I am looking to replace our 2006 Saab 93 estate, your advice on an SUV style vehicle as a replacement would be appreciated? Our budget is up to £14,000 for a car of 3 years/ 30,000 miles (inc P/x if there is much value in the Saab).

Our requirements are for a car allowing me to do motorway driving for work (circa 20,000 a year), diesel and fuel economy (50mpg). As a second car it would also have to be capable of two children and all that they involved at weekends hence sensible rear legroom.

I am currently looking at the BMW X1 and Nissan Qashqai but open to your suggestions for the best / most suitable in the market sector. Due to family events safety is a key priority and hence five star NCAP.

I am a regular reader and appreciate you professional and practical advice, many thank.