What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Can you recommend a workhorse vehicle that will carry five people in comfort, traverse floods and tow a 1.5-ton trailer?

Now that the family have left home my wife and I do almost all our motoring in our MINI Clubman (with which we are well pleased). But I still have our trusty 12-year-old Volvo estate for the relatively infrequent occasions when we need to carry passengers in comfort. I also have a 1989 Land Rover 110 diesel that I use almost exclusively for my (semi-retired self employed) work on the nearby river which is prone to flooding. Both Land Rover and Volvo are getting a bit 'long in the tooth' and as neither of them now covers more than 5,000 miles annually, economics dictate that I replace them with a single vehicle.

Can you suggest something that will cope with multiple short journeys, some of which may be through water up to a couple of feet or so deep, can carry up to five people in comfort OR the tools and equipment of my trade, and will safely tow a trailer of up to 1.5 tons? Budget is not hugely critical but I would prefer to buy something a year or two old. I have been warned off modern Land Rovers due to the vulnerability of their electronics in anything much more than a foot of water; is this right?

Asked on 24 December 2010 by JE, Quorn, Leicestershire

Answered by Honest John
I'd look at a pick up, such as an Isuzu Rodeo 2.5 or 3.0 I-TEQ or maybe a Mitsubishi L200. But if they have diesel particulate filters they won't take kindly to repeated short runs from cold. No diesel with a particulate filter will. And there really aren't many economical 4WD petrol SUVs. The Toyota RAV4 2.0 Valvematic is probably the best.
Similar questions
I am thinking of buying a new or nearly new 4x4 automatic twin-cab pick-up. I have searched the web and reviews for Toyota, Mitsubishi, Isuzu and Mazda are all very similar. My requirement is off-road...
I currently own a 5-year-old Porsche Boxster and am looking to change it in the next three or four months. I am retired, and enjoy my driving. However, family and bad back considerations suggest a change...
I currently drive a Toyota RAV4 and have been extremely happy with its versatility, reliability and comfort. I need good legroom being 6-feet 3-inches. It has been a great workhorse, helping to move flat...
Related models
More practical alternative to the standard MINI. Five useable seats and neat extra rear door to make getting into the back easier. Cooper D is the pick of the range.
Bigger and now 5-door only. More luxurious but not as practical as previous RAV-4. Car-like road manners. Petrol and diesel automatics. Facelifted 2010.
Extremely tough running gear, long tyre life, durable interior, proven four-wheel drive system.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer