Ask Honest John

Honest John Ask Honest John » Jag X-Type or Mercedes-Benz C220?
What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Jag X-Type or Mercedes-Benz C220?

I am planning to change my 2007 Mercedes-Benz C200CDI automatic as I have now done 65,000 miles. I am considering a 2009 Jag X-Type Sovereign auto or a 2009 Mercedes-Benz C220 auto with satellite navigation. I love the equipment and looks of the Jag and the price is £2000 less than the Merc. Which would be a better vehicle for 15-20,000 miles a year? I am unsure how the cars compare for reliability, which is important as I use my car for work. Does the Jag have a cam chain? The service intervals on the Jag are shorter but services are cheaper.

Asked on 24 August 2010 by John Uxb

Answered by Honest John
All the Jag engines are chain cam, whether petrol or diesel. All Mercedes-Benz engines are chain cam. W204 C-Class diesels have had some trouble with Piezo injectors, but long term I'd rate it as the more solid bet.
Similar questions
We would like to buy either a Ford Focus hatchback or estate or a 2008 Ford C-Max from British Car Auctions, where we have purchased several cars in the past. The car will serve as an all purpose workhorse...
I am about to choose between a Golf TDI 90 PS and a Polo 75 PS TDI, but am concerned about reports concerning DPF problems with the Polo in particular. There are also reports about Volkswagen dropping...
I am a reasonably keen driver and have always bought various older high performance BMWs, Audi's and even a Porsche Boxster over the last 20 years, and have whittled down my choice of next car to either...
Related models
Compact Jaguar, launched as V6 only with four wheel drive. Held price well at first.
A big improvement on the previous C-Class. Feels well built and robust. Very comfortable and refined. High quality ride. Good CDI diesels.