Ask Honest John

Honest John Ask Honest John » Different diagnoses from 2 garages on MOT?
What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Different diagnoses from 2 garages on MOT?

I recently had to have my MOT done and the first garage said the exhaust needed welding and failed the emissions test, and that various bulbs needed replacing and wanted £160 for the repairs - £42.60 for the exhaust & the rest for replacing bulbs + VAT + Labour.

I didn't have it done as I replaced the bulbs myself at the cost of £6.37 & the exhaust had a slight leak from the seal, which some gungum fixed for £2.90, a total of £10.27.
I took the car to another garage, where it passed the MOT but had 11 advisories on it?

So how can one garage find exhaust problems and the second find all the other faults? I thought the MOT is a standard test throughout, so how can it differ so much?

Asked on 8 April 2013 by elvishero

Answered by Honest John
VOSA allows latitude for the inspector's "opinion".

Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.

The Good Garage Guide
Similar questions
Recently had an MOT and one of the results is "Damage to inner beads possibly caused by potholes". Would there be a chance of claiming for this through the council?
My daughter has seen a car for sale, but it's off the road and is not taxed or MoT'd. How can it be legally driven to the garage to be tested?
My Wife has just purchased a 2nd had Mazda 3 from Arnie Clark. On several occasions she asked if the MOT was ok and if anything came up. She was told that a new wish bone and bushes were fitted. She...