(Translated from the French by Mr Google)
Contrary to the belief of most people, subjected to continual political propaganda and industry, the electric car is no more virtuous to the climate than the thermal car, petrol or diesel.
These are the findings of a study, already old, the Agency of Environment and Energy Management (ADEME), deliberately ignored by the Frence government (Development according to the principles of LCA of energy balance sheets, gas emissions of greenhouse gases and other environmental impacts resulting from all sectors of electric vehicles and internal combustion vehicles by 2012 and 2020, November 2013).
The most crucial factor is that the manufacture of the batteries is so emitting CO 2 that we must have traveled 50 000-100 000 km in electric car to start to be less producer of CO 2 a thermal car. Or from 15 to 30 km a day, 365 days a year, for 10 years!
Knowing that these cars are primarily used for short trips, it is likely that the mileage necessary to estimate "virtuous" will never be reached. In addition, all the CO 2 emitted by an electric car is sent into the atmosphere even before any read or kilometer, while the thermal car emits its CO 2 over time ...
Furthermore, it is claimed that all the electric car does not emit fine particles. But as reports the magazine Science et Vie (January 2015), the "es tires, brakes and road wear emit almost as much as diesel microparticles". While the electric car emits fewer particles than the thermal car, since it does not have a muffler, but it has good brakes, tires and rolling on the tarmac!
In the end, the electric car is not more environmentally friendly than the thermal car. Public money spent on its development is therefore totally unjustified. However, these are astronomical:
- The government launched an installation plan 7 million charging stations at about 10,000 euros each at a cost of about 70 billion euros. Moreover, it is poignant to see the elected officials of small communes, believing to do something for the environment, breaking the municipal piggy bank to afford a terminal;
- The "green" bonus with the purchase of an electric car exceeds 10,000 euros per vehicle, often supplemented by a premium in the region. Almost all buyers are wealthier households: Once again, all the money is available to more privileged.
In reality, the land of the atom, all means are good to "boost" the consumption of electricity in continuous decline for years. For the electric car in France can be regarded as a "nuclear drive": almost all of the installed charging stations are connected to the regular power grid, 80% nuclear.
Do not let deceive by the certificates put forward by Bolloré and its Autolib (Paris), Bluecub (Bordeaux) and Bluely (Lyon), ensuring that they are recharged with renewable energy: there is only of games writing; the electricity used is the same as elsewhere.
We do not just here promoting thermal car, itself an environmental calamity. But, in fact, no one would have the idea of offering 10,000 euros to buy a diesel car, her book parking spaces and fill his tank at a knockdown price! ...
En savoir plus sur www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2015/10/23/emissio...9
|