My current manual Jaguar S-Type Diesel with under 30k miles and Jaguar History is brilliant, with 40+ mpg over the 5000 miles a year I cover, mostly over long distances. I do use the rev range through the gears to keep it clean.

A growing family and economies mean that I need to consider an single SUV to replace my car and my wife's old CRV - which has 105K miles. The family consists of two adults, two kids aged 11 and 15 and a small dog. We cover a mix of long and short journeys of 10k per annum.

What would be best for the long term as we would keep the car for some 7+ years. The budget is around £12K with the Jag in part exchange and expecting little for the V plate Honda (supermarket condition).