camp that we have be in the EU in order to influence its evolution to our benefit, we have to remember the significance of the "European Project" - ever-closer union. That is exactly what Germany and France want - eventually. Logically that means political and economic union. Do the British want to be part of that, and as the Project moves forward, for how long could we expect to be in Europe but not part of it?
There are those who believe the EU is doomed anyway, with or without the UK. The strains of supporting the single currency have been huge, and at the heart of those problems is the cultural difference between member states. The mind-set of your average Greek is very different from the German-in-the-street and their attitudes towards rules, regulations, taxes, the work-ethic and so on are disparate.
The thing that gets me is the wastefulness of the institutions of the EU, the parliamentary expenses, the cost of the constant monthly re-location between Brussels and Strasbourg (once memorably described as “the farce of the EU travelling circus”), the lack of accountability and transparency, the incessant stream of often trivial bureaucratic regulations which no-one reads or understands.
It’s not as if I’m anti-Europe; I speak French reasonably well, and a bit of German. I’m a musician and music is one of those things that unites countries. I’m aware of the historical and cultural heritage we share with Europe. My wife is Polish. And yet…
It just seems to me that the EU has become some kind of weird monstrosity.
Edited by FP on 02/03/2016 at 16:54
|