Best new car to last a long time

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Best new car to last a long time

Hi. I know nothing of cars but I want to buy a good used diesel automatic to last for many years. I don't care about buying the latest greatest model every year or two and I just want the best chance of a reliable, long-lasting car which will go on and on an on.

I'm looking at either BMW or Mercedes as I believe these are two highly rated options. In particular I'm considering either a 3 or 5 series BMW or a C or E class Mercedes.

Can you give me advice as to my best options please?

Asked on 12 February 2012 by honeybun45

Answered by Honest John

Probably a Mercedes C200 or C220CDI. But anything fitted with piezoelectric fuel injectors could have problems. Avoid all VA/Audis with DSGs/s-tronics. They don't last. Latest BMW F30 3-Series very impressive but can't tell you anything about longevity because it has yet to prove itself.

Tags: buying executive cars used cars reliability

Similar questions

E-Class reliability

I am looking to purchase a three or four-year-old E-Class diesel automatic (Avantgarde preferred). From the many 'expert' reviews that are around, am I right in believing that there are fewer mechanical...

VIN he owns

I read your car-by-car breakdown on second-hand Jaguar XKRs and XK8s where you recommend avoiding 96 to 2000 models with a VIN numbers 001036 to 042775 inclusive. My XKR was registered on 20 04 2000 and...

Which 3 Series without too many gadgets?

My 206,000 mile BMW 530d needs to be replaced. How recent a 3 series can I buy while avoiding recent electronic bling like stop start and run flat tyres?

Related models

BMW 3 Series (2005 - 2012)

Superb to drive. Great handling and steering. Upmarket image. Economical diesel engines culminating in amazingly efficient 320d Efficient Dynamics at 109g/km of CO2.