What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Should the police have the power to issue on-the-spot fines for hogging the middle lane?

I have grave misgivings about on-the-spot-fines, as they turn the police into witness, prosecutor and judge rolled into one. A minority of police are over-zealous, target-driven or just wish to impress their superiors and there is little chance of a wrongly accused motorist getting justice. In particular, with middle lane hogging it is a question of judgement how long it is reasonable to stay in lane two in preparation for passing a lorry, let alone how long is worthy of a £100 fine. With a busy motorway it is all too easy to get trapped in lane one at 57mph, and that must be one reason for some of the apparent hogging.

Asked on 26 October 2013 by KB, via email

Answered by Honest John
Every traffic car now has video recording equipment so it is a comparatively simple matter to prove that a member of CLOG has been selfishly hogging the centre lane for an unreasonable distance. If the cops video some idiot staying in lane two for a mile while lane one is empty then it's case proven.
Similar questions
I regularly hear of people being pulled over by the police for having satnav and phones within the view of the arc of the windscreen wipers, but it seems as if every other vehicle has distracting air fresheners,...
Whilst motoring last month on hundreds of miles of excellent new and uncrowded roads in Spain, I was stopped by the Guardia Civil for going through a tunnel without putting my lights on. This was a very...
I have just been reading a local IAM bulletin that lists "new guidelines nationally introduced.” It does not indicate who issued the guidelines, but goes on to say that "These new guidelines have been...