What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

People prefer analogue speedometers because they're easy to read with peripheral vision.

I read your reply to JN of Midhurst in which you said you couldn't understand why people preferred analogue speedometers. The reason is very simple. With a digital speedo you have to actually look at the figure, which means re-focussing your eyes from the road to the instrument panel. This means that you are momentarily not looking where you're going. With an analogue speedo you're constantly aware of where the needle is in your peripheral vision without having to actually focus on it - rather like a primitive version of a head up display.

This was brought home to me vividly when I drove a 911 for a few weeks. The analogue instrument in the centre of the instrument panel is the tachometer, which incorporates a digital speedo, the analogue speedo being to the right, and normally blocked from vision by your right hand on the wheel. I lost count of the times I found myself speeding because I couldn't see the analogue dial and didn't want the distraction of looking at the digital readout. I would NEVER have a digital speedo as my main speedo again, and I suspect this view is shared by many others.

Asked on 30 March 2013 by ML, via email;

Answered by Honest John
Toyota solved all of this by its line-of-sight digital speedo in the original Yaris. Brilliant. They did the same with the Prius II and II. The digital speedo on them is at the base of the screen, again in line-of-sight. And, of course, head-up displays are always digital, projected onto the windscreen. I take your point where the digital display is in a conventional dash. But I don't swallow the analogue wristwatch argument because, while watches only read 12 hours, cars can have speedos reading from 100mph to 200mph or more, so top centre could be anything from 50mph to 100mph.
Similar questions
I have decided to upgrade from my 2005 Avensis to a 2017 Toyota Auris. The new car was fine but the speedo is too small for me to see easily. It is much smaller and buried away in a tube compared to my...
When driving, the speedometer in my Citroen C3 Picasso is showing a different speed to that which I'm actually driving it. How do I fix it?
If I disconnect the speedo on my 54-reg Ford Fiesta Zetec 1.4, will I lose the mileage? The dash has lost everything apart from the clock, indicators and oil light.
Related models
All-new 911 is lighter and faster. Retains familiar shape with a new interior. Six speed PDK or seven speed manual transmissions. Still the definitive sports car.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer